Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give my nearly 4 week old baby some water?

167 replies

elm26 · 15/06/2023 16:52

Hello

I made a thread the other night as it's 26-28 degrees in my flat all night long, my usually content nearly 4 week old has been so unsettled last couple of nights.

I've tried sleeping her in a nappy, in a nappy with a muslin wrapped around her, in a nappy and a vest and she's not satisfied at all bless her. The back of her hair, neck and back are sweaty.

She's formula fed and plenty of wet nappies, however my Stepmum (long time Nanny of many children and babies as an occupation) suggested I give her half an oz to 1oz of cool boiled water (not to replace formula) just to see if she may be a little thirsty.

I thought guidelines have changed now and we're not meant to give babies water however I googled and NHS says that formula fed babies can have small amounts in hot weather but I'm still nervous as a first time mum that I'm going to hurt her somehow! She also hasn't done a poo for 2 days and I've heard water can help with constipation (I've tried bicycle legs, massaging tummy etc).

Did any of you give your newborns a tiny bit of water in hot weather or shall I leave it?

OP posts:
WomanOfSteel · 15/06/2023 17:21

In some places in Greece a babies first feed is chamomile tea. The mothers are then advised to keep alternating milk and chamomile tea. I have seen my friends babies thrive on it. Obviously it’s a much hotter country and I had never heard of it before or would have dreamt of doing it, but thought it might ease your mind that a little bit of cooled boiled water is not going to harm your child.

Congratulations on your baby. 💐

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 15/06/2023 17:21

Right. No. Just no.

You are doing a fab job, breastfeeding is not a reflection on how well you are doing. At all. I promise you. The very fact you are worried means you're a really good Mum. You're doing great.

I understand, I couldn't breastfeed and I really beat myself up over it. Honestly I do understand. It's OK. You're doing the right thing.

What is baby's weight chart looking like? Is she tracking her centile?

I'm sure she's fine. I'd ignore. But, if you're worried, the GP will probably be happy to reassure you. I know whenever I took DD to the Dr they always said they'd rather see a perfectly healthy baby in clinic than have a worried mum at home.

1stTimeMummy2021 · 15/06/2023 17:20

My baby was formula fed after a while and we were told to change the water to formula ratio, so for an 8oz bottle we only put in 6 scoops of formula, it really helped with constipation. We didn't give him plain water until we started weaning.

Cakeorchocolate · 15/06/2023 17:17

Mummytolittleones92 · 15/06/2023 17:12

Ignore your HV. You are doing a great job and I’m sorry you’re so anxious. When you’re a new mum it’s a bloody minefield trying to navigate the steps. Feed your baby when she’s hungry. The HV may have a manual, but the baby sure as heck hasn’t read it. If your baby is content and settled with a bit of extra milk then again I urge you to follow your gut. You need sleep and not to feel fraught with worry, your health matters too OP x

Completely agree with this!

HVs, although I'm sure well intentioned, can make any mum feel crap!

Trust your gut. And if the HV makes you feel worse rather than helping you could try asking for a different one or even opting out altogether.

All babies are different so one size does not fit all for feeds, clothes, milestones etc.

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 17:15

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:10

Just wish I could have breastfed but my milk wasn't enough and she wouldn't latch. Feel useless right now.

It doesn't matter. Let it go. You're feeding her well and are very attentive to her needs. That's what she needs: food and love.

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 17:14

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:09

The HV has actually added a note to my app to say she had advised baby is being over fed.

She was 5lb 15oz when born a week early, she's now 7lb 1oz and midwives have said she's thriving.

If I give her the recommended 2-3oz she cries for more and they told me to wake her every 2 hours as she could go into a deep sleep and never wake up if I leave her for 4 hours in between feeds as that's how long she sleeps.

It's all causing me so much anxiety and I suffer with it anyway.

Oh good grief. What a lot of pressure.

Look, not all HVs are as good as the best HVs and they're not always right.

If the baby is following its growth percentile and is thriving - and isn't throwing whole feeds back up - I very much doubt she is being over fed. All this "by the book" exact times and amounts of feeds was very popular in my mother's generation but babies are individuals.

You know your baby. You know her better than the HV does. If she's losing weight or something major that's different but a happy, healthy baby who hasn't read the guidance about exactly how many ozs to take at which hour of the day, is a very normal baby.

As for the water, if you think she is hot and a bit dehydrated, follow your instincts, using appropriate caution.

It makes me quite annoyed to think of HVs nitpicking away nonsensically and undermining mothers' confidence.

FlounderingFruitcake · 15/06/2023 17:13

I’d give water, it was advised when I had my now 6YO. 2oz per day max, 0.5-1 ounce at a time.

Curtains70 · 15/06/2023 17:13

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:10

Just wish I could have breastfed but my milk wasn't enough and she wouldn't latch. Feel useless right now.

Ah I feel for you. I know it's easier said than done but honestly try not to worry. They're tough little things babies even though they're so little.

If she's hungry give her formula and maybe try a drop of boiled cooled water if you think she needs it.

Unfortunately being unsettled in hot weather is just part of it, I mean even I struggled to sleep last night so it's nothing to worry about.

Mummytolittleones92 · 15/06/2023 17:13

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:10

Just wish I could have breastfed but my milk wasn't enough and she wouldn't latch. Feel useless right now.

You are not useless, not in the slightest. I know it’s hard OP but try to remain positive. You can do this. You are mum, you know what your baby needs.

Mummytolittleones92 · 15/06/2023 17:12

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:09

The HV has actually added a note to my app to say she had advised baby is being over fed.

She was 5lb 15oz when born a week early, she's now 7lb 1oz and midwives have said she's thriving.

If I give her the recommended 2-3oz she cries for more and they told me to wake her every 2 hours as she could go into a deep sleep and never wake up if I leave her for 4 hours in between feeds as that's how long she sleeps.

It's all causing me so much anxiety and I suffer with it anyway.

Ignore your HV. You are doing a great job and I’m sorry you’re so anxious. When you’re a new mum it’s a bloody minefield trying to navigate the steps. Feed your baby when she’s hungry. The HV may have a manual, but the baby sure as heck hasn’t read it. If your baby is content and settled with a bit of extra milk then again I urge you to follow your gut. You need sleep and not to feel fraught with worry, your health matters too OP x

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 15/06/2023 17:10

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 17:04

Not a mum and genuinely interested. Why is it OK to give a bottle fed baby small amounts of water but not breast fed? I assumed that water was fine to give to a baby if it appears the baby is thirsty and not hungry.

My understanding is that breast milk adapts itself to all sorts of things, so in hot weather will have more water in it / be more 'diluted' if you like.

Formula is always the same, and you can't put extra water in as then it can fill baby up without giving them the nutrition they should be getting.

Water will help hydrate, but baby is unlikely to drink very much of it (as it doesn't taste like milk) so wouldn't get full up on water and then refuse milk. Which could happen with extra diluted formula.

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:10

Just wish I could have breastfed but my milk wasn't enough and she wouldn't latch. Feel useless right now.

OP posts:
Curtains70 · 15/06/2023 17:09

I had a newborn last summer, remember those days that were over 30 degrees 🔥.

HV said that baby could have a bit of boiled and cooled water but no more than 2oz over the whole day. That being said baby had no interest in it and didn't have it anyway 🤣

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:09

The HV has actually added a note to my app to say she had advised baby is being over fed.

She was 5lb 15oz when born a week early, she's now 7lb 1oz and midwives have said she's thriving.

If I give her the recommended 2-3oz she cries for more and they told me to wake her every 2 hours as she could go into a deep sleep and never wake up if I leave her for 4 hours in between feeds as that's how long she sleeps.

It's all causing me so much anxiety and I suffer with it anyway.

OP posts:
JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 17:08

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 17:04

Not a mum and genuinely interested. Why is it OK to give a bottle fed baby small amounts of water but not breast fed? I assumed that water was fine to give to a baby if it appears the baby is thirsty and not hungry.

Because in hot weather, the breast milk produced is more hydrating. It's a clever bit of biology.

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 17:06

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:02

Thanks everyone.

I've just turned 30 and I think my generation of mum's and grandparents did this as standard and like you all said, we all survived but obviously new research comes into play for a reason and I'd never want to harm her.

I might boil the kettle and offer half an oz once cooled.

Try 1oz. If giving healthy babies small amounts of cooled, boiled water was dangerous, there would have been publicised cases.

Ofcourseididthat · 15/06/2023 17:06

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 17:04

Not a mum and genuinely interested. Why is it OK to give a bottle fed baby small amounts of water but not breast fed? I assumed that water was fine to give to a baby if it appears the baby is thirsty and not hungry.

Breast milk is more watery in the heat so they don’t need it!

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:05

Belmondo · 15/06/2023 17:01

Hi OP, do you have any support at home? I remember how horrendous it was to wake up after an exhausted accidental nap to feel like I hadn't been in control/practising safe co-sleeping 😱

Hi @Belmondo

My DH is great and we do shifts but he had to be up at 5am to drive to London for a job so we decided it was best to leave him sleep in bed and I'd sleep on sofa with her in Moses last night however I obviously fell asleep with her and scared myself. I've never slept with her on me/in the bed etc as I'm petrified. I really scared myself.

Luckily DH is doing the 10-6 shift tonight as he doesn't have work tomorrow so I can get a good 7-8 hours.

OP posts:
WithOneLook · 15/06/2023 17:04

I had a similar aged baby during last year and gave a small amount of cooled boiler water. Formula fed babies do need it in hot weather as per the NHS pages. Breastfed babies don't need it in the same way because the breast milk changes consistency/water content depending on what baby needs. Its really interesting looking at how breast milk changes for different tempretures/times of day etc. Formula can't do that.

Cakeorchocolate · 15/06/2023 17:04

Please don't feel like a failure.

We've probably all been there, both nodding in less than ideal positions (I know I did!) And feeling like a failure.

You're not doing anything wrong. Newborn phase and sleep deprivation are tough! Even more so I'd guess with the heat.

From other replies it sounds like trying a little water would be fine.
Whatever you do, you're not a failure.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 17:04

Not a mum and genuinely interested. Why is it OK to give a bottle fed baby small amounts of water but not breast fed? I assumed that water was fine to give to a baby if it appears the baby is thirsty and not hungry.

PuffinsRocks · 15/06/2023 17:02

I was advised by HV to give up to 2oz (60ml ish) water to DC1 when he was an unsettled baby in the record-breaking summer of 2020. He was formula fed and on the 98th percentile so we didn't want to overdo it with the milk. The water did settle him to be fair.

elm26 · 15/06/2023 17:02

Thanks everyone.

I've just turned 30 and I think my generation of mum's and grandparents did this as standard and like you all said, we all survived but obviously new research comes into play for a reason and I'd never want to harm her.

I might boil the kettle and offer half an oz once cooled.

OP posts:
Mummytolittleones92 · 15/06/2023 17:02

Give her some water OP. A little bit isn’t going to do any harm. It’s hot, she’s unsettled, your instinct (correctly) is to keep her hydrated. If you feel an oz of water would help then go for it. Listen to your gut. I know you want reassurance from us and I hope we are giving you that, but follow your own lead as well. You are doing great x

Belmondo · 15/06/2023 17:01

Hi OP, do you have any support at home? I remember how horrendous it was to wake up after an exhausted accidental nap to feel like I hadn't been in control/practising safe co-sleeping 😱