Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should have kept my confidence

469 replies

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 11:39

Namechanged...

I'm pregnant for the first time. I found out three weeks ago, I think I'm around seven weeks now so it's early days. I was planning to wait until after my 12 week scan to tell most people as that seems like the thing to do - I was also waiting a while to tell my parents as I'm not sure they'll be supportive... long story as to why but the main point is I'm nervous about telling them.

I was unexpectedly very sick a few days ago. Much more than I thought would be normal for morning sickness, and much sooner. I wasn't sure how to handle it so I spoke to my DSIL for advice - that meant telling her I was expecting, of course.

My DSIL is older, married to DH's brother, and has DC already. We have had a pretty close relationship so far so it felt normal to confide in her. They live overseas with the rest of DHs family.

Anyway she was pretty supportive about the pregnancy as a whole and the sickness. At the end of the conversation I said, almost as an afterthought, 'obviously I haven't told anyone else yet, so please can you keep this to yourself until I get a chance to tell the rest of my family and DH can talk to his parents and siblings'

And she said 'Oh! No, sorry, I never keep any secrets from my DH so I will have to tell him as soon I see him.'

Well, it didn't seem right for the two of them to know before our DMs, and I had no idea if the two of them would have kept it a secret either, so we ended up scrambling to tell the rest of our close family that day. It's not what I would have chosen to do at all. My parents were not at all supportive and also perplexed that I told them 'so early'.

It's done now, but am I being unreasonable to think DSIL should have kept my confidence?

OP posts:
NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:56

@saraclara thank you for the defence. I'm going to be more aware in future, but I'm reassured that the majority think I was being reasonable.

Thank you as well to everyone who has offered congratulations, that is really encouraging 😊

OP posts:
saraclara · 15/06/2023 19:52

Mumsnet is all about pregnant women's rights. Yet lots of people here think it's perfectly okay for someone else to give the news of OP's pregnancy to her family members before she's ready, even when she categorically asked them not to.

People really cant get their logic straight can they? Either the pregnant woman is the priority, or she's not. I'd be absolutely furious with anyone who didn't respect my right to give such big news to family members myself and on my own timeline. Yet a third of people on this thread are defnding the SIL who did exactly that. Because they cant have 'secrets' from their hubby. Pathetic.

HandsupSue · 15/06/2023 19:50

CurlewKate · 15/06/2023 19:43

Incidentally- nobody's had a go at deciding how long into a relationship this shared confidences thing kicks in....

Because it’s a daft question

like **nobody's had a go at deciding how long into a relationship you move in together / introduce to parents / fart in front of each.... it is on a relationship by relationship basis!

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:46

HandsupSue · 15/06/2023 19:45

you got that right.

She is the wife of the OP’s husband’s brother. Not exactly Emma from three doors down.

you know, the one he was desperate to tell him self. Yet was totally cool with the op telling his brother’s wife 5 weeks before he did actually tell him.

Hilarious. Emma definitely would have weaponised the information. Clumsily though. And it all still would have worked out in the end.

OP posts:
HandsupSue · 15/06/2023 19:45

EasterBreak · 15/06/2023 19:11

She's not your friend OP.

you got that right.

She is the wife of the OP’s husband’s brother. Not exactly Emma from three doors down.

you know, the one he was desperate to tell him self. Yet was totally cool with the op telling his brother’s wife 5 weeks before he did actually tell him.

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:44

CurlewKate · 15/06/2023 19:43

Incidentally- nobody's had a go at deciding how long into a relationship this shared confidences thing kicks in....

I think that's an interesting question! I'm going to take a swing at when they get engaged, or decide to move in together, or other culturally relevant sign of commitment. I'll be more aware of the possibility for sure from now on.

OP posts:
NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:43

sandyhappypeople · 15/06/2023 19:38

Sorry, it does sound a bit sinister when I read it back! I just meant a secret pertaining to the family, rather then a friend/colleague etc.

Did you have reason to believe that you BIL would tell the wider family? Is there a reason you felt compelled to break the news right away after realising that he would find out from SIL, or could your DH not have rang his brother and asked him to keep it between themselves? I would have assumed that they would keep in their joint confidence if you said you didn't want to tell anyone for another 5 weeks.

OK, that's fair enough I guess! I think I was so surprised that DSIL wouldn't respect my confidence that I didn't know what to think about anyone else after that. And it seemed like my discomfort with making the family announcement right away wasn't worth the risk of hurting DMIL's feelings, or DH's other siblings, or my own family.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 15/06/2023 19:43

Incidentally- nobody's had a go at deciding how long into a relationship this shared confidences thing kicks in....

CurlewKate · 15/06/2023 19:39

@Spidey66 "If someone said to me 'don't tell anyone, even your husband ' I wouldn't tell him. If someone said 'don't tell anyone' bug didn't specify him, I probably would."

It wouldn't cross my mind to say that- to me that sounds really insulting. As if I was saying "Don't tell anyone-you know what that means, don't you? It means don't tell anyone!"

sandyhappypeople · 15/06/2023 19:38

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:22

I don't think I'm talking about "secrets" though, much less dark mysterious "family secrets". I wasn't ready to announce my pregnancy to my own parents particularly, and DH had agreed that we would tell our parents at the same time. That's not really a "secret" so much as some news that wasn't shared yet - a confidence.

I think I am guilty of thinking that pregnancy news, especially so early, would be assumed to fall into the confidential category and thus to be shared more widely at the discretion of the pregnant woman. Or a "surprise" that I was in control of, if you like. I guess I know better now.

There was a time limit too - a maximum of five weeks, which you can infer from my OP pretty easily.

Sorry, it does sound a bit sinister when I read it back! I just meant a secret pertaining to the family, rather then a friend/colleague etc.

Did you have reason to believe that you BIL would tell the wider family? Is there a reason you felt compelled to break the news right away after realising that he would find out from SIL, or could your DH not have rang his brother and asked him to keep it between themselves? I would have assumed that they would keep in their joint confidence if you said you didn't want to tell anyone for another 5 weeks.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 19:35

But not bug.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 19:34

If someone said to me 'don't tell anyone, even your husband ' I wouldn't tell him. If someone said 'don't tell anyone' bug didn't specify him, I probably would.

phoenixrosehere · 15/06/2023 19:32

Mari9999 · 15/06/2023 18:55

I would never presume to announce anyone's pregnancy. If the couple have not made an announcement, I would not think it my business no matter what the family connection.

My partner may be entitled to certain aspects of my privacy, but in no way is he entitled to every aspect of other people's business. Gossiping other people's business to your partner is not an indicator of the closeness in your relationship, it is simply an indicator of your inability to respect a confidence.

Said it better than I could.

Wonder if this is because it’s about pregnancy since when it comes to it so many feel they have the right to know as soon as the stick has a plus sign and certain people have to know first.

I couldn’t imagine people doing “must tell my spouse” if this was a man getting a vasectomy and asking for guidance from another man who has had one.

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:32

CurlewKate · 15/06/2023 17:42

"Op what is the cultural background? Because there must be some kind of family dynamics seeing as you’re all scared of bil finding out and panic and tell the rest of the family prematurely I am guessing you are not that stupid"

This gets more bizarre by the minute. DP and I wanted our mothers to be the first to know. If I had needed advice before we were able to tell them, I would have asked that person not to tell anyone else. Nothing "cultural" No "fear" No "panic". Just wanting the two grandmothers to be the first to know.

Thanks @CurlewKate - that's pretty much it. You seem pretty sensible in your views and that's reassuring!

OP posts:
NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:28

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/06/2023 17:26

Its so weird that people are saying the OP put her SIL in a difficult position by asking her not to tell anyone. Not betraying a confidence isn't keeping a secret from your husband. Can married couples really not hold on to confidential information these days?

I think the fact that it was his family makes it muddier.

I've kept loads of secrets from my dh, mostly relating to friends/work, I.e. cheating husbands. All totally irrelevant to him. I was told for support which I provided. In one case of cheating husbands, he found out later and wasn't fussed that I'd known for a long time because it wasn't his business. All the other cases to the best of my knowledge, he still doesn't know.

A couple of years ago my mil told me a secret which pertained to fil and like the OP, asked me to keep the secret after she'd told me. Given it was health related, I was really uncomfortable but I kept my word and supported her as best I could. Finally when treatment and side effects meant they told everyone, they let slip I'd known for months. Dh and his siblings were really hurt both by the fact that mil had confided in me over them and that I hadn't told dh who would have told them. In fact it led to the first serious row dh and I have ever had because he thought my loyalties to him should be stronger than my loyalties to his parents.

I'm not sure what I'd do in similar circumstances.

I'm sorry that was a bad experience for you @Dinosauratemydaffodils. It sounds fairly messy, I must admit. Would it have made a difference if your MIL had asked you to keep it confidential for around a month while she got herself in order to tell the other family members? As that's what I was suggesting to my DSIL.

OP posts:
WeWereInParis · 15/06/2023 19:23

Maybe I’m in the minority but if I fully trust someone, I wouldn’t need to give a disclaimer before revealing information to them because they have already proven themselves worthy of that trust to begin with.

To me, trusting someone with information doesn't really mean trusting them not to tell anyone. It means trusting them to treat the information with respect. So not gossiping about it, not telling loads of people, but not necessarily keeping it quiet from their partner. Anyone I tell something serious to is someone I trust to have my best interests at heart, and whose judgement I trust. I don't need a promise of secrecy because I know if they do tell anyone, they've used their judgement in that decision, for whatever reason.

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:22

sandyhappypeople · 15/06/2023 17:03

because SIL never agreed to that at any point and was only asked at the very end at which point she declined? She has a right to choose who she tells and who she doesn't, whether she's right or wrong to do that is really besides the point, once the information is out there it's too late to hold them to it.

I think this post proves that there's a very mixed response when it comes to who would and who wouldn't want to tell their partner. I think it was better for SIL to make her position clear than say she'll keep it secret then tell her partner anyway though.

I personally think it's unreasonable to burden a single person with a family secret (which WILL become common knowledge) for an indefinite amount of time and not allow them to share that burden with their partner (the crux of that for me is because there's a chance her partner could find out elsewhere and be hurt it was kept from him). Unless there was a time limit or a good reason for her to keep it secret from her partner (which wasn't mentioned in the OP or by the OP, so we can only assume there wasn't one offered) I don't think she should have been asked to do that in the first place, wider family yes, partner no.

I don't think I'm talking about "secrets" though, much less dark mysterious "family secrets". I wasn't ready to announce my pregnancy to my own parents particularly, and DH had agreed that we would tell our parents at the same time. That's not really a "secret" so much as some news that wasn't shared yet - a confidence.

I think I am guilty of thinking that pregnancy news, especially so early, would be assumed to fall into the confidential category and thus to be shared more widely at the discretion of the pregnant woman. Or a "surprise" that I was in control of, if you like. I guess I know better now.

There was a time limit too - a maximum of five weeks, which you can infer from my OP pretty easily.

OP posts:
saraclara · 15/06/2023 19:18

Mari9999 · 15/06/2023 18:55

I would never presume to announce anyone's pregnancy. If the couple have not made an announcement, I would not think it my business no matter what the family connection.

My partner may be entitled to certain aspects of my privacy, but in no way is he entitled to every aspect of other people's business. Gossiping other people's business to your partner is not an indicator of the closeness in your relationship, it is simply an indicator of your inability to respect a confidence.

All of that.

Of course OP and her DH want to be the one to tell her brother. It's not SIL's news to tell.

And it's just pathetic that there are people on here that seem to think that their relationships (which involve telling their DHss their friends' confidences) are better than those of people who respect privacy. Seriously, it's hard to fathom that kind of thinking.

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 19:16

@magma32 There are some cultural differences but not the ones you're thinking of. Not nearly as big, nor as dramatic. I've known DSIL about as long as I've known DH and was, I think, a good friend to her when she was vulnerable and on my 'home turf' so to speak. I don't think I was being dreadfully naive to consider her as a friend based on our history. I'm just a bit disappointed in the outcome.

OP posts:
EasterBreak · 15/06/2023 19:11

She's not your friend OP.

Mari9999 · 15/06/2023 18:55

I would never presume to announce anyone's pregnancy. If the couple have not made an announcement, I would not think it my business no matter what the family connection.

My partner may be entitled to certain aspects of my privacy, but in no way is he entitled to every aspect of other people's business. Gossiping other people's business to your partner is not an indicator of the closeness in your relationship, it is simply an indicator of your inability to respect a confidence.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 15/06/2023 18:50

GalileoHumpkins · 15/06/2023 15:51

But he absolutely has to know even if he's not interested, think of the damage to the relationship that keeping that info to yourself could cause.

😆

Grumpy101 · 15/06/2023 18:40

And to be fair to her 1) you didn't make it clear at the beginning that she would have to keep something from her our husband and 2) she was fair and honest about it with you.

Grumpy101 · 15/06/2023 18:38

YABU. If you really wanted to keep a secret from family, you shouldn't have told family. She's is your SIL first, and your friend second. Not fair to expect her to keep such a big secret from her DH when it actually relates to his family.

Febreezefantastic · 15/06/2023 18:34

SquirrelFeed · 15/06/2023 18:31

Someone else’s secret is ok to share. Your own is ok to keep. I get it!

If you are speaking to me, you should read my posts. I did say that I assume my friends will share confidence with their partners, and that it's ok for them to do so.

If I want to have a "secret", i keep my mouth shut. It's not up to me to decide what people need to share or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread