Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Chermeup · 17/06/2023 07:32

SwordToFlamethrower · 17/06/2023 06:50

Absolute rubbish!!!
American TV is dull af.

British drama will always be number 1

I think no one does detective series like Brots. And comedy. The british humour is something I grew up with and it was glorious!

SwordToFlamethrower · 17/06/2023 06:50

Florenz · 16/06/2023 22:16

American TV has been a lot better than British TV for the last 20 years, probably 25 years now.

Absolute rubbish!!!
American TV is dull af.

British drama will always be number 1

Rubyupbeat · 17/06/2023 06:09

@Mintfly I totally agree, just one thing though, the nuns in Call the midwife were Anglican, not Catholic.

Chermeup · 17/06/2023 05:48

I think people should be more angry with Netflix and likes. The Cleopatra debacle was the last nail in a coffin currently. It just made everyone quite hyper aware of diversity productions and casting for the sake of tick, rather than anything else. I mean even Egyptian government had to comment fgs.
It's these things then make people wonder if every x is diversity hire/purpose written character, if you see what I mean, and it ruina natural flows because people suspect they are there for the tick. And take a piss.
No need to "steal" other people's history. Anyone who went to school knows that every nation, religion, race has amazing characters/heroes which could be easily made into movie, let alone a documentary.

It's simple, if they kept writing naturally flowing stories with characters being there for the story not for the sake of it (like in examples given on this thread) people wouldn't need to complain about low quality output (and in case of Egyptian gov, actual lies)

Chermeup · 17/06/2023 05:26

Peole are misrepresenting what some say on purposes. (not talking ad diacussion, not into that)
I am not native English speaker and even I understood op doesn't have issue with dkversity but with forced, often badly written and not fitting with kveral theme/plot/character behaviour lectures some shows and movies provide lately.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 04:40

MovinGroovinBarbie · 15/06/2023 23:39

Agree 100%.

You think a more diverse cast would not have developed a similar chemistry? And why would that be, I wonder?

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 04:36

MovinGroovinBarbie · 17/06/2023 03:26

You can be accurate enough. We have plenty of recordings of people speaking from that time.

Not enough for a drama. Most dramas are about us not really about the past. Why would they be?

MovinGroovinBarbie · 17/06/2023 03:26

Fisharejumping · 15/06/2023 20:06

I don't see what's wrong with that. It's just using the language of the present day. There is nothing to be gained from trying to emulate the language of the past because you could never be 100% accurate. So much language is lost to time. It's like when I see films set in the 80s now I think "nobody spoke like that" Much better for younger writers to write "in their own tongue" as it were.

You can be accurate enough. We have plenty of recordings of people speaking from that time.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 17/06/2023 03:23

mintlily · 16/06/2023 19:27

I don't find inclusion/representation patronising. I don't like it when people rewrite history, put words into the mouths of authors who would have had no such views, or have the "good" characters sermonise about the latest woke issue, especially when it is set in an era when people didn't use the kind of ethical vocabulary that we use today.

I agree.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 02:16

Haven’t read the article yet but I remember Full Monty being very political - the closure of works, people losing their jobs, unemployment, poverty; there was a beautiful signposting of diversity, sexual
politics were alluded to with the women making fun of the men. I seem to remember a scene where the men are horrified that yhe women are now peeing standing up - hilarious and ridiculous. It is a lovely film

BlippiIsAnnoying · 17/06/2023 01:30

I'm old. I remember similar complaints about:

ITV promoting left wing filth because Curly Watts in Coronation Street was going out with a black woman from the factory.

The loony left BBC pushing homosexual filth on our children when those 2 blokes kissed in Eastenders.

The tiresomely left wing BBC somehow fixing it for Nadia to win Bake Off.

And plenty more if I wrack my brains

Twas ever thus.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 01:06

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

Time moves on, culture changes - as do artistic values. When the art (or TV) of our time becomes irrelevant we start saying that our art was better, more sophisticated and nuanced. It wasn’t. Great art is hard to come by. In any era.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 00:55

mintlily · 15/06/2023 20:33

Interestingly there was actually an article in the Telegraph about this today. Not sure if all can read it because of the paywall https://www.telegraph.co.uk/tv/0/todays-television-dramas-are-betraying-20th-century-history/

I think it articulated what I'm trying to say quite well here:
"In the recent BBC One drama Ten Pound Poms, Annie and Terry Roberts, two new migrants from Britain to Australia, have been invited to a barbecue. Their host is an unreconstructed Antipodean called Dean, whose opinions on his country’s indigenous people would make John Tyndall blush. Annie, perhaps emboldened by the beer, stands up to him. “They’re just people,” she says. “And they were here long before you were.”

Quite right, and hopefully the viewers at home would be cheering Annie on. Except that this scene just didn’t ring true.
Ten Pound Poms is set in the 1950s but Annie’s reaction felt oddly 21st century. Of course, many in that generation found racism abhorrent, but few would have articulated their horror in such a way. This is becoming more and more of a problem with period dramas about the 20th century. As we move further from the time in which they are set, so there will be fewer who can offer authentic insight into the way we were. "

You say people in the 1950s would not articulate anti racist views in that way? I’m afraid you are incorrect. During the slavery abolitionist movement in this country for example people did just that. They also boycotted sugar (a form of cancellation). People from bygone eras were not as different to us as old time TV period dramas would have us believe.

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 00:40

MarkWithaC · 16/06/2023 18:41

The person or people who inspired Q in James Bond was possibly not gay. And I'd imagine the person or people M was based on were not female. Do you find that a problem?
James Bond may be based on a real person, but a) the books and films are nonetheless fiction and b) that's at least partially because when the books were conceived, high-level/prestigious jobs were not nearly so available to non-white people as to white ones. In other words, he wasn't white 'just because'; lots of social forces played into that. I think it's rather interesting to look at what they were and what the franchise looks like if you play with that from our (I say this in a qualified way) more progressive modern point of view.

I don't really see how what you've said is really relevant to my post.

Florenz · 16/06/2023 22:16

American TV has been a lot better than British TV for the last 20 years, probably 25 years now.

LaMaG · 16/06/2023 20:34

@Chermeup I really agree what you say about Modern family. It somehow managed to be diverse without preaching. Most of the storylines about the gay couple were about their struggles with parenthood that any parent could relate to. Also it showed people who struggled with their own prejudices without being 'bad guys'. Like Jay, a white irish American who found it hard to accept his son was gay, yet his kids struggled to accept his latina much younger wife. The person who found it hardest to fit in was probably Alex, the highly intelligent white middle class kid. There are other examples but I feel it struck the right chord.

OP I think US shows were always a bit more preachy, I remember shows geared at young viewers like 90210 always having a theme like alcoholism etc and each episode would have a narrative. I always found the pro USA narrative in TV and films to be a bit disturbing and a form of propaganda. The blue collar hero and the foreign bad guy. My memory is the British soaps jumped onto whatever bandwagon was popular, always trying to be a little controversial but actually being cliche. I feel British dramas were always more intelligent, totally generalising of course.

mintlily · 16/06/2023 19:32

StarmanBobby · 16/06/2023 09:30

It's not PC to show more realistic demographics, than everyone who's a 'boss' figure being white and male. gay people have been around FOREVER. Britain has been racial diverse for a very VERY long time.
Just because the mainly wealthy,mainly white, mainly male writers, historian and authority figures didn't represent them, write about them or discuss them doesn't mean they didn't exist.

Some people lost their shit over that Xmas ad - set in Victorian London - that had a diverse cast shown. Not realistic apparently. that ad had a fecking DRAGON in it. But the bigots thought the unrealistic bit was the non-white victorians in the background...

My point wasn't really about representation. It's more about moralistic sermonising from characters in a way that sounds inauthentic, and rewriting works to fit a new agenda.
I like art that has complex morality, where you can't easily work out what is the writer's view and what is the characters'. Where "good" people might have "wrong" opinions and where moral issues are presented in a way that is authentic to the period and context it is set in.

OP posts:
Chermeup · 16/06/2023 19:30

Don't care about JB's skin but I think Elba is tad too old. Craig was too in the last few. Page, who was also mooted, might fit. At his age he could do few movies and I like his smile. Killer smile

ThreeCoursesForMe · 16/06/2023 19:28

Yanbu at all Op, I am ND but always found it absolutely absurd even as a child that society is considered so impressionable we can't watch TV shows or view a character that portrays a certain narrative or view on something without adopting those beliefs as our own. TV is not responsible for society's wokeness, I grew up on Only Fools, Inbetweeners, Carry on Films etc and I know what you can and can't say, the world's gone mad.

mintlily · 16/06/2023 19:27

Lndnmummy · 16/06/2023 14:27

OP, can you elaborate on why you find inclusion amd representation patronising?

I don't find inclusion/representation patronising. I don't like it when people rewrite history, put words into the mouths of authors who would have had no such views, or have the "good" characters sermonise about the latest woke issue, especially when it is set in an era when people didn't use the kind of ethical vocabulary that we use today.

OP posts:
MarkWithaC · 16/06/2023 18:41

DemiColon · 16/06/2023 17:47

He's not really wrong, the person James Bond was based on was white.

Part of the issue with this is that the progressive culture around this has become extremely contradictory.

Not in the sense that some productions look to be realistic in their approach while others are doing things like blind casting. It's that there has been a huge push to open up all roles depicting people who might broadly be called white, to anyone. And sometimes sex swapping too, particularly males to females as in Dr Who. Those who aren't crazy about this are labeled bigots, (in this thread for example,) even when you are talking about historical settings or culturally rooted stories.

At the same time, there is more and more demands that roles that might have traditionally been non-white must always be played by members of that actual group. Especially if the stories are historical, or culturally rooted. Older examples where white people played, for example, the King of Siam, are seen as fundamentally problematic, even though often they come out of a stage tradition where race and ethnicity based casting was mostly impossible. This is all pushed as being deeply important, and you're a bigot if you disagree.

And then there is the addiction of deeply weird stuff like the recent "documentary" film about the life of Cleopatra, where is is suggested by the producers that it is very important and empowering to bring forward the true stories of black women, but of course everyone with even a little education in ancient history knows she probably wasn't even mixed race. But pointing that out also makes people bigots.

The fact that it often seems that race-blind casting isn't blind at all, but is actually being used as a hook, doesn't make it easier for people to accept.

People sense that these ideas don't all fit together and there is a double standard, and it pisses them off.

It's possible to prefer race-blind casting, or historically accurate casting, or want culturally rooted stories to reflect that culture, without any of them being wrong, or unreasonable approaches to a particular production.

The person or people who inspired Q in James Bond was possibly not gay. And I'd imagine the person or people M was based on were not female. Do you find that a problem?
James Bond may be based on a real person, but a) the books and films are nonetheless fiction and b) that's at least partially because when the books were conceived, high-level/prestigious jobs were not nearly so available to non-white people as to white ones. In other words, he wasn't white 'just because'; lots of social forces played into that. I think it's rather interesting to look at what they were and what the franchise looks like if you play with that from our (I say this in a qualified way) more progressive modern point of view.

DemiColon · 16/06/2023 17:47

Lndnmummy · 16/06/2023 14:32

Reminds me of a taxi journey I was in the other week. The driver was furious that 'Eda, Edo, Eba, whatever the fellas name is' (Idris Elba) was considered for James Bond. As its 'totally unrealistic'. I asked him sarcastically if he thought so as the 'real james bond is white' and he said 'yes!! The real one is white'.

If this shit wasn't so triggering and soul destroying I would have laughed at this loser with his minute brain power and no teeth.

He's not really wrong, the person James Bond was based on was white.

Part of the issue with this is that the progressive culture around this has become extremely contradictory.

Not in the sense that some productions look to be realistic in their approach while others are doing things like blind casting. It's that there has been a huge push to open up all roles depicting people who might broadly be called white, to anyone. And sometimes sex swapping too, particularly males to females as in Dr Who. Those who aren't crazy about this are labeled bigots, (in this thread for example,) even when you are talking about historical settings or culturally rooted stories.

At the same time, there is more and more demands that roles that might have traditionally been non-white must always be played by members of that actual group. Especially if the stories are historical, or culturally rooted. Older examples where white people played, for example, the King of Siam, are seen as fundamentally problematic, even though often they come out of a stage tradition where race and ethnicity based casting was mostly impossible. This is all pushed as being deeply important, and you're a bigot if you disagree.

And then there is the addiction of deeply weird stuff like the recent "documentary" film about the life of Cleopatra, where is is suggested by the producers that it is very important and empowering to bring forward the true stories of black women, but of course everyone with even a little education in ancient history knows she probably wasn't even mixed race. But pointing that out also makes people bigots.

The fact that it often seems that race-blind casting isn't blind at all, but is actually being used as a hook, doesn't make it easier for people to accept.

People sense that these ideas don't all fit together and there is a double standard, and it pisses them off.

It's possible to prefer race-blind casting, or historically accurate casting, or want culturally rooted stories to reflect that culture, without any of them being wrong, or unreasonable approaches to a particular production.

Lndnmummy · 16/06/2023 14:32

Reminds me of a taxi journey I was in the other week. The driver was furious that 'Eda, Edo, Eba, whatever the fellas name is' (Idris Elba) was considered for James Bond. As its 'totally unrealistic'. I asked him sarcastically if he thought so as the 'real james bond is white' and he said 'yes!! The real one is white'.

If this shit wasn't so triggering and soul destroying I would have laughed at this loser with his minute brain power and no teeth.

Lndnmummy · 16/06/2023 14:27

OP, can you elaborate on why you find inclusion amd representation patronising?

FrostyFifi · 16/06/2023 14:15

We have things like Succession which was remarkably free of manifestations of the New Puritanism.

I mentioned Succession further back in the thread as an excellent example of a current tv show that has managed to swerve the New Puritinism.