Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby name entitlement

160 replies

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 07:56

My sister and I are both pregnant. I’m due about a month before she is, she’s having a boy, we’re waiting til birth to find out.

Initially she told me a boys names she’d like to use so obviously I took that off my list. However she now keeps adding to her list and we’re up to about 6 or 7 boys names that’s she considering and I’m guessing doesn’t want me to use. She hasn’t directly said it’s heavily implied. Such as randomly testing ‘oh btw we also like Jack’ for example, I’ll say ‘oh yea we also like that one’ and she’ll reply ‘well we’re not sure if we’re going to use it yet’ 👀.

As we’re not sure what we’re having, we’re thinking about naming baby after my mum if we have a girl. Sister also isn’t keen as ‘is that fair, then yours will be the favourite’.

I feel this is getting a bit silly, one name of she’s really likes it and doesn’t want us to use , fair enough, but after that she just needs to accept what we call our baby even if it’s on her ‘possibles’ list. There are a couple I really like and liked before she ‘claimed’ them.

on the other hand they’re are still
plenty of other names??

AIBU?

Also is it worth discussing or just dealing with any fallout if/when baby arrives?

OP posts:
twoshedsjackson · 15/06/2023 14:06

Well it's entirely up to her, but I grew up with two cousins bearing the same first name, one on each side of the family, and it never caused any confusion which I remember, if that's any consolation.
It might be different if she had expressed a preference for one or two names, but she is being unrealistic about "bagging" so many, and I think you're right in guessing that she feels you have "beaten her to it". especially with her comment about a possible niece being called after your mother - "Not Fair" has the ring of a tantrum about it!

greyhairnomore · 15/06/2023 13:52

Call your baby what you like. Your sister is ridiculous saying yours will be favourite if it's named after your mother.

Sugargliderwombat · 15/06/2023 13:46

Tell her if she decides on a name then she can have it. But can't reserve any others, she probably just has a horrible irrational fear that you'll use a name she wants. But of course she is being unreasonable.

Splishsploshsplash · 15/06/2023 13:43

Just say, I’m not ruling out ten plus names because you like them. We’ll choose a name we like and if the cousins are the same that’s fine. I’m not talking about it anymore with you.

dottiedodah · 15/06/2023 13:36

I would just say something like "Hey Sal ,this is all getting a bit silly now,isnt it?" Just agree Jack, or the girls favourite for her.After just say "You have a number to choose from as well and will choose your fave " As far as Mums name is concerned maybe use that for a middle name .It may cause a fuss and also confusing with Big Mary little Mary sort of thing

Nothingisblackandwhite · 15/06/2023 13:30

Tell your sister you will name your baby whatever you like and she should do the same !
my sister got really s*y with em when I used my mums name as a second name and my cousins the same when I used my nana name as my oldest daughter , despite them having kids and choosing nit to use it before 🤷🏻‍♀️. People are weird .

Sartre · 15/06/2023 13:28

Wow, is she mature enough to be having a child? Demanding you don’t name your baby any of the 25 names on her list is crazy. If she chose one name then that would be far more understandable. Just call your baby whatever you want and ignore her.

2bazookas · 15/06/2023 13:26

She's being very silly and insensitive. Nobody can "book" babynames in advance. You are just as excited about your baby as she is.

Have your baby, call it what you want, and if she objects you say " Well, you had so many favourite names lined up I knew you'd be happy with any of them".

KR2023 · 15/06/2023 13:24

I would have to keep saying in front of her a different name, just to wind her up.

"Here's little Jack, Aunty Trouble"
"You are calling him Jack? I WANTED THAT NAME"

"Do you want to hold your new nephew Oliver, Aunty Trouble?"
"Oh, is it Oliver? I WANTED THAT NAME"

"Doesn't little John look like Great Uncle Robert? Thinking of calling him that." "Now he will be the most popular baby - I WANTED THAT NAME"

And ad nauseum ( in front of others) till it becomes a joke

Kedece2410 · 15/06/2023 13:18

I'd ignore her. Pick your name and don't tell her. It would be different if there was one name that she & her partner had their heart set on but she can't 'reserve' them all. Next time she mentions it just say you've picked names and leave it at that

Don't be put off calling a girl after your mum either because you can bet your life if you don't she'll have it as top of the list for future pregnancies

Pick what ever name you want. By the sounds of it if you do pick one she likes she's got plenty left on her list to choose from

MooMooSharoo · 15/06/2023 13:15

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 12:46

@Emotionalsupportviper I can’t stop laughing at this

@Grumpusaurus its the aftermath that’s the problem and being made to feel you’re unreasonable or being a bitch for choosing a ‘claimed’ name. (Other family just stick their head in the sand with any sort of unreasonableness, so I’m on my own!)

I was going to hazard a guess and say your DS is the golden child that can do no wrong and is used to getting her own way. The family head burying would seem to confirm that!

I like your compromise idea.

Either that or hope that you give birth less than 6 weeks before her and make her choose first then decide!

FriedEggChocolate · 15/06/2023 13:11

I'd be careful how / when you meet her post birth. If you're sore, knackered and a puddle of hormones, the last thing you need is her waddling in, 8 months pregnant, to berate you for giving your new baby the "wrong" name and badgering you to change it. Get your birth certificate signed off pronto if it looks like she's causing issues.

Riapia · 15/06/2023 13:04

Only in the delightfully ditsy world of MN.
😉😂😂😂

Itsadogone · 15/06/2023 12:56

Topseyt123 · 15/06/2023 12:53

Why are you discussing names with anyone other than your own DH? I see this quite often on here and it is always a really bad idea. Give nobody else a say in how you name your baby. Nobody at all.

We never discussed names with anyone else, just announced them after the birth. I didn't even discuss them with my own younger sister in the year that we were both pregnant at the same time and with the same due date (though my own DD was born 5 weeks early). She never mentioned it to me either. It wouldn't have occurred to either of us to do so.

Name your baby whatever you want to and stop letting others (particularly in your case your sister) put arbitrary obstacles in the way.

This 🙌🏼 Discussing names with people other than your partner is 9 times out of 10 only going to cause someone to give you an opinion you don’t want or try to ruin the name for you! If they hear it for the first time when the baby is already born they will just have to like it regardless

Itsadogone · 15/06/2023 12:53

The rule is whoever has the baby first picks the name first! Two of my best friends and I are all due next month, within 2 weeks of each other. We’re all having the same gender! At the start one friend said we’d have to give a few names we were thinking of using each. I’ve said no any time it’s came up in conversation and just said I haven’t got names yet. I have one/possibly two names and one in particular I am quite worried my friend could be likely to choose but chances are I will be last so if they do use it, I will just have to suck it up and choose something else without them ever knowing that was ‘my name’.

Last time I was pregnant a family friend was due months after me (both babies the same gender) and she told me what her baby was going to be called and made loads of jokey comments about how I wasn’t ‘allowed’ to pick it. Your baby isn’t called anything until it’s born so technically if that had been the name I’d had my heart set on there would have been nothing to stop me picking it! I’ve seen people even announce the name on Facebook before the baby is born too, to almost ‘claim it’ 🤦🏼‍♀️ It’s just bad luck if someone else gets there first, you just need to hope they don’t and practise a fake smile for when you say how much you love the name if they do!

i wouldn’t tell her anything else and say you’ll just wait and see who’s baby is first!

Topseyt123 · 15/06/2023 12:53

Why are you discussing names with anyone other than your own DH? I see this quite often on here and it is always a really bad idea. Give nobody else a say in how you name your baby. Nobody at all.

We never discussed names with anyone else, just announced them after the birth. I didn't even discuss them with my own younger sister in the year that we were both pregnant at the same time and with the same due date (though my own DD was born 5 weeks early). She never mentioned it to me either. It wouldn't have occurred to either of us to do so.

Name your baby whatever you want to and stop letting others (particularly in your case your sister) put arbitrary obstacles in the way.

TheMurderousGoose · 15/06/2023 12:51

I couldn't be dealing with these sisterly squabbles. My brothers would never irritate me with this shizz.

Gremlins101 · 15/06/2023 12:50

Name baby what you want. Your sister sounds very childish herself. "Your baby will be favourite".... honestly....

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 15/06/2023 12:47

I would have avoided using one name but she can't just keep adding on. Just go with whatever you want to use- she will have PLENTY of other names to choose from

Pregnantforwaytoolong · 15/06/2023 12:46

@Emotionalsupportviper I can’t stop laughing at this

@Grumpusaurus its the aftermath that’s the problem and being made to feel you’re unreasonable or being a bitch for choosing a ‘claimed’ name. (Other family just stick their head in the sand with any sort of unreasonableness, so I’m on my own!)

OP posts:
SweetBirdsong · 15/06/2023 12:45

As an aside, I have to say, I don't think I have ever known anyone name their daughter after their mum. Not a living mum anyway. People may name a baby after a mum who has passed away - but I don't actually know anyone personally, who has named a baby after a deceased mum. Grandmother/great grandmother yeah, and even a great aunt, but never the mum. (I'm sure it happens, I just don't know anyone who's done it.)

I have known people name a boy after his dad, but even then most people don't, not these days. Was very common pre 1970s, but I don't see it happen now.

AndDoTheTangoInTheNightTAAAAAANGOOO · 15/06/2023 12:44

Just name the baby whatever you want to name them. You shouldn't have discussed names at all, you both just need to do your own thing. Whoever gives birth first names their child whatever they like, whoever is second picks whatever they like. I just wouldn't entertain conversation on it. I never found out the sex of our children until birth and I never discussed names, in fact 2 of our children were only named a few days after they arrived.

oakleaffy · 15/06/2023 12:40

Call your child whatever you like..Your sister cannot 'Own' names, that's ludicrous.

In our family two people have the same name- It's not a problem.

millymog11 · 15/06/2023 12:36

maybe it was the family i grew up in but I find the point of this whole thread totally baffling.
You and your husband/partner are having a baby. Basically you and your husband/partner are the only people to be consulted in picking a name for your baby. Maybe it will be inconvenient / annoying if you end up picking the exact same name that your sister ends up picking for her baby, but the point is, this is a name for your own baby who carries that name for the rest of their life. Above everything else it must be a name which you and your partner like and want and feel is right for the new human being who will soon be part of your family. The "our entire family including extended family members/friends etc get to veto the name choice" is just strange. What if in the future you don't spend much time with your sister? You will have made a lifelong decision for your baby based on someone who is no longer in your life.

justpushingthrough · 15/06/2023 12:34

Your due the month before her so you have first dibs....unless shes told you " we are naming baby boy Jack" and refers to baby as Jack whilst shes pregnant, then i think that would be a bit mean.

But as she hasn't decided or made a choice you can name your baby what you want .

Swipe left for the next trending thread