Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacherless classrooms with kids running amok in schools buildings that are crumbling

65 replies

noblegiraffe · 14/06/2023 23:52

....that's where we're at in education, after 13 years of Conservative rule.

Ed Dorrell thinks that the state of schools could be a big election issue.

I fucking hope so.

https://capx.co/could-the-looming-schools-crisis-become-a-big-election-issue/

Could the looming schools crisis become a big election issue? - CapX

Received wisdom tells us that schools will not be a core electoral issue when Rishi Sunak goes to the country, probably next year. Most education policy wonks and pollsters (I am both) are at pains to explain that we shouldn’t expect a repeat of Tony B...

https://capx.co/could-the-looming-schools-crisis-become-a-big-election-issue/

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 13:46

I’ve posted on MN before about how my school was unable to get subject specialists to teach A-level so Y13s were left teaching themselves the course from textbooks for months.

OP posts:
Hannamarie0098 · 15/06/2023 10:03

Lullibyebye · 15/06/2023 07:44

I went on mat leave in December and the class I taught is still teacherless. There is an adult in the room but they are not a teacher because the school could not get one.

I'm on mat leave too. School was unable to recruit a maternity cover so they've resorted to a mixture of re-timetabling, cover supervisors and external cover. Shambles.

zingally · 15/06/2023 10:02

I'm a supply teacher, and have been for nearly 5 years.

Nowadays, I no longer surprised to arrive at a school to hear I'm covering Miss X, who is off more than the rest of the staff put together.
Of the 3 schools I visit most recently, 8 times out of 10 it's to cover the same teacher each time, who is off ill.

My friend's DD is in Year 6 and got a teacher who was new to the school in September. That teacher has had 2 long periods of absence, and then a phased return each time. Apparently, the kids feel like she's away more than she's in. And when she's off, the deputy head has to sit in the class, with the supply teacher teaching, because the class are so badly behaved when the usual teacher is off.

Changechangechanging · 15/06/2023 09:59

I mean, what you would really expect in a first world civilised society is someone with an eye on public buildings and a rolling inventory of some kind that replaces before they come to the end of their useful life. It may be that some buildings can go on longer than anticipated but it is clear a huge number of 1960/1970s buildings are no longer fit for purpose.

Changechangechanging · 15/06/2023 09:56

it doesn't mean that all buildings are crumbling and falling down

in a civilised, first world society, you would hope that no child was being taught in a building that is crumbling and falling down. It's not acceptable that there are buildings considered to be at risk of collapse. But there are - you really don't need to go very far to find that information. Sure, it's not all schools. But one is one too many. And god forbid, one should crumble whilst children are in it.

Sherrystrull · 15/06/2023 09:54

It never fails to surprise me that some people are saying school staff are incorrect when they pop into a school once in a while.

Anyone visiting my classroom would think all is well. However, the door collapsed on me twice, there is black mould on the ceiling, the curtain rail collapsed on a child and three windows are cracked.

Visitors generally don't get told these things as they are focused on their visit.

katmarie · 15/06/2023 09:17

During recent storms my ds's primary school roof collapsed. There are rooms they are unable to use now as a result. The PTA is fundraising to get it fixed, because there doesn't seem to be any money coming from anywhere else to fix it. That's not the role of the PTA, but bless them, they are doing it anyway. The same school has announced that more than half of its teaching assistants and lunch time staff are being let go at the end of the school year, and not replaced. They also have a combined year one/two class due to teacher shortages and low pupil numbers.

Schools are in crisis. Teachers are doing their best, with limited resources and constantly increasing expectations. Our children, teachers and school staff deserve better. If school conditions and education funding is not a central issue in the next election then all of our political parties have totally lost touch with the general public and what is important to them.

timetorefresh · 15/06/2023 09:08

My school is one of the best in the county. Massively oversubscribed. Just in my dept alone we are short three full teachers for Sept as people are leaving teaching and we've not been able to recruit enough replacements. No idea who'll be teaching those groups

Its true that the school isn't falling down. It was rebuilt on the cheap by a private company that the school has to rent the buildings from. We have "invacuation" alarms for when it gets windy as sometimes bits of the building blow off....

CalistoNoSolo · 15/06/2023 09:03

What is relevant is that we have had 13 years of chronic under investment in education; a right wing media constantly undermining teachers, the value of education, anyone with a different opinion to the tory govt, anyone at university; a majority of the workforce who are just too up against it trying to stay afloat to protest/volunteer/afford private. Added to which our education system seems designed to discourage critical thinking and isn't even trying to produce a half decent workforce.

The whole thing is an utter shambles and needs to be torn down and rebuilt from scratch by people who actually know what they are doing. It should be a cross-party responsibility not confined to central govt. We're already seeing the results of lack of NHS reform and investment and its bloody terrifying. There is a time lag with education:workforce but its coming and its going to be equally bad.

Outofthepark · 15/06/2023 09:03

SarahAndQuack · 15/06/2023 00:23

It's hard to take seriously an article full of unsupported quotations.

That's your takeaway from the article? 😄

NoFunAnymoreHere · 15/06/2023 09:00

I believe all the stuff teachers say here about the state sector. Which is why so many are now choosing private for their kids. I know it too will be affected by the recruitment crisis but for now, the many private options we have around us provide much greater security for worried parents. A great state school is now a lucky luxury rather than something we can take for granted. And that’s the fault of the government not teachers.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 15/06/2023 08:54

I used to work in a university and one of the departmental noticeboards had a poster up reading 'The plural of anecdote is not data'. Threads like these always suffer from individual posters saying 'Well, I've never seen that, so it can't be happening anywhere'. Must be very wearing for those who are seeing the problems of state education in real time.

toomuchlaundry · 15/06/2023 08:49

DS’s Primary school had temporary classrooms that had been there for over 50 years. It was only when none of them were really usable that a new building was finally commissioned

Adenomyosisisntyourosis · 15/06/2023 08:28

Our local MP is currently campaigning for a local secondary school to be renovated after parts of the sports hall actually fell off. In York there have been two new schools built but the existing ones have had no improvements in decades.

toomuchlaundry · 15/06/2023 08:11

A secondary school I know has a large part of the site condemned so can’t be used. Other parts of the school are heading that way. It’s finally been granted money from DfE building scheme. However, that is 10 year scheme and school doesn’t know where it fits in that 10 years. It is competing with other crumbling schools across the country. In the meantime they have to decide whether to have other parts of the site condemned and not have sufficient space for the students or use precious depleted school budget to patch up these buildings which will then be eventually demolished once the building scheme starts. It is ridiculous.

noblegiraffe · 15/06/2023 07:58

Nightlystroll

You don't appear to understand. The thread title comes from the article by Ed Dorrell, who is not a teacher, but a journalist who is reporting on the situation in schools. He, and I have posted links to data which back up these claims.

You cannot, therefore, counter this by saying things like " my school isn't crumbling". It's the DfE who have reported that the risk of school collapse is "very likely" (although the Conservatives voted down telling parents which schools are the most at risk). And it's not just the autoclaved concrete issue, the DfE reports that "the modelled cost of “remedial work to repair or replace all defective elements in the school estate” is £11.4 billion, with the average secondary school needing £1.6 million worth of work."

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 15/06/2023 07:48

Iamnotthe1 · 15/06/2023 06:52

I'm reminded of that West Wing quote:
"Mallory, education is the silver bullet. Education is everything. We don't need little changes, we need gigantic, monumental changes. Schools should be palaces. The competition for the best teachers should be fierce. They should be making six-figure salaries. Schools should be incredibly expensive for government and absolutely free of charge to its citizens, just like national defense. That's my position. I just haven't figured out how to do it yet."

Governments are too short-termist. Education shouldn't be seen as spending: it should be considered as investment. The most effective thing you can do to improve the economy, the tax revenue, etc. in the future is invest and improve the quality of education today. Governments don't do it because they don't want their spending to bear fruit during their opposition's time in government. As such, measures are sought only as quick or minor fixes, the long-term changes needed are ignored and schools continue to do their best with what they have rather than having what they need to do their best for children.

This is a great post. The UK is supposed to be one of the richest countries in the world and one of the most advanced economies. We specialise in industries that need a highly educated workforce - very niche areas of manufacturing, financial services, the arts, and so on. All the things that can be made cheaply by lower skilled people are mostly imported. There aren't many jobs left for poorly educated kids. So why aren't we investing in our young people so we can keep this economy going? We need to invest heavily in education and really push it as a priority for everybody - lifelong learning, properly funded in service training for all sorts of jobs, top notch vocational training for those who don't want to go to university.

As well as drastically improving what goes on in schools from nursery to sixth form we need a huge push to support families with babies and young children. Far too many kids have their card marked in the early months of life. Their language and social skills are poor when they start school and they never catch up.

As for schools, my children are adults now, but what I want for current schools is what I wanted for them - a qualified teacher in every class. In secondary schools I want children taught by subject specialists. It doesn't seem much to ask. Other countries manage it, what on earth's gone wrong here?

HidingInAForest · 15/06/2023 07:45

We also have woeful send provision that is falling apart at the seams. Our lea seems to have a revolving door of case workers and a lskc of sen spaces

Lullibyebye · 15/06/2023 07:44

I went on mat leave in December and the class I taught is still teacherless. There is an adult in the room but they are not a teacher because the school could not get one.

uninspiredpanda · 15/06/2023 07:38

Some of these replies are a little deluded as to the state of things.

In the last 12 months two separate classrooms in different buildings in my school have had ceilings literally falling in, both narrowly missing the teachers in the rooms at the time. One of the offices has mould covering the wall.

Remember those temporary classrooms from the 80s you say? Yup. We still have one. It has 6 rooms that are in daily use.

No teachers? Might be a slight exaggeration but we have a number of temporary staff that were taken on from supply but are woefully under skilled and we haven't managed to recruit for the 3 vacancies we have for September so we will have non specialists teaching ks3 next year.

Yes I'm just one school. A snapshot. But you will find similar stories everywhere.

Experienced teachers moved on because they were resistant to change? Because consistency and continuity from skilled and experienced experts in their subjects is definitely a bad thing. I've been teaching for 20 years. I would like to think I know how to teach my subject inside out. Whilst there are many positives to ECTs- being full of enthusiasm, great ideas and energy - I'm also sure someone fresh from teacher training doesn't have the same depth of knowledge or understanding of how students learn as I do.

Nightlystroll · 15/06/2023 07:38

lazyfucker · 15/06/2023 07:01

Come to my school then. You will find plenty of classrooms without teachers. There may be supply teachers who are non-specialists or cover supervisors, who are not teachers.

We have parents on social media complaining that their dc are not allowed to the toilet. By this they mean they are challenged if they are found to go every lesson, or asked if they really need to go five minutes before the end, or removed from toilets if they are spending lunchtime in there, preventing younger ones from using the loos. What some parents say isn't completely reliable.

Some of our buildings have recently been deemed unsafe by DfE inspectors but a successful bid for funds to replace the roof has been agreed but 'pending' for weeks now, with no explanation given, meaning the works are unlikely to be completed over the summer - or at least there is a risk they won't be as more time goes by with it just 'pending'.

It's an utter shitshow in schools now and if you are visiting several and can't see it I'm not sure what use your visits can possibly be.

You don't know what my visits are for so you don't how useful they are!

In my local school, I know, because I've been there, that all the toilets are locked during lesson times. Students need a key to go which they can't have without permission from the teacher. All teachers encourage children to wait. I never heard of anyone being told no, except maybe the usual suspects. However, unlike your school, the students aren't rioting in the hallways nor rampaging round the buildings.

Your building is deemed unsafe and you have been allotted money to have it made safe.

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/06/2023 07:21

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 00:50

Oh good m. Just like 80s again. What could go wrong?

I was at a very very poor school in the 80s. It’s nothing like the 80s.

HidingInAForest · 15/06/2023 07:18

Yup local grammar school to me has often had their cover teacher in as there are missing teachers - and that's a very good school. It was getting to the point where "oh it was a cover" was something that was just normal several times a week.

I've posted about this before but many many primary schools will use an hlta 1 day a week to cover for head of yesrs ppa day. We fairly regularly get "my child is being taught by a TA!' Threads. Not legal in Scotland and didn't used to be in England- we used to have a rule that there had ti be a qualified teacher in the class and now there isn't are we surprised what we have got!?

It's just further eroding the expectation that you will even have a qualified teacher teaching your child.

lazyfucker · 15/06/2023 07:01

Nightlystroll · 15/06/2023 01:02

I don't teach anymore but I still have cause to go into school and colleges. I never see teacherless classrooms. Nor are children running round the admittedly old but perfectly serviceable buildings. And certainly, MN is full of parents complaining that their children aren't even allowed to leave the classrooms to go to the loo so I don't think it's common in their schools either.
Is your school like this? Are you all just sat chatting or maybe cowering in the staffroom whilst the students run riot and rampage through the corridors?

Come to my school then. You will find plenty of classrooms without teachers. There may be supply teachers who are non-specialists or cover supervisors, who are not teachers.

We have parents on social media complaining that their dc are not allowed to the toilet. By this they mean they are challenged if they are found to go every lesson, or asked if they really need to go five minutes before the end, or removed from toilets if they are spending lunchtime in there, preventing younger ones from using the loos. What some parents say isn't completely reliable.

Some of our buildings have recently been deemed unsafe by DfE inspectors but a successful bid for funds to replace the roof has been agreed but 'pending' for weeks now, with no explanation given, meaning the works are unlikely to be completed over the summer - or at least there is a risk they won't be as more time goes by with it just 'pending'.

It's an utter shitshow in schools now and if you are visiting several and can't see it I'm not sure what use your visits can possibly be.

Billabongo · 15/06/2023 06:55

MintJulia · 15/06/2023 06:20

I don't think it's as bad as you say.

One school local to us was in a mess, moved from Good to Inadequate, has joined a successful academy group, and several of the long-standing (and resistant to any change) staff were moved on. It was dealt with. That's one senior school among six in our town.

My ds was 11 and given a place at that school two years before the Ofsted. I already knew it was in chaos so I mortgaged my soul and sent him to a local independent. Great school, small class sizes, good results etc. Their music & drama department is in a terrapin. Remember those temporary classrooms from the 80s! The school hall is a 1950s building that badly needs heating, insulation, new windows etc. Crumbling buildings are not confined to the state sector. And they don't stop decent education/good grades/good behaviour.

I'm afraid I agree with a pp that it is likely more expensive teachers were pushed out. There was a thread just recently about a teacher who'd had a career of Good or Outstanding lesson observations suddenly being told she was inadequate. The only two teachers in school in the same boat were also the other two at the top of the main pay scale. I think I've met a grand total of two people in primary education who have positive things to say about academisation, and one of them benefitted from it financially; I know plenty others, including heads and Ofsted inspectors, who think it is dreadful, and several who have left education altogether because of it.