Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how much time off sick some people have?

468 replies

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 12:54

I work in a school and since I started in the sector it’s been a bit of eye opener to me how much sick time some people seem to take, and it always seems to be the same people. Days here and there, sometimes weeks on end then they come back for a bit go off again. As I said always the same people.

The last time I was off was last year when I had Covid, and I was only off because then you still legally had to isolate if positive. I actually felt well enough to go in. Before that I genuinely can’t remember when I was off sick. If I feel bad I just dose myself up and get on with it.

AIBU to think it displays a lack of resilience?

OP posts:
Circe7 · 15/06/2023 14:57

I was so healthy until I had children. No days off in about 5 years not because I was particularly resilient but because I was genuinely never ill. Now I’m sleep deprived and catch everything that comes home from nursery. I work through most of it but only because I can work from home. And you can’t really work through having a fever or norovirus. So I have had a few days off for those. I can only imagine how much worse it is if you have chronic health conditions.

Stickybackplasticbear · 15/06/2023 14:57

Greenqueen40 · 15/06/2023 13:21

I would have thought it was obvious the OP wasn't talking about people with cancer or serious illnesses! But yes so may people take the piss, especially within organisations like the NHS where its near enough impossible to get rid of anyone.

Oh yeah I forgot everyone with cancer or long term health conditions wears a sticker... Oh wait no they don't. So how do you know who you're talking about?

technotstarnotechstar · 15/06/2023 14:57

I agree. There are of course people who have chronic conditions, depression and a bad run of illness but there are also a lot who take the piss. I think it's a real societal problem at the moment. It's great because at last people are understanding of mental health but now it means a lot of people ride along on that wave..it's a shame because it means there will be a backlash at some point and it takes sympathy away from.those that need it.

MysteryBelle · 15/06/2023 14:56

Swg · 15/06/2023 14:46

The problem is I'm not now because I have a diagnosis - and once the c word is mentioned people go very quiet. But there were three or four months off sick before a diagnosis where even a nurse in my GP told me I wasn't really that sick and accused me of health anxiety. And about six months before that of periodic absence because I was getting ill so often and so easily. I probably feel better day to day now than I did then because I actually have meds.

"Tired all the time" is a symptom of an awful lot of things but it looks just like a lack of resilience and whining. Its hard to explain that by "Tired" you mean "I can no longer bend and pick up the saucers to feed the cats so I'm buying pouches I can empty into them whilst standing" and not just "well everyone gets tired".

You’re absolutely right. It’s people who are genuinely struggling that we should all support and you should have gotten that support from the beginning. Weirdly, it’s the ones who are putting on who get the support and the ones like you who actually deserve it who don’t. It’s very unfair. My mil once made a speech at church, yes church, where she complained about people who “claim to be tired” and I think she meant me. She had no idea what I was going through because I’m a private person. I do think people find out who really cares about them and who doesn’t, by how they’re judged.

Viviennemary · 15/06/2023 14:56

I absolutely agree. There are some chancers around who will grab any chance of a few duvet days when there is nothing wrong with tnem. And leave others to pick up the slack. No conscience whatsoever.

Sunshineishere1988 · 15/06/2023 14:56

user1466068383 · 15/06/2023 13:45

I saw my Dr recently who said a lot of people have been unusually and often ill at the moment. She said they are now finding they covid has a serious affect on your immune system, and even wipes out immunity you’d built up previously to colds, flus and sickness bugs and it was normal to catch more illness in the six - eight months post a covid bout. Even if you weren’t very ill with covid. She was saying that this, coupled with the very cold winter, the energy crisis and the natural rise in bugs following normal social mixing post lockdowns was making the perfect storm for people to really struggle with staying well.

And this is totally backed up by a Winter full of every type of bug going at our school (and every other school hearing from friends). Theres bugs still going round now and this is meant to be the time everyone’s well, sunshine, loads of Vit D! The kids hadn’t mixed in the same way for the last few years, so everyone got everything going. Hopefully they can all start to build up stronger immunity again and it can be a less germ ridden winter! 😅

Catchasingmewithspiders · 15/06/2023 14:56

Bluebells1970 · 15/06/2023 14:53

Every day you are absent with a GP note, you are costing your employer money. And yes you may have chronic illness/MH conditions, whatever genuine reason for that absence but the reality is that only larger organisations can effectively absorb this cost. As a small business owner, it is a huge cost to us. Someone off recently was costing us over £800 a month with the cost of their SSP, NI, pension contribution and accrued leave but with zero work output. We've been hit by massive price hikes in energy, supplies, wages and running costs and yet being signed off is seen a massive right for a lot of people especially on MN.

Being signed of sick and getting SSP is a massive right and one that was hard fought for.

What's the other option? People starve if they break a leg?

SheWentWest · 15/06/2023 14:55

If I get a heavy cold I need a couple
of days to sleep it off and regroup. If I carry on working it trends to get worse and tune into a sinus infection and need a week off. So I’ve learnt to take a coupe of days instead. Maybe let other people sort themselves out. We aren’t robots.

Bluebells1970 · 15/06/2023 14:53

Every day you are absent with a GP note, you are costing your employer money. And yes you may have chronic illness/MH conditions, whatever genuine reason for that absence but the reality is that only larger organisations can effectively absorb this cost. As a small business owner, it is a huge cost to us. Someone off recently was costing us over £800 a month with the cost of their SSP, NI, pension contribution and accrued leave but with zero work output. We've been hit by massive price hikes in energy, supplies, wages and running costs and yet being signed off is seen a massive right for a lot of people especially on MN.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 15/06/2023 14:52

TickyTok · 15/06/2023 14:44

Potentially unpopular opinion but if someone is so ill that they are "hanging on by a thread" then shouldn't that be a sign to change jobs, quite jobs or accept they need to be on disability payment? Forcing themselves to work through chronic illness or accepting that their colleagues must always pick up the slack doesn't do anyone's health a favour. Most conditions also tend to improve when give sufficient time to relax and recuperate.

There are also many careers that involve freelance work, WFH or flexible hours where the person can fit work around their schedule. Working in an office or in shifts is an ableist structure by design. You need to physically show up somewhere every day, work, and then commute home while juggling all the tasks like groceries or errands outside of those times.

This is probably all true. But it's not going to be easy to switch jobs if your sickness level is high. If you quit your job you can't claim benefits straight away so unless you've got a ton of savings/ another income you can't quit (I had to wait to be sacked, which looks worse on my CV quitting for health reasons, but meant I could afford to live)
Disability benefits are really hard to get. I was turned down despite being so ill I hardly ever left the house. Apparently the fact I could plan a bus/train journey and go to church once per week (a friend used to collect me) meant I wasn't anxious enough.

@kizziee thank you. I'm well enough now that I'm starting to look for a part time job. I want to take it slowly and not go full time straight away.

Swg · 15/06/2023 14:52

TickyTok · 15/06/2023 14:44

Potentially unpopular opinion but if someone is so ill that they are "hanging on by a thread" then shouldn't that be a sign to change jobs, quite jobs or accept they need to be on disability payment? Forcing themselves to work through chronic illness or accepting that their colleagues must always pick up the slack doesn't do anyone's health a favour. Most conditions also tend to improve when give sufficient time to relax and recuperate.

There are also many careers that involve freelance work, WFH or flexible hours where the person can fit work around their schedule. Working in an office or in shifts is an ableist structure by design. You need to physically show up somewhere every day, work, and then commute home while juggling all the tasks like groceries or errands outside of those times.

Sure if you can.

There's a cost of living crisis on if you haven't noticed. Switching jobs frequently puts people in a worse financial position. Going onto disability definitely does. Starting a new job means you can be sacked within two years for any non protected reason which if you think you're likely to have a poor sickness record is a big risk. And people may have something like income protection insurance which won't pay out for resignation but will for being sacked on medical grounds, or a pension which would only take early retirement on medical grounds if you don't resign first.

Onefootinthegroove · 15/06/2023 14:52

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 13:05

Yes a lack of resilience. People who have several bouts of ‘flu’ a year when it’s probably just a heavy cold (if that). We all know the kind of people I’m talking about.

Yes, my psychopathic un empathetic ex line manager said the same about me . I " put it on" apparently. Christ, I must be some actress if I can con a cardiologist and various invasive tests. I'd been having a run of heart attacks - they present differently sometimes in women. Instead of getting Occupational health involved once I was diagnosed she put me on a performance plan. Obviously she was under the impression that I could just will my heart to work properly and was not trying hard enough. HR did get involved but by god, she wade a worrying time truly shitty.
NEVER assume that someone is swinging the lead.

youcandanceifyouwanna · 15/06/2023 14:51

It's always hard to know someones individual circumstances and I tend to believe people when they phone in sick. Unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise. One of my colleagues was off sick for months and months and appeared on a tv show during that time (while prerecorded, we knew when it had been filmed) Without going into too much detail it was obvious his symptoms weren't as he had claimed. He didn't come back to work.

allthebeautifulflowers · 15/06/2023 14:51

hattie43 · 15/06/2023 13:53

I read that the government needs to find an extra 19 billion a year to pay benefits of the long term sick now . A staggering amount of money .
Lazy / sick note Britain and I'm sure we all know people who milk the system.

Perhaps if you read a little more, you'd understand the drivers behind increasing rates of disability.l and sickness absence. For example:

  • many people are experiencing long-term ill health because under- resourcing the NHS is leaving people with untreated conditions
  • many people are experiencing unmanageable levels of stress and mental ill health, after struggling through the pandemic and then working on with high workloads and staff shortages, for wages that are increasingly inadequate.
  • a worryingly large number of people have long covid.

I fall into both the last two categories and I'm indirectly affected by the first. Since catching covid when I was utterly burned out by my public sector job (and caring for my husband who can't get the mental health support he needs). I've been bedbound with long covid for months.

Hardly any of my colleagues knew how poorly I was until I simply couldn't work. At this point, my priority is whether I'll have an independent life again, not what some shitty gossip-monger at work might think.

Sunshineishere1988 · 15/06/2023 14:50

If we take out long term sickness and are talking about general coughs, colds, sore throat etc, then I do agree with you. I had horrendous tonsillitis in the winter and could have easily stayed in bed for days. It took everything to force myself out but felt so much better for it. I do think some people will keep going and others will be in bed for a sniffle.

Personally, I have to feel I absolutely cannot do my job in anyway to stay off and even then im racked with guilt. I average 1-2 days a year with an exception for Covid (which is the longest ive ever stayed off when we had to and that was a week).

However, any of us could be struck down with something very serious at anytime, so you cant generalise all sickness.

RedFaerieBoots · 15/06/2023 14:49

Enfys1982 · 15/06/2023 13:05

Yes a lack of resilience. People who have several bouts of ‘flu’ a year when it’s probably just a heavy cold (if that). We all know the kind of people I’m talking about.

Aye that would be me except I have asthma.

A simple tiny wee cold would exacerbate my asthma. I would have to use my reliever inhaler, up my preventer inhaler (high dose enough to need to carry a steroid card) and I'd still need 5-7dys prednisolone at 40mg and a higher dose antibiotics (last one was 3000mg a day of amoxicillin for a week then 200mg a day of Doxycycline for another week).

My airways are always more sensitive than non asthmatics it's why some things can trigger an attack. When I say colds/respiratory bugs exacerbate my asthma I'm talking about needing to throw everything including the kitchen sink to not get to the point of having a severe attack.

Not sure if people are aware but steroids tend to work by dampening down your immune system because asthma exacerbation is an overreaction to something. So to calm that down it needs to shut down the immune reaction. But you also have a respiratory bug/virus/cold /flu etc so your body then is fighting them off with one arm behind its back.

I had a colleague like you. Every time I went back she refused to speak to me, bitched behind my back and told me to my face that asthma was. Pathetic excuse for being off sick and I needed to be more resilient.

Yet she never twigged that her coming in sick and powering through might just be making me sick in first place. I mean have you ever considered you might be making people around you sick with your powering through your "just a cold"?

xogossipgirlxo · 15/06/2023 14:49

Sloth66 · 15/06/2023 14:23

The issue isn’t so much taking time off sick in itself. If someone is genuinely unwell, they need to be off work.

but yes, I’ve met people who would be off for weeks, back for a couple of days, then off again. The same people who were all over Facebook detailing holidays, nights out and even their second jobs.
we had someone like this who would openly admit she didn’t want to work, and could easily get sick notes. Now thanks to her, our work has decided to tighten up sickness allowance and it’s affecting the genuinely unwell staff.

Same happened at my FIL's workplace. They started hiring people through agency (and we know how shit their sick pay policy is), because people were exploiting sick pay policy,i.e. for hangover 🙄

Swg · 15/06/2023 14:46

MysteryBelle · 15/06/2023 14:37

You deserve support, I hope things improve. You are definitely not who op means, I’m sure. ❤️

The problem is I'm not now because I have a diagnosis - and once the c word is mentioned people go very quiet. But there were three or four months off sick before a diagnosis where even a nurse in my GP told me I wasn't really that sick and accused me of health anxiety. And about six months before that of periodic absence because I was getting ill so often and so easily. I probably feel better day to day now than I did then because I actually have meds.

"Tired all the time" is a symptom of an awful lot of things but it looks just like a lack of resilience and whining. Its hard to explain that by "Tired" you mean "I can no longer bend and pick up the saucers to feed the cats so I'm buying pouches I can empty into them whilst standing" and not just "well everyone gets tired".

HarpyValley · 15/06/2023 14:46

I've been a manager for almost 25 years, managed large teams and small. In that time I've had two members of staff who knew exactly what they were doing, 'managed' their sickness so that they never quite went onto half-pay, always stayed just within the tolerances of the sickness policy. The timing of their illnesses was always very convenient / coincidental - team workload pinch points, weeks where they'd been too slow putting in leave requests and had had to be declined as the maximum permitted staff were already off, days they were rostered for the tasks they disliked, that sort of thing. You do get a feel for the type of worker who operates like that.

BUT I've managed far, far more people who were committed, conscientious, came in when they really shouldn't and I had to have the "are you sure you're well enough to be here, do you think you should go home?" conversation; people with chronic conditions who wanted and had it kept confidential, who battled in as much as they could but (rightly) had to take time when their conditions flared, or who had a reasonable adjustment that allowed more sick leave than the usual policy; people who behave like mature adults in that they work when they are well and take time off when they are sick.

kizziee · 15/06/2023 14:45

@MillicentTrilbyHiggins I think that's quite common (people giving different reasons.) I hope you are much better now

SunshineShines · 15/06/2023 14:44

Oh my god, some of these answers are so rude. Posters calling the OP a ‘pillock’ and similar. What is wrong with you people? Everyone is so intolerant of each other on mumsnet, it’s bloody depressing - I bet people wouldn’t reply in this fashion face to face.

for what its worth, my view on the OPs question is

a) some people have genuine health issues and have to take more time off work sick. That’s why sick pay exists

b) some people don’t have health issues ‘per se’ but just don’t cope with being ill as well as others. Whereas someone else might soldier through, others take time off for what is likely the same level of ‘illness’. Is that ‘less resilience’ or do those people genuinely feel worse? Who knows 🤷‍♀️

c) opposite of b - some people are able to just keep on going, despite not feeling well. Ofte those who either don’t get enhanced sick pay (or sick pay at all!), those who can work from home or those with a lot of responsbility where that cannot easily take a day off.

d) some people take the piss

TickyTok · 15/06/2023 14:44

Potentially unpopular opinion but if someone is so ill that they are "hanging on by a thread" then shouldn't that be a sign to change jobs, quite jobs or accept they need to be on disability payment? Forcing themselves to work through chronic illness or accepting that their colleagues must always pick up the slack doesn't do anyone's health a favour. Most conditions also tend to improve when give sufficient time to relax and recuperate.

There are also many careers that involve freelance work, WFH or flexible hours where the person can fit work around their schedule. Working in an office or in shifts is an ableist structure by design. You need to physically show up somewhere every day, work, and then commute home while juggling all the tasks like groceries or errands outside of those times.

motherofcatsandbears · 15/06/2023 14:39

Well aren’t you lucky having such good health. Not everyone is as lucky as you - don’t judge people before you know the full story.

Puppers · 15/06/2023 14:39

There are lots of reasons that some people take more sick leave than others. To lump them all in together and pretend that it's because you are superior and "resilient" is arrogant and unthinking.

You are very fortunate to apparently have been born into a body that is in generally good health, does not routinely suffer severe symptoms from common illnesses and responds well to medication that allows you to continue your day-to-day activities (and spread your germs to everyone else). That's pure luck. Nothing to do with resilience or you being a better kind of person. Just luck. And unfortunately not everybody shares that luck.

Have you honestly never had the experience of your whole household coming down with the same bug or virus and different family members being affected differently? Some being really genuinely very poorly while another has a minor sniffle? It's really not difficult to fathom.

There's also the obvious possibility that your colleagues are not telling you the truth about why they are absent because it's quite simply none of your business and they'd rather tell you they've had the flu than tell their (judgemental) colleague that they are experiencing mental health difficulties or a long term health condition for example.

Unfortunately people like you are rarely capable of reconsidering their prejudices and preconceived notions about things so, have a medal instead for being such a resilient little worker bee 🏅

LadyKenya · 15/06/2023 14:38

Preps · 15/06/2023 14:32

Oh the naivety. Excessive sickness absence is one of the easiest legal ways to get rid of someone, even when it's all perfectly genuine and certificated.

So much so that the HR support company we use send a "consultant" for sickness absence cases and a "senior consultant" for pretty much everything else.

If you're not well enough to do your job reliably it's easy to be dismissed on ill health capability grounds, unless it's connected to a disability.

The poster I was responding to has chronic asthma. Which is classed as a disability. They should not have been sacked because of that. Where is the naivety in that?