Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be able to stand film and TV nowadays because it always has an agenda?

561 replies

mintlily · 14/06/2023 19:49

I've noticed that I can only bear to watch TV shows and films produced until roughly 2008.

It feels like everything nowadays has some kind of moral or political agenda. The writers are either trying to show off how enlightened they are, or condition you to accept their certain neo-Marxist world view. Virtually ALL dramas have an LGBT, feminist or anti-racist agenda, delivered with 0 subtlety or nuance. And the way it is done is so patronising and disrespectful to historical writers and figures - as if we 21st century people are the moral arbiters of history, and must overlay our more enlightened worldview on their bigoted work, which was surely produced in ignorance. It's also patronising to the intelligence of viewers, as if we need everything censored for our innocent eyes and can't make our own moral judgements. There is something puritanical and unartistic about it, like the Victorians censoring art to not corrupt the masses.

For example:

The new Little Mermaid deleting the line "men don't like women who blabber" from Ursula's songs. Ursula is a villain. We can cope with her being sexist, for goodness sake - we know that we're supposed to think she's wrong. The writer didn't need to fret that children would internalise the worldview of the villain.

Anne of Green Gables and her gay best friend. Why? This is not the genre to deal with LGBT issues. The author had no interest in this subject (as far as I'm aware).

Call the Midwife and it's pro-abortion stance. As if CATHOLIC MIDWIVES IN THE 1970s would have been pro-abortion?!

It's nothing to do with your actual views on these subjects. I just find that TV and film lacks the nuance and intelligence that it used to and I actually can't bear to watch any of it anymore, as it just feels so soulless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
DemiColon · 16/06/2023 01:16

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 15/06/2023 23:43

The first series was set in 1957.
The most recent shows (series 12 I believe?) were set in 1968.
It hasn't reached the 70s yet!

Personally, I've quite enjoyed Call the Midwife, and have appreciated the way it's covered all sorts of 'controversial' topics (everything from abortion to prostitution to racism to the unfolding Thalidomide scandal), and included a lot of nuance. and been based on real women's life experiences in that era/ in the East End.

There's not necessarily anything wrong with 'having an agenda' - sometimes it's with the intention of foregrounding and raising awareness of history that would otherwise be unknown, cultural perspectives that don't get mainstream coverage, social inequalities and issues etc...

Arguably almost every TV show/ film ever broadcast is the result of someone's 'agenda'. In many ways, the BBC's output in its early years can be seen as pretty unsubtle propaganda for the British State/ Empire/ Royal Family etc.

Many of the programmes I remember seeing as a child obviously reflected the mindset of the men who were making and commissioning them - their 'agendas' were obviously not progressive, their output was misogynist, homophobic, relied on racist/ ageist/ jingoistic stereotyping and was just as unhealthy for society as anything being produced right now. You seem to be viewing the past through some very rosy lenses.

I thought that CTM handled these things far better in the early seasons, maybe up through about season five. In a way it's a really good example of what people are frustrated by, because it's the same show that went from dealing with serious topics in a way that was extremely well done, to being, at best, bland and predictable, but often just really misrepresenting the period.

Partly I'm sure because the first two seasons were autobiography, talking about real people, but even after that, the show seemed to be very much trying to give a window on how people felt and thought during a very interesting historical period. They didn't all think the same way of course, but they seemed to try and authentically represent the kinds of views people really held. And they trusted the audience to be able to think about things from a different perspective than the ones they were used to, to accept that characters they liked might think in a very different way, and also that people could be good people and see things from a very different perspective.

The abortion issue is a really good example. The likelihood that all of the main characters, the doctor, the nuns, would all take what is essentially a modern view is really slim. There are a few who it is a real stretch to think they are as blase as portrayed. Many of the arguments they make in favour also seem very modern, while you hear very little about what have been widely held reasons for being against the change in laws at the time.

They've had to turn Sister Julienne into a kind of dithering idiot, quite unlike she used to be, because they don't seem to be able to write a conservative religious woman as an intelligent, kind person, even though that is clearly what she was at the beginning of the show.

It's absolutely a problem with the writing, but stems in large part from an inability on the part of the writers to think from multiple perspectives It's all very much baddies and goodies. It used to be said that good fiction writers tended not to take any one side much, because they were good at seeing things from multiple perspectives, but that doesn't seem to be the case any more.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 16/06/2023 00:31

Well, tbf woke people don't usually tend to be the sharpest tools in the box....

FeigningConcern · 16/06/2023 00:26

I completely agree OP. I am so sick of being preached at in practically everything you watch. And it's the same viewpoints, over and over again. I don't mind something nuanced and interesting and that makes you think on occasion, but this isn't that - it's the preaching of one way to think is the only way to think, over and over. And sometimes, you know, I just want some fucking entertainment, not a political message shoved down my throat. I turn stuff off now the minute it starts getting preachy - have no tolerance for it. So bored of being told what to think! When I was younger the "cool" thing to be was an individual, with your own mind, and often controversial viewpoints. I struggle to understand how we've got to the "groupthink" we seem to have ended up with today! It's depressing tbh.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 15/06/2023 23:43

mintlily · 14/06/2023 20:59

Pretty sure the episode about abortion was in the 60s or 70s by then. It went through the decades

The first series was set in 1957.
The most recent shows (series 12 I believe?) were set in 1968.
It hasn't reached the 70s yet!

Personally, I've quite enjoyed Call the Midwife, and have appreciated the way it's covered all sorts of 'controversial' topics (everything from abortion to prostitution to racism to the unfolding Thalidomide scandal), and included a lot of nuance. and been based on real women's life experiences in that era/ in the East End.

There's not necessarily anything wrong with 'having an agenda' - sometimes it's with the intention of foregrounding and raising awareness of history that would otherwise be unknown, cultural perspectives that don't get mainstream coverage, social inequalities and issues etc...

Arguably almost every TV show/ film ever broadcast is the result of someone's 'agenda'. In many ways, the BBC's output in its early years can be seen as pretty unsubtle propaganda for the British State/ Empire/ Royal Family etc.

Many of the programmes I remember seeing as a child obviously reflected the mindset of the men who were making and commissioning them - their 'agendas' were obviously not progressive, their output was misogynist, homophobic, relied on racist/ ageist/ jingoistic stereotyping and was just as unhealthy for society as anything being produced right now. You seem to be viewing the past through some very rosy lenses.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 15/06/2023 23:39

thebellagio · 15/06/2023 17:09

But it's often so patronisingly done. And usually preaching to the converted. Let's be real, no hardened racist is going to change their views after watching a sitcom

That’s the thing isn’t it @MovinGroovinBarbie

much is always written about the lack of diversity in Friends (never the same criticisms about Frazier or Will & Grace).

even the creators said if they made it today, they would never have an all-white cast. But if a sitcom was cast today you could almost guarantee of six characters, one would be white, one black, one gay, one trans or non binary rather than focusing on the chemistry between the actors.

now I do agree that friends does look problematic looking back. But it was the chemistry between the six cast that made it the show that it was.

a show like Brooklyn 99 did diversity excellently. Two Latina characters, black characters, white characters, different ages, but again, each character was beautifully written and when it covered tricky topics, it did it sensitively and in reference to the previous character development

Agree 100%.

DdraigGoch · 15/06/2023 23:08

Valeriekat · 15/06/2023 20:28

The Catholic Church's teaching on abortion couldn't be clearer! So she is a hypocrite sorry.

Or just an individual with her own views.

DdraigGoch · 15/06/2023 23:06

DemiColon · 15/06/2023 19:00

Yeah, it was a very believable scenario. It's common for people to have friends mainly of a similar race and class even now, and many people still live in neighbourhoods where one group is dominant, certainly in NYC. You could do the same kind of show where they were mostly black or Asian or whatever and it would still work.

The complaints just reminds me of the complaint about how white the Buckingham Palace balcony was following the Coronation. Er yeah, people from the same family usually do look alike...

phoenixrosehere · 15/06/2023 22:25

DemiColon · 15/06/2023 19:00

Yeah, it was a very believable scenario. It's common for people to have friends mainly of a similar race and class even now, and many people still live in neighbourhoods where one group is dominant, certainly in NYC. You could do the same kind of show where they were mostly black or Asian or whatever and it would still work.

You could do the same kind of show where they were mostly black or Asian or whatever and it would still work.

There was the same kind of show in the US with mostly Black people and it was called Living Single (1993) about 20-something Black people living in a brownstone in Brooklyn. It has been said that its Living Single’s success, at the time, is the reason Friends (1994) was green-lighted. I remember watching both and the biggest things that stood out to me was that with the Black cast you had women of different sizes where as with the white cast the women were all around the same body type.

QueenOfHiraeth · 15/06/2023 22:14

MissTrip82 · 14/06/2023 23:24

Surely not?

You think people who were leaning towards being non-hostile to refugees might change their thinking because an episode of Silent Witness is poorly done?

Surely nobody is that stupid.

No, I don't mean people would be overtly less tolerant to refugees after watching a shit TV show!
I phrased it badly but I meant that, if programmes are done well, people might be more likely to watch things outside of their comfort zone and learn from it whereas, if done badly, people are maybe less likely to take chances and watch things that challenge their views.
Ultimately though, I guess a narrow world view may lead to less tolerance

TheHandmaiden · 15/06/2023 22:09

@mintlily - yes. It starts to strip away what was the actual attitude.

So to with feminism or homosexuality. I find it patronising when it's written like this, as if people were openly supportive. That didn't happen very often.

It wasn't because people had a chat at a BBQ. It's like a spot of soft soap to make people feel better.

JudgeJ · 15/06/2023 21:54

leilani83 · 15/06/2023 11:56

people of colour are overrepresented on TV = complaining

Whereas ' white people are overrepresented on TV' is a perfectly acceptable view, not complaining at all. Thus spake the MN hyocrites, it's only wrong if I disagree with it!

mbosnz · 15/06/2023 21:52

I think that many women who are midwives are pragmatists. They're on the pointy end of shit. It's her God who will judge her - and it sounds like she was unto her ownself, true.

JudgeJ · 15/06/2023 21:46

MarkWithaC · 15/06/2023 14:49

😆

She sounds a bit like my late MIL, we were watching a Kevin Costner film when the girls were in their teens and he, KC, was getting very very close to a woman in the back of a limo going round Washington DC at night, MIL piped up Oh Mummy, lets watch something else, the girls were making frantic Press record gestures, predated V boxes etc. No Way Out was the film, not many films have made me gasp at the end.

MasterBeth · 15/06/2023 21:38

Hmm.

Lucky the Daily Telegraph doesn't have "an agenda".

hopeishere · 15/06/2023 20:45

Well she's no longer with us @Valeriekat so it's a moot point. I didn't say she was a "good" catholic!

mintlily · 15/06/2023 20:33

Interestingly there was actually an article in the Telegraph about this today. Not sure if all can read it because of the paywall https://www.telegraph.co.uk/tv/0/todays-television-dramas-are-betraying-20th-century-history/

I think it articulated what I'm trying to say quite well here:
"In the recent BBC One drama Ten Pound Poms, Annie and Terry Roberts, two new migrants from Britain to Australia, have been invited to a barbecue. Their host is an unreconstructed Antipodean called Dean, whose opinions on his country’s indigenous people would make John Tyndall blush. Annie, perhaps emboldened by the beer, stands up to him. “They’re just people,” she says. “And they were here long before you were.”

Quite right, and hopefully the viewers at home would be cheering Annie on. Except that this scene just didn’t ring true.
Ten Pound Poms is set in the 1950s but Annie’s reaction felt oddly 21st century. Of course, many in that generation found racism abhorrent, but few would have articulated their horror in such a way. This is becoming more and more of a problem with period dramas about the 20th century. As we move further from the time in which they are set, so there will be fewer who can offer authentic insight into the way we were. "

Today’s television dramas are betraying 20th-century history

The BBC’s Ten Pound Poms is the latest series to distort the past. We need more unflinchingly truthful shows like Mad Men

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/tv/0/todays-television-dramas-are-betraying-20th-century-history

OP posts:
Valeriekat · 15/06/2023 20:31

Ooops pro choice or Catholic I meant.

Valeriekat · 15/06/2023 20:31

You can be pro choice or you can be pro abortion but you can't be both.
I don't know why people cling to their Catholicism.

aloris · 15/06/2023 20:28

MarkWithaC · 15/06/2023 09:23

But to a person in, say, the sixteenth century, a person in a play of that century would have talked like a ’modern person’.

I'm still working my way through the thread and wanted to comment on this one. I agree that talking like modern people can be done well and usefully. It really depends how it's done. I don't think it's about the slang that is used, it's more about whether you are modernising how people back then would have thought, and whether that changes the meaning of the story. Sometimes, keeping things the way they were back in "the olde days" actually distracts from what the story is trying to do, because the story is not about that specific thing.

Valeriekat · 15/06/2023 20:28

hopeishere · 15/06/2023 08:37

My mum was a catholic midwife - call the midwife is essentially her job she went around delivering babies in people homes. She was the most pro-choice person I know!!!

The Catholic Church's teaching on abortion couldn't be clearer! So she is a hypocrite sorry.

Fairislefandango · 15/06/2023 20:20

I totally agree, OP. It's not the political views themselves that are the problem, it's the way they are presented. It feels like the viewer is being scolded or schooled in right-think, rather than being left to form their own opinions. And it seems that a lot of (particularly younger) viewers want to be shielded from views they disagree with, and find it hard to deal with ambiguous characters with complex motives. It's so childish! Doctor Who (the Jodie Whittaker series) was the worst for this.

Fisharejumping · 15/06/2023 20:06

LaBefana · 15/06/2023 08:34

What I really hate is period dramas where they make the characters use modern turns of phrase, and 'simplify' things for Generations X Y and Z. Like people in World War II saying 'run that past the General'.

I don't see what's wrong with that. It's just using the language of the present day. There is nothing to be gained from trying to emulate the language of the past because you could never be 100% accurate. So much language is lost to time. It's like when I see films set in the 80s now I think "nobody spoke like that" Much better for younger writers to write "in their own tongue" as it were.

Triptoqueen · 15/06/2023 19:59

I would guess that prime time has ads with many minority groups featuring - watch in the afternoon and it's not the case imv.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 15/06/2023 19:57

Doctor Who had a series where it seemed like each episode had been storyboarded as "X is bad", and they'd just swap in littering/racism/giant retail conglomerates. They're all perfectly good ideas for episodes, but they were so heavy handed.

Re the advertising, I'm guessing it's because one black parent, one white parent, and obviously mixed race children covers three different skin colours all in one go. I agree it isn't that representative of all areas though — around me there are a lot more Asian (both east and south) and Jewish families than black ones.

MasterBeth · 15/06/2023 19:50

MovinGroovinBarbie · 15/06/2023 08:58

I agree. It's like how every furniture advert you see seems to have an interracial couple. No issue with it but it's not representative of the actual demographics of our society.

I think it'd make more sense to represent different demographics in line with their prevalence in society rather than going for absolute equal representation.

  1. It’s interesting that that’s how it seems to you, because every furniture ad doesn’t have a mixed heritage couple, as a quick Google shows (below).

So, your perception is not reality. Where do you get your data from when you categorically state that the racial mix on TV is not representative of the UK. Did you do a survey? What channels and programmes did it cover? Do you watch every show and every ad on TV, or is your perception skewed by what you watch and your own biases (we all have biases).

https://equinox-tv.co.uk/project/sofa-store/
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LXhEMdmBSbo
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=T_51CzomE2I
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6mgXwfz1-ew
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6mgXwfz1-ew

  1. There is no central clique of furniture advertisers who get together to decide on the precise racial mix in their combined advertising output. So, even if there were a mixed heritage couple in every TV ad, it would be the result of a series of decisions by individual brands,

So, Oak Furnitureland have decided to have a mixed heritage family in their latest TV ad.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AQ8FALPEpP8&list=PL0T73dtKaPHfzoyqAZIru4wIY8DwD9bIj&index=1&pp=iAQB

But their previous campaign featured a white couple and two white sales staff. Are we supposed to aggregate the number of ethnicities over time, or by advert, or what? There is, after all, a long history of huge under-representation of people of colour in TV and advertising.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QYgry04ZXpc

  1. If you have “no issue with it”, why are we having this conversation?

IKEA – Show Off Your Savvy - TV Advert 60 #WonderfulEveryday

It’s time to show off your savvy. These days it's not all about who has the biggest house with the most expensive furniture. No, these days the real bragging...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=T_51CzomE2I

Swipe left for the next trending thread