Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Chermeup · 18/06/2023 12:36

Sent too early.
The good doctpr always had bits in but in season 4 they just suddenly quikly decided to do 2 per episode for about 4 or 5 episodes with nothing coming out of them except people rguing and shutting others down. No continuance like with other issues. It was just like issue speed dating. Totally different to other episodes. The last few episodes then went back to normal where the stories actually flowed again.

Chermeup · 18/06/2023 12:34

phoenixrosehere · 18/06/2023 12:26

So things actually happening in the States are preachy? The Good Doctor is based in the States, those issues you mentioned have been brought up for years on other medical drama shows and based off of actual experiences.

It is HOW they are brought up

phoenixrosehere · 18/06/2023 12:26

Chermeup · 18/06/2023 06:56

I am an immigrant, DH is brown immigrant, I am often surprised when I hear moaning about areas of UK being mainly white, because... Of course they are. It doesn't mean they are bad. We lived in few. I sometimes wondered if people want equal diversity everywhere and how the heck wojld that work? Move people around based on quotas? We actually joked about how it could go.
"Hey, sorry, we know you want to live in Manchester, but we actually need 1 arab in a village by Morecombe, so... Yeah. Enjoy!"
UK is the "white area". Nothing bad on having majority of indeginous population?

But we are steering away from preachy TV.
I don't know how others but we always enjoyed The good doctor. Nkce light thing to watch. Season for in the post covid episodes was just abysmal. Good examples of what we are talking here about issue being preached and then dropped. Just randomly in there. If they really wanted to ahow racism against patients, why drop it? It's actual serious issue but we saw report being given and.... That's it. It would be great if they carried it over a bit in background fgs. Nah. Make 20 min dance about racism, and then drop it. Pregnant man was also bit odd episode. Guns, with shot kids, but at least that carried via different characters. And so on.
Then it went better again, I think it may have something to do with losing quite cast numbers.

So things actually happening in the States are preachy? The Good Doctor is based in the States, those issues you mentioned have been brought up for years on other medical drama shows and based off of actual experiences.

Bingbangbongbash · 18/06/2023 12:22

FrostyFifi · 16/06/2023 14:15

We have things like Succession which was remarkably free of manifestations of the New Puritanism.

I mentioned Succession further back in the thread as an excellent example of a current tv show that has managed to swerve the New Puritinism.

You do understand that Succession is a satire full of people so hateful and awful because they are painfully ‘antiwoke’, don’t you? One of the primary themes is the characters wrestling with their desire for power v their fear that they are creating an anti-democratic, decisive, racist media landscape. It’s about as woke as it gets.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 18/06/2023 12:22

GreenApplesPinkShoes · 15/06/2023 08:39

YABU - media and art have always had slants, biases, included opinions on social issues etc. All forms have always had their good and bad attempts at representing these. The idea that the past was innately better is rose-colored glass thinking. You will have forgotten the truly terrible stuff on tv way back when, and sounds like you're missing some amazing stuff now.

There are good discussions to be had about true representation, tokenism, nuance, cultural appropriation, various forms and values of story telling etc. But the idea of some nefarious 'agenda' going on just makes me think of conspiracy theorists and evangelical Christians. I'm a church refugee and I am so over mysterious oft-touted 'agendas' in media or society that I'm supposed to feel victimized by. I just really, really don't.

It's no skin off my nose if Netflix goes overboard with non-White casting to make up for decades of White-washing by most media (which most people who bemoan today's 'agendas' apparently don't have a problem with). Ditto for sexuality and gender. Honestly, why is my white, hetero body considered 'normal' and brown bodies considered 'diverse'? Why is my love story or sexuality the default, and other stories different from mine are an 'agenda'? It is truly bizarre to me.

Also, anyone using woke as a pejorative should look into the history of the term, and reconsider.

U have manged to articulate how I'm feeling so much better than how I could

GilChesterton · 18/06/2023 12:16

Why can't Britain make TV that has mass appeal all around the world like Game of Thrones, Walking Dead, etc?

Did Doctor Who just whizz right by you, then? Or Sherlock, Black Mirror, Shetland, Catastrophe, The Thick of It, etc.

Florenz · 18/06/2023 11:52

Why can't Britain make TV that has mass appeal all around the world like Game of Thrones, Walking Dead, etc? Those shows are full of British actors too.

StarmanBobby · 18/06/2023 11:36

Annika on BBC 1 is very, very good. But not all the characters are white, OP. And one is gay, so you’d probably hate it.
normal people should like it though. The type who don’t think a character with brown skin and a Scots accent is an ‘agenda’ and in fact night just be be a non- white Scot.

Chermeup · 18/06/2023 06:56

Triptoqueen · 18/06/2023 06:04

Exactly - most of England was white . I mentioned previously in a post that I was talking about outside London.

I am an immigrant, DH is brown immigrant, I am often surprised when I hear moaning about areas of UK being mainly white, because... Of course they are. It doesn't mean they are bad. We lived in few. I sometimes wondered if people want equal diversity everywhere and how the heck wojld that work? Move people around based on quotas? We actually joked about how it could go.
"Hey, sorry, we know you want to live in Manchester, but we actually need 1 arab in a village by Morecombe, so... Yeah. Enjoy!"
UK is the "white area". Nothing bad on having majority of indeginous population?

But we are steering away from preachy TV.
I don't know how others but we always enjoyed The good doctor. Nkce light thing to watch. Season for in the post covid episodes was just abysmal. Good examples of what we are talking here about issue being preached and then dropped. Just randomly in there. If they really wanted to ahow racism against patients, why drop it? It's actual serious issue but we saw report being given and.... That's it. It would be great if they carried it over a bit in background fgs. Nah. Make 20 min dance about racism, and then drop it. Pregnant man was also bit odd episode. Guns, with shot kids, but at least that carried via different characters. And so on.
Then it went better again, I think it may have something to do with losing quite cast numbers.

Triptoqueen · 18/06/2023 06:04

DataNotLore · 17/06/2023 21:44

No you bloody don't.

You just grew up in a very white area.

Exactly - most of England was white . I mentioned previously in a post that I was talking about outside London.

beguilingeyes · 18/06/2023 05:59

MovinGroovinBarbie · 18/06/2023 02:02

I don't quite understand your point. A film about past events is a film about the past.

I do still think a fair approximation of a particular dialect is going to be less jarring than using modern speech. It's not like the vast majority of people will care or be able to tell if it's 100% accurate. Most, however, would find it a bit odd if Mr Darcy uttered the phrase "innit bruv".

There was the horror of the recent Persuasion, with Anne Elliott swigging wine from the bottle and talking about her 'ex'. shudders

nolongersurprised · 18/06/2023 05:19

*unattainable, not attainable

nolongersurprised · 18/06/2023 04:26

chaosmaker · 15/06/2023 01:20

disneyfied anyway. The little mermaid - no name as far as I remember - died of a broken heart and became foam on the waves. Gotta love Hans Christian Anderson.
Proper fairy tales have all been sanitised and have lost the morals that were the point of them in the first place.

I have always thought The Little Mermaid was a cautionary tale about female sexual desire, rather than having a moral per se.

TLM is a teen girl, yearning for an attainable man. She knows she is what the Prince is looking for (she saved him and all that) and all she needs to do is show him that she’s “the one” and they will be together.

In return for legs (and the part in between) the Sea Witch chops out her tongue and ensures that every step she takes will feel like knives are stabbing her. She loses her voice, her status and her family in order to pursue her desires.

Once on land, TLM pretty much makes it obvious she is available to the Prince, including refusing to sleep in her own bad but sleeping on the floor outside his room. IIRC he is responsive to his charms, he fondles her and is affectionate but never treats her as an equal and certainly never appreciates that she is the one (who saved him).

Predictably, when he does fall in love it’s with a princess and when he marries her and dawn breaks TLM literally dissipates, dissolving into foam.

The moral could be: Girls and women, don’t think that making yourself sexually available to powerful men will make them love you. They’ll play around with you but marry a woman who’s similar to them, and you’ll be discarded 😀. Not very Disney though

MovinGroovinBarbie · 18/06/2023 03:28

DemiColon · 18/06/2023 02:51

Usually people like historical dramas because they are interested in history. Otherwise it's basically a random setting with no relevance to the story. Shitty writing.

But if you want an argument for it being a good thing, one reason is that it helps protect us from the very dangerous assumption that we are at the end of history.

The kinds of political cultures that are desperate for people to forget the past take that approach because they want to control people's thinking and prevent them from questioning current orthodoxies.

If you don't like historical settings, or understanding how people in other times and places thought, that's your business, but it rather disqualifies you from having any kind of useful POV on historical dramas.

This in a nutshell.

DemiColon · 18/06/2023 02:51

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 18:07

I have a question for you: why do you think we have to keep re-living the attitudes of those times? When people express attitudes we now consider offensive what do you get out of it? How does it help you or anyone?

Usually people like historical dramas because they are interested in history. Otherwise it's basically a random setting with no relevance to the story. Shitty writing.

But if you want an argument for it being a good thing, one reason is that it helps protect us from the very dangerous assumption that we are at the end of history.

The kinds of political cultures that are desperate for people to forget the past take that approach because they want to control people's thinking and prevent them from questioning current orthodoxies.

If you don't like historical settings, or understanding how people in other times and places thought, that's your business, but it rather disqualifies you from having any kind of useful POV on historical dramas.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 18/06/2023 02:02

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 04:36

Not enough for a drama. Most dramas are about us not really about the past. Why would they be?

I don't quite understand your point. A film about past events is a film about the past.

I do still think a fair approximation of a particular dialect is going to be less jarring than using modern speech. It's not like the vast majority of people will care or be able to tell if it's 100% accurate. Most, however, would find it a bit odd if Mr Darcy uttered the phrase "innit bruv".

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 18/06/2023 01:02

It depends what you're doing doesn't it? For example, if you cast Call the Midwife I a completely colour blind way, then you couldn't have some of Lucille's storylines. There were some related to her coming from the West Indies, and being black. And I think based directly on some Windrush generation nurses/midwives experiences.

You wouldn't be able to write that storyline if all the characters were different races from the beginning because it wouldn't make sense to single her out. Pride and Prejudice wouldn't be historically accurate if the Bennets were played by mixed race actors but it wouldn't affect the plot.

nolongersurprised · 18/06/2023 00:25

nolongersurprised · 17/06/2023 22:51

It’s not the agenda though, it’s the obvious shoehorning. At school, my children were advised to “show, don’t tell” with their writing.

I like the author Curtis Sittenfeld, she wrote Prep. That covers gay relationships, racism, social class divisions deftly, within the actual plot. I thought her book Rodham ended brilliantly, emphasising that misogyny is ubiquitous across men in political parties.

Her latest one is based on a script writer for SNL and for me, it doesn’t work, it’s insipid. It’s like she tried to shoe horn in everything- BLM marches, same sex couples having babies, black women and higher rate of complications during labour, non binary presenters etc.

It’s not that these topics aren’t worthy (although non-binary is a load of crap) but I miss the writer’s satirical, funny edge evident in her previous novels. I don’t want to feel as though I’m being “educated” when I read.

To elaborate on this: the “old” Sittenfeld would’ve had a character who cared strongly about racial injustice, went on BLM marches but whilst there, felt awkward, met some people she didn’t like, maybe got the chants wrong.

With her latest book it’s like the story is actually stopped every now and then for the reader to be “educated”.

myveryownelectrickitten · 17/06/2023 23:34

DemiColon · 17/06/2023 12:22

With historical dramas: There is a real art form to doing them well. Something like Wolf Hall needs to feel, to the viewer, like it a window on another time and place, without being incomprehensible, or distracting.

Dialogue is part of that. It would be completely inappropriate to have a Jane Austen character speak in Valley Girl type slang, unless you are writing Clueless. Clueless is brilliant, but if we want something set in period you try, as a writer, to reflect the place and time, a more formal use of language, some more archaic, but still understandable, vocabulary, and especially avoiding very clearly modern colloquialisms.

Costuming etc is similar, you aren't going to present people of the past looking as scrubbed up as modern people, but on the other hand many productions avoid things like very bad teeth or skin diseases, because they are so distracting to the viewers.

Colourblind casting isn't necessarily a no go, but it will make a production something more like a play, and less like an immersive drama. But at the moment that kind of thing is clearly not as "blind" as people seem to like to imply. Notwithstanding the idiocy of the Cleopatra "documentary," as a role Cleopatra has been for years treated as something mainly seen as appropriate for black actresses, with an implication that a white actress in the role is somehow colonialist or something. Which is pretty silly

I don't really see ethnic diversity in a particular production as intrinsically good. I am quite fine with productions that aim to reflect accurate representations, be they set in Tudor England, or the far North of Canada, or a village in India. On television that's usually my preference, for realistic productions - for the theater I don't care so much. I am also happy for anyone to play any role they can be convincing in, but that will in many cases relate to their physical appearance - identity, IMO, is irrelevant in acting.

I'm not sure why anyone though would think like crap like Cleopatra, and that kind of casting in general, is anything other than deeply patronizing.

This. I happen to prefer realism, but i’m perfectly aware (I’m a historian 😂) that it only goes so far. We never get a truly accurate portrayal of even the recent past (just think of how many men in historical dramas are clean-shaven: in reality, most would have had facial hair in the majority of historical periods). But then, artistic and cultural productions always take some licence: with makeup, with the lighting, with the way reality is represented, whether they’re historical or contemporary.

The issue that the OP is talking about is not diversity, but the heavy-handedness of too-obvious preaching on social issues. There are examples of doing it well, just as much as of doing it badly. The current CBBC Malory Towers, which my DD loves (and I find really enjoyable too), has a diverse cast, for example, which is completely unrepresentative of the books or of the time period; but it’s done so well and without preaching, that it just becomes another way of telling the story in the books but subtly updating it, to make it fresh and relevant to today. It isn’t really, in that at least, very accurate to the original time period at all, but this doesn’t matter because the actual plots are adapted very well. (Thankfully, though, in the scene in which Bill the tomboy doesn’t want to wear a dress to practice dancing, she firmly says that she’s still a girl even if she doesn’t want to dress like one - no nonbinaryness so far! 😂)

There’s room for adaptations that are more historically accurate, and also those that take more obvious liberties — but surely it’s the uniformity of the preaching and turning everything as a vehicle for an Issue that’s the annoying thing?

(NB pp were referring to Dickens - but he was also the popular middlebrow writer of his day, and hugely sentimentalist! There were other nineteeenth-century novelists who were far more interested in social realism — for example, George Eliot’s Daniel Deronda; or Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South. Certainly there is a huge proportion of Dickens which is not remotely plausible social commentary, but sensationalist fantasy for the middle classes — think of A Christmas Carol, Oliver Twist and Great Expectations, in which even the depictions of poverty are cranked up to the max — and not to make them Issues so much, but to make them titillating as plot devices. And even then, lots of readers could never stand the preachier bits of Dickens!)

nolongersurprised · 17/06/2023 22:51

HeckinBamboozled · 15/06/2023 09:22

This. OP is deluded if they think there hasn't been agendas in art since the beginning of time.

It’s not the agenda though, it’s the obvious shoehorning. At school, my children were advised to “show, don’t tell” with their writing.

I like the author Curtis Sittenfeld, she wrote Prep. That covers gay relationships, racism, social class divisions deftly, within the actual plot. I thought her book Rodham ended brilliantly, emphasising that misogyny is ubiquitous across men in political parties.

Her latest one is based on a script writer for SNL and for me, it doesn’t work, it’s insipid. It’s like she tried to shoe horn in everything- BLM marches, same sex couples having babies, black women and higher rate of complications during labour, non binary presenters etc.

It’s not that these topics aren’t worthy (although non-binary is a load of crap) but I miss the writer’s satirical, funny edge evident in her previous novels. I don’t want to feel as though I’m being “educated” when I read.

DataNotLore · 17/06/2023 21:44

Triptoqueen · 17/06/2023 21:33

Often people (I'm not saying this is you) like to imagine an England before immigration

We don't need to imagine it we remember it. Good and bad. And it's not that we want a quaint or happy fantasy - we want truth not a lesson.

No you bloody don't.

You just grew up in a very white area.

Triptoqueen · 17/06/2023 21:33

Often people (I'm not saying this is you) like to imagine an England before immigration

We don't need to imagine it we remember it. Good and bad. And it's not that we want a quaint or happy fantasy - we want truth not a lesson.

StarmanBobby · 17/06/2023 21:25

Go and watch Annika - on BBC and iPlayer now- brilliant.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 17/06/2023 21:19

I don't think the past of the UK that you want to immerse yourself in never existed in the way that you think it did - except in Dickens novels and on chocolate boxes. Perhaps what you mean is that you want to immerse yourself in a fantasy world - much like the people who love Bridgerton do.
You seem to have completed misinterpreted what the OP has said - and I mean completely. You seem to have understood the exact opposite!

Fisharejumping · 17/06/2023 21:09

Chermeup · 17/06/2023 05:48

I think people should be more angry with Netflix and likes. The Cleopatra debacle was the last nail in a coffin currently. It just made everyone quite hyper aware of diversity productions and casting for the sake of tick, rather than anything else. I mean even Egyptian government had to comment fgs.
It's these things then make people wonder if every x is diversity hire/purpose written character, if you see what I mean, and it ruina natural flows because people suspect they are there for the tick. And take a piss.
No need to "steal" other people's history. Anyone who went to school knows that every nation, religion, race has amazing characters/heroes which could be easily made into movie, let alone a documentary.

It's simple, if they kept writing naturally flowing stories with characters being there for the story not for the sake of it (like in examples given on this thread) people wouldn't need to complain about low quality output (and in case of Egyptian gov, actual lies)

I don't think "xi s a diversity hire" because I can see with my own eyes that Television companies are now getting wise to the wealth of talent in the (for want of a better phrase) black community. Talent that was overlooked for generations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread