Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how much time off sick some people have?

468 replies

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 12:54

I work in a school and since I started in the sector it’s been a bit of eye opener to me how much sick time some people seem to take, and it always seems to be the same people. Days here and there, sometimes weeks on end then they come back for a bit go off again. As I said always the same people.

The last time I was off was last year when I had Covid, and I was only off because then you still legally had to isolate if positive. I actually felt well enough to go in. Before that I genuinely can’t remember when I was off sick. If I feel bad I just dose myself up and get on with it.

AIBU to think it displays a lack of resilience?

OP posts:
Fortboyard · 16/06/2023 20:36

yanbu I have every sympathy with people who have real illnesses and conditions and it’s often clear who is genuine and who isn’t. Rarely can you prove it but people in the end tend to inadvertently expose their own bullshit. I had one recently off work for weeks and weeks with a sprained ankle. Could have easily worked in a desk based role and a colleague had offered a lift everyday but instead got herself signed off by dr repeatedly. Was seen out and about, even posted on social media. After the 4th two week sick note (ie already had 6 weeks off and planned a further two) she booked 2 weeks holiday (abroad - despite claiming to currently be unable to leave her house) to start immediately at the end of final sick note. management refused holiday and next day she literally strolled in walking completely normally and gave in her notice. The absolute CF I couldn’t believe her total lack of shame.

Florenz · 16/06/2023 20:32

If you employed a cleaner or a gardener who regularly rang you saying they couldn't clean your house or tend your garden that week because they were sick, but expected you to pay them regardless, and you knew someone else you knew could do the job just as well and were a lot more reliable, what would you do?

Achwheesht · 16/06/2023 20:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Florenz · 16/06/2023 20:12

bringincrazyback · 16/06/2023 20:09

If workers aren't well enough to do their job effectively, get rid and give the job to someone else.

What about workers who are usually well enough but need more time off than most? Should they be got rid of too?

Could someone else take the job and do the job just as well or better and have less time off work sick? If the answer is yes, there really isn't a question.

bringincrazyback · 16/06/2023 20:09

If workers aren't well enough to do their job effectively, get rid and give the job to someone else.

What about workers who are usually well enough but need more time off than most? Should they be got rid of too?

bringincrazyback · 16/06/2023 20:08

Oops just realised I mistyped, meant to say against the public sector. Your post still answers the question though.

Florenz · 16/06/2023 18:37

bringincrazyback · 16/06/2023 17:10

You sound like you have a grudge against the private sector?

Not at all, I work in the private sector. I don't have a grudge against the public sector but I do think it could be run far more efficiently and cost-effectively for the benefit of the private sector worker instead of the public sector workers who work within it. And that includes cracking down on absenteeism. If workers aren't well enough to do their job effectively, get rid and give the job to someone else.

bringincrazyback · 16/06/2023 17:10

Florenz · 15/06/2023 21:25

It's not fair on the other people who have to pick up the slack. Or in the public sector, on the private sector workers who have to foot the bill.

You sound like you have a grudge against the private sector?

Superfloop · 16/06/2023 16:13

Also.. unless you are the business owner, I can’t imagine caring that much about some one not being in??

Yes you may have to pick up a little extra work but what happens when people take annual leave for example?

if it has much of an impact on your work then the fault is at the company for not having a system robust enough to cope with someone not being in

Superfloop · 16/06/2023 16:11

Jo176 · 16/06/2023 12:08

So sorry to hear about the pain you went through before you had your lovely family, OP.

Yes, I responded similarly to this post having line-managed women who have gone through similar struggles for many years - and still are. It often results in odd days off here and there and not just for physical reasons. I’ve heard other colleagues say things like “Off again?! She’s only part time as it is!”

Sometimes you find yourselves in a compulsory ‘back to work’ box-ticking meeting with a colleague and when they explain why they’re off frequently, you can’t help but think “Fuck work.” (Of course, I never say this but I try to express the sentiment as professionally as possibly.)

My sister is currently in the constant bug cycle with her little uns. She has a supportive manager though who understands that the motherhood penalty often comes up in terms of children’s illness too, having gone through it herself years ago. My husband’s (male) manager also gets it, which makes my DH a better manager in turn. It’s a parent rite of passage!

It’s heartening to see lots of compassionate people in the replies here though!

You sound like a lovely line manager!

now I’ve moved jobs I have a really sweet manager too and it makes such a difference

most people feel guilty enough taking time off, without other people they work with rolling their eyes and questioning if they are actually sick

trampoline123 · 16/06/2023 14:47

I have a friend at work who has suffered with an autoimmune disease and has been fighting cancer for the last 3 years.

She has come to work Ill and as soon as she needs to take time off people bitch and gossip. It's quite frankly disgusting.

trampoline123 · 16/06/2023 14:42

YABU - you don't know the circumstances, and don't know how many times that person drags themselves when they are poorly.

I have a long term health condition, the times I've dragged myself to work when I should have been in hospital far outweigh the times I've called in sick.

HarpyValley · 16/06/2023 14:38

Having been in post for a few years*

HarpyValley · 16/06/2023 14:38

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 12:25

I was public sector for years. It's 6 months full pay, six months half pay and then nothing iirc.

I realise that it's generous compared to the private sector, but it shouldn't be a race to the bottom.

Especially at a time when the NHS is so fucked that anything that you need to see a consultant for, or that requires surgery, has such a long wait that people will be more unwell and in a lot more pain for longer than they used to be.

That may still be true for NHS but for many public sector departments it's one of the T&Cs that has been chipped away at, so several top out at 5 months not 6, and that's after having been in post for a few months. For many new starters it's one month full / one month half and increases incrementally with years in post. Which I appreciate is still generous compared to many policies, but as the PP says it shouldn't be a race to the bottom.

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 12:25

Ninjasan · 15/06/2023 15:13

It's public sector mainly. Ulimited full pay sick leave must be great. I have 6 (six) full pay sick leave days per year allowed at work - private sector obviously.

I was public sector for years. It's 6 months full pay, six months half pay and then nothing iirc.

I realise that it's generous compared to the private sector, but it shouldn't be a race to the bottom.

Especially at a time when the NHS is so fucked that anything that you need to see a consultant for, or that requires surgery, has such a long wait that people will be more unwell and in a lot more pain for longer than they used to be.

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 12:14

loislovesstewie · 16/06/2023 11:29

Well, I'm currently trying to get PIP for my adult child who is now severely sight impaired, as well as already having a host of other medical conditions. I'm fully prepared to take the matter to a tribunal because I know that refusals are really just about saving money. The government don't give a toss about people with disabilities, or the people who care for them. As a nation I think we have also swallowed the line about shirkers so people suffer.

I really hope he gets it, @loislovesstewie . There's a good PIP thread in the Money Matters section on here, where you'll get loads of good advice.

Especially helpful if the form hasn't gone in yet!

Jo176 · 16/06/2023 12:08

Superfloop · 16/06/2023 09:21

In my old job people probably thought I was “one of those” who was often going off sick. The only person who knew why was my manager. I went through 4 miscarriages, with two of them being at 12/13 weeks, in the space of a year - surgery, tests, appointments, investigations, heartbreak, counselling, trauma. Not exactly something I want to broadcast round the office, and no one’s business to judge how often I was off.

Now I have two nursery age kids. Sometimes they bring bugs home with them and I have to look after them or get it myself. this often works out at “one or two days here and there” - it’s more minor and annoying but still warrants time off as much as my previous more serious issues.

of course there is the odd person that tries to manipulate using sick leave but you don’t know everything about the people you work with and you have no right to judge them

So sorry to hear about the pain you went through before you had your lovely family, OP.

Yes, I responded similarly to this post having line-managed women who have gone through similar struggles for many years - and still are. It often results in odd days off here and there and not just for physical reasons. I’ve heard other colleagues say things like “Off again?! She’s only part time as it is!”

Sometimes you find yourselves in a compulsory ‘back to work’ box-ticking meeting with a colleague and when they explain why they’re off frequently, you can’t help but think “Fuck work.” (Of course, I never say this but I try to express the sentiment as professionally as possibly.)

My sister is currently in the constant bug cycle with her little uns. She has a supportive manager though who understands that the motherhood penalty often comes up in terms of children’s illness too, having gone through it herself years ago. My husband’s (male) manager also gets it, which makes my DH a better manager in turn. It’s a parent rite of passage!

It’s heartening to see lots of compassionate people in the replies here though!

loislovesstewie · 16/06/2023 11:29

Well, I'm currently trying to get PIP for my adult child who is now severely sight impaired, as well as already having a host of other medical conditions. I'm fully prepared to take the matter to a tribunal because I know that refusals are really just about saving money. The government don't give a toss about people with disabilities, or the people who care for them. As a nation I think we have also swallowed the line about shirkers so people suffer.

Apricotflanday · 16/06/2023 11:26

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 11:11

I work in welfare rights, and exclusively with clients with MH problems, but plenty of them have physically problems as well.

I do 2-4 PIP applications a month, only around 40%-50% are successful. I then appeal them. My appeals are 100% successful. (The low initial success rate isn't because I'm shite at the applications, it's a little higher than the average for my team, and the team's success rate at appeals is in the high 90's.)

If it was easy to "milk the system", I doubt if the success rate for appeals would be so high.

Staying on earnings replacement benefits because you're sick isn't easy either. It's hard to get deemed incapable of working, and the success rate for those appeals is incredibly high, too.

They're even trying to get carers back to work now. A friend is FT carer for her 15YO son, who has a autism and MH issues, and gets carer's allowance. She's also getting ESA for herself, albeit only at the basic rate (and reduced somewhat because she gets carer's allowance as well).

She was summoned to an appointment at the job centre to be interrogated about what she was doing to find a job, and her response that she was a FT carer was ignored. I'm going to go with her next time, armed with a copy of the rules and regulations.

All of which is why I know that it's hard to "milk the system" when it comes to health benefits, and that the (imo few) people that succeed should take up acting, because they must be bloody good.

If you haven't seen it, @hattie43 , I reommend the film "I, Daniel Blake". For people working in welfare rights, it felt like watching a documentary, it was so true to life.

Exactly.

And why don't people who make up lies about people 'milking' the system stop to think about why people might want to do that, if it were true?

A happy, healthy society would mean happy, healthy work environments people looked forward to participating in; if people really are going to desperate and illegal measures, risking imprisonment and poverty, for meagre incomes on precarious benefits, there must be something terribly, disastrously wrong with workplaces, colleagues and working environments to be causing this. The focus ought be on fixing that, on making work fulfilling and worthwhile.

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 11:11

hattie43 · 15/06/2023 13:53

I read that the government needs to find an extra 19 billion a year to pay benefits of the long term sick now . A staggering amount of money .
Lazy / sick note Britain and I'm sure we all know people who milk the system.

I work in welfare rights, and exclusively with clients with MH problems, but plenty of them have physically problems as well.

I do 2-4 PIP applications a month, only around 40%-50% are successful. I then appeal them. My appeals are 100% successful. (The low initial success rate isn't because I'm shite at the applications, it's a little higher than the average for my team, and the team's success rate at appeals is in the high 90's.)

If it was easy to "milk the system", I doubt if the success rate for appeals would be so high.

Staying on earnings replacement benefits because you're sick isn't easy either. It's hard to get deemed incapable of working, and the success rate for those appeals is incredibly high, too.

They're even trying to get carers back to work now. A friend is FT carer for her 15YO son, who has a autism and MH issues, and gets carer's allowance. She's also getting ESA for herself, albeit only at the basic rate (and reduced somewhat because she gets carer's allowance as well).

She was summoned to an appointment at the job centre to be interrogated about what she was doing to find a job, and her response that she was a FT carer was ignored. I'm going to go with her next time, armed with a copy of the rules and regulations.

All of which is why I know that it's hard to "milk the system" when it comes to health benefits, and that the (imo few) people that succeed should take up acting, because they must be bloody good.

If you haven't seen it, @hattie43 , I reommend the film "I, Daniel Blake". For people working in welfare rights, it felt like watching a documentary, it was so true to life.

OpenDoors72 · 16/06/2023 10:45

OpenDoors72 · 16/06/2023 10:44

Right, now imagine 4/6 of your team are off for 6+ months with no cover.

That happened to mr at one job. I ended up working 12+ hour days including Saturday work.

I told the company post-offer I had bipolar. Since I wasn't an employee, no-one cared about my rights. I had a total of 5 sick days (one week - flu) in 9 months. I was then called into a meeting a criticised for taking time off when I 'knew they were understaffed.'

  • Me not Mr.

I only do solo work now. I reject projects where I end up carrying employees.

OpenDoors72 · 16/06/2023 10:44

Shamefulsecrets0 · 15/06/2023 18:01

My colleague has been off sick for 6 months now, and yes the workload is increased but if we cant handle it we take that to the manager to deal with. The only thing anyone has said is to comment that we hope they are well and get better soon/and that we miss them. We know she's genuinely very unwell, must of us have no idea what's actually wrong with her because we don't need too. We have a pretty relaxed team and we're all friends but even so I couldn't imagine any of my managers thinking it was appropriate to gossip about an employees personal life and health issues.

Right, now imagine 4/6 of your team are off for 6+ months with no cover.

That happened to mr at one job. I ended up working 12+ hour days including Saturday work.

I told the company post-offer I had bipolar. Since I wasn't an employee, no-one cared about my rights. I had a total of 5 sick days (one week - flu) in 9 months. I was then called into a meeting a criticised for taking time off when I 'knew they were understaffed.'

LakieLady · 16/06/2023 10:43

bryceQ · 16/06/2023 09:51

I never used to get unwell, then after a horrific chronic pain experience to years I was so run down I couldn't stop getting ill.

In one year I had terrible shingles, tonsillitis, infected wisdom tooth, a migraine monthly where I couldn't move, covid twice, and a horrendous sickness bug. I was absolutely demented. I have always been a healthy person I'm early 30s.

What could i have done? I work for myself so no sick pay but it was just vile.

I had 4-5 years like that in my late 30s.

I got chicken pox, which left me really low for a long while afterwards, followed by repeated attacks of shingles, a kidney infection that nearly put me in hospital, flu (which I've only had 3 times in 30 years), concussion from a fall, gastric problems that turned out to be a hiatus hernia after loads of tests and time off, viral pneumonia, food poisoning (campylobacter, so again left me low for several weeks) from a meal in a pub that nearly got closed down because their kitchen was so filthy, and chronic sinusitis that eventually equired surgery.

And back then I suffered from frequent migraines that had me vomitting up to 12 times an hour for 24-48 hours, and I was asked at work why I couldn't just take painkillers and go in.

Eventually, I was dismissed under the capability procedure: I couldn't do my job because my attendance was so poor.

Things started to improve after that. I got a job with a charity that was WFH and hardly ever got anything worse than a cold, a newly-qualified GP prescribed me anti-sickness meds in suppository form, so I could take my migraine meds without puking them up 5 minutes later, and I was really pretty well, although arthritis started to be a problem when I hit my mid-50s.

When my partner died, I hadn't had a single day's sick leave for over 2, maybe 3, years, and have only had one day off in 18 months (my old friend shingles again!).

There are 6 on my team, I'm nearly 68 and have the best absence record out of everyone. WFH makes a big difference imo, I don't catch much from people and can choose where I sit to work. I represented someone at a benefit tribunal from my bed once, when my back was bad - telephone hearings are great for that!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2023 10:43

Berlinlover · 16/06/2023 10:14

Maybe don’t keep getting Covid jabs?

If you read the post, the first one wasn’t recognised…..🙄 which is why l thought the next one would be ok.

But thanks for your advice. That’s something I’d obviously never thought of..🤨

OpenDoors72 · 16/06/2023 10:33

Nospringchix · 16/06/2023 10:19

Couldn't have said it better!
I've got chronic conditions and being judged is just another thing to deal with on top of them.
Being judged when I had a severe bout of depression was the worst. I came close to suicide because of it, the only thing that stopped me was the thought of my family who would be left behind.
Please think twice before judging OP.

Lots of people with severe depression do continue to work without taking time off though.

You can't tell by looking at someone what they have.

My issue is some companies have serial long-term sick leave types and the resilient staff (who also have mental health issues) but a different attitude, end up covering for them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread