Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be irritated by this work email?

132 replies

BoldChild · 15/06/2023 19:35

Note: This is a large international company, and I am a very tiny fish in a very large pond, but I’ll still paraphrase to avoid any major identifiers

An email went around our (fully remote) company today by new management and went a little something like this:

”Hello, everyone. As this year has been hard on our business, we have decided to implement the following rule: If you are behind in target, you will have to report to your local office and attend the office for a minimum of 4 days. This is so your manager can oversee your daily work and ensure you are doing your job. Your manager will track every phone call and email, and how many clients/customers you reach out to. You will continue to report to the office until your numbers to pick up.

Failure to meet targets will result in an immediate requirement to report to the office. This is non-optional, and everyone must comply. We will not accept any excuses.”

NOW… I am totally on board with the whole “if you’re not doing what you’re supposed to be doing, there’s an issue there” but the nature of the email really just irks me.

It reminds me of being back in school, with a teacher threatening to sit beside you to make sure you’ve done your maths instead of talking to your friends. Like if employees do not show up the office, they’ll call our parents.

Am I being unreasonable to feel this is very condescending? And unfair to those who may be struggling due to reasons that aren’t their fault (mental health, illness, personal issues, etc)? These people will be called out in front of their entire team and marched into the offices against their will, and it just seems totally unfair to do to someone instead of handling any issues privately.

I’m honestly considering handing in my notice

OP posts:
TimesRwo · 15/06/2023 22:19

Issue is you’ve paraphrased that email and in a tone that reflects your dissatisfaction with it, so it sounds much worse than it is. I’d be interested to see the original email and how it was written, as I don’t think the underlying message is an issue. If an employee is going to abuse the trust that comes with wfh, then they need to be managed accordingly.

weirdoboelady · 15/06/2023 22:08

There are two issues here. The first is obviously that forcing attendance at the office on remote workers is a serious proposed change of contract, and I would suggest that workers challenge this through their union or by getting legal advice.

Even supposing that this problem is sorted out, the email is written in a gratuitously offensive way! For fun, I redrafted it. Doesn't the below look perfect (and go some way to preventing the immediate challenges on grounds of discrimination which the original last paragraphs were simply asking for!)

”Hello, everyone. As this year has been hard on our business, we have decided to implement the following rule: If you are behind in target, you will have to report to your local office and attend the office for a minimum of 4 days. This is so your manager can oversee your daily work and work with you to address any problems you are having. We will also be able to address problems where people are not being able, for some reason, to make the number of phone calls and reach outs expected. This office based coaching and review will continue until targets are reached and we are confident that any problems have been overcome.

if there are any particular problems with attendance at the office, we will meet with you to discuss these problems. However, we would suggest that you read your contract carefully to ensure you are meeting your contractual obligations, and attendance for this in-office coaching will normally be non-negotiable.”

WaitingfortheTardis · 15/06/2023 22:04

That email sounds incredibly childish and unprofessional, as well as rather unintelligent on the whole. Good quality management do not need to be looking over their employee's shoulders in order to effectively manage. This just seems good way to destroy morale and good will at a time that is already difficult for many.

Feraldogmum · 15/06/2023 21:58

People who take the mick and don’t do their job cost companies money,if companies fold because of slackers then that’s many people who lose their jobs. We are quite possibly going into a recession,some businesses are struggling and cannot afford those who coast and they shouldnt cost others their livelihoods.
If folk do their work like grownups ,and not play hooky like kids because they’re not being watched,then they don’t need to be treated like children.
Only those who have not done their jobs will be affected, if they are physically or mentally sick then their drs can provide letters to this eff3ct
Sadly often the innocent pay for the mistakes of others.

thecatsthecats · 15/06/2023 21:53

Alphabeaters · 15/06/2023 21:46

Yep, no CRM system here! And now even less calls happening as it takes 5 minutes to fill out the form after every call. I made 5 calls today. So even 2 minutes after each call is 1 hour 40 minutes wasted. Madness.

Well, yeah. And you won't have any systematic way to find out which kinds of calls are more successful.

Back on topic, it's another reason why this email is stupid (whilst getting underperformers in for coaching isn't).

The business is doing badly, probably because of external factors. So they are turning around to staff, and saying,

  1. we're doing badly, worry about your jobs
  2. this is the fault of some of you
  3. we're going to "punish" those who we identify

Not exactly inspiring if you're a HIGH performer, is it? I know it isn't because I have always been that overperformer, and when I didn't think management were handling a situation well, I dusted off my CV. Because how the company performed affected my career too.

And when I was management, I dealt with underperformers individually, and listened to staff without blaming them for external problems, but taking their ideas for how to address them. Weirdly, treating them like adults worked for both morale and the bottom line.

LlynTegid · 15/06/2023 21:50

I support the basis that poor performers should have to work in an office, but think it should follow a private conversation between manager and poor performer, not some general email.

Brefugee · 15/06/2023 21:49

tbh i couldn't get overly excited about this. If there is some reason you're not hitting your targets, then one-on-one or group coaching can help.

I agree the email is possibly (but paraphrased in the OP so difficult to tell) worded badly. Companys are only interested in the bottom line
I work either at home or in the office depending on what i have to do so I don't have a horse in the "wfh means skiving" or "only people who work in the office do it properly" camp

Alphabeaters · 15/06/2023 21:46

Yep, no CRM system here! And now even less calls happening as it takes 5 minutes to fill out the form after every call. I made 5 calls today. So even 2 minutes after each call is 1 hour 40 minutes wasted. Madness.

bluelagoon12 · 15/06/2023 21:46

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 15/06/2023 19:56

I can imagine WFH is a dream come true for lazy piss takers. I don't really agree with fully remote working tbh, I think hybrid working is a good compromise.

I am fully-remote and my management is very happy with me.

I think a slacker is going to slack, no matter where they are.

I have seen people Internet browsing all day long, vanishing from their desk for hours and being on their mobile phone too many times in offices - I really don't believe being office-based will make lazy people more diligent and hardworking.

thecatsthecats · 15/06/2023 21:41

Alphabeaters · 15/06/2023 21:07

Are you in sales?
Most of us are below target due to the cost of living etc.
We now have to complete a written chart showing who we have called each day and the outcome of every call and submit it to management at 5pm daily.
It's giving me the rage.
Clearly if a team of 20 are all below target when previously we've all been hitting targets then it's not down to our poor work ethic.

I mean, maybe if your company employed even rudimentary customer relationship management systems, you might not have to spend time writing reports about who you're contacting!

I've been able to pull records on employee call and email handling since I started my career almost fifteen years ago!

Tracker1234 · 15/06/2023 21:41

Performance mgt is fine if you have a line manager who stays more than six months and doesn’t move to another team or gets a promotion etc.

The wfh brigade have taken complete advantage (that and covid!)

recsw · 15/06/2023 21:36

it is possible to performance manage in most jobs while WFH, without this sort of cr*p

Tracker1234 · 15/06/2023 21:34

It’s clear from this thread that wfh is used and abused by many. It’s a shame cause there are some benefits but don’t get me started on government depts skiving off at home.

Worked for a long time with public sector and even before covid the productivity was shit! You might think you can measure output i.e employee can handle 4 passport applications every 4 hours. The employee blames the process, the technology basically anything to cover up their workload. There was a very big council I worked with who asked us to tell them which was the most popular website for their employees and the answer by a mile was Facebook with many running with it all day..

Jemandthehologramsunite · 15/06/2023 21:25

I agree that they probably shouldn't have done the blanket email, but they would have had to have the conversation anyway. This way less reason to kick up a fuss as you have been told. Pretty sad that so many appear to be taking the piss! Personally if was one of the people who actually worked at the company I would be pleased. I'm so sick of working hard and seeing others around me slack off. Don't understand why people find this so terrible, do people think businesses are a charity? No wonder the economy is in such a dire state.

2018anewstart · 15/06/2023 21:21

The wording of the email may not have been great but I fully agree with the company and if employees are not hitting their target bring them back into the office. A number of reasons for this they could be not working so why should other team members who are working hard picking up their slack. Also they could be suffering with their mental health but very often people can hide this behind a screen when home working but they have the chance to talk about it in person in the office. If you are hitting your targets working from home you have nothing to be worried about.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 15/06/2023 21:19

Micromanaging jobsworths imo

Doggymummar · 15/06/2023 21:19

BoldChild · 15/06/2023 19:50

Yes. In the last month alone, we’ve lost half our team, and that’s just our area. This company has 100s of offices around the world.

People’s time spent at the company would have been around 8-10 years pre Covid/pre management change. It’s 2 years now.

Is it a bank beginning with B?

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 21:19

OP is it possible that the slackers have had multiple conversations about their performance already, and this is the first time a group email has been sent?

It’s not unusual for errors by an individual to be addressed via a group email, not mentioning names, to ensure the same problems don’t continue.

for example, where I work, if employee A made a mistake and booked a client in to the wrong type of appointment, employee A would be quietly spoken to. If employee B did the same thing, then they would be spoken to as well. Then there might be a group email sent out saying “just to remind you all, clients xyz must only be booked into appointments xyz” - something like that. Employees C, D, E, F etc would be thinking “what’s that all about, no need to have a go, we were doing that correctly already”. But they wouldn’t know about employees A and B.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 15/06/2023 21:18

There are ways to talk to and motivate staff, and it’s with respect, especially if you demands respect in return.

They’re unbelievably wide of the mark with that email. It’s condescending, threatening and wannabe autocratic.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/06/2023 21:14

There are so many ways in which they could have worded that where they didn't come across as absolute wankers.

Even wording it as 'As part of our culture of supporting our associates' wellbeing, we are revising our WFH policy. We are aware of the challenges that working from home can present to staff in terms of social connection and support and therefore have decided that anybody who appears to be in need of individualised support will be provided with this through in person training and advice from their Line Manager. We also provide an Employee Assistance Programme, which can be accessed through (website) with the user name (firm) and the password (firmeap), which provides access to six sessions of counselling and many resources relating to health, financial management and wellbeing.' would make it slightly less 'you're shit, we're hauling you in to be bollocked, micromanaged and ultimately fired'.

BoldChild · 15/06/2023 21:11

Soapyspuds · 15/06/2023 21:08

Sorry just seen you mention that your contract gives you the option. What does it say about them being able to demand you attend the office?

Nothing. There’s nothing to say they can enforce office days. I think that was an oversight on their part

OP posts:
Alphabeaters · 15/06/2023 21:11

And in addition to our written charts we fill in every day we already work from the office for 40 hours a week with a manager within 10 feet of us. It's upper management wanting to see the written charts. Our direct managers can hear the conversations we have daily!

sudo · 15/06/2023 21:08

Sounds like Ricky Gervias in The Office.

Soapyspuds · 15/06/2023 21:08

Sorry just seen you mention that your contract gives you the option. What does it say about them being able to demand you attend the office?

Alphabeaters · 15/06/2023 21:07

Are you in sales?
Most of us are below target due to the cost of living etc.
We now have to complete a written chart showing who we have called each day and the outcome of every call and submit it to management at 5pm daily.
It's giving me the rage.
Clearly if a team of 20 are all below target when previously we've all been hitting targets then it's not down to our poor work ethic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread