Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
bumblebee2235 · 15/06/2023 06:18

IsThereAnEchoInHere · 14/06/2023 20:05

I have more problem with the gratuitous sex scenes for no reason, nudity - mostly just to objectify, even worse if it’s in the name of ’sex positivity’ or ’female empowerment’ 🙄.
Also there is a strong push for the bdsm shit.
And I don’t even watch type of movies that are about relationship/romance etc.
They push that shit on every genre.
I don’t know why.

Totally! Every movie I'm like at some point there will be a pointless shower scene. 😂

loislovesstewie · 15/06/2023 06:12

I think the problem is that it's very clunky signalling, no subtlety to it. Very obvious and sometimes totally out of place.

Triptoqueen · 15/06/2023 06:01

I agree. Things aren't represented well, how do I know? I'm old enough to remember the 60s and 70s.
I argued previously about swearing in progs set in the past - I was told we've always sworn look at Chaucer - but that wasn't always angry blaspheming it was more bawdy slang.
Hardly anyone swore when I was growing up. Or if they did not F and C and not normally in front of women or by women. People wanted to be seen as respectable - I'm SURE there were areas of the country, parts of society where the language was bad but not that I came across. People went to church. Keeping up appearances - not to say there weren't dreadful things going on. It was kept quiet by a sort of acceptance that there were immoral lesser beings who should know better and got no sympathy.
But progs set then have a 'hero' who can see what is wrong and is fighting for the underdog which hardly happened then in real life - unless the 'hero' was a rich and influential person.

FOJN · 15/06/2023 05:40

I agree. Books, TV, films, art have always dealt with social and political issues but these days it feels like we're fed a diet of pure propaganda. We're told WHAT to think rather than actually think.

I miss the days of feeling really challenged and made to think by books, TV etc because they presented the full complexity of life and the real world rather than there is right and wrong, pick a side. I hardly watch any TV now because it's so tedious.

Oh and I can't bear the amount of gratuitous nudity and sex either, so much time is wasted on those scenes I'm convinced it's just filler to make up the required amount of time for a programm.

Words · 15/06/2023 05:32

Because of the reasons @Fisharejumping set out.

It's frightening, because in my view its total lack of nuance and ambiguity discourages critical thinking. Context is everything. And we see that seeping into all areas of life these days.

It's also boring, simplistic and patronising.

TodayInahurry · 15/06/2023 05:30

We watch very little TV and have not been to the cinema for years. We have loads of DVDs from the past and watch them. I refuse to buy new ‘censored’ books and only buy second hand ones. Best program on TV ‘Clarkson’s Farm’ new series in October !

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 15/06/2023 05:25

Words · 15/06/2023 05:12

I entirely agree OP. It's profoundly depressing and rather frightening.

What is frightening about tv shows you're not into?

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 15/06/2023 05:25

Victoria05 · 15/06/2023 02:39

What were the agendas of these shows? Star Trek had the 1st interracial kiss but what were the other shows promoting? Not being goady just genuinely wondering as have just got into watching clips of I ♡ Lucy on YouTube

I love Lucy has the first pregnant woman on TV. Showed the first married couple sleeping in bed together. Also, it almost didn't get made because the executives didn't think it was believable that a Cuban man could be with a white woman, despite the fact they were an actual couple.

Words · 15/06/2023 05:12

I entirely agree OP. It's profoundly depressing and rather frightening.

myveryownelectrickitten · 15/06/2023 05:05

Fisharejumping · 15/06/2023 03:25

I am interested to know what you mean by “historical accuracy” or “historical realism” and wonder if those past representations of history are any more authentic than contemporary works. Probably not. How do you know they are accurate? Remember that even novels written at the time are performances and themselves served an agenda so the idea of authenticity or truth within any artistic representation is rather nebulous.

Obviously. But you can see the difference in, for example, the attitude to producing at the Globe in the mid-2000s compared to today. Of course in 2005 the Globe wasn’t offering authentically dirty orange-peddlers from 1600, teenage boys playing all the female cast (though they did experiment with this a bit), or doing away with the fire exit signs in pursuit of a more authentic experience. But they were much more conservative in terms of historical conservationism, interest in performance history etc. than today.

Lots of interest in the mid-2000s in “grittier”, less polished versions of historical drama, too: less Colin Firth and more dirt, mud and bad teeth. That doesn’t mean they weren’t producing something just as constructed as before: but those shifts in how we think about different kinds of authenticity and whether they matter are pretty interesting. It’s not at all historically plausible for Anne with an E or Catherine called Birdy to have had gay friends, and it isn’t in the original texts. But currently it seems to be important to the people producing adaptations to shoehorn in contemporary political issues, in a way that 15 years ago was much less obviously urgent.

You might prefer the current approach. OP might be bored with it. But it’s undeniably there.

Palmasailor · 15/06/2023 04:49

I haven’t turned the TV in in a decade.

And I don’t consume any mainstream media which is all propaganda

DontGetEvenGetEverything · 15/06/2023 04:22

Boomboom22 · 14/06/2023 22:10

Is dumbing down decolonisation?
Why do you / the BBC think wc or ethnic minority audiences can't cope with good quality programming hosted by actual experts?
Is strictly worth paying for? Or what passes for women's hour? I've moved to radio 5, much better but still a bit low brow.

"Is dumbing down decolonisation?"
I rekon there's probably a thesis in that.
Maybe it's because we once again live in an age of moral certainty, so works that are subtle or ambiguous are ousted and replaced with works that have a simple, moral clarity.

On the other hand, us viewers can be a bit dim. When Todd Hayes made [Safe ] in 1995 he had to add a scene showing the guru's luxurious mansion alongside other cult members' one-room hovels because viewers kept assuming the guru in the film was Hayes' mouthpiece. I think because the guru is only ever seen through the eyes of the main character Carol, who is mesmerised and uncritical.
So maybe script writers are right to assume we need things spelled out for us?

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 15/06/2023 04:14

Pocahontas, Tintin in Congo, Little House on the Prairie… totally apolitical. Definitely not plugging colonialism or the dominance of white men. Nope, pure entertainment.

Emptycrackedcup · 15/06/2023 04:01

Fisharejumping · 15/06/2023 03:25

I am interested to know what you mean by “historical accuracy” or “historical realism” and wonder if those past representations of history are any more authentic than contemporary works. Probably not. How do you know they are accurate? Remember that even novels written at the time are performances and themselves served an agenda so the idea of authenticity or truth within any artistic representation is rather nebulous.

Agree. History is a representation, not fact. It's called hisstory

Fisharejumping · 15/06/2023 03:25

myveryownelectrickitten · 15/06/2023 02:59

Yes, this^^. OP isn’t wrong, and many of the responses are unwittingly demonstrating that, too. Anyone who works in media/scriptwriting/TV/the cultural sector knows that “issues” are in, and that the current fashion is for identity politics and moralising inserted into all sorts of cultural arenas. (And historical realism is out, in favour of creatively interpreting the past so that it serves modern political ideas.) This isn’t always the case (it wasn’t the case in the early 2000s, for example, when historical realism and moral ambiguity were fashionable in dramas). Look at how Shakespeare adaptations have changed over the last twenty years. In 2005 the fashion was for historical accuracy and uncovering original performance conditions, and attempting to produce something as close as possible to the original staging of the plays. Today, the current fashion is for reinterpreting the plays to reflect modern sensibilities, DEI and identity politics, gender and race-blind casting, etc.

These different styles go in and out of fashion, but it’s certainly true that didactic and political modes of cultural production are currently dominant. Partly that’s the media industries trying to appeal to a younger crowd, and also starting to be dominated at the creative end by young millennials/older Gen Z, who are very into this. The result, though, is right now pretty clumsy. I find there’s a lack of historical awareness in this, such that the moralising is very surface and often simplistic. It’s a bit tiresome to be lectured at about an Issue in dramatic form when you can remember the same Issue being done far better on the last go round (in the 90s, say, or the 60s. Not that I was alive for the 60s, but I’ve seen a fair old amount of 60s TV over the years).

Maybe I’ve just reached the age when you get irritated that the Yoof seem to think that everyone over the age of 30 has no idea about Issues, and needs to be told, very patronisingly and in dumbed-down narrative plots, that Backstreet Abortions Are Bad, or that Gay People Exist (I’m gay by the way, and I can probably do without yet another episode of a TV drama misrepresenting lesbian and gay history just because it fits into a current fashionable narrative).

But I’d put good money on things switching back in ten years or so. It’s just that art may be a bit crap until then 😂 (you could hardly pride me from my TV in my twenties, yet now I barely switch it on. It would be nice if it was good again in time for my retirement in twenty years please 🤣)

I am interested to know what you mean by “historical accuracy” or “historical realism” and wonder if those past representations of history are any more authentic than contemporary works. Probably not. How do you know they are accurate? Remember that even novels written at the time are performances and themselves served an agenda so the idea of authenticity or truth within any artistic representation is rather nebulous.

myveryownelectrickitten · 15/06/2023 03:10

Badabingbadaboomm · 15/06/2023 03:02

Have you considered that they aren’t agendas but relative topics in our modern culture? Abortion, anti racism and LGBT rights are very much at the forefront of issues in the western world. I get that you might want to escape all that but there are plenty of programs with no reference to any of those topics for you to watch. It seems like you probably don’t support those issues not being taboo anymore.

I just have to throw in, you don’t get points for always having a “classic novel” in your hand. Stop being so pretentious and go read 50 shades, better still, go watch it. There’s no agenda other than to possibly make you do a love honey shop after a few glasses of wine.

I’m afraid that 50 Shades glorifies problematic abusive relationships and toxic masculinity, not good at all, didn’t you get the memo? 😆

Those topics have been issues of the modern day for sixty years or more, but it’s only intermittently fashionable to shoehorn them into TV dramas in a moralising way, is what OP is getting at. We just happen to be in a period when identity politics in particular is obsessing the culture and the people making the culture. But there are also political topics that don’t make it into TV, and that’s telling too. Where are the dramas and TV documentaries with minor plotlines about climate crisis, class, poverty, homelessness or geopolitics, for example? Not much in evidence. Perhaps in ten years’ time, what are considered important issues of the day will be completely different.

WhyDontYouGoVegan · 15/06/2023 03:06

All media is propaganda, and the posters criticising you are its footsoldiers.

myveryownelectrickitten · 15/06/2023 03:03

*prise me from my tv! Not pride me 😂 I definitely don’t want to be prided 😉

Badabingbadaboomm · 15/06/2023 03:02

Have you considered that they aren’t agendas but relative topics in our modern culture? Abortion, anti racism and LGBT rights are very much at the forefront of issues in the western world. I get that you might want to escape all that but there are plenty of programs with no reference to any of those topics for you to watch. It seems like you probably don’t support those issues not being taboo anymore.

I just have to throw in, you don’t get points for always having a “classic novel” in your hand. Stop being so pretentious and go read 50 shades, better still, go watch it. There’s no agenda other than to possibly make you do a love honey shop after a few glasses of wine.

myveryownelectrickitten · 15/06/2023 02:59

DemiColon · 15/06/2023 02:10

Yes, it can be pretty hard to take.

There seem to be periods where film and television don't seem to have much commitment to telling real stories, they become very formulaic, or kind of a formal declaration of certain moral stances. It can be hard to pin down because of course stories have always had reflected ideas about things like ethics, but these deeply puritan moments are very bad for stories.

Call the Midwife has a lot of issues with this in later seasons. Like they had to brush over the realities of what the different people are likely to have actually thought. Another I find unwatchable now is Father Brown. I could buy him as a very live and let live kind of priest, most are really since their job puts them in contact with a lot of the worst moments people have. But he doesn't actually seem to believe anything that is actually Catholic, and what's more, you get the sense that the show is embarrassed by it.

Yes, this^^. OP isn’t wrong, and many of the responses are unwittingly demonstrating that, too. Anyone who works in media/scriptwriting/TV/the cultural sector knows that “issues” are in, and that the current fashion is for identity politics and moralising inserted into all sorts of cultural arenas. (And historical realism is out, in favour of creatively interpreting the past so that it serves modern political ideas.) This isn’t always the case (it wasn’t the case in the early 2000s, for example, when historical realism and moral ambiguity were fashionable in dramas). Look at how Shakespeare adaptations have changed over the last twenty years. In 2005 the fashion was for historical accuracy and uncovering original performance conditions, and attempting to produce something as close as possible to the original staging of the plays. Today, the current fashion is for reinterpreting the plays to reflect modern sensibilities, DEI and identity politics, gender and race-blind casting, etc.

These different styles go in and out of fashion, but it’s certainly true that didactic and political modes of cultural production are currently dominant. Partly that’s the media industries trying to appeal to a younger crowd, and also starting to be dominated at the creative end by young millennials/older Gen Z, who are very into this. The result, though, is right now pretty clumsy. I find there’s a lack of historical awareness in this, such that the moralising is very surface and often simplistic. It’s a bit tiresome to be lectured at about an Issue in dramatic form when you can remember the same Issue being done far better on the last go round (in the 90s, say, or the 60s. Not that I was alive for the 60s, but I’ve seen a fair old amount of 60s TV over the years).

Maybe I’ve just reached the age when you get irritated that the Yoof seem to think that everyone over the age of 30 has no idea about Issues, and needs to be told, very patronisingly and in dumbed-down narrative plots, that Backstreet Abortions Are Bad, or that Gay People Exist (I’m gay by the way, and I can probably do without yet another episode of a TV drama misrepresenting lesbian and gay history just because it fits into a current fashionable narrative).

But I’d put good money on things switching back in ten years or so. It’s just that art may be a bit crap until then 😂 (you could hardly pride me from my TV in my twenties, yet now I barely switch it on. It would be nice if it was good again in time for my retirement in twenty years please 🤣)

Victoria05 · 15/06/2023 02:39

RebulahConundrum · 14/06/2023 19:57

YABU tv has literally always had an agenda. Look at Bewitched, I Love Lucy, Star Trek, even Brookside.

What were the agendas of these shows? Star Trek had the 1st interracial kiss but what were the other shows promoting? Not being goady just genuinely wondering as have just got into watching clips of I ♡ Lucy on YouTube

aloris · 15/06/2023 02:34

chaosmaker · 15/06/2023 01:20

disneyfied anyway. The little mermaid - no name as far as I remember - died of a broken heart and became foam on the waves. Gotta love Hans Christian Anderson.
Proper fairy tales have all been sanitised and have lost the morals that were the point of them in the first place.

Yeah I seem to remember when I read the original sad story, thinking the moral of it was that you shouldn't try to venture out of your place in life.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 15/06/2023 02:28

Yes, I agree with you, there's a way to do it seamlessly, but a lot of things I've seen have it just shoehorned in.

DemiColon · 15/06/2023 02:10

Yes, it can be pretty hard to take.

There seem to be periods where film and television don't seem to have much commitment to telling real stories, they become very formulaic, or kind of a formal declaration of certain moral stances. It can be hard to pin down because of course stories have always had reflected ideas about things like ethics, but these deeply puritan moments are very bad for stories.

Call the Midwife has a lot of issues with this in later seasons. Like they had to brush over the realities of what the different people are likely to have actually thought. Another I find unwatchable now is Father Brown. I could buy him as a very live and let live kind of priest, most are really since their job puts them in contact with a lot of the worst moments people have. But he doesn't actually seem to believe anything that is actually Catholic, and what's more, you get the sense that the show is embarrassed by it.

chaosmaker · 15/06/2023 01:20

Buffypaws · 14/06/2023 21:53

Agree with you so much OP. I was literally singing poor unfortunate souls last weekend when my companion informed me that the line “it’s she who holds her tongue who gets a man” was removed from the little mermaid. I am an ardent feminist but I love Ursula’s evil misogyny.

why patronise audience by removing this? Is to because they are too stupid to understand that it’s a mean lady being mean and not real life? Are they worried the assumption is that the director agrees with the sentiment? Ffs.

disneyfied anyway. The little mermaid - no name as far as I remember - died of a broken heart and became foam on the waves. Gotta love Hans Christian Anderson.
Proper fairy tales have all been sanitised and have lost the morals that were the point of them in the first place.