Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Other parents leaving their kids in the pool

210 replies

Monkeymonkeymoo · 15/06/2023 13:32

We’re on holiday at the moment with our 2 DS (age 3 and 14 months). It’s a hotel resort with a couple of pools/splash pads areas for kids as well as a bigger pool for adults.
DH and I have been taking the kids to the pool everyday and every time we’re there other families just send their children over or leave them in the pool on their own.
We then end up feeling like we can’t just leave the pool because it’s dangerous to leave the other children with no supervision (there’s a lifeguard but he also covers the adult pool so isn’t constantly watching).

We haven’t agreed to look after these kids (and in some cases have no idea who their parents are). But obviously we’d feel dreadful if something happened to them. I think their parents see that we’re around and assume we’ll keep an eye out.
Their behaviour isn’t always great and we’ve had to say something a couple of times when they’ve been rough with the younger children (pushing them, pulling them under the water, throwing toys at them etc). So I don’t really want to be responsible for them.

The children are mostly aged between 3 and 8ish although occasionally they’re accompanied by older siblings who then wander off.

Is it unreasonable for us to just leave if there are no other adults around? Or do we need to do something to try and track down the parents before we go? (I assume they’re either in the bar area or in the garden area where all the sunbeds are but I don’t actually know who I’m looking for).

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 16/06/2023 07:11

Strong swimmers can drown in bath tubs, hot tubs, pools, the sea, lakes anywhere water is

How on earth does being a strong swimmer guarantee you can't drown?

Goldencup · 16/06/2023 07:05

And to be clear I would never expect a child below the age of 16 to supervise a toddler around water, far too dangerous.

Goldencup · 16/06/2023 07:04

Catching up on this thread I am really interested at what age people would leave their children out of direct eye line around water. We live by the sea and my DCs swam daily at school in the summer term from yr R. By year 6 I wouldn't be bothered about them going off with friends on the beach (to be clear I was on the beach but not following them). My perception is that the sea is more dangerous than a pool, but I might be wrong. Once in secondary school they swam with friends in rivers and pools with friends and no adult present. They also had done lifesaving at school in year 6.

RedHelenB · 16/06/2023 06:57

This is classic number martyrdom. No way are you keeping an eye on all those children and your own so just get out of the pool when you want and then the lifeguard can tell the children to get out if necessary .

Paq · 16/06/2023 06:43

YANBU OP and I can’t believe someone on this thread decided that a six year old who can swim 25m is safe to be left unsupervised 😕 I hope you speak to the hotel management.

MoltenLasagne · 16/06/2023 06:38

I hate this too OP. It makes me angriest seeing parents leave an older sibling "in charge" when they're still tiny themselves. Unless your kid has lifeguard training, don't leave them responsible for a toddler around water! How would a 7 year old be able to react if a younger sibling fell into water?

Alana1983 · 16/06/2023 06:22

A few years ago there was a case where a small child aged around 8 drowned when his parents returned to their room believing but not asking other adults around the pool would watch him. They didn't. At the inquest the parents blamed those other adults. Sad for everyone but an unbelievable sense of entitlement. I've seen shocking things on beaches in the UK and whilst holidaying abroad and I'm anxious about exactly this when we go in a few weeks

Peanutbutteryday · 16/06/2023 06:11

Jasmine222 · 16/06/2023 05:03

To all the parents saying it's ok to leave a strong swimmer unattended in a pool - my 7 year old is a strong swimmer and last weekend we were in a hotel resort that had a swimming pool. My 7 year old had some goggles on that he had asked to borrow from another kid aged 6, and the other kid suddenly decided he wanted them back, asked my son for them and also grabbed them at the same point, and dragged my son under water by pulling at the goggles. My son started panicking and grabbed at the first available thing to hold - the other boy's head, and pulled him under. They were both panicking and pulling each other under. Thankfully I was only a couple of metres away so I grabbed both of them and pulled them to the side. They were both confused and shaking. The younger child clearly hadn't realised my son couldnt stand in the pool and was very impatient to get his goggles, and grabbed them before my son had had a chance to return them. Long story short - you never know what kids will do and sometimes they could start drowning through no fault of their own. I'm not a helicopter parent in any regard but wouldnt leave my young children unattended in a pool.

agree with this! Hope both children were ok @Jasmine222

Also, for anyone saying it’s ok it’s also really not actually that hard to watch your child.. 🙄

Jasmine222 · 16/06/2023 05:03

To all the parents saying it's ok to leave a strong swimmer unattended in a pool - my 7 year old is a strong swimmer and last weekend we were in a hotel resort that had a swimming pool. My 7 year old had some goggles on that he had asked to borrow from another kid aged 6, and the other kid suddenly decided he wanted them back, asked my son for them and also grabbed them at the same point, and dragged my son under water by pulling at the goggles. My son started panicking and grabbed at the first available thing to hold - the other boy's head, and pulled him under. They were both panicking and pulling each other under. Thankfully I was only a couple of metres away so I grabbed both of them and pulled them to the side. They were both confused and shaking. The younger child clearly hadn't realised my son couldnt stand in the pool and was very impatient to get his goggles, and grabbed them before my son had had a chance to return them. Long story short - you never know what kids will do and sometimes they could start drowning through no fault of their own. I'm not a helicopter parent in any regard but wouldnt leave my young children unattended in a pool.

Peanutbutteryday · 16/06/2023 04:51

Eurgh we had this on holiday too (first one with my Dc so first time I’ve really noticed other kids on holiday). Couldn’t believe the number of parents leaving their kids to play on their own in pool no supervision and not even round the pool to watch (I spent time in the baby pool where we were the only ones round the pool but older kids came in to play….No adults near by).

It is terrible and dangerous. Not your problem. You’re a kinder person than me. If you want to feel like you’re doing the right thing tell the lifeguard each time as pps suggested - at least then you’re clearly handing over any responsibility you may feel

It also means (in our instance) that parents weren’t around to tell kids off if they were doing something they shouldn’t have been. Some parents just can’t be bothered was my experience.

1dayatatime · 15/06/2023 22:36

Sadly I've also seen this first hand whilst on holiday. Even more sadly every year I read news stories of young children drowning whilst on holiday with the same reasons given "oh we were only gone for a few minutes to get xyz", the lifeguard should have done more, the hotel should have had more warning signs up et etc

I guess it comes to parental choices and perception of risk .

SweetSakura · 15/06/2023 22:11

Goldencup · 15/06/2023 21:24

My DCs could both swim 25m at 5. The idea that you supervise because they might hit their head is a bit bonkers. Pre-schoolers should absolutely be supervised but I'd say 6+ it's marginal. Assuming these are much younger children.

I would definitely supervise a 6 year.old. regardless of how well they could swim.

Goldencup · 15/06/2023 21:24

Monkeymonkeymoo · 15/06/2023 14:05

Yep this is exactly the set up. The water isn’t very deep- probably at my mid thigh at the deepest point, but it’s still enough for a child to drown if they fell and hit their head.

I assume they think the lifeguard/other parents will keep an eye on them and intervene if there’s a problem, or they think it’s too shallow for it to be dangerous (or they don’t really think).

My DCs could both swim 25m at 5. The idea that you supervise because they might hit their head is a bit bonkers. Pre-schoolers should absolutely be supervised but I'd say 6+ it's marginal. Assuming these are much younger children.

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:17

flimsywhimsy · 15/06/2023 21:06

I seriously judge parents who can't wait to essentially abandon their children at the pool on holiday. It's horribly dangerous, of course, but also, do they not want to watch their children having fun and take the time to play with them? Why have kids if you're just going to be looking for the first chance to dump them and go drink or sunbathe?

Meh. It’s my holiday too and I want to lie on a sunlounger as I suspect many do

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:17

nobrasfot · 15/06/2023 21:06

I think at 8 a child is fine in a small splash pool without being watched constantly. My 8 year old is a good swimmer and I wouldn't be worried about them in a splash pool.
They can go swimming alone at age 8 at our leisure centre.

God my kids would die of embarrassment if I made them as perfectly good swimmers stay in a splash pool at the age of 8!

Timetochangetheoil · 15/06/2023 21:13

I had this at the beach last summer, splashing about with my then 2 and 4 year olds (West Wittering so a big stretch of nice shallow water) but one kid of about 5 was seemingly in charge of his little brother who was honestly about 18 months, 2 at a push. He fell under and I looked around for any adult who may be with them and couldn’t find them so had to pick him up! Poor thing was coughing, sputtering and crying :( The dad waded over then, didn’t apologise just admonished the 5 year old for not watching his brother! It was shocking.

I personally couldn’t just walk away even if it ruins my holiday/day out I would just worry too much. But totally get why people want to and it angers me that any parent would do this!

flimsywhimsy · 15/06/2023 21:06

I seriously judge parents who can't wait to essentially abandon their children at the pool on holiday. It's horribly dangerous, of course, but also, do they not want to watch their children having fun and take the time to play with them? Why have kids if you're just going to be looking for the first chance to dump them and go drink or sunbathe?

nobrasfot · 15/06/2023 21:06

I think at 8 a child is fine in a small splash pool without being watched constantly. My 8 year old is a good swimmer and I wouldn't be worried about them in a splash pool.
They can go swimming alone at age 8 at our leisure centre.

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 20:57

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/06/2023 19:37

It’s not the lifeguard’s job to babysit them but surely their job to make sure kids aren’t being left unattended?

No their job is to rescue anyone in danger. They can’t do that if they’re too busy trying to find a load of parents

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 20:56

As an aside I doubt swathes of parents are leaving their 3yo’s in a pool and taking off for the day.

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 20:53

My kids were both strong swimmers at age 3 and didn’t need me flapping around them. On holiday by the time my youngest was 3 and oldest was 6 I’d watch them from a nearby lounger and tell them not to go too far. I’d also make sure that we were in a pool that was shallow or had a shallow end - which is basically all pools in family resorts.

An 8yo who can swim definitely doesn’t need helicopter parenting

FKATondelayo · 15/06/2023 20:50

garfieldeatscake · 15/06/2023 19:01

Tomb-stoning is really dangerous! So you wouldn't trust your 9 yr old in a swimming pool without you supervising, but it's fine for them to tombstone off a bridge? You're a way more chilled parent than me, but then I get to see the consequences at work when tomb-stoning goes wrong... it ain't pretty.

It was in no way 'tombstoning'. You've taken quite a leap there (unlike my son).

Strawberrydelight78 · 15/06/2023 19:56

I don't think she is agreeing to keeping an eye on them they are just leaving them to be supervised by other parents. I would have to say something it's not a kids club where you can dump and run.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/06/2023 19:37

It’s not the lifeguard’s job to babysit them but surely their job to make sure kids aren’t being left unattended?

RedRiverSun · 15/06/2023 19:33

This has always gone on. Plenty of parents happily leave kids unsupervised in a shallow kids pool. You can't insist the parents supervise and the hotel clearly doesn't want to enforce it.