Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby name entitlement

160 replies

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 07:56

My sister and I are both pregnant. I’m due about a month before she is, she’s having a boy, we’re waiting til birth to find out.

Initially she told me a boys names she’d like to use so obviously I took that off my list. However she now keeps adding to her list and we’re up to about 6 or 7 boys names that’s she considering and I’m guessing doesn’t want me to use. She hasn’t directly said it’s heavily implied. Such as randomly testing ‘oh btw we also like Jack’ for example, I’ll say ‘oh yea we also like that one’ and she’ll reply ‘well we’re not sure if we’re going to use it yet’ 👀.

As we’re not sure what we’re having, we’re thinking about naming baby after my mum if we have a girl. Sister also isn’t keen as ‘is that fair, then yours will be the favourite’.

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

on the other hand they’re are still
plenty of other names??

AIBU?

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

OP posts:
Gershwining · 15/06/2023 09:09

LakeTiticaca · 15/06/2023 09:00

Don't even discuss any names. Just say you haven't decided yet. When your baby comes just announce the name you have chosen and to hell with anyone else's demands.

Complete agree with this. My brother and sister both liked the name Benjamin for a boy. My sister "reserved" it for if she had a boy, so my brother couldn't name his son (who was born first) Benjamin. Then when my sister had her baby boy she didn't even call him Benjamin!!

So I'd stop discussing names and call your child whatever you like

Robinni · 15/06/2023 09:07

I think you need to have your boys names sorted, no matter what she has said; your baby is born first and you get the choice.

Make it plain to her that she can not take ownership over multiple names. If she settles on one name that is one thing but to monopolise several is unfair.

Always the same when siblings have babies around the same time, she is jealous you’re stealing her thunder by having baby first and is trying to regain control by name domination. Got that vibe when she was upset about you using your Mum’s name for daughter.

LakeTiticaca · 15/06/2023 09:00

Don't even discuss any names. Just say you haven't decided yet. When your baby comes just announce the name you have chosen and to hell with anyone else's demands.

FlounderingFruitcake · 15/06/2023 08:59

She can’t ask you not to use 7 names knowing that she won’t use 6 of them herself (maybe 5 if you generously allow for a middle name)!! The cheek!

I’d tell her that if she wants to share her first choice boy’s name with you then you won’t use it but that’s it and she definitely doesn’t get to give you an ever growing list of names that you can’t use. Also since she isn’t having a girl then she gets zero influence there except maybe that you wouldn’t call yours for example Louise if she tells you that her boy’s name is Louis and that includes anything to do with your mum’s name.

musicforthesoul · 15/06/2023 08:59

Just point blank tell her that you won't be avoiding a big list of maybes.

If she'd already picked a name or has a couple of partucular favourites of course I'd avoid but I wouldn't be restricting my choice over an ever expanding list of possible names.

lookslikeabombhitit · 15/06/2023 08:57

Your sister is bu. She doesn't get to dictate what name you call your child. There's 6 kids between me and my siblings (and more to come) and not once have any of us had a conversation about what names others can't use... She needs to grow up.

JandalsAlways · 15/06/2023 08:56

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 08:15

Don't give sister the real list. Those names will OBVIOUSLY be put on the banned list, then not used, tinkly laugh.

Get a baby name book. Highlight about 20 girls names you don't like, and 20 boys names you don't like. Not obviously hideous ones like Englebert and Euphemia. Just ones you don't fancy, e.g. Aaron, Callum. Give it to her.

She can then stop laying claim to 50 names.

Ha ha, or this 🤣

JandalsAlways · 15/06/2023 08:53

Maybe you both need to settle on top three (don't tell each other) then compare the list. In an ideal scenario you will pick different names. I think the mums name is too bad as she's having a boy anyway (then so might you). I'd try deal with it fairly and amicably as I feel there's no point having a fall out over a name. She can't "bags" all the names. Top three seems fair.

violetcuriosity · 15/06/2023 08:49

Also, you do only get one first baby. Don't let this cast a shadow over it, choose the name you like and deal with your sister if and when it comes to it.

violetcuriosity · 15/06/2023 08:46

My mum and 2 of her sisters all called their sons Jack because they all liked it 😂 Literally never been an issue apart from being a funny story

Fancylike · 15/06/2023 08:44

I suspect whatever name you use, when your baby is born first there will be a big song and dance about how your stole “her name”. You can’t win by playing into these kinds of games. Just tell her you’ve chosen your names and that’s that.

honeylulu · 15/06/2023 08:39

The two names suggestion is a good one. Tell her she can't embargo any more as you're having your baby first and don't want to be banned from other names you like just because she might want to use them! She's being silly and greedy.

WandaWonder · 15/06/2023 08:37

I would give her my name list

Norman Bates
Oh for a boy we were thinking Rosemary after Rosemary's Baby
Can we have Geraldine Grainger for a girl or is that one taken

Etc. Etc.

Justalittlebitduckling · 15/06/2023 08:34

I’ve never seen a post where all the replies are quite so similar before!

Emmamoo89 · 15/06/2023 08:33

Your sister is ridiculous

RattyHealy · 15/06/2023 08:33

I would explain if she's fixed on a name then you're happy to take that off your list but she can't reserve a long list of names.

Justalittlebitduckling · 15/06/2023 08:32

Tell her she’s allowed to reserve two possible boy names as her very favourites but you won’t make allowances beyond that. She’s jealous you’re going to have a baby first.

MrsLiam · 15/06/2023 08:32

I think it's fair for her to pick one boys name which you agree not to use if you have a boy before her. But she can't have monopoly on a long list of boys names as she won't use them all - and she certainly has no right at all over girls names, if your baby is a girl.

SkyandSurf · 15/06/2023 08:31

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/06/2023 08:25

Cant you just say 'sis, were both getting close to the births now and we want to decide on names for the baby. Please can you let me know your final top two choices so you can avoid them? You've mentioned quite a few over the last few months but we can't rule out all of them so let us know your final choices as I'd hate to pick your current favourite by mistake'

This is perfect.

Call an end to this nonsense.

Respecting one chosen name is a courtesy, but a growing list of 'maybes' is just ridiculous.

Tell her to chose one or two that are 'hers' and then stop discussing baby names with you. You'll name your baby what you like, she doesn't get a vote.

She sounds childish beyond belief.

justanothermummma · 15/06/2023 08:29

Call your baby what you want!

We liked a name but my list was just between me and my DH. My cousin who I'm really close to, had a girl and called her the top name on our list.

So we called our DD something else (which I actually think she suits better and I love it more now!)

My cousin doesn't have to know, we're all happy..

If she names her baby the same, well it's odd but it's not like there is only one 'Jack' in the world is there?

Leave her to it!

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 08:29

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/06/2023 08:25

Cant you just say 'sis, were both getting close to the births now and we want to decide on names for the baby. Please can you let me know your final top two choices so you can avoid them? You've mentioned quite a few over the last few months but we can't rule out all of them so let us know your final choices as I'd hate to pick your current favourite by mistake'

This is perfect.

EggInANest · 15/06/2023 08:28

This is why discussing names in advance is bad news. Next you get all the grandparents chipping in not liking your names.

Tell your sister that along with not finding out and sharing the sex in advance you aren’t discussing names. Say you are likely to have similar tastes but if there is one definite name that they want for a special reason, let you know.

She can’t ‘bags’ a long list of names!

Ignore the whole thing around your Mum’s name. She can use a boy family name or give a subsequent Dd the same middle name, even as a first name if her competitive anxiety really gets the better of her.

Drop the rope, don’t engage.

Carrusa · 15/06/2023 08:26

While you're likely to have your baby first, it's not a guarantee.

It's getting ridiculous. Maybe say to her look, you've given me something like 20 names. I can't possibly keep track of them all and you're going to get very hurt if I forget one. Can we just give each other 5 names and the rest is fair game?

If you like you could let her change her top 5 but for every one she adds, one has to come off. Because her baby definitely won't need more than 5 names.

Also try and get her to agree to exclude middle names from the embargo. No one uses them day to day and it really won't matter in the least if one has the same middle name as their cousin's first or second name.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/06/2023 08:25

Cant you just say 'sis, were both getting close to the births now and we want to decide on names for the baby. Please can you let me know your final top two choices so you can avoid them? You've mentioned quite a few over the last few months but we can't rule out all of them so let us know your final choices as I'd hate to pick your current favourite by mistake'

IglesiasPiggl · 15/06/2023 08:23

She's using this as a tool for control. Fine if there's one particular name she really loves, but she can't "reserve" a whole list. In a way, it would be better if hers was born first, because then she can't accuse you of having "stolen" her name.

Swipe left for the next trending thread