Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hacked off at the home ed community already

244 replies

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 20:38

Hi,
I am a mother to a neurodiverse child who has struggled in school since reception. They have had a complete burn out and now cannot access school at all. They are 8. We have tried EVERYTHING to make school work. They aren't suitable for a special school.
I have a reluctant home educator. I say reluctant as I never really envisaged being my child's main source of knowledge. I am a single parent and have very little support. I am also a home owner with a full time job.
I receive nothing from their father.
All of the above means that home education is not really an option but I have no choice due to child's refusal to go into school.
I have tentatively been looking into home education groups which may mean I can keep my career. At the moment I am on a sort of extended carers leave but this is untenable in the long term. My mortgage fixed rate also expires in August and I need to renew!
There is, on the whole, a complete lack of empathy for my situation from the local home education groups. The whole thing feels like a very entitled, white woman's, heterosexual, almost trad fem secret society.
There are very few which offer any support for ND kids, very few who offer hours longer than 9.30 until 2, even fewer which are ofsted registered meaning I can claim UC for the costs. I understand the reasons for this but it's the way that they all act like I'm the first person to ask or the only lone parent they've ever met who isn't willing to Jack in their job at the drop at the drop of a hat.
No one can make my situation better. I know that. But it makes you feel even shitter to feel too poor, single and not 'child focused' enough for the only other option. My only friend who is experiencing the same is utterly miserable, stuck at home with her challenging ND child, declined from every home Ed group and unable to access mainstream school. I just can't believe our lives have turned out this way. We both have qualifications and ambition. No one tells you that your child will not be able to go to school, that's something I always assumed was a given!

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 15/06/2023 08:17

Clymene · 15/06/2023 08:11

@ProfessorXtra - you've just confirmed exactly what I meant

I could home school because I earned decent money, working for myself. At the time. Not every parent is in that position.

Not everyone has the choice. Of course having a school refuser isn't a privilege!

No you said being able to home Ed is a privilege. It’s not. It was a blanket statement that’s not true in every case.

It’s not a privilege if you end up forced into it, having to suck up the negative financial and emotional impacts of it.

AppleWax · 15/06/2023 08:17

OP I think home education is not the right path for you or your child. You need to bat this back to your local authority and badger them for better provision for your child - either through EOTAS, a referral to a special needs school or unit or to hire a 1-1 support in a mainstream school setting. There are groups on Facebook that will help you with this I think searching Not Fine In School maybe a good starting point.

Despite all the vitriol you have thrown at the HE community, we still try to offer help and support and have empathy for your situation.

However, I do think you need recognise that home education means we take on the full financial burden of educating our children. There are no financial incentives, no grants, loans, benefits etc that are paid to us to home educate. Plus any exams, qualifications etc have to be paid for in full by us, not the local authorities or department of education. Therefore to verbally attack many of us who struggle financially to educate our children is unfair.

Finally, you do not have to be a teacher, tutor, etc to home educate, but it would probably surprise you how many teachers, lecturers and other professionals home educate, often side by side with a diverse group of families who have educating their children outside a state school setting as a priority.

On a side note: I personally don’t ‘teach’ Black History Month in a group setting, however my child has access to a diverse educational setting, using tutors from the all over the globe for certain topics. We also cover world history, religions and cultures on a regular basis, throughout the year. There are plenty of BHM resources online, but rather than dedicate just a few weeks a year (as some schools do) diversity is part of our everyday educational philosophy and practice.

Clymene · 15/06/2023 08:11

@ProfessorXtra - you've just confirmed exactly what I meant

I could home school because I earned decent money, working for myself. At the time. Not every parent is in that position.

Not everyone has the choice. Of course having a school refuser isn't a privilege!

MorningShow · 15/06/2023 08:07

AlfietheSchnauzer · 15/06/2023 03:48

Excuse me but not every diagnosed child needs an EHCP! Educate yourself and get your facts straight before giving advice on a serious subject like this please! There is a huuuuge group of diagnosed children who struggle but whom do not meet the threshold for an EHCP (by any stretch)

🤦🏼‍♀️

The first thing you ask for in the EHCP process is an assessment of needs (note, you are not asking to issue at this point, just for needs to be assessed),

This is really important as you cannot figure out the support needed if you don’t understand exactly what they need it with (you say your DC is ND but all children still have different needs, challenges and strengths)

As part of the process, your child would be assessed by education psychologist, as a minimum, and by other relevant professionals such as SALT and occupational therapist. They identity needs and make recommendations.

It is highly likely that a plan is issued at this point. It means that school, if they say they can provide this support, HAVE to do it.

The threshold for assessment is 1) might have SEN 2) might need additional support from EHCP.

When a child cannot attend a setting because of the effect on their mental health, it indicates that they need more support than has been offered.

Your DC meets criteria. There is no point shouting because you have been told nonsense (often spouted by school SENCO’s and LA staff) and you have simply believed it.

Get on the phone to SENDIASS or IPSEA and make a plan, or if you don’t want to do that then that’s okay but stop moaning about how unfair it is whilst doing nothing to change the situation your DC is in. No-one is coming along to do it for you.

gogohmm · 15/06/2023 08:01

There's strict rules in place regarding groups that offer provision to school aged children - they cannot offer any one child more than a certain number of hours per week without registering as a private school because that's what they would be. I had cases locally in the midlands where organisations claimed to be homeschooling tutors but in fact were unregistered schools

HairyKitty · 15/06/2023 07:59

And in the meantime whatever you do, do not deregister or you will get absolutely no help at all

Kiwano · 15/06/2023 07:58

Beautiful3 · 15/06/2023 07:52

Home education is just a form of support to educate your child at home. It's always down to the parents to home school, no-one else. If I were you, do not take him off the school register. Apply to a special school and keep him home until a space opens up. My neighbour had similar issues to you, she sruggled massively getting him there. Then switched to special school. He loves it and even waits outside the house, for the transport bus in the mornings. So nice to see him enjoy school now.

It isn't necessarily always down to the parents. If the child is unable to go to school because of illness - which includes mental illness - then the council has to provide an alternative which is usually home tuition. If there is no appropriate school at all which the child is able to access, then again the council has to provide an alternative long term.

Going to special school is not just a matter of applying. It is normally only possible via an EHCP.

HairyKitty · 15/06/2023 07:58

@dontknowher I don’t understand why you think home educator groups should be able to accommodate your child. They are literally unfunded parents just like you who have arranged activities. Home educator groups are an optional extra, the responsibility for education is in the home.

What I think you are actually looking for is childcare for an older neurodiverse child. So maybe start looking for childminders.

But based on your posts I absolutely don’t think your family should be home educating.

Kiwano · 15/06/2023 07:56

dontknowher · 14/06/2023 23:29

@MorningShow I don't mean to be dismissive but I've done all of that.
I've emailed the draft letter requesting an EHCP, I've been told the council educational psychologist doesn't have capacity until September. I've emailed school repeatedly, had meeting after meeting. They are struggling as my child is pretty chaotic snd it's the variety of issues, so anxiety, disruption, emotional disregulation and not keeping up with school work. They also don't sleep so permanently knackered, it's literally a fight from 7.30am until 9.30am each morning to get them into school!
CAHMs won't help until there's self harm.
GP says as most of the issues are around school, not home, then school are the main agency to deal with it.
School are being as unsupportive and allusive as possible as they want all the complicated kids to drop out to improve results! They pretty much said this in a regional meeting, and we found the minutes online. There is no pastoral lead and the senco is understandably very busy.

I'm just losing it with having to fight and chase whilst working and having another child to take care of.

Councils know perfectly well that they are not allowed just to fob people off because they don't have enough Educational Psychology capacity. Write to the council saying that unless you hear from them within a week that an Educational Psychologist has been appointed who will report within 6 weeks, you will have to take judicial review action to enforce the statutory deadlines. If they don't respond sensibly, contact SOS SEN to get an official pre-action letter sent. https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review/

Do you have any medical or similar evidence to confirm that your child is unable to be in school? If you, you may be able to push the council into funding tutors.

Can I seek judicial review?

https://sossen.org.uk/whats-judicial-review

Smallbirdgreengrass · 15/06/2023 07:54

Can you change school? Some are better with kids with additional needs than others?

Home Ed is clearly not practical for you.

I’m sorry OP, it sucks that the state isn’t meeting your needs. You are far from the only one is this situation.

You are clearly a good parent but in an impossibly hard situation. It’s not you. It is the system.

Beautiful3 · 15/06/2023 07:54

Do you have a EHCP?

ProfessorXtra · 15/06/2023 07:54

Clymene · 15/06/2023 07:38

This thread is really odd. Of course home ed is a privilege. Most of us need to work and so our children are in school. If a child can't cope in MS, then the LA has a duty to fund special school or tutoring or some other form of education.

But it's not the responsibility of people who have chosen to home ed their kids to provide it to anyone else. They're not a service.

It’s not as simple as home education is a privilege, in many cases.

I felt privileged that I was in a situation that I could. However, it’s not a privilege to have your not be able to go to school because their needs can’t be met.

I could home school because I earned decent money, working for myself. At the time. Not every parent is in that position. Some peoples children simply can not attend schools and there’s not enough provision in the area for specialist schools. So they end up having to home school where they would prefer to work. It can be hugely detrimental to a lot of peoples financial security. But they don’t feel they have another choice.

The idea that people home schooling are all fairly well off people who do it completely through choice isn’t based on fact.

AmenAmin · 15/06/2023 07:53

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:03

Indeed! I just don't get how it works for single working parents and I'm yet to have one person explain it to me.

I’m working now, 6-9 ish, then I’ll pick up an evening meeting at 6pm. It’s fairly well paid so 5/6 hours in the day

Beautiful3 · 15/06/2023 07:52

Home education is just a form of support to educate your child at home. It's always down to the parents to home school, no-one else. If I were you, do not take him off the school register. Apply to a special school and keep him home until a space opens up. My neighbour had similar issues to you, she sruggled massively getting him there. Then switched to special school. He loves it and even waits outside the house, for the transport bus in the mornings. So nice to see him enjoy school now.

babyproblems · 15/06/2023 07:51

I wouldn’t step away from the state school system here - they have a duty and responsibility to educate your child; I would pursue that to the absolute hilt. I think if you move to HE they will claim it was your choice. There must be a very small middle ground to be found here and the LA must find it. Please don’t give up. Good luck op xx

Zonder · 15/06/2023 07:48

User2346 · 15/06/2023 07:35

If a child cannot access education then the child needs an EHCP. Why are you so prickly about this? An EHCP is nothing to be ashamed of.

What @User2346 said.

Also, sometimes people say negative things about EHCPs because they failed to get one, not because the child shouldn't have one. Sadly, two different things.

Zonder · 15/06/2023 07:47

dontknowher · 15/06/2023 01:30

@Yfory I work in healthcare, that is my skill set. I don't do well in desk jobs. Plus there's very few working from home jobs by me, they want everyone back in the office. Plus when would I sleep if I'm home educating all day and working 7.5 hours at night?

I'm no proponent of HE but isn't one of the main points that you don't need a full day to teach them?

I do think your title needs changing. What you're looking for is not what the HE community provide, as many have said. Each family is responsible for teaching their own kids but the groups exist to provide social and educational outings together, not to drop your kid off.

It's also not fair to bitch about mums who HE. Lots are not wealthy - for many I know it's a real sacrifice because they absolutely believe in it.

I don't get it myself but it each to their own.

Definitely don't deregister and go back to your LA and ask what they are going to do for your son.

Clymene · 15/06/2023 07:38

This thread is really odd. Of course home ed is a privilege. Most of us need to work and so our children are in school. If a child can't cope in MS, then the LA has a duty to fund special school or tutoring or some other form of education.

But it's not the responsibility of people who have chosen to home ed their kids to provide it to anyone else. They're not a service.

User2346 · 15/06/2023 07:35

AlfietheSchnauzer · 15/06/2023 03:48

Excuse me but not every diagnosed child needs an EHCP! Educate yourself and get your facts straight before giving advice on a serious subject like this please! There is a huuuuge group of diagnosed children who struggle but whom do not meet the threshold for an EHCP (by any stretch)

🤦🏼‍♀️

If a child cannot access education then the child needs an EHCP. Why are you so prickly about this? An EHCP is nothing to be ashamed of.

MichelleScarn · 15/06/2023 07:35

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/06/2023 02:32

Ohhh… you assume I have children?! That is a very privileged stance to take, perhaps you should do better OP than your current traditionalist views.

Once again, did I say anywhere I was off to bed? I really do have all the time to dedicate to helping you.

Let’s make sure I got it all.

  • You want to drop your child off to be educated
  • You don’t want to be involved in this education to give your child independence
  • You want these educators to be OFSTED rated
  • You want to ensure diversity in this education
  • You want this to be a “home education” group- but not your home
  • You think that these “home” educators are racists
  • ‘You think these “home educators“ have damaging ‘traditional‘ and ‘privileged’ views

Have I missed anything? Because surely random strangers will be lining up to educate your child under these conditions. I’m shocked you don’t have a mailbox full of pMs begging you to for the opportunity.

Don't forget they must welcome op with open arms,while accepting her sneering, judgemental opinion of them as 'saintly' over-priviliged, white women, who really need to 'do better' i.e teach what she wants, when she wants, and for free.

Dancingcandlesticks · 15/06/2023 07:33

Hi OP,
I work with the Home Ed community in my job. There are thousands upon thousands of people in your shoes nationally. I’m sorry you’re finding it tough.
You won’t find childcare really. That’s also not what home Ed groups and meet ups are for, so that’s why they are probably being a bit frosty with you.
You would need to employ a Home education nanny/tutor. They can be ofsted registered. Occasionally you can get a home Ed childminder but they are mainly in places with huge home Ed communities like Bristol and still very rare. They also can’t be the main place your child is educated as they could fall foul of school registration rules. So you must still be educating your child outside of these hours. Whereas a nanny/tutor can take on the education on your behalf which you then monitor. All this is pricy.

If your child can’t manage in mainstream then they are a candidate for special schools. There are schools which cater for academically able children but they are usually independent and LA prefer not to pay. If she hasn’t got an EHCP, apply for one yourself and then appeal when they refuse to assess.

Cabbagey · 15/06/2023 07:29

OP there are lots of resources for Black History Month that can be used for homeschooling. You seem 'hacked off at the home ed community' because no other home educators have volunteered to teach content relevant to Black History Month to your child? But of course they haven't - they're home educating their own children, not yours. You would need to use those resources and provide that teaching yourself.

Merlinsbeard83 · 15/06/2023 07:24

I have not read all the replies
I'm confused . You are angry you can't drop your child off with a home educators group for how many hours a day ?
I didn't think they existed in most parts of the UK.
Maybe the odd 2 hour forest school but insurance wise I doubt many people set that sort of situation up.
If someone has enough money they hire tutors but even then a parent/supervision to some degree is expected in the home .
I didn't think many other options existed for home educated children.
Have you tried a different school to see if they are more understanding to your child's needs.
Also if applying or have a echp don't de register. You will regret it when it comes to secondary school

Namechangedforthis2244 · 15/06/2023 07:08

It sounds like things are really hard at the moment.

I know that this might sound like a bit of a random question but have you considered whether there is a private school which would meet his needs and which might not cause school refusal?

They are really expensive but, assuming that you earn a reasonable wage, are likely to be a lot less than losing your full wage because you can’t keep your job while you are home educating. And comparable to paying for decent tutoring or childcare during working hours which is your other feasible option here.

I’m not an expert on ehcp but I believe that you can list private provision on them if state isn’t possible, although I imagine that would take a fight to get it implemented

CompletelyOverwhelmedAgain · 15/06/2023 06:58

"Ultimately as your child grows up they will probably go off and learn about what ever takes their fancy at the time and or do online schooling and won’t need the amount of child care or input as he needs now."

I don't know the OP's child but from my experience of ASD, ADHD and LD, this will unlikely to ever be the case for them.