Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby name entitlement

160 replies

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 07:56

My sister and I are both pregnant. I’m due about a month before she is, she’s having a boy, we’re waiting til birth to find out.

Initially she told me a boys names she’d like to use so obviously I took that off my list. However she now keeps adding to her list and we’re up to about 6 or 7 boys names that’s she considering and I’m guessing doesn’t want me to use. She hasn’t directly said it’s heavily implied. Such as randomly testing ‘oh btw we also like Jack’ for example, I’ll say ‘oh yea we also like that one’ and she’ll reply ‘well we’re not sure if we’re going to use it yet’ 👀.

As we’re not sure what we’re having, we’re thinking about naming baby after my mum if we have a girl. Sister also isn’t keen as ‘is that fair, then yours will be the favourite’.

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

on the other hand they’re are still
plenty of other names??

AIBU?

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 15/06/2023 10:11

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

I think you have it here. Tell her if she settles on a name you won't use that one but you can't discount a whole list of names when you like several of them too.

knockyknees · 15/06/2023 10:07

Your sister sounds like a toddler with the attitude of ''what's mine is mine, and what's yours is mine''.

I wouldn't even continue the discussion about this. Just name your baby what you want, and if your sister also chooses to use that name, then oh well, there'll be two ''Jack's'' in the family.

phoenixrosehere · 15/06/2023 10:05

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:58

Because it’s bonkers and causes confusion for ever. Everyone is confused saying big Jane and little Jane, old Jane and young Jane, Jane junior, Jane senior etc etc. When there are thousands of names to choose from, why give a child a name that a close family member already has?

And actually, if OP isn’t bothered about her baby sharing her mum’s name, why worry about her baby sharing the name with her sister’s baby? Why not just all use the same names?!

Because it’s bonkers and causes confusion for ever. Everyone is confused saying big Jane and little Jane, old Jane and young Jane, Jane junior, Jane senior etc etc.

It is not that confusing and often families give nicknames if there is some.

Mariposista · 15/06/2023 10:03

I would not be allowing my sister to be so heavily involved in my own family planning. Certainly not conferring over lists. I would be naming my child what I want, and let her do the same. Those are decisions for me and my husband alone.

Alstoybarn · 15/06/2023 10:02

Your first so get to have anything you want. Unlucky for her. She can't make you feel like your not allowed to use certain names. It's weird as fuck. Fair enough if she had 1 definite and it was decided but she doesn't so she's clearly unsure herself.

rainbowstardrops · 15/06/2023 10:01

snitzelvoncrumb · 15/06/2023 08:13

I would tell her she gets one name she can ask you not to use and that’s it.

Yep! I'd do this too

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:58

User1367349 · 15/06/2023 09:36

Why wouldn’t she use her mother’s name as a girl’s name? I know lots of family names where this is the case.

Because it’s bonkers and causes confusion for ever. Everyone is confused saying big Jane and little Jane, old Jane and young Jane, Jane junior, Jane senior etc etc. When there are thousands of names to choose from, why give a child a name that a close family member already has?

And actually, if OP isn’t bothered about her baby sharing her mum’s name, why worry about her baby sharing the name with her sister’s baby? Why not just all use the same names?!

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:55

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 09:36

Do you honestly think entitled sister will 'take them off her list?'

But OP is having her baby first! And she’s set a precedent by taking off the list the names her sister has mentioned. So OP could easily say “it’s great you’ve given me the names you want. Makes life so much easier. This is my list”. Then she can’t be blamed for using one of the names on her own list, that her sister was aware of.

Lcb123 · 15/06/2023 09:51

I think it’s very weird to discuss baby names with anyone apart from the baby’s parents. Let alone chose one before baby is here safe and well. I’d just stop talking about it, it’s causing unnecessary angst

user1492757084 · 15/06/2023 09:49

I agree with offering to not choose your sister's favourite name. She can only veto one.
Stop discussing all your names with her.

zingally · 15/06/2023 09:46

Ignore her.

Call your baby what you like.

Goldbar · 15/06/2023 09:41

EVHead · 15/06/2023 08:06

Name your baby what you want. Your sister sounds about 12 years old.

Whoever has their baby second will just need to decide whether to name them the same thing as their cousin, or something different.

This. Unfortunately for your sister, as your baby is arriving first you get first dibs. That's just life.

I wouldn't even discuss names with her, just inform everyone what your baby is called when they arrive.

User1367349 · 15/06/2023 09:36

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:35

I’m confused - why are you standing by while she gives you boys names that are banned? Why not just get in there first and say “these are the boys names we’ve chosen”. Then she can take them off her list.

And if it’s a girl - surely you’re not planning to give your daughter your mother’s name as her first name, because that would be ridiculous and confusing? I assume you mean as a middle name, in which case you can both use it if you both end up having girls at some point.

Why wouldn’t she use her mother’s name as a girl’s name? I know lots of family names where this is the case.

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 09:36

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:35

I’m confused - why are you standing by while she gives you boys names that are banned? Why not just get in there first and say “these are the boys names we’ve chosen”. Then she can take them off her list.

And if it’s a girl - surely you’re not planning to give your daughter your mother’s name as her first name, because that would be ridiculous and confusing? I assume you mean as a middle name, in which case you can both use it if you both end up having girls at some point.

Do you honestly think entitled sister will 'take them off her list?'

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:35

I’m confused - why are you standing by while she gives you boys names that are banned? Why not just get in there first and say “these are the boys names we’ve chosen”. Then she can take them off her list.

And if it’s a girl - surely you’re not planning to give your daughter your mother’s name as her first name, because that would be ridiculous and confusing? I assume you mean as a middle name, in which case you can both use it if you both end up having girls at some point.

WhamBamThankU · 15/06/2023 09:30

I'd ask her to pick one (two if you're feeling generous) name for you to avoid, but not five or six!

viques · 15/06/2023 09:30

Tell her you are not bothered what she calls her baby, and what is more you are not sharing your baby name lists with anyone, but that if you do coincidentally decide on the same name it will be a sweet link between the cousins.

steppemum · 15/06/2023 09:25

ThatFraggle · 15/06/2023 08:29

This is perfect.

I came on to say this.

There is no point in falling out over baby names, but she is being ridiculous to think that you can keep all her possible choices off your list.

I had a favourite boys name and it also had connections to dh's family. I would have been sad if my sibling used it as it had no connections for them, just a nice name.

So I think it is nice to your sister to say give me your top 2.
I would do the same with girls names, but she doesn't get to stop you using your mum's name. More like if there is a name which is key to her dh (his mum's name or Gran's name) then it would be nice to let them use that one.

No-one has the right to a name, but give and take goes a long way in families!

Hollyppp · 15/06/2023 09:24

Just name your baby exactly what you want, you’re likely going first.

and you are only having one of the names off the list so if she’s reserving TONS she will have loads of alternatives to pick from
for her baby

JaukiVexnoydi · 15/06/2023 09:22

Yanbu

You need to text/say to your sis "if you want to nominate one single name for us to not use if we have a boy then I don't mind avoiding that one but I am not going to avoid a whole list of possibilities that you might use so if you don't want to settle on a single choice we will just be choosing a name when the time comes without worrying whether its on your list and if the two cousins end up with the same name that's ok"

She cannot veto you using your mums name if you have a girl and of course doing so would not make that baby a "favourite" because your mum is presumably a woman of integrity and sense.

ApplesInTheSunshine · 15/06/2023 09:15

You shouldn’t be discussing it at all. Just pick the name you like and call your baby it.

Katiesaidthat · 15/06/2023 09:13

Ignore, stop talking to her about this. Say you have chosen your names and will reveal at birth, and that you will discuss names no further. I´m called like one of my first cousins and we are fine. No drama.

LysHastighed · 15/06/2023 09:13

Make sure the agreement goes both ways as she may end up having hers first.

justasoul · 15/06/2023 09:12

I’m one of the rare people on MN who thinks it’s ok to call dibs on a name as long as it’s one name. Both my siblings mentioned (in casual conversation) one name they’d like to use so I avoided those. Now, avoid a whole list “just in case” is beyond ridiculous. Unless she’s planning on birthing her own football team.

AxolotlEars · 15/06/2023 09:09

I would ignore....smile and wave! . Don't talk to your sister about names. Be really non-committal even if you have absolutely settled on a name. I wouldn't even entertain a negotiation about 2 names. I can understand that she may feel anxious but anxiety doesn't mean you can exert control.