Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 21:05

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:02

I have a hard time thinking you aren't taking the piss with a comment like that. No one has said anything remotely resembling that.

I think you need to read some of the posts again because they say exactly that. They say that the dramas an not as well written as they used to be in the past because the writers are pursuing an agenda. You can't get any clearer than that, can you?

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 21:01

mintlily · 17/06/2023 20:04

For many reasons. For one thing, I don't think that morality and attitudes inevitably get better as time moves forward, and I think it is extremely arrogant for producers to think that we enlightened 21t century people are the moral arbiters of history. I think that there is a lot that we condone nowadays which, in the future, will be considered horrifying. I am not saying everything was better in the past, just that there were a number of positive values which people held dear in the past which we have now lost. And I like to relive times when these things were valued.
Secondly, the main reason I watch something set in the past is to immerse myself in that time. I want to understand how people thought, what they were really going through, what were the hot topics of the day, how people's worldviews were conditioned by the politics of the time. I already know what the hot topics are for now - if I want to think about that, I'll turn on the news or have a conversation with a friend.

But don't you understand that the past may not be what you think it is. It sounds as though you want the past to be represented in a way that you imagine it to be, but others aren't allowed to use their imagination in the same way. Often people (I'm not saying this is you) like to imagine an England before immigration, before the "wokeness" etc fantasising that it was a better time then, but you only have to read the memoirs of ordinary people to see that it was great for an elite and shit for everybody else.

I don't think the past of the UK that you want to immerse yourself in never existed in the way that you think it did - except in Dickens novels and on chocolate boxes. Perhaps what you mean is that you want to immerse yourself in a fantasy world - much like the people who love Bridgerton do.

Noicant · 17/06/2023 20:04

I kind of get what you are saying OP. I was watching a crime drama involving an asylum seeker and the moralising was so clumsy it was off putting. I’m 2nd gen immigrant and I was rolling my eyes and wondering when the hell we were going to get to the bit about the murder. It was the heavy handness that distracted from the actual storyline. I love a good morality tale but it should be prickly your brain lightly to carefully nudge you on your perceptions not bashing you over the head.

Done well with nuance and subtlety good tv/films make you question your own prejudices without dragging you there. “Unthinkable” for example was excellent on torture or homosexuality in “The imitation game”.

I’m fine with diverse casting, it’s fictionalised history not a documentary or a news broadcast.

mintlily · 17/06/2023 20:04

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 18:07

I have a question for you: why do you think we have to keep re-living the attitudes of those times? When people express attitudes we now consider offensive what do you get out of it? How does it help you or anyone?

For many reasons. For one thing, I don't think that morality and attitudes inevitably get better as time moves forward, and I think it is extremely arrogant for producers to think that we enlightened 21t century people are the moral arbiters of history. I think that there is a lot that we condone nowadays which, in the future, will be considered horrifying. I am not saying everything was better in the past, just that there were a number of positive values which people held dear in the past which we have now lost. And I like to relive times when these things were valued.
Secondly, the main reason I watch something set in the past is to immerse myself in that time. I want to understand how people thought, what they were really going through, what were the hot topics of the day, how people's worldviews were conditioned by the politics of the time. I already know what the hot topics are for now - if I want to think about that, I'll turn on the news or have a conversation with a friend.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 17/06/2023 19:36

Re Henry viii, he went from being ' the hansomest prince in ChristenDom' to being an obese, miserable, bloated, impotent, stinking tyrant. It was part of his problem, so surely that should be reflected in films.

AnorLondo · 17/06/2023 19:03

mintlily · 17/06/2023 18:43

My point wasn't really at all about diverse casting. Not sure why people think that's what I'm talking about

Probably because there are people in this thread complaining about things like the little mermaid being black and Idris Elba possibly playing Bond and too many black people in adverts. Not that they're racist or anything.

mintlily · 17/06/2023 18:43

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 17/06/2023 17:32

Historical dramas are never accurate.
I love it when I see someone who looks like me or has my background in them. I don't need my race regulated to cowboy and Indian movies. Nor does my son need to see black people as only servants and slaves. It's just a movie.

My point wasn't really at all about diverse casting. Not sure why people think that's what I'm talking about

OP posts:
Fiftyisthenewsixty · 17/06/2023 18:19

I agree OP - it's not so much that it's political it's that it's so heavy-handed. They don't trust readers and viewers to understand nuance. And children's programmes which are overtly educational are DULL.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 18:07

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 17:21

When a show like Call the Midwife can't get a reasonably accurate portrayal of social attitudes, at a time that is recent enough that many people still remember it, that suggests that the problem isn't what you are suggesting.

We have lots of books and other historical material from the Victorian or even the Tudor period, we have some sense of how people thought and spoke.

I have a question for you: why do you think we have to keep re-living the attitudes of those times? When people express attitudes we now consider offensive what do you get out of it? How does it help you or anyone?

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 17/06/2023 17:32

Historical dramas are never accurate.
I love it when I see someone who looks like me or has my background in them. I don't need my race regulated to cowboy and Indian movies. Nor does my son need to see black people as only servants and slaves. It's just a movie.

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 17:21

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 14:07

This.

It is so frustrating to me that people think that it is possible to represent the past authentically. It's so weird. When I was a very young kid there were dramas about Henry VIII and his wives and Queen Victoria and everybody seems to think that those dramas were authentic representations of the past. How the hell could we know that? 100 years from now they won't be able to represent our time accurately. As I mentioned before when I see shows about the 1980s they are nothing like my memory and why should they be? They're TV shows.

And how far do you go with this historical realism that people seem to want? So only someone who really has blonde hair and blue eyes can play Harry Hotspur or only someone who really carries a bit of weight can play Henry VIII.

When a show like Call the Midwife can't get a reasonably accurate portrayal of social attitudes, at a time that is recent enough that many people still remember it, that suggests that the problem isn't what you are suggesting.

We have lots of books and other historical material from the Victorian or even the Tudor period, we have some sense of how people thought and spoke.

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 14:07

DataNotLore · 17/06/2023 11:07

Historical dramas, are not history lessons. They're escapism.

Non of them are "historically accurate". They're not supposed to be.

This.

It is so frustrating to me that people think that it is possible to represent the past authentically. It's so weird. When I was a very young kid there were dramas about Henry VIII and his wives and Queen Victoria and everybody seems to think that those dramas were authentic representations of the past. How the hell could we know that? 100 years from now they won't be able to represent our time accurately. As I mentioned before when I see shows about the 1980s they are nothing like my memory and why should they be? They're TV shows.

And how far do you go with this historical realism that people seem to want? So only someone who really has blonde hair and blue eyes can play Harry Hotspur or only someone who really carries a bit of weight can play Henry VIII.

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 13:49

mintlily · 17/06/2023 13:04

That's the thing. I don't think there is plenty out there that doesn't do this. You either have to watch old productions, or only the very very best TV and film out there, of which there's very little. Sometimes I want something lighthearted and low budget that's not preachy.

And I disagree but that could be because many of the shows with a diverse cast I have enjoyed and way into the story to notice or see these preachy things people claim.

Saying that, my own reality has been nothing but diversity so perhaps seeing such things in shows and movies as far back as I was a child, makes it difficult for me to notice any so-called preaching because I wasn’t looking for fallacies.

I recently watched BBC’s Inside Man and by some of these comments wonder if they would have found the beginning preachy about misogyny on public transport or complained how unrealistic it would be for a journalist to ride the tube, or the lack of mobile signals on tube trains, instead of just watching it as if they were reading a book.

mintlily · 17/06/2023 13:04

phoenixrosehere · 17/06/2023 08:42

Many shows “rewriting history” also put disclaimers that they aren’t accurate depictions and that it is fiction based loosely on true stories. It’s really on those watching to take such things into consideration as well as stories that are actually based off of other fictional stories. If you want what the creator wrote, you can just as well get their works and ignore the stuff based on it. I also think some forget many authors gave license/permission for their works to be used in a certain way and were even involved with how they were portrayed.

People can always not watch such shows if it is so tiresome. There are plenty out there that you won’t see as “preaching” to you or suits your chosen values and it is not new whatsoever as other posters have pointed out for there to be some type of moral or message in shows. Human history is filled with stories where morals, lessons are being pushed and always have. Myths and legends, religious texts, fictional stories from different eras , etc.

That's the thing. I don't think there is plenty out there that doesn't do this. You either have to watch old productions, or only the very very best TV and film out there, of which there's very little. Sometimes I want something lighthearted and low budget that's not preachy.

OP posts:
mintlily · 17/06/2023 12:59

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:27

He didn't say no one was against racism. But the way it was thought about, and particularly the language used, has changed since then. As you'd expect.

This sort of thing is what anyone writing a historical piece should be well versed in. Or they aren't doing their jobs.

Of course I'm not saying that there weren't people who were passionately opposed to racism in history. One of my great interests is in the history of the abolitionist movement, propelled primarily by the Quakers and William Wilberforce. I was just agreeing with this journalist's point that a lower middle class northern English family probably wouldn't have voiced their views using that particular vocabulary.

OP posts:
mintlily · 17/06/2023 12:57

StarmanBobby · 17/06/2023 10:38

‘My point wasn't really about representation.’

No if course it wasn’t. I’m not racist but… I’m have gay friends but…

I can only assume you haven't read any of my comments here. My issue is not with diverse casting. It's with characters sermonising on moral issues.

OP posts:
mintlily · 17/06/2023 12:54

GilChesterton · 17/06/2023 11:10

The carry on over casting in The Little Mermaid and Rings of Power strongly suggests a lot of objections to diverse casting are also driven by an 'agenda', and not a benign one at that.

Still, I'm sure the same people would have had the same objections to, say, Robert Powell playing Jesus, right?

I had no problems with the diverse casting in The Little Mermaid. My problem is primarily with how moral and political issues are presented.

OP posts:
DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:27

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 00:55

You say people in the 1950s would not articulate anti racist views in that way? I’m afraid you are incorrect. During the slavery abolitionist movement in this country for example people did just that. They also boycotted sugar (a form of cancellation). People from bygone eras were not as different to us as old time TV period dramas would have us believe.

He didn't say no one was against racism. But the way it was thought about, and particularly the language used, has changed since then. As you'd expect.

This sort of thing is what anyone writing a historical piece should be well versed in. Or they aren't doing their jobs.

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:22

With historical dramas: There is a real art form to doing them well. Something like Wolf Hall needs to feel, to the viewer, like it a window on another time and place, without being incomprehensible, or distracting.

Dialogue is part of that. It would be completely inappropriate to have a Jane Austen character speak in Valley Girl type slang, unless you are writing Clueless. Clueless is brilliant, but if we want something set in period you try, as a writer, to reflect the place and time, a more formal use of language, some more archaic, but still understandable, vocabulary, and especially avoiding very clearly modern colloquialisms.

Costuming etc is similar, you aren't going to present people of the past looking as scrubbed up as modern people, but on the other hand many productions avoid things like very bad teeth or skin diseases, because they are so distracting to the viewers.

Colourblind casting isn't necessarily a no go, but it will make a production something more like a play, and less like an immersive drama. But at the moment that kind of thing is clearly not as "blind" as people seem to like to imply. Notwithstanding the idiocy of the Cleopatra "documentary," as a role Cleopatra has been for years treated as something mainly seen as appropriate for black actresses, with an implication that a white actress in the role is somehow colonialist or something. Which is pretty silly

I don't really see ethnic diversity in a particular production as intrinsically good. I am quite fine with productions that aim to reflect accurate representations, be they set in Tudor England, or the far North of Canada, or a village in India. On television that's usually my preference, for realistic productions - for the theater I don't care so much. I am also happy for anyone to play any role they can be convincing in, but that will in many cases relate to their physical appearance - identity, IMO, is irrelevant in acting.

I'm not sure why anyone though would think like crap like Cleopatra, and that kind of casting in general, is anything other than deeply patronizing.

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:02

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 10:33

So all the dramas with diverse casts etc are poorly written and produced? Okay…

I have a hard time thinking you aren't taking the piss with a comment like that. No one has said anything remotely resembling that.

Chermeup · 17/06/2023 11:34

Also it's a concentration issue with books in my case (as I said) , not about being choosy. Concentrating all day at work does my adhd brain no favours towards evening

Chermeup · 17/06/2023 11:33

Bubblyb00b · 17/06/2023 11:28

@Chermeup true, but, as you said, books take an effort to consume so probs require a bit of a more discerning taste.

In any case, if you "cant stand" something just avoid it?

That's what I do after few episodes.
But it's annoying when something starts well and turns into pretty annoying meh.
Same with books though!

Bubblyb00b · 17/06/2023 11:28

@Chermeup true, but, as you said, books take an effort to consume so probs require a bit of a more discerning taste.

In any case, if you "cant stand" something just avoid it?

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/06/2023 11:26

Amol Rajan is excellent on Today. Looking forward to UChallenge.

bluebell34567 · 17/06/2023 11:21

havent rdtft but i would like to add that i dont like Amol Rajan, the way he speaks, etc. he seems so fake to me. i dont know why they are pushing him forward nowadays, what they see in him. he seems to think of himself as gold dust, too. i have to change the channel he is on so quickly.