Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mintlily · 22/06/2023 13:12

Sigmama · 22/06/2023 12:56

'21st century producers don't care about the moral issues', what are you on about? What a bizarre, unfounded, broad, generalised statement about hundreds of people you've never met

Calm down. We can discuss things without getting confrontational.

Aside from shows that whose main theme is race or feminism or lgbt issues, this is what I find: that cookie - cutter moral stances are usually injected into the plot or the script in a way that feels really insincere and almost childish in its simplistic view of right and wrong. The views are extremely predictable and copy-paste, and there is no artistry in the way they're presented.

I can totally see why this is. My friend is a script writer and he says the producers basically ask him to shoehorn certain themes in to make the commissioners happy. Hence why it's entirely contrived.

OP posts:
Sigmama · 22/06/2023 12:56

'21st century producers don't care about the moral issues', what are you on about? What a bizarre, unfounded, broad, generalised statement about hundreds of people you've never met

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:34

(or should I say youthful folly).

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:33

Huge fan of Ciaran Hinds but I'm not sure that he actually nailed the character.

Just to elaborate... He tends to have a lot of gravitas.
His character did become much more serious after the accident, but before it (and even after it) that character had a bit of light heartedness, humour, even cavalier-ness; and I don't think CH can portray traits like that well. All in all he was too serious. He also seemed too old for a 30/early 30s something youbg man who's still got a bit of youthfulness about him (see his behaviour towards the Musgrove sisters etc).

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:25

TheMurderousGoose · 22/06/2023 12:14

It was Persuasion for the Netflix/Insta generation. It was unadulterated shite but I don't really care as the ultimate Persuasion adaptation already exists. (Root and Hinds obv).

Huge fan of Ciaran Hinds but I'm not sure that he actually nailed the character.

She also came under flack for looking a bit grim (just get natural physionomy and expression) and I get that - Anne was supposed to be a "pretty girl" who became increasingly more so (after a period of stagnation that affected her looks ) around the time he came back into her life and as she came out of her shell and away from the influence of her family members & substitute Mum .... And she was still quite young (mid to late 20s). I don't think Root really represented that. She certainly had the depth and earnestness but ...

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:21

I just don't think it works either way.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:19

TheMurderousGoose · 22/06/2023 12:14

It was Persuasion for the Netflix/Insta generation. It was unadulterated shite but I don't really care as the ultimate Persuasion adaptation already exists. (Root and Hinds obv).

It's a travesty.

Pick your era and do it ... Is my view.

I've just thought through more why I find the "colour blind" casting so uncomfortable....it's like the reverse of casting Caucasian actors in non Caucasian roles ... That's mostly been stopped and seen, correctly, as wrong - so why are we doing the opposite with Caucasian characters (?)

TheMurderousGoose · 22/06/2023 12:14

It was Persuasion for the Netflix/Insta generation. It was unadulterated shite but I don't really care as the ultimate Persuasion adaptation already exists. (Root and Hinds obv).

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 12:00

*On a related but different note - I've not seen the latest version of Persuasion but similar issues about authenticity crop up ...... But have seen and read all the reviews, I should add. Which put me off watching it.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:59

On a related but different note - I've not seen the latest version of Persuasion but similar issues about authenticity crop up.

Modern phrasing based on modern concepts hat would not exist in the context of the novel (exes).

Main character referring to listening to Beethoven in their room with a bottle of "red" before gramophones were in use.

If you're going to do that with it, turn it into a contemporary version. ... Like Clueless.

Why run with a period/historical context and then shit all over it in cringey ways.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:56

*Is it that

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:54

I'd it that it's illegal and they'd be open to suing if they reject actors on the basis of race for any role; even if the role would is clearly a Caucasian British aristocrat in the 1800s?

Or is it just that the producers feel they should represent all races, totally regardless of the race of the characters? It seems that way. But it just totally jars for me (and I should emphasise that is not due to anyone's race; it's due to them playing a role that I'd a different race, and it matters because of the context of the story.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:50

*vast majority Caucasian population

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:49

Im trying to define why it irritates makes me uncomfortable and I think it's because it's so inauthentic.

Not a word, I know but...

Those novels/plays were set in a country with with a vast majority Caucasus population. The class of the people that the novels are about were 99% or more Caucasian. This is true of both novels written around the time that there set, and of historical/period novels written recently but set in the e 1700s and 1800s.
So I don't get why we're expected to accept non Caucasian actors being cast in the roles; and as I said, if we're supposed to now be colour blind, it's BS . . None of our issues on this front would exist if humans were colour blind.
I find the casting jars because it's so unauthentic.

If it's "Rome" and every race on the planet Is cast; cool, that's authentic. 1800s Victorian England among aristocrats and the UMC; no.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:42

*not colour blind.

TheoTheopolis23 · 22/06/2023 11:42

I don't know he to phrase this without inciting a pile on, but I feel irritated by the producers of historical series expecting viewers to be colour blind when they cast.

With a few very minor exceptions (the mixed race aristocrat (Belle?) About whom a film has been made, the small numbers of black people in the UK in the 17 and 1800s were not aristocrats, UMC etc. So why are we pretending they were? And if it's because we're supposed to be colour blind (and it seems were expected to be so in an attempt to redress the total lack of black rgc characters in period dramas) ... Why? We're not vote blind. If we were, we wouldn't have to redress the balance in the first place.

I don't get it.

Catspyjamas17 · 22/06/2023 11:00

I should imagine that people, even nuns, who worked with women having multiple pregnancies, dying in childbirth, young girls getting pregnant, forced marriage, rape etc would be pretty pro-choice. And they are Anglican nuns also.

StarmanBobby · 22/06/2023 10:54

@JaneyGee the only people I know who use the word 'woke' are the frothing, rabid right-wingers - so not sure why the word makes you 'laugh' when no sane, normal person would actually use it

DemiColon · 22/06/2023 10:33

I'm really not sure how anyone thinks it's credible that in CTM, the majority of the main characters seem either fully or partly on board with changing the abortion laws. Some, maybe especially the ones who weren't nuns? Sure. That's realistic and would have made for a good show, if they showed the kinds of real conflicts in people's thinking.

What I found very notable is when they were addressing it, you didn't actually get anyone really describing what the beliefs and principles of many people, especially nuns, would have been at the time.

You almost get the impression that the writers think anyone from the 60s who isn't socially progressive according to 21st century norms just was a fuddy duddy for no reason, and incapable of making an argument for their position. Which is clearly bollocks.

Doctor Mansplainer in particular seems completely improbable, not so much for his views, he could have been a radical person, but because he behaves as if he is completely unaware why many people felt differently. It's like he's been transplanted from 2020.

I'm sure Sister Evangelina wouldn't have put up with any of it.

mintlily · 22/06/2023 09:46

Even then, having actually studied Victorian writers at university, I would say that Dickens comes last place in the great novelists in terms of nuance. He does many things fantastically, but the way he paints villains and heroes and the sexes is very pantomime-esque. E.g. His female characters are either crazy hags or angelic saints. Read the scene when Nell dies in the Old Curiosity Shop. Victorian sentimentalism at its sugariest.

I do love Dickens, but he wasn't the benchmark of nuance when it came to charactisation

OP posts:
mintlily · 22/06/2023 09:40

GilChesterton · 22/06/2023 06:47

It’s not about being environmentally skeptic. I want to hear environment-related content—at other times, like when I’m reading or watching news content or a documentary. I don’t want it when I am watching Tolkien. Is that too much to ask?

If you don't want to hear a message about society when you're reading then for goodness' sake stay away from Charles Dickens.

We already talked about Dickens. In a nutshell, Dickens, unlike the writers of these shows and films, was counter cultural for his day. Also, Dickens actually cared deeply about these issues and the themes dominated the entirety of many of his works. 21st century producers don't really care about the moral issues they're addressing - they're just doing it tokenistically to stay on the right side of activists. They inject moral lessons in a way that is incongruous to the rest of their work to tick a box. Dickens does it in a way that is coherent with the entire plot, because the issues he's concerned about are literally the entire theme of his novels.

OP posts:
mintlily · 22/06/2023 09:35

Sigmama · 22/06/2023 08:38

Gilchesterton, spot on, stay away from dickens op

Look through the thread. We already discussed Dickens

OP posts:
Sigmama · 22/06/2023 08:38

Gilchesterton, spot on, stay away from dickens op

Nordicrain · 22/06/2023 08:28

mintlily · 21/06/2023 16:05

I actually happen to know several Anglican midwives who are are all against abortion - and this is the 21st century. So I'm pretty sure that the majority of devout CofE nuns in the 1950s/60s/70s would have been too.

I'm absolutely not turning this thread into a discussion on abortion - my point was not about the ethics of abortion. I was merely saying that the BBC was unconvincing in its scriptwriting of that particular episode of the Call the Midwife. It would have been better for the nuns to have had views on abortion that were actually convincing for the time, even if it complicated them as "good" characters in the eyes of many viewers. Because that's what makes for great television! Nuance and layered, convincing characterisation :)

Sure. That doesn't mean others aren't. Also the whole point of the story is the battle at the time between what is best for women's health and then the morality of the society at the time (including religion).

CTM also included a stroy line of a nun running off with the doctor. You aren't getting your knickers in a twist about that, although I am sure most nuns wouldn't be up for that.

beguilingeyes · 22/06/2023 07:38

The left-leaning BBC??!! Seriously? Have you seen Question Time lately? Fiona Bruce is so Tory it's not funny.
The DG is an ex-conservative candidate and the controversial director is a Tory donor.
It was the BBC that gave that famous lefty Farage a platform..he was on Question Time 33 times (it's probably more now).