Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School withholding food as punishment

296 replies

catgirl1976 · 15/06/2023 16:25

DS is due to start high school in September.

I’ve just seen a highly alarming thread about the school in a local Facebook group.

Massive disclaimer : Obviously people can write any sort of garbage on social media and it may well not be true and I will of course be speaking to the school at the earliest opportunity to gain clarity before taking any action but enough people have confirmed the allegations to make me a bit worried.

The issues raised are

  1. Toilets are now pretty much all gender neutral. I can deal with that - I know enough about the law to be confident I. Challenging and ensuring sufficient single sex provision is in place so whilst I’ll be challenging if true I’m confident in my ability to do that.
  2. Kids are getting a detention for being one minute late. I can live with that. Late is late. Important lesson.
  3. Classrooms are 29 degrees (new building has thermometers in each classroom) and kids cannot have water during class or in the playground at breaks. Seems a bit mad. Willing to listen to the rationale and alternative arrangements if this is true.
  4. This is the big one for me…kids are routinely being denied lunch as a punishment for bad behaviour. I am totally fine with appropriate sanctions for bad behaviour. E.g. mess about in the lunch queue eat lunch in isolation or miss break. But actually not he allowed to have lunch? To be denied food? Surely that’s illegal? I would have thought this was nonsense but at least 10 people have commented that their child has been denied lunch. No other arrangements or food just no food. So breakfast at home and nothing to eat all day. Surely this cannot be legal?

as said before I’ll check with the school about the truth of this and points one to three I can deal with but if point four is true and good is being withheld as a punishment…what would you do? There’s a transition evening coming up where I will have chance to ask questions and I’m gong to email the school asking for their response to these comments but surely a school can’t deny a child the opportunity it y to eat as a punishment?

Even googling I can’t find any incidences of this. It seems barbaric. AIBU or is this a thing?

OP posts:
PaigeMatthews · 15/06/2023 18:12

VasariMichelangelo · 15/06/2023 18:04

I'm almost 40 and was allowed a drink at break, it was usually a small carton of milk.

Yes. But it was constantly sucking on a litre of water all day long.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 15/06/2023 18:09

Febreezefantastic · 15/06/2023 16:42

kids are routinely being denied lunch as a punishment for bad behaviour.

I'd be ok if it was my own kids, they are hardly starving, but I can't see how that would be acceptable for vulnerable children. The only chance some have to eat a semi decent meal is school.

On that basis, I would try to get more information. Again, the water is unacceptable. No water in the classroom is fine, but on the playground? ridiculous.

This is NOT OK.

I do not withold food from my children and I do NOT expect anyone else to either. If this is happening it is abusive.

I am shocked you would be OK with this for your children.

Kokopenny · 15/06/2023 18:09

Shhhquirrel · 15/06/2023 18:03

This

I’d be rethinking my options if I were you OP.

Or stop believing fb nonsense

MayThe4th · 15/06/2023 18:08

So these desperately worried parents of course went to the governors, ofsted? Oh no wait, they posted on the cesspit that is your average fb group.

And I would lay money on the fact that the ten parents who all claim this happened to their child too all know each other, and their little darlings are the thugs that hang about outside the local shops and intimidate the locals after school.

JRHartleysmum · 15/06/2023 18:06

suburbophobe · 15/06/2023 18:03

Food and water being DENIED??

No fucking way. That's just cruelty.

Or utter bullshit

off · 15/06/2023 18:04

PaigeMatthews · 15/06/2023 17:55

Im surprised every day so many of us over the age of 30 didnt die of thirst as children.

My primary school's water fountains didn't work, and occasionally we didn't get water at lunch either because it was coming through the taps brown. Nobody brought in their own drinks with their packed lunch (I don't remember whether it was disallowed, or whether people just didn't). I remember being thirsty and getting headaches quite frequently. Sometimes it stung when I peed. None of us died, but it wasn't pleasant and I doubt it helped learning.

VasariMichelangelo · 15/06/2023 18:04

PaigeMatthews · 15/06/2023 17:55

Im surprised every day so many of us over the age of 30 didnt die of thirst as children.

I'm almost 40 and was allowed a drink at break, it was usually a small carton of milk.

Shhhquirrel · 15/06/2023 18:03

L3ThirtySeven · 15/06/2023 16:35

Not the kind of school I’d send my DC to, that’s for sure. It’s run more draconian than a military post.

This

I’d be rethinking my options if I were you OP.

suburbophobe · 15/06/2023 18:03

Food and water being DENIED??

No fucking way. That's just cruelty.

VasariMichelangelo · 15/06/2023 18:02

*say

NorthStarRising · 15/06/2023 18:00

I wonder how many parents find their children suckling on water bottles all day long at home? Or does access to water when they need it mean their child drinks a reasonable amount, rather than constantly?

VasariMichelangelo · 15/06/2023 18:00

catgirl1976 · 15/06/2023 16:34

See denied hot food and given a sandwich in a detention sounds fine. But at least ten people have now said their child was told no food at all as a punishment and left it go hungry all day.

it surely can’t be true I’m just a bit worried by the amount of people saying it is. Perhaps they are being told things that are not true by their kids. It can’t be true.

And what did they parents saying they did about it? There is not a chance in hell I'd let that go unchallenged if it was mine!

Same for the water.

NorthStarRising · 15/06/2023 17:58

Please come back and tell us exactly what the school said in response you your detailed questions.
Save the email, so you have it on record as a reference for later.
I’m pleased you’re not relying solely on parents and children as a source of accurate information.

PaigeMatthews · 15/06/2023 17:55

Im surprised every day so many of us over the age of 30 didnt die of thirst as children.

Changechangechanging · 15/06/2023 17:53

even at primary school they have a water bottle accessible at all times. Surely that’s a basic need

I’ll stick my hand up as a teacher and say….if I keep a child back at break or lunch, I would always give sufficient time for them to go to the loo and get something to eat. In other words, I wouldn’t keep them the whole of lunch or break, but they wouldn’t get the pick of the food.

Water bottles are a pain. A real pain. In and out of bags, spilling on tables, crackling of single-use plastic, breathing in and out of the bottle, demands to be allowed to fill it up (2 minutes after break/lunch), demands to go to the loo ‘cos they’ve refilled 15 times since 9am and it’s now 11:15 (and I’m really not exaggerating). No, it’s in your bag and it stays there. You don’t need to be drinking constantly.

Quinoawoman · 15/06/2023 17:52

I very much doubt that denying lunch as a punishment is true. I also doubt it's true that kids can't have water at breaktimes.

Classroom 29 degrees - pretty much standard. Why don't you offer to fundraise for air con? The teachers would love you forever.

LlynTegid · 15/06/2023 17:50

Ring the school about what you presume to be malicious lies. Someone could be spreading them because of a disagreement about the way their child has been treated, or with some other axe to grind (think things such as the thread about parking on a local resident's drive).

I'm sure you'll get a response.

babyproblems · 15/06/2023 17:47

Can’t you ring the school and ask to speak to the safeguard and also the head or deputy head and just ask out right what’s their policy on this and clarify if what you have read is true?? X

Stressfordays · 15/06/2023 17:46

My friend recently went to work in a local school. A few weeks later I saw a whole bunch of parents ranting over Facebook about the school. Some of the stuff being posted was outrageous. I messaged my friend who was laughing her head off and the truth was very different from the versions being posted over social media.

There seems to be an epidemic of parents who believe everything their little darlings tell them and are completely blind to their poor behaviour.

MeridianB · 15/06/2023 17:46

Ask your child. If they can't give you a clear answer then email the head teacher or HOY and say share the list of allegations from other parents. Ask them for their responses on each point, then you'll know.

Mummy08m · 15/06/2023 17:45

Children say all kinds of things to their parents and many believe them.

I had a student P who was tapping his ruler while waiting for the lesson to start. I asked him to stop. Then two more boys came in, one had his arm around the other's shoulder. P shouted out a homophobic slur. I went apeshit, took him out, bollocked him, etc. His mum phoned me that afternoon asking why I sent her son out for tapping his ruler!!!

Maireas · 15/06/2023 17:43

@PaigeMatthews - spot on 👍

PaigeMatthews · 15/06/2023 17:41

Toilets are now pretty much all gender neutral. I can deal with that - I know enough about the law to be confident I. Challenging and ensuring sufficient single sex provision is in place so whilst I’ll be challenging if true I’m confident in my ability to do that
This would concern me. Are they legally compliant with being gender neutral, or have they just relabelled doors?

Kids are getting a detention for being one minute late. I can live with that. Late is late. Important lesson
there are two bells in my school for the two lessons after a break. One if to move to class. One is to start the lesson. So I student might think there are one minute late, but if it is one minute after the start the lesson bell then they have missed parts of the intro to the lesson and now the whole class suffer.

Classrooms are 29 degrees (new building has thermometers in each classroom)
yes. School buildings are terrible snd not fit for a hot summer or a cold winter. Schools needs investment and proper design.

and kids cannot have water during class or in the playground at breaks.
absolute nonsense. They more likely arent allowed the disposable bottles, and the school is pushing for the more environmentally friendly and behaviour friendly reusable bottles. Check the policy on water bottles.

kids are routinely being denied lunch as a punishment for bad behaviour
again, this will be nonsense. Far more likely those kids are getting detentions and then not liking the choices that are left.

and finally, from my experience, those parents ranting about the school on social media are the entitled parents of poorly behaved children. The ones who frequently have short lunches due to detentions. The ones who are not allows to have their bottle put in class because they will squirt people with it.

catgirl1976 · 15/06/2023 17:41

Thank you all

i am sure it isn’t true and is either just Facebook nonsense or kids distorting things

I will contact the school when I get back to check and I’m sure it will turn out to be claptrap. And yes I could email them now as a PP has said but I’m on holiday and have had a few cocktails and would prefer to send a considered email without mojitos or initial reactions influencing the wording

OP posts:
Srin · 15/06/2023 17:41

It sounds like a load of bollocks. A lot of people who complain about strict secondary schools don’t realise that the alternative is Lord of Flies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread