Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hacked off at the home ed community already

244 replies

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 20:38

Hi,
I am a mother to a neurodiverse child who has struggled in school since reception. They have had a complete burn out and now cannot access school at all. They are 8. We have tried EVERYTHING to make school work. They aren't suitable for a special school.
I have a reluctant home educator. I say reluctant as I never really envisaged being my child's main source of knowledge. I am a single parent and have very little support. I am also a home owner with a full time job.
I receive nothing from their father.
All of the above means that home education is not really an option but I have no choice due to child's refusal to go into school.
I have tentatively been looking into home education groups which may mean I can keep my career. At the moment I am on a sort of extended carers leave but this is untenable in the long term. My mortgage fixed rate also expires in August and I need to renew!
There is, on the whole, a complete lack of empathy for my situation from the local home education groups. The whole thing feels like a very entitled, white woman's, heterosexual, almost trad fem secret society.
There are very few which offer any support for ND kids, very few who offer hours longer than 9.30 until 2, even fewer which are ofsted registered meaning I can claim UC for the costs. I understand the reasons for this but it's the way that they all act like I'm the first person to ask or the only lone parent they've ever met who isn't willing to Jack in their job at the drop at the drop of a hat.
No one can make my situation better. I know that. But it makes you feel even shitter to feel too poor, single and not 'child focused' enough for the only other option. My only friend who is experiencing the same is utterly miserable, stuck at home with her challenging ND child, declined from every home Ed group and unable to access mainstream school. I just can't believe our lives have turned out this way. We both have qualifications and ambition. No one tells you that your child will not be able to go to school, that's something I always assumed was a given!

OP posts:
JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 01:11

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:06

@saltinesandcoffeecups or maybe because it doesn't work and isn't an option but if they say that it would support the argument that it isn't actually accessible to all. It's like private school.

It is like private school, yes. But nobody ever said it was accessible to all.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 15/06/2023 01:10

@saltinesandcoffeecups 😂😂😂

JeandeServiette · 15/06/2023 01:09

Indeed! I just don't get how it works for single working parents and I'm yet to have one person explain it to me.

I had to give up work for about 15 months to do the educating and childcare while we churned our way through the system to get the school we wanted names on an ECHP. I scraped by on tax credits, Carer's allowance, small amount DLA and modest savings. EXH was dodging CM energetically.

It was hairy and I couldn't have done it long term.

I did meet some home educating single mums who were renting and surviving long term on benefits. Some of them were inspirational, but it's a huge sacrifice of career, pension, luxuries etc, and that was a few years back before the CoL crisis.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 01:08

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:06

@saltinesandcoffeecups or maybe because it doesn't work and isn't an option but if they say that it would support the argument that it isn't actually accessible to all. It's like private school.

What law says that HE provided by other people needs to be made available to your child?

Honestly OP, you’re like a Vegan that turns up at a steak house bitching they don’t have any food to offer you

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:08

@octaurpus it's true if you've met one autistic person you've met one autistic person. Also I'd love to see someone try to 'discipline' a child with PDA, what do they think will happen?

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 15/06/2023 01:07

@dontknowher and yet there you go again with your incorrect assumptions:

"You will get a true mixture of ethnicities, family set ups, genders, disabilities, religions, cultures, economic status's."

You very much get the same mixture in the home ed community. Believe me, I know what I'm talking about.

"With home education, you will only get families where one parent can take substantial time off work."

Wrong again.

Many people have a gripe about home ed because they don't want to listen to experienced home edders that do try to explain the realities and possibilities. It's not for everyone, and doesn't work for everyone, that's true, however, it absolutely can work in the circumstances that you're saying it can't. But what would I know, I've only been doing it myself for five years and am deeply involved in the home ed community at national level.

octaurpus · 15/06/2023 01:06

dontknowher absolutely. My nephew attends an elite private school, and my SIL and DB think they know everything about autism because DN has two autistic boys in his primary school class. So it is as a result of my PDA DS's parenting that he cannot attend school. And his meltdowns are a result of our permissive parenting. Argh! Despite endless talk of inclusion and acceptance, nothing has changed for so many of us.

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:06

@saltinesandcoffeecups or maybe because it doesn't work and isn't an option but if they say that it would support the argument that it isn't actually accessible to all. It's like private school.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 01:04

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:03

Indeed! I just don't get how it works for single working parents and I'm yet to have one person explain it to me.

Maybe because you’ve insulted them?

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:03

Axahooxa · 15/06/2023 00:54

@ReadingSoManyThreads

Home ed is flexible and can be slotted around employment. There is no requirement for home ed to be done during school days or hours

But who looks after the children while the parents work?
When on earth is the time to slot in flexible education around work?!

Indeed! I just don't get how it works for single working parents and I'm yet to have one person explain it to me.

OP posts:
dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:01

@octaurpus so how do we change the system? Just out of interest, if school was an option would you send your children?

OP posts:
octaurpus · 15/06/2023 01:00

There is a subset of home-edders with ND kids who struggle hugely financially. I am one, and know plenty of others. I've had to give up my career, and my DH now works part-time tutoring ND home-ed kids. It's not a privilege for many of us, it's an absolute necessity, because our kids cannot access mainstream or other formal education, or care settings. We are poor. Home ed can be financially devastating for families, but needs must.

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:59

@Axahooxa PDA alone is so difficult. That's why I think there's so much more education needed around the different types of autism. Everyone knows one high functioning but mostly beautifully behaved autistic kid, or one slightly dreamy ADD girl and they don't recognise your experience or feelings. The irony is that this has become the public face of neurodiversity. So when my shrieking child bites or hits or runs from me in public, there is as much taboo as there has ever been, because they are seeing autism or ADHD as being a certain set of quirks or traits and not what is most peoples reality.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 00:59

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 00:55

I literally have no horse in this race but you need to stop digging @dontknowher

Stomp your feet and shake your fist at the clouds if that makes you feel better. But insulting a group of people that are in no way responsible for the situation you are in is wasting your time and energy and the goodwill of people who may be able to offer advice.

Unless this is an attempt to cast derision on HE parents… in that case you’re a sad individual. But hey I’m willing to believe the best people!

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 00:55

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:40

As I have stated many times, I was wrong to blame home educators.
But it is a privilege to be able to do so.
I think that part is lost amongst all the propaganda about it being some, noble higher calling.
And I think it's a world away from being excluded from mainstream education with no alternative.
And I also wonder about UBI and whether this will make home education more popular, and economically diverse, especially with the recruitment crisis in schools and higher ratios of Sen children.

I literally have no horse in this race but you need to stop digging @dontknowher

Stomp your feet and shake your fist at the clouds if that makes you feel better. But insulting a group of people that are in no way responsible for the situation you are in is wasting your time and energy and the goodwill of people who may be able to offer advice.

Axahooxa · 15/06/2023 00:54

@ReadingSoManyThreads

Home ed is flexible and can be slotted around employment. There is no requirement for home ed to be done during school days or hours

But who looks after the children while the parents work?
When on earth is the time to slot in flexible education around work?!

Axahooxa · 15/06/2023 00:52

I hear you OP. My child (autistic, PDA, OCD, language processing difficulties) is older but also burnt out and going through similar problems. Camhs aren’t worth getting through to- even with self harm and an overdose the weren’t interested in helping.

I absolutely understand your feelings.

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:51

@ReadingSoManyThreads this is not a criticism but there are many people who would not be able to make home education work for them, so it may be diverse in some respects but it is not as diverse as your average school. And I say that as someone who's child is excluded from a mainstream school!
The beauty of school is that most children can attend. You will get a true mixture of ethnicities, family set ups, genders, disabilities, religions, cultures, economic status's.
With home education, you will only get families where one parent can take substantial time off work. This may not be true in the age of 'working from home' but I don't think many employers would be happy with an employee being a teacher as well! Most state that you cannot have dependents at home during working hours. I doubt that you could offer a full education for a primary age child and work core 9-5 hours.
Therefore, having two parents at home makes it significantly easier to homeschool.
Which is what irritates me slightly. The assumption that it's easy.... except it's not easy if you are a lone parent.

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 15/06/2023 00:41

@dontknowher well I was responding to your whole list, the home ed community are incredibly diverse so your list was totally wrong in my experience.

But of course they can work full time and home ed full time, a lot of us do, including myself! Home ed is flexible and can be slotted around employment. There is no requirement for home ed to be done during school days or hours.

Your comments very much read to me as someone who has preconceived ideas of home edders, as most people do to be fair, it's just that these preconceived ideas are nothing like what the realities of home edding is, in most cases.

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:40

As I have stated many times, I was wrong to blame home educators.
But it is a privilege to be able to do so.
I think that part is lost amongst all the propaganda about it being some, noble higher calling.
And I think it's a world away from being excluded from mainstream education with no alternative.
And I also wonder about UBI and whether this will make home education more popular, and economically diverse, especially with the recruitment crisis in schools and higher ratios of Sen children.

OP posts:
dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:36

@ReadingSoManyThreads yes so 'trad fem' as in the women being at home nurturing and educating. They can't really do that full time and work full time can they?

OP posts:
bridgetreilly · 15/06/2023 00:35

In my experience, both parents contibute in home education. Very often they divide up subjects according to their skill sets. But the point of home education is that the schedules are flexible, so that schooling can be done around work schedules. Childcare, obviously, can’t.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 15/06/2023 00:34

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:23

@ReadingSoManyThreads because you were saying that my preconceptions of it being mostly mums with partners who are the breadwinners was wrong...

No I didn't. Those are not the list of preconceptions that you listed. You said:

"The whole thing feels like a very entitled, white woman's, heterosexual, almost trad fem secret society."

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 00:28

@AmyandPhilipfan fair enough, thanks for replying! I'll get off my soap box now

OP posts:
AmyandPhilipfan · 15/06/2023 00:23

I know a home educating family where both parents work part time in order to always have someone at home with the kids. I see the kids fairly regularly at activities my daughter does too and it's usually the dad I see with them. I also see two other dads out and about with their HE kids and I'm not sure what their set up is but I presume they either don't work or work around the kids and their activities.

As I said before, HE families are a diverse lot. I'm not vegan, I expect my child to listen to adults and do what she's told and we definitely don't have a big enough garden to raise chickens or crops. I know some families like ours and I know some who are very different. I know single parents, mums and dads, same sex parents, Christian parents, atheist parents, Muslim parents and so on. We all have our own children's interests at heart but we do things very differently. I can get on with most people very well but like in any situation I gel with some parents more than others.