Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 09:19

PurpleBugz · 14/06/2023 08:38

We are desperate for more Forster carers. If people are able to they really should consider it.

And don't vote Tory

Thing is we see on here all the time about people not being able to even take in their neglected nieces and nephews because of work patterns, size of house, money etc... How can we expect people to become foster carers when most people wouldn't qualify with their existing work patterns and housing situations? The whole system is a mess

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 09:13

Beachbreak2411 · 14/06/2023 08:58

This is horrendous! Poor poor little boy! He deserved so much better!!! Social services are shit. They took my daughter off me on the say so of only my parents. I had a very long fight to get her back and eventually an admission that they over reacted.

So social services are s for taking kids off people and also s for not taking kids off people? Make it make sense

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 09:11

LifeIsPainHighness · 14/06/2023 08:57

No, and it’s ridiculous to suggest that’s the only way to help. But I do my bit - I report concerns, I don’t vote Tory, I get involved in lobbying MPs etc.

There are incompetent SWs, the same way there are incompetent nurses, doctors etc - and for some reason we can’t say a bad word about SWs the way we can others. Which is a huge part of the problem IME.

But there are only ever bad words said about child social workers.

Seriously, where are all the threads applauding child social workers? Or posters saying they had a good experience with CYPSS involvement?

Just on this thread you've got posters saying they're lazy, incompetent, don't care and not doing enough to remove children and other posters saying their children were removed because of incompetent SWs overreaching.

No SW or ex-SW here are saying every SW is brilliant or doing a stellar job, they're just trying to explain the complexities of the law, and the ridiculous caseloads, stressors and pressures child SW are under.

It is one of the most thankless jobs there is.

Whiskyinajar · 14/06/2023 09:08

Ffswhatsthepoint · 14/06/2023 00:04

Then I'm sure the next murdered child will sleep soundly in their grave knowing that.

It would be better if there were more social workers. You can respond to reasoned posts with emotive snippy comments but it changes nothing.

We need to invest so much more on social care. A SW with 100 children and young people on their caseload is a disgrace.

Instead of asking why they missed this child you should be asking why the service is underfunded to the extent these cases happen.

It's not SW who remove children, that only happens with an order from the court and a SW needs masses of evidence to get this. Evidence which will be missed if that SW is juggling a caseload of over 100 cases.

Frankly I am amazed that we don't get more cases like this

Time we invested more money, acknowledged the shit job SW's have and offer support if we see families struggling.

I'm not a SW by the way but I do come across them on a very regular basis, their workload is impossible and when it remains that way we will get more cases like this.

laydownsally · 14/06/2023 09:04

The video of him screaming to be let back inside his house made my blood run cold. Poor poor boy.

XNC · 14/06/2023 09:04

I was saying exactly the same to DP this morning. Including the unjustified personal guilt.

I called the police a few months a go after witnessing this boy being hit repeatedly over the head by his step "father". We were in a pub garden and this man was clearly a bully. Got a huge kick out of intimidating him. He then asked the boys mum if he could properly punish him and the grin that came over his face when she agreed was beyond disturbing. He then started dragging him around and smacking him across the head. I couldn't stand it. I called the police who said it would be a priority response, so we left after that. I hope to goodness that the scum bag was charged and subsequently not involved with this family any more, but I suspect even if that was the case, the mum would have moved on to another evil bastard.

I often wonder what happened and even worry that I made things worse.

This CAN NOT keep happening.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 09:02

LifeIsPainHighness · 14/06/2023 08:57

No, and it’s ridiculous to suggest that’s the only way to help. But I do my bit - I report concerns, I don’t vote Tory, I get involved in lobbying MPs etc.

There are incompetent SWs, the same way there are incompetent nurses, doctors etc - and for some reason we can’t say a bad word about SWs the way we can others. Which is a huge part of the problem IME.

of course you can! As a social work manager I've dealt with my fair share of incompetent social workers and it feels like someone else share too sometimes it would be insane to eat there aren't any! However that's not what people on this thread are saying. 1% of social workers are competent, we are ALL lazy, incompetent, useless etc...that's just unfair and incorrect and we have the right to respond to that.
it's possible Alfie's social worker was incompetent. However they also had a manager who should have had oversight and senior managers who are also tasked with knowing about high risk/edge of care children and who are also responsible. Unless you have a social worker who is actively lying about visiting children and colluding with parents (and of course that happens too! Rarely but it does) then there are many people who were responsible for Alfie's care. Not just one social worker.

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 09:02

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 08:47

I don't believe this happened.

Me neither.

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 09:02

KayohB · 14/06/2023 08:14

For most people, this is beyond our understanding, it is hard to imagine how anyone could hurt another human being, let alone a defenceless child that should be under their care. I have worked with social workers too and to blame them is completely cruel and unfair, this poor child was killed by evil people, not social
workers, I don’t have the facts of the case but I’d say he was also let down by his wider family.

To assume that a systematically flawed and understaffed system can easily take a child away from their legal parents is just not correct. I have seen social workers in tears after a court has ordered a child in foster care be returned to their birth parents, completely contrary to the recommendations of the social care team.

Do people realise that there aren’t children’s homes anymore, where do you imagine a child is placed after they are finally removed from an unsafe environment? If even 1% of people disgusted and horrified by this looked into becoming foster carers, there might be more options available.

I know we can’t all open our homes to another child but honestly, some people commenting here must be able to and we’re all so quick to be horrified and rightly so, this is incredibly and unbearably upsetting. The fact is, the system is flawed, even if it were overhauled it would take a generation to improve, we know that’s not going to happen to if anyone can become part of the solution, why not consider becoming a foster carer.

I know some social workers just aren’t good at their jobs but a lot
of them literally destroy their own mental health trying to make any change they can in a world that constantly disappoints us all.

RIP Alfie, I’m so sorry that we couldn’t protect you x

Everyone always wants it to be someone else's responsibility while they sit at home complaining that 'more should have been done'.

I think people think SW can just remove children at a whim when they can't. And issues of disproportionately, trauma of the parents, poverty, culture etc are all part of the assessment and have to be taken into consideration.

And I've seen the numerous posts from MNetters not wanting to live near a drug clinic, hostels, PRU and no doubt wouldn't want to live near one of these mythical children's homes that should be built using money from God knows where.

So long as they don't have to be near the abused, neglected, addicted, homeless, criminals etc but can make demands that someone somewhere do more. But somewhere else...not near me or the other 'decent' people 🤔

Beachbreak2411 · 14/06/2023 08:58

This is horrendous! Poor poor little boy! He deserved so much better!!! Social services are shit. They took my daughter off me on the say so of only my parents. I had a very long fight to get her back and eventually an admission that they over reacted.

LifeIsPainHighness · 14/06/2023 08:57

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 08:34

@LifeIsPainHighness

i take it you will be training to become a social worker then? Given you know so much better than the existing ones?

No, and it’s ridiculous to suggest that’s the only way to help. But I do my bit - I report concerns, I don’t vote Tory, I get involved in lobbying MPs etc.

There are incompetent SWs, the same way there are incompetent nurses, doctors etc - and for some reason we can’t say a bad word about SWs the way we can others. Which is a huge part of the problem IME.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 08:55

So to be clear here, any concerns expressed about the fact that in this specific case some opportunities missed to help this little boy cannot be voiced unless the individual decides to train to be a social worker?

You can express any concerns you like, but labelling all social workers as incompetent, lazy, deserving of jail time etc is unfair if you have no concept of what the job entails. I’d also suggest that folk don’t actually know of opportunities missed without being involved in the case - because most folk have no idea the amount of hoops that needs to be jumped through - or the time that can take - to put the most basic of supports in place, much less to remove a child. And that’s assuming the parents are willing to engage with you.

It’s very easy to read a media report and jump on the “social work are shite” bandwagon. We know folk think we’re shite, we hear it all the time, from everyone. We also know those same people for the most part could never cope with what we have to deal with daily.

So feel free to comment, but if you think you could do it better by all means come and have a go.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 08:47

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 14/06/2023 08:11

I reported my neighbour and the bloke I spoke with at SS laughed and said 'what do you expect us to do? We don't actually VISIT people' then started laughing again. He also denied there was any SS involvement which was a lie as I knew for a fact there was.
They're an absolute joke.

I don't believe this happened.

Bagpuss2022 · 14/06/2023 08:47

Some people are just evil imagine being those neighbours/teachers and knowing your outcry was not listened to.
my children had a SW and were on a CPP due to my mental health but as we are middle class with a clean home and they did well at school nearly every statutory visit was late/missed underfunding and a government that only seem to care for the richest means poor children are suffering right now the fact that so many people reported issues and he still was left at home sickens me.
I had social workers growing up I was still SA by two males in parental roles for over half my childhood and it seems things haven’t changed in 40 years

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 08:46

if people are able

Not many are, are they?

Zebedee55 · 14/06/2023 08:45

I worked for a social services dept under the last Labour government.

There were just as many scandals then - "lessons were learned" then, and yet, the same thing happened again.🙄

There has been a shortage of social workers for many years. Because of pay, and because, a lot of the time, it's a thankless job.

PurpleBugz · 14/06/2023 08:38

We are desperate for more Forster carers. If people are able to they really should consider it.

And don't vote Tory

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 08:36

So to be clear here, any concerns expressed about the fact that in this specific case some opportunities missed to help this little boy cannot be voiced unless the individual decides to train to be a social worker?

Is that really what passes for an acceptable viewpoint here?

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 08:34

@LifeIsPainHighness

i take it you will be training to become a social worker then? Given you know so much better than the existing ones?

LifeIsPainHighness · 14/06/2023 08:25

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 07:38

I’m wary of being deleted again but I really don’t think it’s fair at all to be point scoring on a thread like this.

It is so wrong to suggest that if you personally are unable to do anything (beyond general decent behaviour such as reporting abuse) that you have contributed in some way to tragedies like this. How is it again a man murders a child and women are the ones berated for ‘not doing enough.’

Yes exactly. The overly defensive and aggressive manner is one I’ve often found with social workers - who blame everyone and everything without an iota of self reflection.

Sausagedogmum · 14/06/2023 08:24

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2023 02:31

As someone who used to have a caseload of 10s of people who this could happen to, who was overworked, underpaid, blamed and pilloried for existing, and everyone knew better than me how to do my job... I left.

People think SWs have a caseload of maybe 20, with one person where this could happen. It's more like 100, where in 50 cases this could happen. There are NO easy cases. SWs aren't psychic, they have to assess, listen to unreliable witnesses who all lie, knowing that removing a child will definitely fuck their whole life up. Definitely.

SWs save lives every day but it is completely invisible. They can't talk about it and no one knows.

If you think SWs are thick (from this thread), incompetent (from everywhere) and lazy and heartless, retrain. Do it yourself. Quickly while you know everything. Make sure to never make a mistake, never miss anything, know who is lying, know who is telling the truth and finish all your work while there's still time to sleep and eat.

Or:

  1. Don't vote Tory
  2. Be important in the life of a child
  3. Volunteer
  4. Welcome the DC who are smelly, poorly behaved and violent to your homes
  5. Actually care about your neighbours
  6. Foster
  7. Don't vote Tory

I know it's easier to blame the people who do the hard work while you're sitting on your arse, but the fact is violent abuse happens every day. It's constant. You just don't have to see it every day. SWs do, poor bastards.

Well said!

I say this as someone who is a foster carer and is training to be a social worker

loislovesstewie · 14/06/2023 08:20

@BerriesPineCones I agree, it detracts from the real issues. Underfunding, trying to control the economy by cuts in public spending and boasting about it. What used to make me seethe with anger was getting a letter from the MP asking, for example, why MrA hadn't been housed. I wish I could have given a piece of my mind, I used to point out that there is a shortage of social housing but knew they didn't care.

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 08:19

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 14/06/2023 08:11

I reported my neighbour and the bloke I spoke with at SS laughed and said 'what do you expect us to do? We don't actually VISIT people' then started laughing again. He also denied there was any SS involvement which was a lie as I knew for a fact there was.
They're an absolute joke.

Firstly not every social worker does visit. Some teams just triage and pass the referral on the to right department.

secondly do you honestly expect people to give out confidential information about families to random members of the public?

lastly, if the system is such a “joke”, when are you training to take the job on and show us all how it should be done?

BerriesPineCones · 14/06/2023 08:15

loislovesstewie · 14/06/2023 08:11

The whole of local government is chronically underfunded. I was only a homeless officer but I had far too many cases, my phone didn't stop ringing all day. The rules said that I had to answer that phone within so many seconds. I've interviewed a homeless person on a Friday afternoon and had them phone me the next Monday and ask if I had made a decision. Upon being told that I didn't work weekends I've been told that I was a lazy bitch. The common misconception is that public sector workers do nothing, but sit on their arses and wait for their gold plated pensions. Most are fire fighting, we deal with cases as fast as possible but it's never fast enough. Home visits take more time out of a busy day. I had to write reports which would stand up in court. And that was just me as a homeless officer, a social worker is far busier, far more home visits, far more report writing. No one had a secretary, own letters etc to write, and the managers were rushed off their feet too. Yet the myth of lazy workers continues.

The myth of lazy social workers is actively encouraged by the right wing press. It distracts people from looking at the real reason public services are in such a terrible mess in this country. The government

KayohB · 14/06/2023 08:14

For most people, this is beyond our understanding, it is hard to imagine how anyone could hurt another human being, let alone a defenceless child that should be under their care. I have worked with social workers too and to blame them is completely cruel and unfair, this poor child was killed by evil people, not social
workers, I don’t have the facts of the case but I’d say he was also let down by his wider family.

To assume that a systematically flawed and understaffed system can easily take a child away from their legal parents is just not correct. I have seen social workers in tears after a court has ordered a child in foster care be returned to their birth parents, completely contrary to the recommendations of the social care team.

Do people realise that there aren’t children’s homes anymore, where do you imagine a child is placed after they are finally removed from an unsafe environment? If even 1% of people disgusted and horrified by this looked into becoming foster carers, there might be more options available.

I know we can’t all open our homes to another child but honestly, some people commenting here must be able to and we’re all so quick to be horrified and rightly so, this is incredibly and unbearably upsetting. The fact is, the system is flawed, even if it were overhauled it would take a generation to improve, we know that’s not going to happen to if anyone can become part of the solution, why not consider becoming a foster carer.

I know some social workers just aren’t good at their jobs but a lot
of them literally destroy their own mental health trying to make any change they can in a world that constantly disappoints us all.

RIP Alfie, I’m so sorry that we couldn’t protect you x

Swipe left for the next trending thread