Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to discipline my child?

62 replies

jelmar · 14/06/2023 19:50

Will try keep it short.

I'm a single mum to a 10 year old daughter, dad is involved, she sees him quite frequently. She isn't often cheeky to him.

She is definitely going through puberty already as she is showing signs.

I've messed up in that I've tried to be too much like a friend to her. I never had a close relationship with my mum so always thought I wanted to change this with my daughter.

However, she has absolutely no respect for me. She leaves everything at her arse and the talking back is horrendous. I just don't know how to pick a consequence and stick to it. I always feel I'm being too harsh or not harsh enough.

For instance tonight her friend was here and she kept talking back to me. I said, 'DD if you continue talking back I'll send your friend home' she said 'no you won't'. So of course I sent her friend home. However, she then continued crying and screaming and begging me to change my mind then when I wouldn't, she would say 'this is why everyone hates you'.

So tonight has ended with her not having her friend here, not having a phone/tv and being up on her room.

But I just don't know if it's too much. I've read about natural consequences but I can't think of a natural consequence of talking back.

Sometimes I'll take her phone from her and she'll say, 'I don't care, I wasn't going to watch it tonight anyways' etc. it's like she's testing me.

I'm clueless on what to do, I feel I have completely lost control.

Please help

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 14/06/2023 21:28

PomPomChatton · 14/06/2023 21:17

They push boundaries to check that they are there. Kids get security from appropriate boundaries. So it's normal for them to push and your job is to reinforce the boundary.

This . It’s a lot easier to loosen up as they get older and their behaviour is generally fine, than it is to start lax and try to put the boundaries in later.
Start now - stay calm but be clear about what is not acceptable and follow through consistently.

Whatthediddlyfeck · 14/06/2023 21:27

jelmar · 14/06/2023 19:59

Totally misses the point 😂

It rally doesn’t miss the point, it’s you who is missing it.
A 10 year old doesn’t need a phone.

by sending the friend home it was she who was punished

jelmar · 14/06/2023 21:24

WonderingWanda · 14/06/2023 20:58

In a situation where the friend is there I would state 'Don't be rude dd, we'll have a chat about this later' once friend has left I would calmly describe what I disliked about the behaviour and that it needs to stop. Natural consequence would be no more friends round if she continues to back chat you. Maybe next time she wants a friend round, remind her of the last time and challenger her to be extra polite and helpful in the days leading up to it.

We use no screen time the next day as a consequence as well, it's a good one to motivate them. In general you need to be clear about what you expect, don't react to every answering back or get into tit for tat situations. Rise above it but if you feel she has been especially cheeky issue a consequence. Often when mine are being snipey and backchat I will just give them a little smile and say 'Just like an overgrown toddler' and that usually makes them laugh at there own ridiculousness. They will usually apologise but sometimes we have tears and tantrums.

You need to create lots of opportunities for positive interactions too. Maybe draw up a chores rota together and decide on rewards like going our for a milkshake, bonus screen time on the weekend, extra pocket money etc.

I like this one and laughed at your smiling and 'just like an overgrown toddler'. I'll need to try this. Thank you!

OP posts:
jelmar · 14/06/2023 21:22

saraclara · 14/06/2023 20:48

Why did you punish the friend for something that your daughter did?

A friend of mine did this to my DD when she was younger.than yours Her son was playing up (not hugely) and she threatened him with sending saraclarajunior (and consequently me!) home if he didn't stop. He didn't, and my DD, who'd been really excited about the visit and had behaved perfectly, was really confused and upset at having to leave after only twenty minutes of playing.

I failed miserably to be able to explain to her why she (and I) had been punished for her friends behaviour.

What you did made no sense at all, and humiliated and disappointed your DD's friend.

Her friend lives down the street and they are constantly playing together. Friend has been sent home before and so has my daughter from friends house. Me and friends parent are in touch and she completely understands. I sent her a text just explaining that friend is on her way home due to DDs behaviour.

I wouldn't send a friend on a play date home as like you say, it would be unfair on friend.

This was an I arranged play.

OP posts:
PomPomChatton · 14/06/2023 21:17

They push boundaries to check that they are there. Kids get security from appropriate boundaries. So it's normal for them to push and your job is to reinforce the boundary.

Justalittlebitduckling · 14/06/2023 21:10

Sounds like you set a consequence and stuck to it. Well done. Keep going, I think you’re doing better than you think you are.

WonderingWanda · 14/06/2023 20:58

In a situation where the friend is there I would state 'Don't be rude dd, we'll have a chat about this later' once friend has left I would calmly describe what I disliked about the behaviour and that it needs to stop. Natural consequence would be no more friends round if she continues to back chat you. Maybe next time she wants a friend round, remind her of the last time and challenger her to be extra polite and helpful in the days leading up to it.

We use no screen time the next day as a consequence as well, it's a good one to motivate them. In general you need to be clear about what you expect, don't react to every answering back or get into tit for tat situations. Rise above it but if you feel she has been especially cheeky issue a consequence. Often when mine are being snipey and backchat I will just give them a little smile and say 'Just like an overgrown toddler' and that usually makes them laugh at there own ridiculousness. They will usually apologise but sometimes we have tears and tantrums.

You need to create lots of opportunities for positive interactions too. Maybe draw up a chores rota together and decide on rewards like going our for a milkshake, bonus screen time on the weekend, extra pocket money etc.

saraclara · 14/06/2023 20:48

Why did you punish the friend for something that your daughter did?

A friend of mine did this to my DD when she was younger.than yours Her son was playing up (not hugely) and she threatened him with sending saraclarajunior (and consequently me!) home if he didn't stop. He didn't, and my DD, who'd been really excited about the visit and had behaved perfectly, was really confused and upset at having to leave after only twenty minutes of playing.

I failed miserably to be able to explain to her why she (and I) had been punished for her friends behaviour.

What you did made no sense at all, and humiliated and disappointed your DD's friend.

Jeannie88 · 14/06/2023 20:47

Sorry but yes we have to go through the tantrums of them hating us, it's immediate response and soon changes.

As a teacher I learnt by only taking things to the next level of discipline would I get any respect back as I meant it, also as a parent. I'm naturally soft and hate doing it but you do have to follow through and take the reaction. Amazingly almost every time students or my dc have come back with an apology so it does work.

Jeannie88 · 14/06/2023 20:47

Sorry but yes we have to go through the tantrums of them hating us, it's immediate response and soon changes.

As a teacher I learnt by only taking things to the next level of discipline would I get any respect back as I meant it, also as a parent. I'm naturally soft and hate doing it but you do have to follow through and take the reaction. Amazingly almost every time students or my dc have come back with an apology so it does work.

SnackSizeRaisin · 14/06/2023 20:39

I think your initial punishment was quite severe, was humiliating for your daughter in front of her friend, and has punished the friend too.

The way I would tackle this situation is to act early, so as soon as she she back chats say calmly "I don't want you to speak to me like that" then if she does it again take her to another room away from friend (explain calmly "I want to talk to you for a moment come with me" then lead her out). Then say "I don't like being spoken to like that. Would you like to be polite or would you like me to take your friend home?" Then it gives her a chance to back down without losing face to her friend. The important thing here is to act quickly before it escalates and to remain calm yourself. If she gives in say thank you. If not, calmly follow through.

If you do send friend home there's bound to be strong feelings so acknowledge that she's upset and let her cry and shout until she calms down. Treat it like a toddler tantrum.

Once she's calmed down move on.

I wouldn't let her take her phone in her bedroom at this age.

Iceicebabytoocold · 14/06/2023 20:38

sounds like she has been exposed to all the attitude crap on the internet which is probably accessed on her phone. I also think she has been given a phone too young as she is still very immature and cannot comprehend reasonable conduct.

if I was you, every time she gives you grief, give her a warning and if she carries on the phone is confiscated for a period depending on the severity of the act.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 14/06/2023 20:31

GobbolinoCat · 14/06/2023 20:25

Re previous poster and don't be rude to me that's loss of TV..

I can't see how that works except on a very superficial level.

You need to gradually make her want to not be rude.

Also try and get anything praise in where you can... And turn things positive.

Yeah, I agree. Asking what punishments should be is really the wrong question. Asking where the behaviour comes from and how it can be prevented in the first place is better.

Positive reinforcement, leading by example. It's very very hard to be self aware of the example we set. I'm not claiming to be perfect, but it is striking how many parents don't realise that their kids are only doing what they do....and asking how to punish it away isn't the way to deal with it. You're the parent and grown up, they take their lead from you.

Alargeoneplease89 · 14/06/2023 20:30

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:17

@mauveiscurious but you don't know my daughter or her screen time activity so give it a rest eh

Can't see were the attitude comes from 😂

007DoubleOSeven · 14/06/2023 20:29

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:17

@mauveiscurious but you don't know my daughter or her screen time activity so give it a rest eh

Well you asked for us to discipline her for you and your opening post suggested that boundaries were both poor and porous. No one is attacking you so no need to be so defensive.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 14/06/2023 20:26

What exactly do you mean by "talking back"? I think a lot of parents place far too much importance on getting the last word (which is basically what this comes down to).

If she's doing as you told her to do (eg, handing over her phone) and just complaining or face saving a bit about it by claiming she doesn't care, I'd let that one go. Parents should be above the petty, childish, last word stuff. She might have to do as you say but she doesn't need to pretend to be delighted about it. It's kind of authoritarian to insist that you are always obeyed with absolutely no suggestion of any reluctance.

If she's shouting abuse, obviously that's a different matter.

I'm not accusing you of anything, but kids do generally copy what they see at home even if they don't realise it, so if there are behavioural problems, look to see how you handle conflict, stress etc. Leading by example is always the best thing you can do.

JanuarySnow · 14/06/2023 20:25

I feel this so much, my dd is 11. Always been a ray of sunshine and never really disciplined her as didn't need to. She really was like my little friend.

Now she's hit puberty and pushing boundaries. When I try to enforce rules and actually parent she loses the plot. Wish I'd been stricter earlier!

GobbolinoCat · 14/06/2023 20:25

Re previous poster and don't be rude to me that's loss of TV..

I can't see how that works except on a very superficial level.

You need to gradually make her want to not be rude.

Also try and get anything praise in where you can... And turn things positive.

queenMab99 · 14/06/2023 20:25

I don't think you were too harsh, you warned her if she didn't stop, that you would send her friend home, she didn't stop so you sent her friend home. Meaning what you say, and carrying it out, is important. It is also crucial not to say you will do something, and then find it impossible. She may still be furious at the moment, but she knows that you are in charge, and it will sink in presently. Having friends round after school is a privilege, she was rude and cheeky to you, the privilege is withdrawn until she can behave nicely.

HowardKirksConscience · 14/06/2023 20:22

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:17

@mauveiscurious but you don't know my daughter or her screen time activity so give it a rest eh

Does she get her arsey attitude from you?

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:17

@mauveiscurious but you don't know my daughter or her screen time activity so give it a rest eh

OP posts:
mauveiscurious · 14/06/2023 20:14

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:11

What has phone use actually got to do with it? I haven't stated how much time she is allowed the phone/what limits are in place, so you're assuming there's none.

My question was regarding consequences.

It's to do with development and behaviour

Rafferty10 · 14/06/2023 20:12

I found setting clear expectations of behaviour and consequences for not, and sticking to them come what may.
(so set them carefully)

Two categories
House rules

eg; do not yell at me, if you do then lose 1 hour TV time/activity.
Doing chores daily, if not done then lose Tv time/activity
Backchatting, one warning then immediate loss of phone and tv for rest of day.
Keep backchatting lose phone and tv for another day and so on.

These are just ideas...you will know what is appropriate.

Expectations of behavior,
before an outing l used to lay out my expectations of behaviour ie in the case of friend over, before she arrives say, whilst x is here l expect you to be polite to me and do as you are asked, come for lunch when called/stick to any home rules/ games not allowed/any rooms not to be entered.
If you do not you will get one warning then if you still disobey l will take x home straightaway.

You must NEVER cave in, and stay calm. so plan the consequences to ensure you can follow through.

Remember you are preparing her for life in the real world where people will not pander to her, so you are doing her a favour by teaching consequences of actions and boundaries.

Lastly she will not love you any less, although she may kick up to begin with.

jelmar · 14/06/2023 20:11

What has phone use actually got to do with it? I haven't stated how much time she is allowed the phone/what limits are in place, so you're assuming there's none.

My question was regarding consequences.

OP posts:
mauveiscurious · 14/06/2023 20:10

The amount of the inappropriate information and bullying these young children get over phones is worrying, these kids need time to develop without these influences

Swipe left for the next trending thread