Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should have kept my confidence

469 replies

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 15/06/2023 11:39

Namechanged...

I'm pregnant for the first time. I found out three weeks ago, I think I'm around seven weeks now so it's early days. I was planning to wait until after my 12 week scan to tell most people as that seems like the thing to do - I was also waiting a while to tell my parents as I'm not sure they'll be supportive... long story as to why but the main point is I'm nervous about telling them.

I was unexpectedly very sick a few days ago. Much more than I thought would be normal for morning sickness, and much sooner. I wasn't sure how to handle it so I spoke to my DSIL for advice - that meant telling her I was expecting, of course.

My DSIL is older, married to DH's brother, and has DC already. We have had a pretty close relationship so far so it felt normal to confide in her. They live overseas with the rest of DHs family.

Anyway she was pretty supportive about the pregnancy as a whole and the sickness. At the end of the conversation I said, almost as an afterthought, 'obviously I haven't told anyone else yet, so please can you keep this to yourself until I get a chance to tell the rest of my family and DH can talk to his parents and siblings'

And she said 'Oh! No, sorry, I never keep any secrets from my DH so I will have to tell him as soon I see him.'

Well, it didn't seem right for the two of them to know before our DMs, and I had no idea if the two of them would have kept it a secret either, so we ended up scrambling to tell the rest of our close family that day. It's not what I would have chosen to do at all. My parents were not at all supportive and also perplexed that I told them 'so early'.

It's done now, but am I being unreasonable to think DSIL should have kept my confidence?

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 17:20

@HandsupSue "no one, absolutely no one has said or even implied that there is a specific point in a relationship where this happens to those couples that share secrets"
I know they haven't. That's why I'm asking. Because if there isn't an answer, you can't expect confidentiality from anyone in any sort of relationship from day 1. Which is plainly stupid. So....6 months?

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 17:18

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 16/06/2023 16:53

The reason I’m struggling, which I thought I said pretty clearly last night, is that, imagining you are my DSIL you are saying that you think your husbands feelings about and investment in my pregnancy warrant greater consideration than my own- when it’s my pregnancy.

You did say it very clearly, I completely understand that you feel that way, you're not wrong either, but unfortunately it doesn't really change anything, it's 100% subjective.

YOUR SIL's husbands feeling are more important than your feelings TO HER.

YOUR feelings about your pregnancy and when to share it are of course more important that your BILs feelings on the matter TO YOU.

Neither of those statement above are wrong in any way, it's just a difference of opinion/loyalties essentially, but you can't MAKE people change the way they feel, nor should you want to, it's best not to put people in that position in the first place if you can help it.

My problem with being told to keep 'secrets' stems from my childhood, I'd have to have a very good reason to keep secrets from the people I love the most if I think that secret may have some bearing on that person.

If the information had no bearing on my DH, I wouldn't have a problem not disclosing it, that's a different thing all together and is not the same as being asked to keep a secret.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/06/2023 17:09

saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:55

I never promise to not tell DH anything. However, everyone who knows me knows that.

I hope you don't work anywhere where you're asked to keep anything confidential then. Or if you do, that you made that clear at interview.

I'm sorry that your earlier life has affected you this way, genuinely. But I suppose that I'm making the point that I doubt many posters here rush to tell their partners everything that happened at work. It's only juicy friend and family stuff that they feel obliged to share.

Work confidentiality doesn’t remotely impact me in the same way. I’ve never had any fear of harm at work so it doesn’t have the same impact.

And it’s nothing to do with finding things “juicy” or otherwise. I’ve easily kept confidences (that they chose to share knowing) that have been “juicy” yet panicked about utterly mundane things. It’s personal relationships that it affects.

saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:55

I never promise to not tell DH anything. However, everyone who knows me knows that.

I hope you don't work anywhere where you're asked to keep anything confidential then. Or if you do, that you made that clear at interview.

I'm sorry that your earlier life has affected you this way, genuinely. But I suppose that I'm making the point that I doubt many posters here rush to tell their partners everything that happened at work. It's only juicy friend and family stuff that they feel obliged to share.

NobodysBabyEverybodysGirl · 16/06/2023 16:53

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 15:10

I don't really understand why people are insisting it's such a black and white thing, and you have to be all or nothing, life just isn't like that?

I would say I'm in the 'no secrets from my DH' camp, but there's a difference between a keeping a secret, and just not sharing someone's information that you're privy to, two completely different things.

In OPs case, it's not straight forward as it's actually a bit of both, if I was the SIL I'd be uncomfortable being given that information then not asked to share it with DH, especially when there's absolutely no reason for him not to know, you'd be asking me to keep something secret for the sake of it, and then when it does come to light (which it obviously will) he'd feel like me, SIL and his brother has conspired not to tell him, which is an awkward position to be put in for a partner you supposedly trust wholeheartedly.

In the cases as you mentioned, you're saying that because of my position on 'secrets' if I worked in the bank/pharmacy/GP I'd be straight home to tell my DH all about their families finances / STI / whatever? but it's not the same AT ALL, apples and oranges, I'm NOT being asked to keep a secret from my DH, I'm privy to information through my job/acquaintances which doesn't impact my DH in anyway so I'm not keeping it secret by not discussing it with him. The key difference being if he found out later somewhere else and found out I already knew about it he wouldn't be bothered by it because it doesn't have any bearing on him or our relationship in anyway.

That's my personal take on it, but I'm not sure why people are struggling to understand that there are two different things here completely, and they can be completely independent thought processes involved.

The reason I’m struggling, which I thought I said pretty clearly last night, is that, imagining you are my DSIL you are saying that you think your husbands feelings about and investment in my pregnancy warrant greater consideration than my own- when it’s my pregnancy.

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:52

Let's be clear about this. Anyone saying 'of course SIL has the right to tell her husband something told to her in confidence' is saying that a pregnant woman has no right to the timing and delivery of her own pregnancy news.

Only when it comes to the SIL's husband?

No. When it comes to anyone. When you're asked to keep a confidence, as I said, there's no hierarchy. But a lot of mumsnetters seem to feel that their DH/DP isn't an actual person in their own right, so as part of a couple they don't count.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/06/2023 16:45

I think if you have the relationship where you never keep anything from your partner then the onus is on you to be open about that with people.

I never promise to not tell DH anything. However, everyone who knows me knows that.

They also know why (keeping secrets was one of the nasty tactics my parents used as abuse - one would tell us something, then the other would punish us for hiding it from them), they know that 99.9% of the time I don’t tell him, but they also know that not panicking at being asked to keep secrets is something I’m still working on with the therapy about my childhood.

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 16:42

saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:22

I don't think it was fair to expect her to keep this a secret from her partner.

So you're saying that a pregnant woman and her partner don't have the right to tell members of their family at a time of their own choice? That someone's relationship with their husband is more important than a pregnant woman's right to give her news when she wants to and to who she wants?

Let's be clear about this. Anyone saying 'of course SIL has the right to tell her husband something told to her in confidence' is saying that a pregnant woman has no right to the timing and delivery of her own pregnancy news.

Of course this would be a whole different thread of it was the MIL who spilled the beans🙄

So you're saying that a pregnant woman and her partner don't have the right to tell members of their family at a time of their own choice?

Of course they have that right, but why tell a wife but not the husband? You're asking someone to bear the burden of that secret.. to what end, for what reason? What's the ultimate goal here? It's unreasonable to expect people in the same household to keep secrets from each other.

That someone's relationship with their husband is more important than a pregnant woman's right to give her news when she wants to and to who she wants?

The married couple's relationship IS more important to THEM. The pregnant women's right to give her news IS more important to HER. Can't you see how subjective it is? everyone in that equation has a different viewpoint and different priorities/loyalties. Not one person trumps everyone else automatically.

Let's be clear about this. Anyone saying 'of course SIL has the right to tell her husband something told to her in confidence' is saying that a pregnant woman has no right to the timing and delivery of her own pregnancy news.

Only when it comes to the SIL's husband? At no point was it indicated they would go on to tell anyone else? So the timing and delivery of her own pregnancy news was still well within their control at that point? In fairness, if the timing is really crucial and delicate it should probably be kept away from ANY family members until you're ready to break the news.

TripleDaisySummer · 16/06/2023 16:41

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 15:42

And all the nonsense about telling trade secrets, sharing friends affairs, talking about colleagues’ secrets…. Is just not relevant.

The above…. Unreasonable to share as your partner is either wholly unconnected to the person in question OR it’s illegal

This scenario is very much firmly putting the SIL slap bang in between two brothers, one being her husband

-and I remain confused why the op and her dh was so sure SIL would not tell a soul but OMG OMG OMG the brother now knows so shit shit shit “our hand has been forced” assarrrrggghhh

I have to admit this is my thinking - everyone is ignoring the family and the family politics.

The fact SIL as so swift and decisive with no I don't keep secretes does suggest some bitter experience with family game playing with secret keeping and loyalty testing - to me at least or maybe the Op is just very naive - and just never considered the situation from anyone else's point of view in the family and has sadly learnt a painful lesson.

saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:34

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 16:28

Exactly but I think @CurlewKate thinks she’s nailed a cutting an incisive and relevant question

when in fact… no one is answering it because it’s plain daft!

She knows it's impossible to answer sensibly. Just as the whole "I can't possibly not share my friends confidences with my hubby because we're SO much more happily married than you" is not remotely sensible or logical.

That's why she asked it. No-one can answer it because it's a totally illogical premise in the first place. Confidences are confidences. There is no hierarchy of people that you simply HAVE to blab to.

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 16:28

GalileoHumpkins · 16/06/2023 16:23

I'm not sure why you're labouring this point, how long is a piece of string, which came first the chicken or the egg, when should you start blabbing your friend's secrets? It's unanswerable.

Exactly but I think @CurlewKate thinks she’s nailed a cutting an incisive and relevant question

when in fact… no one is answering it because it’s plain daft!

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 16:27

CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 15:59

@sandyhappypeople "The key difference being if he found out later somewhere else and found out I already knew about it he wouldn't be bothered by it because it doesn't have any bearing on him or our relationship in anyway."

And as I said-if he's bothered by the fact that you kept a friend's confidence by not telling him then he's a controlling dick. And I don't use the word controlling lightly.

I'm just going to politely agree to disagree on this one. If it was the other way around and my husband kept a secret like that from me about my own sister/brother I would understand the reasons behind it but I would wonder why I wasn't trusted with it and other people had been specifically told not to tell me, I'm not going to lie, I would feel a bit hurt by it.

It doesn't make me a controlling dick.

Before I make decisions with regards to my DH, I ALWAYS swap the scenarios in my mind to see how I would feel if the situations were reversed, it's only fair.

I think the fact that everyone keeps saying she's a 'friend' when she's actually her SIL has clouded the waters on the topic tbh, if she was just a friend to me I wouldn't have a problem not disclosing that information to my DH as it has no bearing on him at all, but not when it pertains to one of his family members.

GalileoHumpkins · 16/06/2023 16:23

CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 16:00

Still no suggestions about what point in a relationship this automatic sharing thing kicks in....

I'm not sure why you're labouring this point, how long is a piece of string, which came first the chicken or the egg, when should you start blabbing your friend's secrets? It's unanswerable.

saraclara · 16/06/2023 16:22

I don't think it was fair to expect her to keep this a secret from her partner.

So you're saying that a pregnant woman and her partner don't have the right to tell members of their family at a time of their own choice? That someone's relationship with their husband is more important than a pregnant woman's right to give her news when she wants to and to who she wants?

Let's be clear about this. Anyone saying 'of course SIL has the right to tell her husband something told to her in confidence' is saying that a pregnant woman has no right to the timing and delivery of her own pregnancy news.

Of course this would be a whole different thread of it was the MIL who spilled the beans🙄

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 16:06

CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 16:00

Still no suggestions about what point in a relationship this automatic sharing thing kicks in....

Because it’s a bloody stupid question

no one, absolutely no one has said or even implied that there is a specific point in a relationship where this happens to those couples that share secrets

get over it 😂

Stompythedinosaur · 16/06/2023 16:03

I don't think it was fair to expect her to keep this a secret from her partner.

She didn't agree to keep your secret and was open when you asked her to.

Honestly, you are blaming her totally unfairly.

CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 16:00

Still no suggestions about what point in a relationship this automatic sharing thing kicks in....

CurlewKate · 16/06/2023 15:59

@sandyhappypeople "The key difference being if he found out later somewhere else and found out I already knew about it he wouldn't be bothered by it because it doesn't have any bearing on him or our relationship in anyway."

And as I said-if he's bothered by the fact that you kept a friend's confidence by not telling him then he's a controlling dick. And I don't use the word controlling lightly.

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 15:42

And all the nonsense about telling trade secrets, sharing friends affairs, talking about colleagues’ secrets…. Is just not relevant.

The above…. Unreasonable to share as your partner is either wholly unconnected to the person in question OR it’s illegal

This scenario is very much firmly putting the SIL slap bang in between two brothers, one being her husband

-and I remain confused why the op and her dh was so sure SIL would not tell a soul but OMG OMG OMG the brother now knows so shit shit shit “our hand has been forced” assarrrrggghhh

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 15:36

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 15:10

I don't really understand why people are insisting it's such a black and white thing, and you have to be all or nothing, life just isn't like that?

I would say I'm in the 'no secrets from my DH' camp, but there's a difference between a keeping a secret, and just not sharing someone's information that you're privy to, two completely different things.

In OPs case, it's not straight forward as it's actually a bit of both, if I was the SIL I'd be uncomfortable being given that information then not asked to share it with DH, especially when there's absolutely no reason for him not to know, you'd be asking me to keep something secret for the sake of it, and then when it does come to light (which it obviously will) he'd feel like me, SIL and his brother has conspired not to tell him, which is an awkward position to be put in for a partner you supposedly trust wholeheartedly.

In the cases as you mentioned, you're saying that because of my position on 'secrets' if I worked in the bank/pharmacy/GP I'd be straight home to tell my DH all about their families finances / STI / whatever? but it's not the same AT ALL, apples and oranges, I'm NOT being asked to keep a secret from my DH, I'm privy to information through my job/acquaintances which doesn't impact my DH in anyway so I'm not keeping it secret by not discussing it with him. The key difference being if he found out later somewhere else and found out I already knew about it he wouldn't be bothered by it because it doesn't have any bearing on him or our relationship in anyway.

That's my personal take on it, but I'm not sure why people are struggling to understand that there are two different things here completely, and they can be completely independent thought processes involved.

Very sensible post and I agree

and detail behind this scenario is critical to my view.
This was the wife of the husband’s brother and the OP had had a fright about her husband’s relative not her relative as such.

if it was two Friends and the DH had squat all link to friend… then utterly unreasonable to share with your husband

but brothers is a pretty big link

Vintagejazzing · 16/06/2023 15:21

YANBU. It's not up to individuals to decide they 'have to' tell their partner someone else's secret. It's not as if it was something terribly important that would impact hugely on her husband when he found out. It was just a nice piece of news that OP and her husband wanted kept quiet until they'd found a suitable moment to tell their parents. Any DH taking umbrage at not being told this news immediately is pathetic and needs to cop themselves on.

sandyhappypeople · 16/06/2023 15:10

Turfwars · 16/06/2023 14:05

A question I have if you are in the "we have no secrets camp"

Say your SIL gets a job in your local pharmacy.
Or gets a job as your GP's receptionist.
Or starts work in your bank branch.
And you only find out when she's handling your reason for being there.

It's then ok for her to tell her husband, your husband's brother because a) she's family and b) they don't have secrets between them?

If that's no, then why not?

I don't really understand why people are insisting it's such a black and white thing, and you have to be all or nothing, life just isn't like that?

I would say I'm in the 'no secrets from my DH' camp, but there's a difference between a keeping a secret, and just not sharing someone's information that you're privy to, two completely different things.

In OPs case, it's not straight forward as it's actually a bit of both, if I was the SIL I'd be uncomfortable being given that information then not asked to share it with DH, especially when there's absolutely no reason for him not to know, you'd be asking me to keep something secret for the sake of it, and then when it does come to light (which it obviously will) he'd feel like me, SIL and his brother has conspired not to tell him, which is an awkward position to be put in for a partner you supposedly trust wholeheartedly.

In the cases as you mentioned, you're saying that because of my position on 'secrets' if I worked in the bank/pharmacy/GP I'd be straight home to tell my DH all about their families finances / STI / whatever? but it's not the same AT ALL, apples and oranges, I'm NOT being asked to keep a secret from my DH, I'm privy to information through my job/acquaintances which doesn't impact my DH in anyway so I'm not keeping it secret by not discussing it with him. The key difference being if he found out later somewhere else and found out I already knew about it he wouldn't be bothered by it because it doesn't have any bearing on him or our relationship in anyway.

That's my personal take on it, but I'm not sure why people are struggling to understand that there are two different things here completely, and they can be completely independent thought processes involved.

Turfwars · 16/06/2023 14:05

MovingBird123 · 16/06/2023 08:01

Kudos to her for her honesty. She will have told him in any event, but she didn't need to admit it to you. It's unreasonable to expect secrets between married couples. I don't think that you did need to spread the news further.

A question I have if you are in the "we have no secrets camp"

Say your SIL gets a job in your local pharmacy.
Or gets a job as your GP's receptionist.
Or starts work in your bank branch.
And you only find out when she's handling your reason for being there.

It's then ok for her to tell her husband, your husband's brother because a) she's family and b) they don't have secrets between them?

If that's no, then why not?

Mari9999 · 16/06/2023 13:41

To all of those who don't keep secrets from their husbands, how do you distinguish between a secret from someone's personal business. It is fine to share your secrets with your spouse or partner, but how do you justify sharing someone else's personal business? Does the concept of not his business ever come into play in your relationship?

Do you truly believe that if your husband's brother were to tell him the he(the brother) was cheating on his wife that your husband would rush home to share that news particularly if his brother asked him not to tell anyone? Would he not be far more likely to respect his brother's confidence ?

HandsupSue · 16/06/2023 13:06

mainsfed · 16/06/2023 12:24

Because lots of companies encourage family and friends to visit. There are often kids at our office on a Friday / school holidays.

Ones that have lots of trade secrets?

and absolutely they encourage partners and their children

not “relatives”