Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby name entitlement

160 replies

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 07:56

My sister and I are both pregnant. I’m due about a month before she is, she’s having a boy, we’re waiting til birth to find out.

Initially she told me a boys names she’d like to use so obviously I took that off my list. However she now keeps adding to her list and we’re up to about 6 or 7 boys names that’s she considering and I’m guessing doesn’t want me to use. She hasn’t directly said it’s heavily implied. Such as randomly testing ‘oh btw we also like Jack’ for example, I’ll say ‘oh yea we also like that one’ and she’ll reply ‘well we’re not sure if we’re going to use it yet’ 👀.

As we’re not sure what we’re having, we’re thinking about naming baby after my mum if we have a girl. Sister also isn’t keen as ‘is that fair, then yours will be the favourite’.

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

on the other hand they’re are still
plenty of other names??

AIBU?

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

OP posts:
Mikimoto · 15/06/2023 11:28

Well if she wants her son to be the "favourite", and your mum is called, say, Jennifer, ask sis if she wants to call her son Jennifer.

3luckystars · 15/06/2023 11:25

Just text back ‘DH is naming the baby so I’m keeping out of naming discussions from now on, glad you have a good list as you have loads of good options there.’

DemonicCaveMaggot · 15/06/2023 11:23

Good grief, it doesn't matter if cousins have the same first name. Either they will end up as 'Jack' and 'Jackie' or 'Grace' and 'Gracie' or Big Jack and Little Jack even if Little Jack is 6 inches taller than Big Jack.

Your sister appears to have a very poor opinion of your mother if she thinks your mother will play favourites based on a name. Does your mother actually want a grandchild named after her? DH and I were going to name one of our DC after my mother 'I've always hated my first name' she told us. I suggested her second name 'I don't like that one much either'.

HelpMeUnpickThis · 15/06/2023 11:21

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 07:56

My sister and I are both pregnant. I’m due about a month before she is, she’s having a boy, we’re waiting til birth to find out.

Initially she told me a boys names she’d like to use so obviously I took that off my list. However she now keeps adding to her list and we’re up to about 6 or 7 boys names that’s she considering and I’m guessing doesn’t want me to use. She hasn’t directly said it’s heavily implied. Such as randomly testing ‘oh btw we also like Jack’ for example, I’ll say ‘oh yea we also like that one’ and she’ll reply ‘well we’re not sure if we’re going to use it yet’ 👀.

As we’re not sure what we’re having, we’re thinking about naming baby after my mum if we have a girl. Sister also isn’t keen as ‘is that fair, then yours will be the favourite’.

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

on the other hand they’re are still
plenty of other names??

AIBU?

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

Gosh do people who act like this look back and cringe at themselves?!

@Pregnantforwaytoolong - ignore. Don’t even give it headspace.

Madness!

RedRosette2023 · 15/06/2023 11:20

EVHead · 15/06/2023 08:06

Name your baby what you want. Your sister sounds about 12 years old.

Whoever has their baby second will just need to decide whether to name them the same thing as their cousin, or something different.

This.

caringcarer · 15/06/2023 11:16

EVHead · 15/06/2023 08:06

Name your baby what you want. Your sister sounds about 12 years old.

Whoever has their baby second will just need to decide whether to name them the same thing as their cousin, or something different.

This. She has to just suck it up if her baby is born second. As for not wanting you to not name a girl after your Mum, there are just no words to describe how ludicrous she sounds. Your Mum will love both her newborn Grandkids.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 15/06/2023 11:10

Just stop discussing names with her, and use whatever name you want

ANonnyMice · 15/06/2023 11:08

Both my grandfathers had the same first name... so unsurprisingly, given I come from a very big family, I have four cousins with that same first name.

Nobody gets confused, nobody got upset... oh except me because it was also my favourite boy name and my husbanded vetoed it!

We told everyone our boy and girl names (including middle) very early on - that way the grandmother who felt "sorry for your poor child with a name like THAT" could get over it before the birth, and one SIL could stop sulking that I'd "stolen her favourite name" (I'd only met her once so wasn't deliberate).

In your position, I'd give her dibs on one boy name and everything else is up for grabs.

Imnotahoarderreally · 15/06/2023 11:07

I advised dd not to discuss baby names with anyone except her dh.
They chose a name that was totally not what I expected.
I would tell your dsis that she’ll find out the name once your baby is born and you’ll choose what you want.

lieselotte · 15/06/2023 11:05

I find the whole same baby name thing silly. You can call your child what you like. It's probably better not to have cousins with the same name, or at least not the same first name, especially if they are likely to be together a lot, but the way people moan on here because their friend has nicked "their" name.

Spoiler - more than one person in the world can have a name.

ShandaLear · 15/06/2023 11:01

Just stop discussing baby names with her! Joke and say - well, if they end up with the SME name it’s not the end of the world, is it? And then shut it down.

MargotBamborough · 15/06/2023 10:57

Just stop discussing baby names with your sister and pick whatever name you want when your baby is born.

BeeDavis · 15/06/2023 10:53

Just stop discussing names completely. We didn’t find out the gender of our baby, absolutely nobody knew our name choices. It’s no one’s business what we chose to call our child and if we chose a name that someone ‘may’ want to use, then tough 🙄

PurBal · 15/06/2023 10:47

You’re due first. She’s clearly got a lot of names and hasn’t decided so you get first pick. We are having a boy this month, SIL is expecting a boy in August. We’ve not even discussed names, no one owns a name.

Febreezefantastic · 15/06/2023 10:38

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:58

Because it’s bonkers and causes confusion for ever. Everyone is confused saying big Jane and little Jane, old Jane and young Jane, Jane junior, Jane senior etc etc. When there are thousands of names to choose from, why give a child a name that a close family member already has?

And actually, if OP isn’t bothered about her baby sharing her mum’s name, why worry about her baby sharing the name with her sister’s baby? Why not just all use the same names?!

you REALLY cannot think why the name of a person you love would be your preference over the name picked from a baby book? Really? 😂

A grand-daughter having her grand-mothers' name. In the real world, there's 0 confusion possible. Close family member will call one "mum, or nan" anyway

KR2023 · 15/06/2023 10:37

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

It doesn't sound like your sister is the "discussing" sort.

Start from the standpoint that anything you do will be wrong, and you can't then lose.

No way would I be letting her know the names we like. Often you change your mind when you see the baby anyway, we did with one of ours.

Moveoverdarlin · 15/06/2023 10:36

You’re due first so the absolute worst case is you’ll use one of her boys names and she’ll have to cross it off her list. At least she has a list, I had one option. You may have a girl so it’s a mute point. Forget the issue with your Mum’s name. If she’s that bothered, she can call her boy your Dad’s name and then he’ll be the favourite - if that’s her logic.

Febreezefantastic · 15/06/2023 10:35

Good luck with her.

She's obviously insecure and jealous that you will have the first born. Brace yourself, it will be a constant competition between the 2 babies. You must learn to ignore from now, and focus on the support of having 2 babies, and cousins being so close in age.

Don't ask her, pick your own name and that's that.

REP22 · 15/06/2023 10:28

Your sister's right to name her baby as she chooses does not trump yours. Choose the name that you like best for your baby and try not to be beholden to her ever-increasing "list". What she's doing is not fair to you.

It was kind of you to be understanding and accommodating with the first couple of names preferred but your sister seems to be playing games with you (and possibly also wants to be the actual one who decides what your baby is called instead of you).

Any post-birth conversations can be shut down straight away with a touch of the old grey rock method (a polite refusal to engage in any nonsense). If she starts or tries to continue any arguments, all you need to say is "This/these is/are the name/s we have chosen and we are very happy with them." Nothing further, that's the end of the discussion and you won't be debating it any more. Repeat this one phrase and no more any time it's brought up, as often as you need to. Her fire can't burn if you don't put any fuel on it.

Best of luck with the birth and with your new little one. x

SerafinasGoose · 15/06/2023 10:26

Hope your sister is responsible enough to be a mother. Her attitude is extremely childish, dictatorial and proprietorial.

If she'd had one name she'd always loved, and would have been devastated if you'd used it, that's one thing. Given there's a list of numerous possibilities, and it keeps growing, I'd say that takes care of that particular issue.

Just tell her that when the babies are born you'll both have to take pot luck, and refuse to discuss it further.

Scottishskifun · 15/06/2023 10:22

Why don't you both do a shortlist of your top 3? Have them written down and exchange at the same time rather then discussing it. That way you can see if there are any crosses. She can't claim every name on the list that's ridiculous and if you have a girl and name it after your mum then that's entirely your choice she can't veto it!

lostat · 15/06/2023 10:19

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/06/2023 08:25

Cant you just say 'sis, were both getting close to the births now and we want to decide on names for the baby. Please can you let me know your final top two choices so you can avoid them? You've mentioned quite a few over the last few months but we can't rule out all of them so let us know your final choices as I'd hate to pick your current favourite by mistake'

This. If you still want to be nice. It sounds to me like she's a bit gutted you're going to have a grandchild first and is trying to control the situation.

User1367349 · 15/06/2023 10:18

MumblesParty · 15/06/2023 09:58

Because it’s bonkers and causes confusion for ever. Everyone is confused saying big Jane and little Jane, old Jane and young Jane, Jane junior, Jane senior etc etc. When there are thousands of names to choose from, why give a child a name that a close family member already has?

And actually, if OP isn’t bothered about her baby sharing her mum’s name, why worry about her baby sharing the name with her sister’s baby? Why not just all use the same names?!

It’s not something I have personally done but I see it all the time. Never had it cause even a tiny bit of confusion. Granny Jane and Jane when talking about the whole family or where context is clear. Or Jane and Janey because loads of people use nicknames (Jane not being the most obvious for a nickname and funnily enough not one I’ve seen replicated).

An odd thing to be so worried about others doing…

2catsandhappy · 15/06/2023 10:14

I too am waiting for the coming up thread. 'Heartbroken, my sister stole my baby name.' I call dibs on that title and nobody else is allowed to use it, ever!

Guaranteed, whatever name you choose will cause her to pout and huff. Get her to pick a first and middle name you can't use.

Pinkyhere · 15/06/2023 10:14

Stop discussing names with her.
You have the advantage of probably being first and she obviously is nervous about you picking something she wants so she's trying to make you feel she has ownership of many names. It's one thing if it's the name she's had earmarked for a long time but to veto several names is ridic
Congrats to you both. But esp to you!