Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how much time off sick some people have?

468 replies

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 12:54

I work in a school and since I started in the sector it’s been a bit of eye opener to me how much sick time some people seem to take, and it always seems to be the same people. Days here and there, sometimes weeks on end then they come back for a bit go off again. As I said always the same people.

The last time I was off was last year when I had Covid, and I was only off because then you still legally had to isolate if positive. I actually felt well enough to go in. Before that I genuinely can’t remember when I was off sick. If I feel bad I just dose myself up and get on with it.

AIBU to think it displays a lack of resilience?

OP posts:
Lolabear38 · 15/06/2023 14:38

I voted YABU because you don’t actually know why a lot of people are off sick. My best friend, for eg, has a debilitating medical condition that has required she take a lot of time off over the last few months. Her head teacher knows about it and has approved all the time off (and offered more). My friend doesn’t want to tell the rest of the staff what it is - nor should she have to - but that hasn’t stopped other people in her team repeatedly ask her what’s wrong and where she is. Presumably the leadership team at your school know what’s going on and are ok with it therefore you should probably mind your own business.

MysteryBelle · 15/06/2023 14:37

Swg · 15/06/2023 14:34

I'm one of those people with lots of time off. Currently on long term sick and even when I go back I'm likely to have a fair amount off on a regular basis.

Started out as just "tiredness" and every single bug knocking me over. Ended up as gallbladder exploding and causing pancreatis at the same time I got the cancer diagnosis. I've no doubt that before the diagnosis came in people were sniffing about my resilience.

I've had three ops. I have meds I will be on for life. I have long term side effects. What I actually need is a year or two to rehabilitate and build my strength back up so I don't get knocked out by a sniffle when I go back. However my office refuse to either retire me on medical grounds or allow me to take a chunk of unpaid leave and resigning would lose my length of service so on the sick I stay.

You deserve support, I hope things improve. You are definitely not who op means, I’m sure. ❤️

MrsLB123 · 15/06/2023 14:35

YABU

I used to think like that, until I had children. Before having children/being pregnant, I had maybe 1 day off sick in about 5/6 years. After breeding the little germ bags, I honestly catch everything going and starting suffering with migraines, and adding the exhaustion of being a parent, I cant cope at work like I used to when unwell.

Good for you that you are able too, but you are not everyone else. You don't know what they are going through, or what they are able to cope it

Swg · 15/06/2023 14:34

I'm one of those people with lots of time off. Currently on long term sick and even when I go back I'm likely to have a fair amount off on a regular basis.

Started out as just "tiredness" and every single bug knocking me over. Ended up as gallbladder exploding and causing pancreatis at the same time I got the cancer diagnosis. I've no doubt that before the diagnosis came in people were sniffing about my resilience.

I've had three ops. I have meds I will be on for life. I have long term side effects. What I actually need is a year or two to rehabilitate and build my strength back up so I don't get knocked out by a sniffle when I go back. However my office refuse to either retire me on medical grounds or allow me to take a chunk of unpaid leave and resigning would lose my length of service so on the sick I stay.

Preps · 15/06/2023 14:32

LadyKenya · 15/06/2023 14:28

Sacked? If you had doctors notes, and proof that you were sick with these conditions, I would have gone to CAB for advice.

Oh the naivety. Excessive sickness absence is one of the easiest legal ways to get rid of someone, even when it's all perfectly genuine and certificated.

So much so that the HR support company we use send a "consultant" for sickness absence cases and a "senior consultant" for pretty much everything else.

If you're not well enough to do your job reliably it's easy to be dismissed on ill health capability grounds, unless it's connected to a disability.

HeckinBamboozled · 15/06/2023 14:29

FFS - you don't know the full picture of what's going on in people's lives. MYOB.

TBH I've had three days of over the past two years as I work from home and am happy to return to work once the initial stage of a cold is over. I've never taken much sick leave until I had a freak issue that would only be resolved by surgery and was off for eight weeks while waiting for my operation. Luckily for me they pushed it forward for me or I would have been off for three to six months going by current wait times. Believe me, if I could have gotten it resolved faster I would have.

AcrossthePond55 · 15/06/2023 14:29

Had a boss like OP. She never took a sick day, even when she was sick as a dog and obviously feverish. She'd infect us all then complain about us being 'babies' when as a result half the unit was out sick or someone had to have a week off with her nasty bug. So I wonder how 'resilient' OP is or if she just goes into work when she should really stay at home out of consideration of her work mates (and their families).

But yes, I've had a few coworkers with what we always called 'Monday- or Friday-itis', especially around 3 day weekends. And also a few who milked the system But by a large none of my coworkers (over my 30+ year career) were leave 'abusers', especially those with chronic illnesses. By and large I found those coworkers to be the most determined to get to work and not be 'defeated' by their illness.

Straightsidedcircle · 15/06/2023 14:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Straightsidedcircle · 15/06/2023 14:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mayorofcasterbridge · 15/06/2023 14:28

user1466068383 · 15/06/2023 14:16

I'm sure there are skivers out there, but I do think there is also a lot of genuinely ill people who are hanging on by a thread.
I have a friend who is a very resilient person, but with very bad luck. they have depression, and at the end of the last year had the double whammy of having their usual medication discontinued in the UK and catching covid in the same month. I watched them become an absolute shell of themselves as they dealt with serious depression and a very serious bout of covid. This person is 31, and usually healthy, I've never seen anyone so low and ill, it was very scary. Fortunately they finally got some help and have found a new medication that works. However they had to take a month off work during the worst period - which their work very graciously granted them as they completely understood the circumstances.
They are on the mend, but are still struggling health wise and regularly having to take a day off here and there. They feel so incredibly guilty about the pressure this is putting on their colleauges, they are seriously considering giving up their good job as they don't think it's right to carry on and lean so much on their colleague. It's an incredibly complicated problem, I see where they're coming from, it isn't fair on the people they work with, but it also seems very tough on my friend - to give up a regular good income because of their brain chemistry and covid. I wish there was an answer that could help everyone.
All I can say is I'd be careful to judge anyone, as you never really know whats going on - they may be skiving or they may be going through the worst time of the lives, and I really don't think it comes down to resilience especially in the current post-covid, cost of living and health crisis climate.

Ah the old money thing! People like you (and sometimes me too, I will be honest - you can usually tell!) talk about miraculous recoveries when absentees are about to go into half pay. I have learned personally that I have to go back at a certain point because I can't afford it.

The reason for my depression is primarily work-related.

"OR is it crap employers, poor management, people being told they CAN'T have the day(s) off that they desire, because there's no cover....loads of work piled on them because there's too few staff for the workload, low pay, and a low amount of holiday days, so that people feel they NEED 2-3 weeks 'sick time' just to get a bit more time off".

That's exactly it! I have a manager who is an extreme micromanager. It really affects my confidence and motivation and they refuse to back off. I found myself in a really bad place, couldn't eat or sleep - I had to get away from them. I know they are not going to change. I know that their manager is worse if anything. I couldn't take the stress of making a formal complaint (which would probably get shut down anyway after taking years to investigate). I am too old to look for another job. I need my salary... trapped.

I bet @Enfys1982 you are still young. Resilience can diminish as you get older, more health conditions, disillusioned and regretful. I do hope you are not in any kind of caring role.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 15/06/2023 14:28

When my MH absolutely dive bombed and I had a lot of time off work, I told my colleagues it was flu, or a stomach bug, or a migraine. Because the truth was none of their fucking business. I don’t care what they thought of me tbh.

In the end I had a total breakdown and had to leave my job.

LadyKenya · 15/06/2023 14:28

fyn · 15/06/2023 14:03

I got sacked by someone like you for being off too much in one year. I was off twice - once week with shingles and a few days with a severe chest infection exacerbated by my chronic asthma. I was made to occupational health and then sacked. I imagine he thought I wasn’t resilient too.

Sacked? If you had doctors notes, and proof that you were sick with these conditions, I would have gone to CAB for advice.

NurseryNurse10 · 15/06/2023 14:26

I work in nurseries and know what you mean. It's almost a surprise to see them at work because they never seem to be there. I don't fully know the circumstances behind it however so I don't want to judge.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/06/2023 14:25

lieselotte · 15/06/2023 13:08

I don't think it shows a lack of resilience in the education sector. If you are a teacher or working with kids, you need to be fit and healthy. You can't teach effectively if you feel grotty.

If I feel grotty I can stay at home and monitor emails while feeling sorry for myself with Lemsip and lots of tea. It's a very different issue. Working from home in general reduces sick leave as you don't have the travel, and you can lie down for an hour and get work done around resting.

Also, you're in an environment where you are more likely to be exposed to nasty bugs. Especially with younger children.

I used to think I had a decent immune system... Until I had a child who we dubbed the typhoid toddler for a while. He's trot off to nursery get some bug (of which he would recover really quickly) whisky taking out me and my husband for a few days. With WFH jobs we can muddle through if not too serious... But in a school setting, that's not so achievable.

Sloth66 · 15/06/2023 14:23

The issue isn’t so much taking time off sick in itself. If someone is genuinely unwell, they need to be off work.

but yes, I’ve met people who would be off for weeks, back for a couple of days, then off again. The same people who were all over Facebook detailing holidays, nights out and even their second jobs.
we had someone like this who would openly admit she didn’t want to work, and could easily get sick notes. Now thanks to her, our work has decided to tighten up sickness allowance and it’s affecting the genuinely unwell staff.

Inertia · 15/06/2023 14:23

I have found the complete opposite in education-colleagues battle on through illness because getting cover is so difficult, and consistency for children is so important . You also have to set all the work and often come back to a pile of marking- it’s less stressful to just go in and teach while ill.

We obviously had to follow covid rules while they were in place, but otherwise people tend to be off for major things like operations, long term serious illness etc.

TellerTuesday · 15/06/2023 14:22

I have come across plenty of skivers in my time don't get me wrong but there are plenty of people who are just unlucky when it comes to illness.

I think I had 2 days off sick with food poisoning pre child (so more than 11 years ago now) and that's the only instance I've ever had in 23 years of working but I also realise that next week I could be struck down with something and need time off, then I could get back and end up with something else not long after, just how it goes.

DD for example made it all way from reception to Year 4 without having a single day off sick, even the school office said it was practically unheard of. Got into year 5 and her attendance is an all time low - she got covid, wasn't long back after that and she had chickenpox, then there was a bout of gastroenteritis and then conjunctivitis just the other week so 4 lots of illness in one year.

kizziee · 15/06/2023 14:21

@Balloonsandroses Flowers hope things are starting to improve for you

brunettemic · 15/06/2023 14:18

It’s certainly not unique to education. A lot of people are smart with sick pay/paid sick leave and they end up treating it as effectively additional annual leave. We know there’s people in our business that do it, they know how mock they get, how much they’ve had in the rolling 12 months etc and game the system accordingly. It’s very difficult to do anything about as far as I know.

user1466068383 · 15/06/2023 14:16

I'm sure there are skivers out there, but I do think there is also a lot of genuinely ill people who are hanging on by a thread.
I have a friend who is a very resilient person, but with very bad luck. they have depression, and at the end of the last year had the double whammy of having their usual medication discontinued in the UK and catching covid in the same month. I watched them become an absolute shell of themselves as they dealt with serious depression and a very serious bout of covid. This person is 31, and usually healthy, I've never seen anyone so low and ill, it was very scary. Fortunately they finally got some help and have found a new medication that works. However they had to take a month off work during the worst period - which their work very graciously granted them as they completely understood the circumstances.
They are on the mend, but are still struggling health wise and regularly having to take a day off here and there. They feel so incredibly guilty about the pressure this is putting on their colleauges, they are seriously considering giving up their good job as they don't think it's right to carry on and lean so much on their colleague. It's an incredibly complicated problem, I see where they're coming from, it isn't fair on the people they work with, but it also seems very tough on my friend - to give up a regular good income because of their brain chemistry and covid. I wish there was an answer that could help everyone.
All I can say is I'd be careful to judge anyone, as you never really know whats going on - they may be skiving or they may be going through the worst time of the lives, and I really don't think it comes down to resilience especially in the current post-covid, cost of living and health crisis climate.

MrsRachelDanvers · 15/06/2023 14:13

Oh come on-we all know there are certain people you work with who abuse the system. Can’t get their holiday? Go off sick. Don’t feel like coming in? Go off sick. Have a difficult day at work? Go off sick. If you’ve never worked with people like that, you’re lucky. There are people who have conditions where I work who make the effort and no one begrudges their time off-but the ones who game the system, taking advantage of our generous sick leave system who really piss me off-because we have to cover for them. And then when they’ve used up all their sick leave? Funny how they’re never off when they’re going to lose money.

ChristmasFluff · 15/06/2023 14:12

People coming in with heavy colds are a fucking liability and cause illnesses that run rife in school - and get taken home to kill the vulnerable.

I'm glad more people are staying home when they are ill. Funny how if you call it COVID everyone cares about the vulnerable - but they never do with any other contagious illness.

MysteryBelle · 15/06/2023 14:11

littleripper · 15/06/2023 14:07

You are right OP. Per year averages: 7.9 days in public sector, 5.1 days in private sector. I am self employed and have taken 1 day off (I was in hospital with pneumonia) in 25 years. A friend of mine has been off sick for over 5 months - she is an admin in a school. She says she is tired and has CFS. But she travels widely, drinks heavily every weekend etc. I think it is shocking.

Good example of someone who is actively deceiving others to do whatever she wants and expects everyone to rally around her and not state the obvious. If they do, they will be shunned or punished as she has enough clout to make it happen. Meanwhile she gets away with her manipulations and benefits from them.

Jo176 · 15/06/2023 14:11

Do you know the colleagues I find more annoying? The ones who come in sneezing everywhere.

I hope you aren’t a senior leader or something OP as you sound narrow-minded. I have line-managed many who needed several odd days off for reasons including mental health and their children’s poor health.

WonderingWanda · 15/06/2023 14:10

As everyone has pointed out. You get all extremes. In education it's incredibly common for teachers to struggle in because the thought of setting the cover and then picking up all those classes when the work hasn't been done is so daunting. The problem with that and the intense workload is that you get burn out so you will get lots of staff with long term stress related issues.

I imagine it's the same in the NHS, people struggling in because they don't want to leave their colleagues understaffed and overstretched and again it leads to burn out.

I don't really have much experience of other jobs I can tell you that everyone I know works at home, at all hours and the pressure is so much more relentless with email and everything being online. I think we have quite unhealthy work habits in the UK.