Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Other parents leaving their kids in the pool

210 replies

Monkeymonkeymoo · 15/06/2023 13:32

We’re on holiday at the moment with our 2 DS (age 3 and 14 months). It’s a hotel resort with a couple of pools/splash pads areas for kids as well as a bigger pool for adults.
DH and I have been taking the kids to the pool everyday and every time we’re there other families just send their children over or leave them in the pool on their own.
We then end up feeling like we can’t just leave the pool because it’s dangerous to leave the other children with no supervision (there’s a lifeguard but he also covers the adult pool so isn’t constantly watching).

We haven’t agreed to look after these kids (and in some cases have no idea who their parents are). But obviously we’d feel dreadful if something happened to them. I think their parents see that we’re around and assume we’ll keep an eye out.
Their behaviour isn’t always great and we’ve had to say something a couple of times when they’ve been rough with the younger children (pushing them, pulling them under the water, throwing toys at them etc). So I don’t really want to be responsible for them.

The children are mostly aged between 3 and 8ish although occasionally they’re accompanied by older siblings who then wander off.

Is it unreasonable for us to just leave if there are no other adults around? Or do we need to do something to try and track down the parents before we go? (I assume they’re either in the bar area or in the garden area where all the sunbeds are but I don’t actually know who I’m looking for).

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 16/06/2023 16:24

Peanutbutteryday · 16/06/2023 14:15

It’s nothing to do with swimming ability though.

the point is if a minor accident that if it happened on land would be a non event (ie bump to head, feeling dizzy, someone barging or jumping on child) happened in or near water instead it can very quickly become dangerous.

Regardless of swimming ability.

It baffles and concerns me that people don’t understand this.

I agree.

Peanutbutteryday · 16/06/2023 14:15

Kyla87 · 16/06/2023 11:37

I have to disagree with people saying this is irresponsible. You’re on holiday and do not know the culture of others. I spent some of my childhood years abroad and let me tell you some countries have very strong (I would say superior) swimming lessons. As a child I remember being forced (as part of school curriculum) to swim in deep pools etc. and they do train the kids very early due to natural disasters or etc reasons. This means that the swimming ability’s of kids 5+ in these countries are quite amazing. I would further add as part of the school curriculum I was supposed to be able to thread water for 45 mins (or I would’ve failed my swimming module)

so if those parents are foreign (as you didn’t mention where the holiday was) I wouldn’t worry too much about it. Their culture is just different and they are clearly confident of their children’s ability to swim. Lastly some parents might just feel comfortable with 1 lifeguard but I know I wouldn’t be the one adult would have to look out over the 2 pools you mentioned and it would be easy to miss a young child (but this is of course not your problem)

It’s nothing to do with swimming ability though.

the point is if a minor accident that if it happened on land would be a non event (ie bump to head, feeling dizzy, someone barging or jumping on child) happened in or near water instead it can very quickly become dangerous.

Regardless of swimming ability.

It baffles and concerns me that people don’t understand this.

LakeTiticaca · 16/06/2023 12:36

People can and do drown in inches of water, especially if it's very busy with lots of inflatables etc. More or less every year the national news will report a small child drowning in a pool at a Mediterranean holiday spot.
Just as predictable as the news of teenagers drowning in rivers, 2 reported in my local news region in the past couple of weeks, sadly x

Mammillaria · 16/06/2023 11:41

Oblomov23 · 16/06/2023 10:53

Splash pools are supposed to be shallow. If OP is saying it's mid thigh on her then that's different. One poster referred to child drowning in dingy. That's not a shallow splash pool then is it?!

I'm not sure if you mean my post about the dingy incident, but the splash pool was only about adult knee height. The dingies were tiny things big enough for 1 child to sit it whilst another child pulled them by the attached string at the front.

The toddler was wearing armbands and I would say that, standing, the water would come up to just under the level of their armpits (if that makes sense!). He had somehow ended up under the dingy, squished between the bottom of the dingy and base of the pool. I am guessing that his armbands were probably making the problem worse.

I mentioned it because it's one of those odd accidents you wouldn't imagine could happen in such shallow water!

Kyla87 · 16/06/2023 11:37

I have to disagree with people saying this is irresponsible. You’re on holiday and do not know the culture of others. I spent some of my childhood years abroad and let me tell you some countries have very strong (I would say superior) swimming lessons. As a child I remember being forced (as part of school curriculum) to swim in deep pools etc. and they do train the kids very early due to natural disasters or etc reasons. This means that the swimming ability’s of kids 5+ in these countries are quite amazing. I would further add as part of the school curriculum I was supposed to be able to thread water for 45 mins (or I would’ve failed my swimming module)

so if those parents are foreign (as you didn’t mention where the holiday was) I wouldn’t worry too much about it. Their culture is just different and they are clearly confident of their children’s ability to swim. Lastly some parents might just feel comfortable with 1 lifeguard but I know I wouldn’t be the one adult would have to look out over the 2 pools you mentioned and it would be easy to miss a young child (but this is of course not your problem)

Monkeymonkeymoo · 16/06/2023 11:03

Oblomov23 · 16/06/2023 10:53

Splash pools are supposed to be shallow. If OP is saying it's mid thigh on her then that's different. One poster referred to child drowning in dingy. That's not a shallow splash pool then is it?!

I might not have described it very well. It’s a splash pad (so just lots of sprinkers, fountains, water table and a slide), with a kids pool next to it (the pool is very, very shallow at one end but mid thigh at the ‘deep end’).

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 16/06/2023 10:53

Splash pools are supposed to be shallow. If OP is saying it's mid thigh on her then that's different. One poster referred to child drowning in dingy. That's not a shallow splash pool then is it?!

rookiemere · 16/06/2023 10:33

Monkeymonkeymoo · 16/06/2023 09:08

Thank you for all your replies. DH spoke to reception and they asked the children to get out and go to their parents, they’re back there again on their own this morning though (we walked past on our way out so I’ve mentioned it to the lifeguard and receptionist again).

I’m sure some of the children can swim (and they don’t really need to because the water isn’t that deep). It’s more that they don’t have the water safety skills or risk assessment skills of an adult.
One girl was pulling a smaller child (possibly her sister?) under the water as part of a game, and some of the boys were running around the edge and pushing each other.

I think I probably am a bit ‘overzealous’. I’m a nurse and unfortunately I was on shift when a primary school aged child was brought in after being left unsupervised in fairly shallow water, so maybe it’s something I’m a bit paranoid about. DH is a primary school teacher so again is very aware that children can be prone to sometimes doing something silly without really understanding or thinking through the consequences.
We obviously don’t want responsibility for these children though (and couldn’t look after them properly even if we wanted to).

Well done both of you !

I'm a fairly relaxed DP, but I don't think there is a thing as being too cautious with young DCs <8 being around water, accidents happen all too easily and the time for them to become fatal
Is scarily short.

Stormyweathr · 16/06/2023 09:59

@Monkeymonkeymoo i had a cousin aged 14 who was a strong swimmer who drown. It was a sad loss for us and shows you can never be too cautious so absolutely you have done the right thing

Mammillaria · 16/06/2023 09:52

I saw a toddler very nearly drown in a huge but shallow splash pool some years ago. He had either tripped over or been knocked over and become stuck under a small inflatable dingy.

Fortunately the two children with the dingy realised and screamed for help and some
older children who were playing nearby were able to pull him up until an adult could get to them.

The water was very shallow and the same depth throughout. The toddler was wearing armbands and the water was below his armpit height. His Dad was keeping an eye on him from the side and there were parents everywhere, but no one noticed until the children with the dingy raised the alarm.

By the time his Dad had realised and entered the water another parent had already carried him nearly all the way back to the side. Mum later appeared and had a scream my children (who also had a little dingy purchased from the same pool-side kiosk, but were completely separate to the incident). I was a bit sympathetic because she'd obviously had a nasty shock, but did correct her. However, it taught me how dangerous inflatables can be and I no longer let my children use them if the pool is busy and/or is being used by lots of young children.

Peanutbutteryday · 16/06/2023 09:16

Monkeymonkeymoo · 16/06/2023 09:08

Thank you for all your replies. DH spoke to reception and they asked the children to get out and go to their parents, they’re back there again on their own this morning though (we walked past on our way out so I’ve mentioned it to the lifeguard and receptionist again).

I’m sure some of the children can swim (and they don’t really need to because the water isn’t that deep). It’s more that they don’t have the water safety skills or risk assessment skills of an adult.
One girl was pulling a smaller child (possibly her sister?) under the water as part of a game, and some of the boys were running around the edge and pushing each other.

I think I probably am a bit ‘overzealous’. I’m a nurse and unfortunately I was on shift when a primary school aged child was brought in after being left unsupervised in fairly shallow water, so maybe it’s something I’m a bit paranoid about. DH is a primary school teacher so again is very aware that children can be prone to sometimes doing something silly without really understanding or thinking through the consequences.
We obviously don’t want responsibility for these children though (and couldn’t look after them properly even if we wanted to).

You’re 200% right to be paranoid. It’s water. It’s dangerous. People don’t get it! This is coming from a family of strong swimmers (I used to swim 3-4 times a week before school growing up).

Monkeymonkeymoo · 16/06/2023 09:08

Thank you for all your replies. DH spoke to reception and they asked the children to get out and go to their parents, they’re back there again on their own this morning though (we walked past on our way out so I’ve mentioned it to the lifeguard and receptionist again).

I’m sure some of the children can swim (and they don’t really need to because the water isn’t that deep). It’s more that they don’t have the water safety skills or risk assessment skills of an adult.
One girl was pulling a smaller child (possibly her sister?) under the water as part of a game, and some of the boys were running around the edge and pushing each other.

I think I probably am a bit ‘overzealous’. I’m a nurse and unfortunately I was on shift when a primary school aged child was brought in after being left unsupervised in fairly shallow water, so maybe it’s something I’m a bit paranoid about. DH is a primary school teacher so again is very aware that children can be prone to sometimes doing something silly without really understanding or thinking through the consequences.
We obviously don’t want responsibility for these children though (and couldn’t look after them properly even if we wanted to).

OP posts:
MumblesParty · 16/06/2023 09:05

Oblomov23 · 16/06/2023 08:02

I don't think it's your responsibility to parent other peoples children in a shallow splash pool. You seem over ???? Zealous.

Did you read the post? Perhaps read it again.

Oblomov23 · 16/06/2023 08:02

I don't think it's your responsibility to parent other peoples children in a shallow splash pool. You seem over ???? Zealous.

Saschka · 16/06/2023 07:58

watcherintherye · 15/06/2023 13:59

Even when you can see a tragedy waiting to happen? What an awful attitude. I thought we were being encouraged to make it our business where safeguarding children is concerned?

You can’t physically watch multiple random children in a pool all day though - even if you want to, it just isn’t possible to do it safely.

OP, I really feel for you - last year one mother repeatedly sent her toddler over “to play with” me and DS (who was 6, and had no desire whatsoever to play with a two year old girl who didn’t speak English). The mother would push her towards us and disappear back off into the hotel. It got to the stage where, when we saw them coming, we’d run and get in the deep end so she couldn’t approach us.

MumblesParty · 16/06/2023 07:58

SummerInSun · 15/06/2023 14:50

I think because your DC are so young you may be underestimating the water confidence and safety skills of these kids. My assumption would be that if the parents let them go in the pool by themselves then it's because the parents are comfortable they are safe. After all, some kids swim pretty well by age 4 (not mine, I must say!) and most kids can swim by age 6-7, and are probably fine in a splash area from 4-5. Not your job to second guess the judgment of those parents.

What??!!!!!!

Stormyweathr · 16/06/2023 07:55

If the lifeguard is by where all the adults are I would go to him and tell him you are leaving but I would do it at the top of my voice I would also say very loudly that there are small children unsupervised in there in the hope that the parents of them kids are around and take note of what you are saying, defo make yourself heard around all the said parents

MumblesParty · 16/06/2023 07:51

Summerishere123 · 15/06/2023 13:40

Are the parents not just sat on a sunbed on the side?
My DD wants to be in the pool 90% of the time we are on holiday, even if it is freezing. She has a float strapped on her and is always in my eyeline but I don't stay in with her. She is 7.

How far away is your “eyeline”? And how long are your eyes closed or looking at a book?

Newname211 · 16/06/2023 07:49

MaybeOneAndDone · 15/06/2023 14:46

@Fairyliz As a newish parent with and 18 month old, can I ask how you dealt with this? When I am at playgrounds or softplay, I often get slightly older (but in my opinion far too young to be left unsupervised) kids of around 4 or 5 years old latching on and following me and DS because their own parents have buggered off somewhere.

It's annoying, because I want to spend time with my DS rather than fend off annoying questions from unsupervised kids. I also don't want anyone to get the impression that I am responsible for some stranger's child either.

I don't want to be horrible to the kids in question, but want to make it clear that it's not the job of random adults to entertain them. I have thought about saying "your parents should be doing this with you, please go and find them". Thoughts?

I think your comment comes across as bitchy even though I agree with the sentiment. I usually ask who they are with and then walk them towards their parent, and give their parent a wee wave before I walk off.

I absolutely hate being swarmed by strangers children if I’m in a park or soft play.

Goldencup · 16/06/2023 07:36

As stated here

Other parents leaving their kids in the pool
Talkingfrog · 16/06/2023 07:29

Totally not your responsibility. If ypu and your children want to leave then leave.

I would only say something to them about their behaviour if it involved my child, otherwise it looks as if you are taking responsibility.
If they are behaving in a way you are uncomfortable with then by telling the lifeguard you are making him aware that he needs to be watching incase something happens. You shouldn't need to as he should be observing anyway.

It sounds to me as if the lifeguard is there for the adult pool, and patents should be responsible for children in the other pool.

If their parents aren't concerned enough about their safety to watch them, and the lifeguard isn't either then definitely not your responsibility.

Agree letting the reception staff know of the problem is a good idea. Not sure what they can do other than put up signs or tell the kids they have to leave as not supervised but that is up to them.

Enjoy your holiday.

Againstmachine · 16/06/2023 07:23

I'd tell reception once and that's it not your problem go and enjoy your holiday.

AlmostCharged · 16/06/2023 07:17

I don’t understand why hotels are not more vigilant. If there was a child death on their watch, it could have huge implications for their business if nothing else.

I would absolutely tell the manager. They should then have staff going to the children’s pool and asking any child without a parent there to leave. There should be clear instructions for parents to stay with their children. This is not on you OP.

Goldencup · 16/06/2023 07:17

WandaWonder · 16/06/2023 07:11

Strong swimmers can drown in bath tubs, hot tubs, pools, the sea, lakes anywhere water is

How on earth does being a strong swimmer guarantee you can't drown?

This is true of adults too. When would you let a child out of your sight around (I am assuming) a safe shallow pool ? 8 ?10 ? 12 ? The age groups most likely to drown are toddlers and teens. My suggestion would be that the teens who drown haven't developed water safety skills.