Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacherless classrooms with kids running amok in schools buildings that are crumbling

65 replies

noblegiraffe · 14/06/2023 23:52

....that's where we're at in education, after 13 years of Conservative rule.

Ed Dorrell thinks that the state of schools could be a big election issue.

I fucking hope so.

https://capx.co/could-the-looming-schools-crisis-become-a-big-election-issue/

Could the looming schools crisis become a big election issue? - CapX

Received wisdom tells us that schools will not be a core electoral issue when Rishi Sunak goes to the country, probably next year. Most education policy wonks and pollsters (I am both) are at pains to explain that we shouldn’t expect a repeat of Tony B...

https://capx.co/could-the-looming-schools-crisis-become-a-big-election-issue/

OP posts:
Iamnotthe1 · 15/06/2023 06:52

I'm reminded of that West Wing quote:
"Mallory, education is the silver bullet. Education is everything. We don't need little changes, we need gigantic, monumental changes. Schools should be palaces. The competition for the best teachers should be fierce. They should be making six-figure salaries. Schools should be incredibly expensive for government and absolutely free of charge to its citizens, just like national defense. That's my position. I just haven't figured out how to do it yet."

Governments are too short-termist. Education shouldn't be seen as spending: it should be considered as investment. The most effective thing you can do to improve the economy, the tax revenue, etc. in the future is invest and improve the quality of education today. Governments don't do it because they don't want their spending to bear fruit during their opposition's time in government. As such, measures are sought only as quick or minor fixes, the long-term changes needed are ignored and schools continue to do their best with what they have rather than having what they need to do their best for children.

Triptoqueen · 15/06/2023 06:46

The crumbling schools are due to a building issue.
'Ministers have launched a UK government-wide inquiry into the use of crumbling concrete in public buildings following fears that nurseries, offices, shops and leisure facilities are in danger of collapse.
Every Whitehall department has been ordered to assign a civil servant to identify the use of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) across the £158bn government estate, the Guardian has learned.'
It's about 150 schools.

Banning going to the loo - What happened to cause that ban? Internal truancy, vandalism and vaping are the usual causes.
And the teachers are to blame for that - hilarious.

HidingInAForest · 15/06/2023 06:41

This often happens on threads about teaching.

Poster A - listen! Real issues in teacher.
Poster B - no not that bad.
Poster A - links to actual evidence, research etc.
Poster B - ignores evidence because when they sat in a school 30 yrs ago/walked past one/read about useless teachers all was all right.
5 yrs time - "why didn't you tell us ..."

It's so infuriating every time. That people on the ground aren't listened too, that evidence isn't listened to. This thread demonstrates that well.

Thelondonone · 15/06/2023 06:34

mintjunior (presume a name change?) I think as an outsider you may be mistaken about what being taken over by a MAT means. It’s also usually incorrect to state the ‘staff unwilling to change’ have been moved on. Not man people want their contracts changed which joining a MAT means. It doesn’t mean the teachers were rubbish, it probably means they were experienced, and therefore expensive and don’t want to teach from the same PowerPoint as the whole MAT use (as, you know, sometimes children and whole classes are different and the current Ofsted ‘consistency’ mantra is just academisation by the back door. If you think that’s a good thing for society, school or pupils then you are very sadly mistaken. I don’t blame you for going primate but please don’t believe everything Ofsted says or that academies are a good thing (other than for the bank balance of their leaders….).

Ofcourseididthat · 15/06/2023 06:25

It would be really interesting to see the list of the buildings not fit for purpose. Round here, there are loads of very new, shiny academies; that seems to be the trend.

MintJulia · 15/06/2023 06:20

I don't think it's as bad as you say.

One school local to us was in a mess, moved from Good to Inadequate, has joined a successful academy group, and several of the long-standing (and resistant to any change) staff were moved on. It was dealt with. That's one senior school among six in our town.

My ds was 11 and given a place at that school two years before the Ofsted. I already knew it was in chaos so I mortgaged my soul and sent him to a local independent. Great school, small class sizes, good results etc. Their music & drama department is in a terrapin. Remember those temporary classrooms from the 80s! The school hall is a 1950s building that badly needs heating, insulation, new windows etc. Crumbling buildings are not confined to the state sector. And they don't stop decent education/good grades/good behaviour.

Nightlystroll · 15/06/2023 03:34

noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 01:17

And children not being allowed out to the loo points to massive issues with behaviour, not a lack of them. What happened to cause that ban? Internal truancy, vandalism and vaping are the usual causes.

If thats the case, isn't that the fault of parents? Why are trying to blame the schools and the DfS?

Nightlystroll · 15/06/2023 03:32

noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 01:10

I never see teacherless classrooms.

Just because there's an adult in the room, it doesn't mean it's a teacher. There is a well-documented shortage of teachers, particularly in secondary. I'm not sure, if you have cause to go into schools and colleges, how you can have missed it.

Nor are children running round the admittedly old but perfectly serviceable buildings.

There's also a well-documented problem with crumbling school buildings. The DfE have raised the risk level of school building collapse to "very likely"

I'm not sure your observations are particularly useful.

They're not useful to you because my experience doesn't back up your argument. 😆

I can't say that every class has had an active teacher in every lesson but that has always been the case as long as I can remember. Even bank teachers going back 20 years, maybe more, would be put in classes that they had no quals in. They were there to keep order and oversee work set by the usual teachers. Clearly that doesn't happen in your school if you've got children rampaging round the classrooms and corridors during lesson times. That would just not be allowed to happen in the school and college where I go to. I wouldn't say discipline it tight but itscreasonable enforced.

Our 2 local grammar schools are both in old buildings. One built in the 1910s. One built in the 1500s. I'm sure they have issues, most buildings do. We have a brand new health centre and the air con still doesn't work. I also taught for many years in a college in the centre of town in a building put up in the 40s. It's solid walls and not crumbling, although it's heating system needs an overhaul. True they've invested in extensions to keep up to date with new technologies.) But it doesn't mean that all buildings are crumbling and falling down. Those 2 grammar schools are actually in high demand. We've had 3 brand new schools built in the adjoining major borough to us.
None of these schools are very likely to collapse. Not even likely. Not even might.

noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 01:17

And children not being allowed out to the loo points to massive issues with behaviour, not a lack of them. What happened to cause that ban? Internal truancy, vandalism and vaping are the usual causes.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 01:10

I never see teacherless classrooms.

Just because there's an adult in the room, it doesn't mean it's a teacher. There is a well-documented shortage of teachers, particularly in secondary. I'm not sure, if you have cause to go into schools and colleges, how you can have missed it.

Nor are children running round the admittedly old but perfectly serviceable buildings.

There's also a well-documented problem with crumbling school buildings. The DfE have raised the risk level of school building collapse to "very likely"

I'm not sure your observations are particularly useful.

OP posts:
Nightlystroll · 15/06/2023 01:02

I don't teach anymore but I still have cause to go into school and colleges. I never see teacherless classrooms. Nor are children running round the admittedly old but perfectly serviceable buildings. And certainly, MN is full of parents complaining that their children aren't even allowed to leave the classrooms to go to the loo so I don't think it's common in their schools either.
Is your school like this? Are you all just sat chatting or maybe cowering in the staffroom whilst the students run riot and rampage through the corridors?

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 00:50

Oh good m. Just like 80s again. What could go wrong?

noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 00:48

SarahAndQuack · 15/06/2023 00:23

It's hard to take seriously an article full of unsupported quotations.

There are links in the article supporting what he is saying.

Here are some more:

Government survey of school behaviour: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/wake-up-call-for-schools-as-weeks-of-lessons-lost-to-misbehaviour/

Recruitment and retention crisis report: https://www.nfer.ac.uk/teacher-labour-market-in-england-annual-report-2023/

Crumbling buildings: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/school-building-safety-funding-repairs-fears-collapse/

'Wake-up' call over scale of lessons lost to misbehaviour

Government survey finds discrepancy between leaders, teachers and pupils' views on disruption

https://schoolsweek.co.uk/wake-up-call-for-schools-as-weeks-of-lessons-lost-to-misbehaviour/

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 15/06/2023 00:23

It's hard to take seriously an article full of unsupported quotations.

UsingChangeofName · 15/06/2023 00:19

I do hope it is, but, as with all elections, it would be very helpful to see what all of the other parties would do, and how it would be funded.