Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how much time off sick some people have?

468 replies

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 12:54

I work in a school and since I started in the sector it’s been a bit of eye opener to me how much sick time some people seem to take, and it always seems to be the same people. Days here and there, sometimes weeks on end then they come back for a bit go off again. As I said always the same people.

The last time I was off was last year when I had Covid, and I was only off because then you still legally had to isolate if positive. I actually felt well enough to go in. Before that I genuinely can’t remember when I was off sick. If I feel bad I just dose myself up and get on with it.

AIBU to think it displays a lack of resilience?

OP posts:
Dinkler · 15/06/2023 16:50

You worry about yourself op.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 15/06/2023 16:41

I started a new job last year. No sick pay. Other women who started same time as me has spent almost half her time off sick. No idea how she's managing to afford it.
I don't have a choice, I need the money.
Don't get me wrong I don't want to go into work when ill but I like having heat, light, food and a roof over my head.

HarpyValley · 15/06/2023 16:36

TickyTok · 15/06/2023 14:44

Potentially unpopular opinion but if someone is so ill that they are "hanging on by a thread" then shouldn't that be a sign to change jobs, quite jobs or accept they need to be on disability payment? Forcing themselves to work through chronic illness or accepting that their colleagues must always pick up the slack doesn't do anyone's health a favour. Most conditions also tend to improve when give sufficient time to relax and recuperate.

There are also many careers that involve freelance work, WFH or flexible hours where the person can fit work around their schedule. Working in an office or in shifts is an ableist structure by design. You need to physically show up somewhere every day, work, and then commute home while juggling all the tasks like groceries or errands outside of those times.

The problem is that the way employee rights have been chipped away can make changing jobs a risky proposition. If you've passed a probation period and the two year mark to gain rights, you have slightly more job security. Plus you need to be in a reasonably good headspace to sell yourself well enough to either apply for different jobs or market yourself as a freelance, which is rarely compatible with a health crisis.

As for the 'freelance, WFH or flexible hours' jobs or claiming PIP...so much to unpack there! The former don't grow on trees, and many a person has been tripped up by a supposedly WFH or flexible hours jobs that in reality turns into office-based and not so flexible. And PIP is a) an in-work benefit and b) insufficient to survive on, assuming most people are paying a mortgage or private rent with their salary.

Most conditions also tend to improve when give sufficient time to relax and recuperate.

Some conditions. Not most. And TBF, 'relaxing and recuperating' is more likely if supported by a decent sick pay policy than being out of work and worrying how the bills will be paid.

Being generous, overall this is a well-meaning but naive view of the realities of living and working with a chronic health condition.

Dreamstate · 15/06/2023 16:34

I think there many be a very small minority who take the micky with sick leave but you could say that about me without really knowing..

For example sometimes but not all the time my tonsillitis can be so bad it absolutely floors me and I can even lose my voice. I get it a few times in a year so I have no choice I just cannot work when its that bad. You might think oh its just tonsillitis what's the big deal just be more resilient but when its that bad I lose my voice its literally me being in bed for a couple days until the antibiotics kick in.

Susuwatariandkodama · 15/06/2023 16:33

YABU, how do you know they don’t have a compromised immune system? Have it had cancer? Or a some form of chronic health issue? It’s not really something most people talk about openly, usually it’s only shared directly with their employer.

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2023 16:31

I don't really understand why people are posting their stories of people pulling sickies when they're blatantly not ill.

That's not what the OP was on about. She was complaining about people being off work when they're not as sick as she thinks they should be, and a lack of "resilience". She thinks there's a minimum standard of illness that people somehow have to pass to be able to stay at home and recuperate.

That's completely different to someone faking an illness to get a longer holiday etc.

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 15/06/2023 16:28

I used to have a customer facing job. I didn't want to be sick as often as I was, but I just kept catching stuff. Some I could work through, some I couldn't. Also, you don't make the company look good if your nose wont stop running so you end up covered in snot. Heck I even went in with what turned out to be laryngitis and all I asked was not to be on the POS that day. I was told no. By mid morning I had no voice left at all and I gave up and went home because my manager wouldn't compromise. I actually felt ok, but you can't work with customers if you can't speak and some of them took it as a personal insult.
Most winters I'd catch something new every week. Without much time in between bugs to recover, I just got sicker and sicker. I blame all the arseholes who came in and spread all their germs around. I really didn't want to take as much time off as I did, but the viral onslaught led to me getting very run down and I developed sinusitis and on another occasion a chest infection.
One of my colleagues boasted about having never taken a day off sick. She was just lucky, whereas I'd just come back having had two weeks off due to swine flu. I suppose I could have gone in, but having a fever over 38 for five days straight and coughing up what looked like massive scabs from my lungs does make it hard.
Some of us just get unlucky when it comes to viruses, no amount of "resilience" seemed to stop me catching every bloody thing going.

aintnospringchicken · 15/06/2023 16:27

I worked for the NHS for nearly 40 years.Over that time I had a couple of periods of being signed off for 6 weeks following surgeries.These periods of sick leave were not by choice.On only 2-3 occasions did I phone in sick.I literally could not get out of bed.The last time I phoned in sick resulted in me being admitted to hospital for a few days.Some people are naturally more susceptible to bugs/viruses /whatever than others.There are also the piss takers who sneeze once and deem themselves too ill to work or who had the habit of being "ill" on a Monday morning after a weekend of clubbing and drinking.

Outsideno9 · 15/06/2023 16:23

I think in education at the moment, you have a lot of people who caught Covid through having no mitigations around hundreds of children and well before they were prioritised for vaccines (it was so obvious teachers needed to be vaccinated if around huge groups who didn't need to be masked, that the general public assumed they had been, though they hadn't) and are suffering the effects of long covid. They're suffering with it more than people are suffering because of their absences.

Avondale89 · 15/06/2023 16:22

Some people do massively take the piss. However there’s no glory in turning up to work unwell. I don’t know why it’s encouraged to just “power through”, instead of taking the time to
properly get well. It’s awful having to work when you’re genuinely ill.

Amy3500 · 15/06/2023 16:22

I taught for over 20 years and at least 6 of them as a supply teacher. The schools needing supply teachers frequently because of people being off generally had poor management, high stress levels, toxic culture or were running teachers and support staff into the ground. Same schools often had the type of culture that forced staff to feel they had to be back in before ready and they would often go off again. I don’t believe for one minute I’ve ever come across a school in which teachers are constantly off just for the sake of it or because of a lack of resilience. I can’t believe anyone who has ever worked in a school would ever write this post.

TallerThanAverage · 15/06/2023 16:20

Balloonsandroses · 15/06/2023 13:03

I’m currently off with an episode of severe depression and have been off since around September last year. I’ve just had 5 months as an inpatient so definitely couldn’t have gone to work then but nonetheless have been terrified that this is exactly how my colleagues will see me and that I am indeed just not resilient enough. It’s a horrible feeling. Being off sick absolutely sucks. I am truly jealous of your good health - please try to be kind to those of us who aren’t blessed with similarly robust good health.

Are you on full pay for six months and then half pay? I’m only cynical about those people who breeze into work after six months off on reduced hours but full pay to ease themselves back into work. It’s miraculous how the prospect of half pay has such healing powers. They’re not well enough at 5 months or even 5 months and two weeks but the moment it’s 6 months hallelujah they’re well enough. They’re the ones that I have an issue with.

babyinthemood · 15/06/2023 16:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ferranteferrante · 15/06/2023 16:19

classrooms are particularly grim places to go to work feeling under the weather. There’s no chance of hiding behind a computer feeling rubbish or cancelling a meeting to make the day manageable. And certainly no working from home! Particularly in a secondary school tough classes are likely to give you a harder time if they sense you’re struggling. I never phoned in sick if I could physically drag myself in though, because setting cover for all your classes at 6am and then dealing with the mess of half done cover work when you get back is almost worse than being there feeling terrible. You also catch everything from the kids. But I often notice new teachers get ill quite a lot - I think it’s the stress plus exposure to so many germs.

kethuphouse · 15/06/2023 16:17

Sick days seem to become more common in my workplace when the sun comes out. So strange.

Locutus2000 · 15/06/2023 16:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cool story. None of that is how it works.

Lightbulbspark · 15/06/2023 16:11

Preps · 15/06/2023 14:32

Oh the naivety. Excessive sickness absence is one of the easiest legal ways to get rid of someone, even when it's all perfectly genuine and certificated.

So much so that the HR support company we use send a "consultant" for sickness absence cases and a "senior consultant" for pretty much everything else.

If you're not well enough to do your job reliably it's easy to be dismissed on ill health capability grounds, unless it's connected to a disability.

That's interesting. Do they suggest support and advice to get the employee working back to capacity again or do they just get rid of them regardless? If the former, is it just going through the formalities before they're let go?

Changechangechanging · 15/06/2023 16:11

Hope you never get genuinely sick, OP, that's all I'm going to say.

Luxell934 · 15/06/2023 16:11

You have a very high and mighty attitude OP. What business is it of yours if people are off sick? Unless you're the manager or HR department shouldn't be any of your concern surely? You can find it annoying or think it shows a lack of resilience all you like but just wait until you're on the other side. Life can change very, very quickly.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 15/06/2023 16:09

Over40Overdating · 15/06/2023 15:05

Haven’t read the whole thread yet but has someone said ‘back in my day’ or talked about workhouses yet?

OP, I hope that if you’re ever diagnosed with a chronic but invisible to busybodies illness, you’ll remember how scathing you are about the resilience of others and just get the fuck on with things rather that expecting empathy or getting angry that most workplaces are set up as factories to squeeze every last drop out of people whatever the cost, rather than supportive work place practices where people aren’t forced to take sick days to cope with stress, MH, heavy periods, fatigue, migraines, personal issues or any one of a number of things that can happen to anyone.

I imagine the ‘kind of people’ you are talking about have a healthier attitude to work and life priorities than you and good for them.
No one is going to give you a medal for working yourself into the ground.

I had hoped that if the covid pandemic taught us anything it would be to not drag yourself intro work if feeling ill (for everyone's sake). Stupid me.

YoucancallmeKAREN · 15/06/2023 16:08

Yes some people do take the mick. I know a paramedic that has been spending half the year off for the last 15 years, how the hell she gets away with it i don't know. Her last period of 2 months and 29 days off sick she spent 3 weeks in florida

HayMaker · 15/06/2023 16:07

stayathomer · 15/06/2023 16:03

Probably a bad day for me to be answering this post but dh is at his colleague’s funeral. People were wondering about him over the last year and more recently. He was diagnosed with mnd only 8 months ago. Most people thought he was taking the piss until he got an actual diagnosis

That’s so sad.

The problem is people can’t mind their own business, they get salty about everything even if it doesn’t affect them. People always make assumptions.
I work for myself now so do as I please but in a previous job I had someone who everyone called lazy - they were battling a serious mental health disorder, but none of them knew so they were awful behind their back.

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2023 16:06

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 13:05

Yes a lack of resilience. People who have several bouts of ‘flu’ a year when it’s probably just a heavy cold (if that). We all know the kind of people I’m talking about.

I think we're all conditioned into thinking we're somehow better people if we struggle into work when we're not feeling great.

But when I'm lying on my death bed and looking back on my life, what am I likely to be thinking:

A) I'm so glad I dragged my arse into work on those days when I felt a bit shitty. Slogging through the day when I felt rotten was worth it.

OR

B) I'm glad I took the time off to rest and recuperate when I didn't feel very well. I'm glad that I made taking care of my well-being a priority.

Quite apart from the fact that going into work when you're unwell spreads germs and could infect others (compromised immune system or not, it's still a shit thing to do)....there's also the fact that what is it about "showing resilience" that is so important? All it means is that you didn't care enough about yourself to take time to recuperate and rest when you weren't feeling well. A heavy cold is a very good reason not to go into work.

I agree people throw the word "flu" around too easily, and I do find that irritating. But I think that's because there's a social pressure to make any illness sound terrible because otherwise people will judge you for not soldiering on.

And I say this as someone who wasn't off sick at all during 11 years in an office, apart from 2 weeks for a miscarriage. I was pregnant with twins, and carried on going in and working extra hours even though I was throwing up constantly all day long. I ended up giving birth prematurely (thankfully the DC are fine now, many years later). But I was stupid and it's taken me years to realise that there's no prizes for not putting yourself first. And for the majority of us who work for companies - rather than doctors, nurses, teachers etc - all you are doing is prioritising their profits over your wellbeing.

I've been self-employed for 13 years+ now and I still have to master the art of taking time off when my body is telling me I need to take a break. But bollocks to resilience. I'm working on looking after myself better and actually I think that's important. Everyone should be encouraged to put their health and welfare first without being shamed. We're shit at encouraging self-care in this country.

stayathomer · 15/06/2023 16:03

Probably a bad day for me to be answering this post but dh is at his colleague’s funeral. People were wondering about him over the last year and more recently. He was diagnosed with mnd only 8 months ago. Most people thought he was taking the piss until he got an actual diagnosis

Mulhollandmagoo · 15/06/2023 16:01

I don't know how I feel about this to be honest, because on one hand' my husband's friend uses his allocated paid sick days every rolling year, he says they're an entitlement so effectively uses them as extra holiday days, so I know these people are out there, but they are the minority.

On the other hand, I do HATE those people who come into work poorly and then make everyone else poorly, it's really frustrating - this happened to me last year around Christmas, I had annual leave booked and spent most of it with a stinking cold, because some martyr came in - did no work just moped around telling everyone how poorly she was, but she came in as it 'wasn't fair' to the rest of us if she was off 🙄

You are of course completely ignoring the fact that when people are off sick - they're not actually taking the piss, which is the case 99.9% of the time, people have health conditions that you don't know about, also that your manager isn't at liberty to tell you about 'flu' could mean anything, it wouldn't be ethical to be told the ins and outs of someone medical information. You don't need to know why someone is off, all you need to be told, is they're off sick today - you don't even need to be told the reason.

People are moving away from work being the be all and end all of their lives now, they are taking their physical and mental wellbeing a much higher priority than burning themselves out for a job - which I think is amazing! You have a really old school attitude, which is thankfully becoming more and more defunct.

Swipe left for the next trending thread