Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we have a national ‘no spend August’ to help lower inflation?

145 replies

ALady78 · 14/06/2023 19:33

Like many people I’m really concerned about high interest rates. We’re actually still in a fixed rate mortgage deal until early 2025 so I was hoping things would calm down by then. But now they’re saying interest rates will have to go higher than previously thought and I’m already panicking about what we’re going to do.

So if the idea behind higher interest rates is to curb spending then why haven’t they clearly said this? I’ve got this from the Bank of England website today:

‘Higher interest rates will make sure inflation comes down by affecting spending habits in the UK.

This happens most directly if you have a mortgage or you are paying back a loan.

Either way, you may have to spend more on these things. And that means you will have less to spend on other things that are captured in theConsumer Price Index (CPI) measure of inflation. This is the measure of inflation that the Government asks us to target.

Food, housing, transport, and household bills are everyday essentials. You can’t choose not to spend on those. But you may put off buying other things.

Also, higher interest rates may mean you are less likely to want to take out a new loan to buy things unless you need to.’

If this is the case shouldn’t we all stop spending immediately on things which aren’t essential? No new household items, takeaway’s, days out, clothes etc. I’ve carried on as normal at the moment because we can, but I would stop if it would help. I mean, I know they always say ‘interest rates have been increased to curb spending’ but then why doesn’t Rishi hold a press conference and CLEARLY request us to stop buying ‘stuff’ if that’s what they need us to do?

Is the solution for us all just to stay in and buy only basic food for the rest of the summer?
But then won’t people who make or provide ‘non essentials’ lose their jobs if we stop so how does that help?

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 15/06/2023 13:20

A modern consumer act to stop rip-offs could lower inflation. No more increases in water bills until there is proper action against sewage dumping. No more oil and energy company large profits without a real windfall tax.

StormShadow · 15/06/2023 13:12

verdantverdure · 15/06/2023 12:21

Especially as food prices will be going up more once the Tories implement their Brexit border checks.

That'll be exciting.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 15/06/2023 12:52

Interests rates don't just impact consumer spending, and it's debatable whether reducing domestic spending will have much impact on UK inflation anyway as much of the inflationary pressures are non-domestic. Interest rates also impact the value of the pound and generally the higher the interest rate the stronger the pound is. So raise interest rates, the pound strengthens and imports cost less. The Bank of England also doesn't have the luxury of operating in a vacuum. If other major economies change their interest rates we generally have to as well just to maintain the status quo.

Tigofigo · 15/06/2023 12:49

SomethingNastyInTheGenePool · 14/06/2023 19:35

That would lead swiftly to National Insolvency September.

😂

frugalita · 15/06/2023 12:44

OP, I asked this before under the Cost of Living topic (Money section). I'm also on the side of low spend but not no spend, purely because I've always been frugal.

The problem is the UK population is addicted to spending and find it hard to stop, unless it was not possible to spend like during Covid lockdowns or during the wars. Life is short, they say. Kids grow up too quickly, they say.

And we need the economy to grow too.

verdantverdure · 15/06/2023 12:35

My husband was absolutely gobsmacked to find out recently that our neighbours are going car less for the foreseeable.

Theirs needs some work and an MOT and instead they have decided to sell it or scrap it I'm not sure which and do without for a while.

Like us their mortgage has gone up several hundred pounds a month, their childcare bill has gone up, the food bill is up, their energy bill is up, their council tax is up,

We're in quite a well off area so it's quite surprising to hear someone say they've decided not to chuck their savings at car repairs, or add a new car payment to their monthly outgoings.

And the Tories have lost a couple of lifelong voters.

verdantverdure · 15/06/2023 12:27

www.ft.com/content/3b3ec1be-1dfe-40fd-b8c9-a29314105118

Should we have a national ‘no spend August’ to help lower inflation?
ChristinaXYZ · 15/06/2023 12:27

SarahAndQuack · 14/06/2023 21:59

OP, they're not hoping you stop spending. They're hoping you magically create a situation where you can afford to spend. This is pretty stupid, which is why there is so much Tory rhetoric pretending that 'the poor' (ie., anyone not coasting along happily in the current financial situation) have only themselves to blame. They would like you to believe that the crisis is caused by feckless poor people who'd have pots of money to invest sensibly, if only they weren't so feckless. It isn't the case.

TL/DR: they don't want you to stop spending; they want you to work an 80-hour week so you can afford to keep spending.

That take is nearly as weird as OP's original suggestion.

Inflation happens for many many reasons and some of our chickens are coming home to roost - QE, spending during the pandemic, getting used to low interest rtes, no incentive to save, a very long issue with UK productivity, wage demands, early retirement, workers not being able to work because of health issues and the NHS backlogs, labour shortages (nothing to do with Brexit - we are importing more foreign workers just from a greater range of countries), the war in Ukraine and cutting trading with Russia, OPEC, ... the list goes on and on.

verdantverdure · 15/06/2023 12:21

BitOutOfPractice · 15/06/2023 12:08

Inflation is mainly being driven by food and fuel prices so good luck with this plan.

Especially as food prices will be going up more once the Tories implement their Brexit border checks.

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/06/2023 12:19

Sorry, won’t work for us.

I think it’s all more complicated than that.

verdantverdure · 15/06/2023 12:17

Our "world beating" energy billls are a big driver of inflation.

Expensive energy adds to the cost of pretty much everything.

StormShadow · 15/06/2023 12:14

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 15/06/2023 12:06

I don’t understand all the sarcastic comments either. OP makes some good points :’if we all stopped spending on credit (credit cards, buying car on finance etc) then the rates would stop increasing.
Just live within your means and you will be better off overall, what is the issue with that??

I think it's because stop buying things that aren't essential and stop using credit/live within your means are two very different arguments, and OP said she wanted us to do the first. Many of us are buying things that aren't essential, that we can afford and that other people's livelihoods depend on.

BitOutOfPractice · 15/06/2023 12:14

It wasn’t the Governor @BustPipes, it was some other highly paid out-of-touch BOE wanker. There’s many to choose from. This particular one is paid £180k pa if I recall correctly 🙄

PoppedNotFried · 15/06/2023 12:11

BitOutOfPractice · 15/06/2023 12:08

Inflation is mainly being driven by food and fuel prices so good luck with this plan.

This.

Also, aren’t the food items most affected by inflation the basic stuff - bread, pasta, baked beans, etc.

BitOutOfPractice · 15/06/2023 12:08

Inflation is mainly being driven by food and fuel prices so good luck with this plan.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 15/06/2023 12:06

I don’t understand all the sarcastic comments either. OP makes some good points :’if we all stopped spending on credit (credit cards, buying car on finance etc) then the rates would stop increasing.
Just live within your means and you will be better off overall, what is the issue with that??

StormShadow · 15/06/2023 11:32

BustPipes · 14/06/2023 23:04

The governor of the B o E said we should all just get used to being poor.

He's a massive arsehole. If you have any cake, and he's around, don't let him have any.

Mmm, I just don't fancy that to be honest.

ThankmelaterOkay · 15/06/2023 10:28

Interest rates are not going to suddenly drop. They may drop slowly from 2024, but it may well be that 2/5 year fixes in Q4 2024, Q1 2025 could still be >5%. And beyond that 3/4% fixed rates are likely to be as good as it gets, maybe for the length of your mortgage. I would be thankful that I’d got on the ladder, had >5 years of low rates, and adjust to the new normal. You’ve got 18 months to increase your incomings or decrease your outgoings.

SunnyEgg · 15/06/2023 10:06

This is supply side inflation though. You’d be better off hoping the situation in Ukraine improves

For them and everyone

Food prices will be impacted again by recent events

zingally · 15/06/2023 10:03

Pointless.

Muddlingthroughthissocalledlife · 15/06/2023 09:07

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/06/2023 08:50

Have woken up this morning with extra existential dread as I contemplate likely personal bankruptcy and homelessness as a struggling small business owner. But hey ho, it's probably because I'm not vibrating at a high enough level and nothing to do with the absolute clusterfuck that is current geo-politics and an economy skewed to funnel more and more money to fewer and fewer people.

I admit I'm too thick to get my head around it all but the whole system is nuts.

Money is supposed to be a tool to make exchange of goods and services easier, right? Because not everyone can carry a bag of goats around and not everyone would find a goat helpful.

How the hell has this become the nightmare that it is?

Money is something we constructed, and that could be controlled in a fairer system if people in power weren't so greedy. There just isn't the will to do it.

This thing about not printing money because it drives prices up etc is because that's how the system is designed - so it could be changed surely?

All the time we hear about how the "market" dictates it all. The stock market is essentially gambling.

Rigging of the markets is entirely plausible.

With the little understanding I have, factor in the inevitable changes that technological advances are going to make to everything and faster than we realise, it's going to be increasingly difficult to keep up if you don't already have money.

Money buys choice and certain freedoms. And widgets. Right now the choices are simply food, shelter and energy for those with the least money. No fun for you. You may be able to afford the bread but you'll only get the circus if you download this app.

It's all doing my head in. The lunatics appear to be running the asylum.

I get that progress is inevitable but I'm not sure as a species we're geared up for the speed of it now. People always say oh this has happened before, things will get better, it will sort itself out, but at what cost? It looks to me as though the economy is structured to benefit the few over the many, but why? Is it ideological?

I just want to be able to pay my bills and perhaps go to the pub once or twice a week. Maybe buy a new frock from the charity shop occasionally because sustainability etc. And for my community to avoid implosion. Why is that too much to ask?

In order to keep myself I sell widgets. I have to pay for the privilege to do so before I even get to pay myself. You can bleat on about hard work etc but it isn't currently paying. I can't meet my obligations. I can't afford to downsize. I'm fucked, unless I take 200.00 a day consistently in my shop. That's all I need. It hasn't happened for months. Debt is catching up with me.

So you'll tell me to wind up my business. Okay, off I trot into the labour market, 54, widowed 18 months ago. Qualified for care work, possibly as I've spent most of my life raising children and caring for elderly relatives. Yes, my choice - but also not really. Because I love my family. And I'll have to claim Universal Credit. So I'll be another part of the problem that is a fucked system.

Sorry for the disjointed rant.

Better get my big girl pants on, seize the day and manifest something positive.....

Good luck and solidarity to anyone else struggling to understand this madness.

I'm going to add to this madness

If you made this rant into a tiktok it would go viral and you could make some money out of your misery.

The world is 🤪

onefinemess · 15/06/2023 09:02

Current Inflation is caused factors outside of the UK, this is why raising rates to they to bring it down is just fucking stupid.

You not being able to afford to pay your mortgage isn't going to convince the middle East to lower the cost of it's oil. Or tomato farmers in Spain to lower their costs, or olive oil producers in Italy to lower their prices.

UK inflation is caused by extra service costs which MUST be passed on the the consumers, therefore prices are increasing. People are asking for wage increases to put food on the table but these increases are half of the rate of inflation so blaming greedy workers is passing the buck.

The real reason we increased rates is because it makes MASSIVE profits for the banks. The controllers of which are all Tory Party doners or members of the "Old Boys Club".

It's a fucking sick game, played by the elite, who never have to worry about money.

Inflation will only come down when other countries lower their costs.

Tinkerbyebye · 15/06/2023 08:53

People will stop spending as they won’t be able to borrow to buy the big ticket stuff, will no longer buy cars on PCP etc etc

they will continue to buy smaller stuff such as clothes etc but in a more infrequent basis

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/06/2023 08:50

Have woken up this morning with extra existential dread as I contemplate likely personal bankruptcy and homelessness as a struggling small business owner. But hey ho, it's probably because I'm not vibrating at a high enough level and nothing to do with the absolute clusterfuck that is current geo-politics and an economy skewed to funnel more and more money to fewer and fewer people.

I admit I'm too thick to get my head around it all but the whole system is nuts.

Money is supposed to be a tool to make exchange of goods and services easier, right? Because not everyone can carry a bag of goats around and not everyone would find a goat helpful.

How the hell has this become the nightmare that it is?

Money is something we constructed, and that could be controlled in a fairer system if people in power weren't so greedy. There just isn't the will to do it.

This thing about not printing money because it drives prices up etc is because that's how the system is designed - so it could be changed surely?

All the time we hear about how the "market" dictates it all. The stock market is essentially gambling.

Rigging of the markets is entirely plausible.

With the little understanding I have, factor in the inevitable changes that technological advances are going to make to everything and faster than we realise, it's going to be increasingly difficult to keep up if you don't already have money.

Money buys choice and certain freedoms. And widgets. Right now the choices are simply food, shelter and energy for those with the least money. No fun for you. You may be able to afford the bread but you'll only get the circus if you download this app.

It's all doing my head in. The lunatics appear to be running the asylum.

I get that progress is inevitable but I'm not sure as a species we're geared up for the speed of it now. People always say oh this has happened before, things will get better, it will sort itself out, but at what cost? It looks to me as though the economy is structured to benefit the few over the many, but why? Is it ideological?

I just want to be able to pay my bills and perhaps go to the pub once or twice a week. Maybe buy a new frock from the charity shop occasionally because sustainability etc. And for my community to avoid implosion. Why is that too much to ask?

In order to keep myself I sell widgets. I have to pay for the privilege to do so before I even get to pay myself. You can bleat on about hard work etc but it isn't currently paying. I can't meet my obligations. I can't afford to downsize. I'm fucked, unless I take 200.00 a day consistently in my shop. That's all I need. It hasn't happened for months. Debt is catching up with me.

So you'll tell me to wind up my business. Okay, off I trot into the labour market, 54, widowed 18 months ago. Qualified for care work, possibly as I've spent most of my life raising children and caring for elderly relatives. Yes, my choice - but also not really. Because I love my family. And I'll have to claim Universal Credit. So I'll be another part of the problem that is a fucked system.

Sorry for the disjointed rant.

Better get my big girl pants on, seize the day and manifest something positive.....

Good luck and solidarity to anyone else struggling to understand this madness.

ALady78 · 15/06/2023 08:49

ALady78
Because you live beyond your means you now want everyone else to cut back in order for you to be able to save a bit of money ?

Eh where have you got this from? I was giving myself as an example but I’m not the only one affected. At least I’m asking the question about whether the public can do anything to help stabilise things. After all we’re the ones buying, spending, saving etc. The policies are made to influence OUR behaviour.

LinMortisanass
If Ive read your OP correctly, you want Rishi to hold a press conference to say "@ALady78 's fixed rate mortgage runs out in 2025, so you must all stop shopping in August".

🙄
So is everyone else OK then and I’m the only one concerned about this? Right OK.

Well I give up. If we struggle a lot we can move in with PIL or my parents - who both have large detached houses with mortgages paid off. We won’t be homeless.

OP posts: