Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to discipline my child?

62 replies

jelmar · 14/06/2023 19:50

Will try keep it short.

I'm a single mum to a 10 year old daughter, dad is involved, she sees him quite frequently. She isn't often cheeky to him.

She is definitely going through puberty already as she is showing signs.

I've messed up in that I've tried to be too much like a friend to her. I never had a close relationship with my mum so always thought I wanted to change this with my daughter.

However, she has absolutely no respect for me. She leaves everything at her arse and the talking back is horrendous. I just don't know how to pick a consequence and stick to it. I always feel I'm being too harsh or not harsh enough.

For instance tonight her friend was here and she kept talking back to me. I said, 'DD if you continue talking back I'll send your friend home' she said 'no you won't'. So of course I sent her friend home. However, she then continued crying and screaming and begging me to change my mind then when I wouldn't, she would say 'this is why everyone hates you'.

So tonight has ended with her not having her friend here, not having a phone/tv and being up on her room.

But I just don't know if it's too much. I've read about natural consequences but I can't think of a natural consequence of talking back.

Sometimes I'll take her phone from her and she'll say, 'I don't care, I wasn't going to watch it tonight anyways' etc. it's like she's testing me.

I'm clueless on what to do, I feel I have completely lost control.

Please help

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 00:17

haven't read all the thread but from your OP., sounds like you are doing grand. the punishment/consequence for her back chat seems exactly appropriate. not sure why you are doubting yourself. you stuck to your guns. you've just got to keep doing it over and over. it's hard work and often seems like it isn't working...but they eventually, mostly grow into pleasant humans

Wallywobbles · 15/06/2023 12:27

Why does she need a phone? We removed all tech for 3 months from all 4 kids. The change in behavior was radical.

nevynevster · 15/06/2023 06:28

Parenting teens is a whole different ball game. I have boys (also single mum) and they tend to be very differently wired at this age but here's a few things that work for me:

  • device parental controls: this takes time and effort on your part to set up but I have controls on EVERYTHING... Xbox, phone, wifi etc. This means that devices automatically have limits rather than me "taking it away" and then I can reward good behaviour by adding time rather than punishing bad behaviour
  • switching the situation: at this age the hormones can overwhelm (actually at mine too but that's another story) and poor reactions can be down to this. I find just taking them out for a walk or doing something different really helps. I am often found tramping to the shops with grumpy teens who then settle down and become normal after a 20 mins walk. Side note it seems to worn best when it's a purposeful walk so I will walk to some shops far away to buy something "important"
  • sleep: many teens these days are sleep deprived due to devices etc. I force everyone to go to their rooms at a decent time and all chargers for devices including mine are in the kitchen ... Role model what you want to see
  • understanding: there are a load of excellent books on teen brains which are going through a remarkable set of changes, personally I found it easier to handle situations when I understood what was going on

Hope it helps and good luck!

SofiaAmes · 15/06/2023 06:18

Maybe you could set your own boundaries instead. If your dd is being rude and disrespectful, set a boundary like "I will not accept being talked to that way" and then remove yourself from the interaction. I have found that when my dc's became stroppy frontal lobe-less beings, this was far more effective than any punishment.

GoodChat · 15/06/2023 06:08

The silent treatment and sending her away is an unacceptable punishment in my book.

Bogggle · 15/06/2023 05:44

saraclara · 14/06/2023 23:23

My mum did that. That's why I was a messed up anxious child, still have issues and have virtually no relationship with her other than a brief duty visit maybe every six weeks.

If a man gives his partner the silent treatment, mumsnet is unanimous in saying that he's abusive. And they're right. So was my mum.

I was just going to say this too as my parents did the same to me. Looking back now I realise how abusive and awful it was and it’s one of the main reasons why I’m so anxious and avoid arguments/confrontation at all costs. I also now don’t have a great relationship with my parents and would not recommend that method of dealing with it at all

Nasolabial · 15/06/2023 05:38

Kanaloa · 15/06/2023 00:24

@Nasolabial

When I say it I mean my kids leave stuff out of place 😂 so if they come in and throw their school bag on the hallway floor then wander off I might say ‘Christ does everyone in this house just leave everything at their arse?’ Or leaving finished with cups on the table and walking away from them.

Ah ok. Thank you!

Kanaloa · 15/06/2023 00:24

@Nasolabial

When I say it I mean my kids leave stuff out of place 😂 so if they come in and throw their school bag on the hallway floor then wander off I might say ‘Christ does everyone in this house just leave everything at their arse?’ Or leaving finished with cups on the table and walking away from them.

HotPenguin · 14/06/2023 23:43

What exactly is the back chat? Is it just moaning or is it disrespectful stuff? Sometimes kids copy things they've seen on TV or read online and they don't realise how unacceptable it is in the real world. In particular some of the comments kids make in American programmes/films are dreadful. I think it's important to point out, in a helpful tone, the impression these things have on other people.

saraclara · 14/06/2023 23:23

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:07

You did the right thing.

My mum used to completely disengage with us. Maybe that sounds awful but she literally didn't look at us or speak to us. It worked.

She was like ice. She got on with her evening and nothing we did could derail her. Nothing. That's what I try to do. After the, "what's going on", and "is everything ok?" And the warnings, that's that. The niceties do not come back until she amends her ways.

As I say, it was harsh and cold but it worked with us.

Try it. But try it and mean it. Completely ignore. Give commands and expect compliance.

Anything else is met with absolute silence. (Unless it's a medical issue or they just want a hug).

My mum did that. That's why I was a messed up anxious child, still have issues and have virtually no relationship with her other than a brief duty visit maybe every six weeks.

If a man gives his partner the silent treatment, mumsnet is unanimous in saying that he's abusive. And they're right. So was my mum.

CrotchetyQuaver · 14/06/2023 22:30

I would say having been through this and out the other side that
You need to pick your battles

Never ever ever make a threat you are not prepared to carry out. So well done for sending the friend home because you warned her and when the warning was ignored you carried out your threat. It might make her think twice before doing it again. It's silly showing off but my DDs being rude to me in front of their friends was a hard line for me.

When they're doing something good praise them for it. (Reinforce good behaviour)

Also try not to raise your voice and shout if you possibly can. It's vital you remain the grown up and it not descend into a slanging match.

I came from a very shouty home and it was lots of unnecessary drama from my mum and brother all the time. I've had to learn as I went along as this was all new to me, but everyone does better in a quiet calm home environment where things are discussed rather than automatically turn into arguments.

vestedinterests · 14/06/2023 22:25

@Royalbloo sorry if I didn't articulate it well. I meant it would have been awkward for a friend and friend's parent. I would never punish this way and make others feel awkward nor would I give a child a silent treatment like it has been suggested on this thread

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:17

vestedinterests · 14/06/2023 22:16

I'm missing a point here but I don't understand why you would send friend home to punish your daughter? Surely, the friend must have felt awkward for being told to go home early or the friends mum would have been called to come and pick up early rather than at agreed time?

Isn't that the whole point? It's awkward and should have made her examine her behaviour.

vestedinterests · 14/06/2023 22:16

I'm missing a point here but I don't understand why you would send friend home to punish your daughter? Surely, the friend must have felt awkward for being told to go home early or the friends mum would have been called to come and pick up early rather than at agreed time?

Nasolabial · 14/06/2023 22:16

‘She leaves everything at her arse’

sorry it’s off topic but what does this mean? I googled but was none the wiser!

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:10

We have a non-negotiable "no shouting" rule in our house. Do as you would be done by.

If either one of us breaks it, we are allowed to tell the other one off.

I truly believe they follow the behavioural methods they are shown and if you shout, they will too.

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:08

wildfirewonder · 14/06/2023 20:08

Yes I think you were too harsh tonight, I would not have sent the friend away. But if have said no friends for a while as you were too rude.

You have to be clear and consistent.

I would also remove the phone.

But if this is the straw that broke the camels back, which is what it sounds like. I get it.

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:08

You're not her mate.

Royalbloo · 14/06/2023 22:07

You did the right thing.

My mum used to completely disengage with us. Maybe that sounds awful but she literally didn't look at us or speak to us. It worked.

She was like ice. She got on with her evening and nothing we did could derail her. Nothing. That's what I try to do. After the, "what's going on", and "is everything ok?" And the warnings, that's that. The niceties do not come back until she amends her ways.

As I say, it was harsh and cold but it worked with us.

Try it. But try it and mean it. Completely ignore. Give commands and expect compliance.

Anything else is met with absolute silence. (Unless it's a medical issue or they just want a hug).

MollysBrolly · 14/06/2023 22:03

When you make a decision - eg sending her friend home - do it and don't fall for the tears etc.
Compains she doesn't want to do homework and you tell her she has to or there's a consequence eg earlier bedtime - keep to the consequence.

it'll soon work out and she'll know you mean what you say. Just have to be firm. If you don't ina few years they be all
manner of she'll be trying it on with you

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2023 21:40

What do you mean by talking back? Specifically.

Because expressing themselves is good, if it's just tone that need's correcting. Rudeness is another thing.

I find a humourous, "sorry I can't hear you, I don't speak whine" worked on DD. With a smile.

TeenLifeMum · 14/06/2023 21:34

Okay, phone actually can have an impact - dd1 is now 15 and lovely. A few years ago she was very rude to me and I confiscated the phone. Her mood and tone when speaking to me vastly improved. As a result, when I gave her back her phone with clear guidelines I was honest and spoke to her about the difference I’d seen in her and how lovely it was so I think she needs to be aware that the phone does affect her because by being aware she can act on that. I asked how she’d felt and if she’d noticed a difference. She had. It meant we decided the rules phone usage together.

When any of my dc (I have 3 girls 11-15) are rude, tell me they hate me etc (doesn’t happen often) I am very disinterested and don’t rise to it “I hate you!” “Oh cool, I’m parenting right”/“good for you”/“uh huh” or “er, no, I don’t want to be spoken to like that so I’m going to make a cup of tea and sit in the garden. Come and chat when you are ready to apologise but otherwise I don’t want to see you” said calmly.

Hormones are not an excuse to speak rudely. Once she’s calm you can talk about hormones and how she can manage them.

one of my girls bursts with emotions. She’s full of them. She struggles. She’ll come and try to apologise and I will offer a hug to help her calm down.

bad behaviour needs immediate discipline and consequence, Later we’ll actually talk through what happened calmly and I’ll say how it made me feel and they’ll talk about their feelings and we fully make up.

Good luck op.

Actually, I have one big one in my pocket that I can only use once a year max. The only think my dc hate more than me shouting is me being silent. Children shouting at me and being totally unreasonable… I walk calmly away and go and get into bed with the cover over my head. I think my dc think they’ve broken me and last time they worked together to tidy their rooms, made me an apology card and came with a pre prepared apology (and I got 20 minutes of peace).

Kanaloa · 14/06/2023 21:33

To be honest I would cut a play date/visit short if my child was being rude and disrespectful to me. Usually I think it’s showing off for the friend and would nip it in the bud by saying if they’re rude and misbehave then they can’t host friends at home. It’s not acceptable.

I definitely wouldn’t apologise for doing so either. She is kicking off because normally she gets away with being rude or unpleasant. Now you’ve enforced boundaries they feel unfair to her.

I would sit her down at a calm time and discuss also. Set some ground rules. Things like xyz must be done or abc will happen, if you want to host friends at home then you need to behave respectfully to me otherwise I won’t allow them to visit at all. And have her agree in a moment when you’re not in the thick of it. Obviously you reflect on your own behaviour also - have you supported her to learn appropriate behaviours? Do you support her in making the right choices? Or have you enabled/encouraged poor behaviour?

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 14/06/2023 21:32

Reading your replies to well meaning advice it’s clear where your DD got her attitude and the back talking from.

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 14/06/2023 21:31

Ignore the secondary behaviour. That's what we are taught as teachers.

Eg kid messing on in classroom. You tell them to move to a different seat They do move but in process slam bag on table. Rather than then picking on the bag incident it's ignore as the primary objective (moving seats) was achieved.

Maybe will help save your sanity?

Swipe left for the next trending thread