Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hacked off at the home ed community already

244 replies

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 20:38

Hi,
I am a mother to a neurodiverse child who has struggled in school since reception. They have had a complete burn out and now cannot access school at all. They are 8. We have tried EVERYTHING to make school work. They aren't suitable for a special school.
I have a reluctant home educator. I say reluctant as I never really envisaged being my child's main source of knowledge. I am a single parent and have very little support. I am also a home owner with a full time job.
I receive nothing from their father.
All of the above means that home education is not really an option but I have no choice due to child's refusal to go into school.
I have tentatively been looking into home education groups which may mean I can keep my career. At the moment I am on a sort of extended carers leave but this is untenable in the long term. My mortgage fixed rate also expires in August and I need to renew!
There is, on the whole, a complete lack of empathy for my situation from the local home education groups. The whole thing feels like a very entitled, white woman's, heterosexual, almost trad fem secret society.
There are very few which offer any support for ND kids, very few who offer hours longer than 9.30 until 2, even fewer which are ofsted registered meaning I can claim UC for the costs. I understand the reasons for this but it's the way that they all act like I'm the first person to ask or the only lone parent they've ever met who isn't willing to Jack in their job at the drop at the drop of a hat.
No one can make my situation better. I know that. But it makes you feel even shitter to feel too poor, single and not 'child focused' enough for the only other option. My only friend who is experiencing the same is utterly miserable, stuck at home with her challenging ND child, declined from every home Ed group and unable to access mainstream school. I just can't believe our lives have turned out this way. We both have qualifications and ambition. No one tells you that your child will not be able to go to school, that's something I always assumed was a given!

OP posts:
cathcath2 · 14/06/2023 23:22

And I am not saying getting him into any provision will be easy. Get advice from SENDIASS and IPSEA. Get your local councillor involved and your local MP if possible. As a previous poster has said, get a paper trial in place.

DrCoconut · 14/06/2023 23:20

@dontknowher I know what you mean about privilege. The vast majority of home ed mums (and they are almost always mums) I've met have husband/partner in a good job, a large house with a big garden for chickens, growing vegetables etc and no need to worry about earning a living. Their children seem very easy to manage and content with mud, wooden animals and homemade organic snacks. Obviously you never know what goes on behind closed doors so I say seem. If these people found themselves single with ND children and living in a flat with UC on their case about getting work I don't think they'd cope to be honest. I'm sure a lot of them are nice enough but the reality is they are privileged. I'm also sure there's the other side of this coin - the people who have had to give up work to pull their children out of a damaging school situation. But for a guess they go unseen as they are too preoccupied elsewhere.

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:19

I will take on board that my anger is misdirected. I am probably bitter about my situation.
I think somewhere in me, this feeling of resentment at my situation whilst a lot of the home ed mums I meet seem joyful, happy, optimistic... it's brought up a feeling of inadequacy about my parenting. My job in healthcare gives me that feeling, that feeling of achievement and confidence in my abilities, whilst parenting my child doesn't.
Quite frankly I don't know what I'm doing when parenting my dc most of the time. I don't know whether to use discipline or when to let things go, I don't know how to deal with meltdowns or what I should be expecting or anticipating to prevent them. I don't know whether I'm too strict or too lenient. No one tells you how to do it.

OP posts:
cathcath2 · 14/06/2023 23:17

OP, with the greatest respect, you need to approach your council to get your son into alternative provision. You can't home educate him as you don't have the resources. That isn't a criticism. Please don't deregister, if you haven't already. What you describe as wanting, is alternative provision, not home education.

gogohmm · 14/06/2023 23:17

What you are describing, dropping off for a few hours, is called school. Part time, private but still school. When I home educated mine most groups required me to stay - I wasn't working at that point. Rather than trad wives i would say most the homeschooling mums were real earth mothers, vegans, cycling everywhere etc whereas we were between houses then struggled to get school placements

FuckStonewall · 14/06/2023 23:16

I think you're looking for a provision that doesn't exist, but I'm afraid that's not the fault of the HE community.

Devonshiregal · 14/06/2023 23:16

I’m confused…what does sexuality have to do with this? Why are these women being berated for being heterosexual? You’re in a tough spot but criticising other women for things they can’t change about themselves seems pretty petty

MorningShow · 14/06/2023 23:15

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:05

@MorningShow how many dads did you meet who were choosing to be at home with the children home educating? It's not bitter, it's honesty. If there were dads all over the country being left without jobs, careers, without financial independence free from benefits, I imagine many more specialist schools/ alternative provisions would open. But as it's only mums having to give up their jobs, no one cares.

It’s hard going, I know.

But don’t waste your time directing your frustration at other parents who have chosen to home Ed their kids.

This isn’t going to get easier anytime soon. So you need to take a deep breathe, buckle up and take action.

Phone education welfare. Tell them your DC can’t attend and part-time timetable failed. Phoned your local SENDIASS service for advice (free service) and put in parental application for EHCP asap.

Find out who is responsible for section 19 provision at your local authority (there will be a named person). Contact them.

Keep emailing school as well and asking them what they are going to put in place. Make a paper trail.

Join local parent carers groups online. Find parents of other ND children, ask them for advice.

Call GP, ask them for help with your DC’s mental health.

Can you find another job working from home, can you retrain? If you claim DLA can you then go part-time and get UC top up?

You are allowed to have a wobble. But then you need to get moving. Direct your anger in the right direction and take control.

JeandeServiette · 14/06/2023 23:07

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:05

@MorningShow how many dads did you meet who were choosing to be at home with the children home educating? It's not bitter, it's honesty. If there were dads all over the country being left without jobs, careers, without financial independence free from benefits, I imagine many more specialist schools/ alternative provisions would open. But as it's only mums having to give up their jobs, no one cares.

Again, that's a fault of the education system/SEN services/society as a whole.

It's odd that you're misdirecting your fury at the Home Edders, many of whom are in a similar tight spot to the one you're in.

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:05

@MorningShow how many dads did you meet who were choosing to be at home with the children home educating? It's not bitter, it's honesty. If there were dads all over the country being left without jobs, careers, without financial independence free from benefits, I imagine many more specialist schools/ alternative provisions would open. But as it's only mums having to give up their jobs, no one cares.

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 14/06/2023 23:03

The advice you have had on here about accessing alternative educational provision sounds like your best bet. School doesn't work for your child and home ed doesn't work for you - I hope you find others options that might be a better fit.

HidingInAForest · 14/06/2023 23:01

Home school groups aren't on the whole "settings." I am not sure where you have approached for care. There are private schools which flexischool or are more alternative but thats not home ed!

Home ed will require someone to be home or a nanny/childminder.

Or keep him on roll and push for alternative settings/ there are settings near me that are outdoor based/animal based etc but only seem to be accessible when there isn't a suitable specialist school/child refusing school (I dont really understand how it works) YOu coudl try another post about this?

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:01

@TheYearOfSmallThings because they love being in control of what they do. If I could make it work, a few hours at forest school a couple of times a week, being at home, reading and writing for a few hours a day and then playing in the afternoon would suit my dc to the ground. They would thrive, their mental health would improve.
But unfortunately I can't offer them that.
I also worry about their future, secondary school, being isolated.

But my child would choose to be home schooled without a doubt.

OP posts:
MorningShow · 14/06/2023 23:01

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 22:55

@Ottersmith I stand by the term 'trad fem' as 99.9% of home educator parents who I have met are mums. The whole ethos is centred around this earth mother model who loves her children and their 'little wild souls' just a little bit more than those mothers who need to work to pay bills.

You sound bitter OP. I’ve met several families at home Ed groups (we went to a few when my DC was first unable to attend school, whilst waiting for LA to arrange and pay for alternative provision) who have ND children, often stretching themselves to the limit financially.

None of the groups were “drop and run” though, it’s not how home Ed works. But, they did have a nice supportive community and took it in turns to help each other out with childcare at times. It takes time to get to know people though, new adults and children. With your sneery attitude, I’m not surprised that you haven’t found it it to be a supportive community.

Are you claiming DLA for your DC? It isn’t means tested and could help you out a little

JeandeServiette · 14/06/2023 22:59

TBH @dontknowher , those aren't really questions for the Home Ed community to answer.

Yes, it's easier for well off people to Home Ed because of the economics. Which is privilege. But worrying about that won't help you now.

The only entitlement your DS has is to an accessible education from the state, which can take some fighting for, a lot of admin and expert testimony. Contrary to PP's comments, you don't need expensive legal teams or private reports to get him what he needs, but you will need to be prepared to push and chase and take the initiative to get CAMHS reports, a suitable EHCP and a suitable provision for him.

If you can do that, though, it will pay off.

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 22:57

@nobodysdaughternow this is what the school have pushed, a 'reduced timetable' which then became no timetable as my dc refused to go at all.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 14/06/2023 22:57

I don't think it's anything to do with privilege, what you are asking for just does not exist for any parent, regardless of wealth or time.

I also don't see why you believe such a setting would work for your child whereas no school could, including special schools.

StrawberryWater · 14/06/2023 22:56

Op have you tried an educational mental health practitioner for your child? You can access them through schools. My son developed school refusal and anxiety after lock down and he did a 6 week course and it was such a game changer.

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 22:55

@Ottersmith I stand by the term 'trad fem' as 99.9% of home educator parents who I have met are mums. The whole ethos is centred around this earth mother model who loves her children and their 'little wild souls' just a little bit more than those mothers who need to work to pay bills.

OP posts:
ThomasWasTortured · 14/06/2023 22:51

Parents don’t need a legal team to secure EOTAS, it is possible to get it without, although, obviously, parents can choose to if they wish. If independent assessments are needed and the parents can’t get them via legal aid there are charities that can sometimes help fund them, such as Parents in Need. Neither is EOTAS only for very poorly children who can’t leave the house or learn in group.

EOTAS via an EHCP often takes an appeal but once you have a detailed, specified and quantified EHCP it must be provided, and can be enforced if the LA try not to, via JR if necessary.

Provision under s.19 of the Education Act 1996 isn’t optional for LAs either and can also be enforced.

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 22:51

Sorry I was in the middle of bedtime when I wrote the post so I didn't articulate myself very well.
When I say that I haven't found a home Ed group for my child, what I meant is that none of the settings for older children where you drop and leave them have said they can cater for my child's needs (Asd, adhd and mild learning disability). I get their reasons why completely but as the parent of a sen child, it still feels like I'm excluded from these spaces. I don't want to drop just so I can work but because I strongly believe that my child needs time away from me. They struggled massively after lock down, even though I worked outside of the home throughout, it made their world much smaller and I'm worried about replicating that by making their world consist of me, their sibling and about five relatives.
I did not mean that ND children aren't home educated but I haven't met many like mine yet. Mostly I have met very high functioning autistic children without the adhd component who disliked and struggled with the social side of school. They do well through independent learning, and the whole set up really suits them.
On the other hand I have met parents with ND kids who have never been able to access school who's children have basically been able to do what they like all day, usually due to PDA or similar. I've met parents who's eight year olds play mine craft all day or go to Forrest school and bash up big rocks and sticks for hours. After five years of school, I am really concerned that if I go down the 'unschooling' route I will never get my DC back into formal education.
There is a certain amount of privilege which I feel the home Ed group doesn't acknowledge. If I 'unschool' then I'm basically signing up to support my child for life. Yes their mental health is important too, but by not giving them an education I feel I'm condemning them to a life without work, independence and job satisfaction.
In regards to learning disabilities, they're not just going to pull B's or C's out the bag in their GCSE's. So by letting them do what they want all day, even if they are happier, I'm going to have to accept that they might rely on me forever... but how can I support them if I have to give up work now?
These are the questions that the home Ed forums can't answer, what happens after? What happens at secondary level? What happens when I need to pay my mortgage? What happens when my other child goes on school camp or school trips and they say they feel left out? How do have any sort of life myself when I'm with them 24 hours a day, seven days a week?

It's a very different experience to a stay at home mum with a rich husband who has made that choice because they like wooden toys and crochet.

OP posts:
humus · 14/06/2023 22:51

@Tygertiger you might be lucky enough to live in an area with a whole plethora of special schools but in my area, the same as the OP there is NOTHING for a child without severe LD or challenging behaviour. If you child doesn’t fall into either category the only option is ETOAS or potentially bespoke provision through mainstream school managing a package. Neither of these are easy to access. Our child has been out of school nearly an entire academic year whilst the EHCP process grinds along. We may or may not have something in place by next year but it won’t be based in a school as they don’t exist.

MorningShow · 14/06/2023 22:50

nobodysdaughternow · 14/06/2023 22:44

Also, EOTAS packages also require money because they are essentially for very poorly children who cannot leave their home or learn in groups.

You will need private EP reports and a good legal team.

EOTAS is often cited as an entitlement/right, when in reality, LA are struggling to delivery SEN basics.

My child has EOTAS and is not a poorly child and she enjoys groups (though has 1-1 in them). She does full days away from home in various placements.

There isn’t a specialist school in our county that can meet her particular needs. Being academically able was actually a barrier to the ones that might have been suitable.

It was an absolute fight to get EOTAS though, that is true, but the fight for a specialist school would have been equally difficult

StrawberryWater · 14/06/2023 22:49

I think you need to change your view of home Ed. It sounds like you envision it more like a childminders or one person teaching a whole bunch of kids over a computer via teams/zoom or whatever.

It’s really not like that. You, as the parent, become the teacher. That means you source and find age appropriate work. You up your subject knowledge. You provide all the fixtures and fittings for learning (so adequate study space, computer and stationary etc). Etc, etc.

As someone who was home educated my outside enrichment (and where I could meet people my own age etc) came from being a member of The Girl Guides, St John’s Ambulance, a reading group at the library and a sailing club etc.

nobodysdaughternow · 14/06/2023 22:44

Also, EOTAS packages also require money because they are essentially for very poorly children who cannot leave their home or learn in groups.

You will need private EP reports and a good legal team.

EOTAS is often cited as an entitlement/right, when in reality, LA are struggling to delivery SEN basics.