Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
Zola1 · 14/06/2023 11:14

weareallout · 14/06/2023 00:09

Agree @Ted27
One person
100 vulnerable children in very poor home lives: so bad that SS have allocated them a person to oversee their welfare.
People have no idea the reality of these 100 kids but it's bad.
One person dealing with it all

This isn't accurate as the supervising social worker just oversees the foster carers, so they are overseeing maybe carers for 100 children. The children have their own social workers. Child social workers have around 30 cases.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 14/06/2023 11:09

As someone struggling with infertility who adores, frets and cherishes my stepdaughter and nephews, I don't understand a world in which such evil people are able to carelessly breed and abuse/neglect their children, when I would give anything to be able to have a young life to protect.

YES completely agree...how many more of these cases will it take? My heart broke for Arthur Lubinjo-Hughes last year..another utterly harrowing and disgusting case. What is the answer?? The neighbours were conscientious and responded to what they saw/heard but clearly were dismissed. Would put my vote behind any political party who prioritises children's services reform (and reform is putting it mildly).

Changechangechanging · 14/06/2023 11:09

Maybe we need to educate men about being suitable partners?

LifeIsPainHighness · 14/06/2023 11:04

Whilst a lot does need to be done to educate women about having unsuitable men in their lives - we also have to accept in this case AlfieMs mother was the one who drowned him. She fully participated in abuse. She may well have abhsed Alfie without that bastard in her life.

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 11:03

OK @Begsthequestion , so what above tells you I don’t want to help?

I would genuinely be interested in an answer to that because at 35 weeks pregnant with a two year old I don’t think I’d be approved to foster, I already work in child protection, and I don’t vote Tory. So what voluntary work should I be doing at this point?

musicalold · 14/06/2023 11:02

PointeShoesandTutus · 14/06/2023 10:57

First point - what happened to Alfie, and all those other children is horrific and unforgivable.

I used to work in child protection (not a social worker thank goodness but worked closely alongside them.)

Let's do some maths.

Training social workers works on assumption they'll manage between 5-15 families.

But there's a chronic shortage of workers.

So at any given time one social worker might have 50 families on their book. That could be 150 children if there are sibling sets.

They work a 50 hour week - maybe with some overtime but let's face it, they can't go out on visits to families at 5am or 11pm.

So they have one hour to allocate per week to each family if it was divided evenly. It's not, of course. Let's say one family is struggling and is ringing the worker multiple times a day. They might move up the priority list. Then a couple of the children on your books start to self harm. You need to see them urgently. Wait, one of your parents has announced she's pregnant! Quick! That'll need an unborn assessment. And one of your teenagers has run away. Oh and all these families are a 15-20 minute drive apart. And you need to keep a record and write up each visit for evidence. So you can't possibly get round everyone.

Then your colleague goes off with work related stress (very very common, unsurprisingly). So you have to take on her caseload too. Now you've got 100 families, maybe 300 kids.

You finally get to court on one family. The Court system is a mess so you sit all day waiting. The Judge grants temporary removal. You go to pick up the child but there's no placement, so you drive the poor terrified child around and around, through the McDonalds drive through trying to keep them calm whilst your managers ring around to try to find a foster home. There's a whole day gone. No other families have been visited.

Finally you get home at 11pm, drained. You read on mumsnet and the Daily Mail that you're lazy and shit. Then your phone pings. One of your children has broken ribs. Not the family you expected. Never the family you expected. Your heart drops out of your chest. You drive to hospital to sit with the child, support them through x rays and medical procedures, sometimes for days at a time because you're the only familiar face they'll see.

I'm good at my job, really good. I've supported thousands of families. But I couldn't keep going, and had to get out before my mental health was destroyed.

Oh and you're paid buttons too. Not that that really matters.

So yes - there are some shit social workers, but the vast majority are firefighting whilst managing a sinking feeling that something will go horribly wrong any moment.

Absolutely this. Thank you for taking the time to write this. I really hope it helps some on here get a better understanding of the reality of the situation.

PointeShoesandTutus · 14/06/2023 10:57

First point - what happened to Alfie, and all those other children is horrific and unforgivable.

I used to work in child protection (not a social worker thank goodness but worked closely alongside them.)

Let's do some maths.

Training social workers works on assumption they'll manage between 5-15 families.

But there's a chronic shortage of workers.

So at any given time one social worker might have 50 families on their book. That could be 150 children if there are sibling sets.

They work a 50 hour week - maybe with some overtime but let's face it, they can't go out on visits to families at 5am or 11pm.

So they have one hour to allocate per week to each family if it was divided evenly. It's not, of course. Let's say one family is struggling and is ringing the worker multiple times a day. They might move up the priority list. Then a couple of the children on your books start to self harm. You need to see them urgently. Wait, one of your parents has announced she's pregnant! Quick! That'll need an unborn assessment. And one of your teenagers has run away. Oh and all these families are a 15-20 minute drive apart. And you need to keep a record and write up each visit for evidence. So you can't possibly get round everyone.

Then your colleague goes off with work related stress (very very common, unsurprisingly). So you have to take on her caseload too. Now you've got 100 families, maybe 300 kids.

You finally get to court on one family. The Court system is a mess so you sit all day waiting. The Judge grants temporary removal. You go to pick up the child but there's no placement, so you drive the poor terrified child around and around, through the McDonalds drive through trying to keep them calm whilst your managers ring around to try to find a foster home. There's a whole day gone. No other families have been visited.

Finally you get home at 11pm, drained. You read on mumsnet and the Daily Mail that you're lazy and shit. Then your phone pings. One of your children has broken ribs. Not the family you expected. Never the family you expected. Your heart drops out of your chest. You drive to hospital to sit with the child, support them through x rays and medical procedures, sometimes for days at a time because you're the only familiar face they'll see.

I'm good at my job, really good. I've supported thousands of families. But I couldn't keep going, and had to get out before my mental health was destroyed.

Oh and you're paid buttons too. Not that that really matters.

So yes - there are some shit social workers, but the vast majority are firefighting whilst managing a sinking feeling that something will go horribly wrong any moment.

Begsthequestion · 14/06/2023 10:48

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 06:50

I must say that I think the repeated use of the word ‘bleating’ to dismiss peoples concerns is both inappropriate, given the circumstances, and actually quite misogynistic.

Lockdowns have clearly been a contributing factor but the list of ‘advice’ given above is misguided at best (although it isn’t sincere.) I don’t vote Tory, but I also know that several very high profile cases of this nature happened deep in the heart of a Labour government - Victoria Climbie, Peter Connolly, Zachary Turner, as well as the grooming gangs scandals and those who abused children in plain sight spanning decades, so straddling many different governments (Savile obviously the most infamous.) It isn’t so much about a government but more about an inherent attitude we have as a society as to what it means to be a child and what will be tolerated.

Then ‘Be important in the life of a child.’ How? Go out and find a random one? I don’t want to sound facetious, the subject is too serious for that, but I do think it’s one of those comments that is largely meaningless.

Volunteer? Some of us genuinely aren’t in a position to do this, and an unreliable / poor volunteer is no help to anybody. We should ideally be welcoming all children into our homes, but that will realistically only come about if you have children old enough to organise their own socialising. And that’s the problem - my two year old attends a private day nursery and we attend a couple of groups for toddlers, but unsurprisingly the parents of the abused and neglected don’t gravitate there. Likewise, we should care about our neighbours and people did care and have cared but it didn’t save the child.

Fostering requires a lot of things that many people do not have; a spare bedroom for a start, an ability to work very flexible or to give up work altogether, a certain gap between your youngest child and youngest foster child. And yet if you don’t do it, you can’t pass comment on cases such as this?

Human nature being what it is, awful things will sometimes happen and I certainly don’t wish to malign social workers. I do however think it is reasonable to ask why this child remained, and can do so without being accused of ‘bleating’ or being told that since I am not a social worker myself I can’t pass comment Hmm

That's a heck of a lot of words to say "I don't actually want to help".

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 10:48

You say social workers are being asked to do more and more. What would likely happen if they simply said no?

What would happen if you refused to do something in your work? Besides which most social workers care about the families they work with, and worry about the consequences of their actions and decisions, and most know they’re one bad decision away from having a dead child on their hands. Which creates an environment where simply saying “no” isn’t a remotely viable option. So they work, get burned out and leave the profession.

Avondale89 · 14/06/2023 10:47

I assume all these outraged MNetters are all signing up to be social workers now then, seeing as SS are apparently all incompetent idiots.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 14/06/2023 10:45

There’s always a “something should be done” thread on here with cases like this, yet when schools or SW dare to ask questions of a MNetter there’s outrage at them sticking their beaks in and being nosy.

We need properly funded social services and people need to stop the outrage when schools and SW ask questions (the outrage on the thread when the OP’s children didn’t started their new school as planned because of covid is a particularly memorable one).

If we genuinely want more done, more interventions, then people need to accept that means that you or I should be asked questions if our child says something concerning. That we shouldn’t expect different treatment because they know us etc.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/06/2023 10:40

There's a really interested podcast on BBC Sounds about social services. It's called Finding Britain's Ghost Children - it's about children that go 'missing' as they're not in school and not registered anywhere. It looks into the issues with SS though.

In short: there are not enough people to manage the amount of abused children, which is really, really sad. And the level of burnout is high, because, well, I'm sure you can imagine.

Anyway, that's not to take from this horrific case, just wanted to drop that in as an interesting read.

ODFODeary · 14/06/2023 10:31

Judges need to start listening to SW, really listen to them
It's a dreadful guilt to carry when you've tried your best and the courts refuse the removal

XNC · 14/06/2023 10:09

Just re read my post. Need to make it clear by "this boy" I didn't mean Alfie himself.

It haunts me to think that the same could happen to the boy I saw.

TheHandmaiden · 14/06/2023 09:55

XNC · 14/06/2023 09:04

I was saying exactly the same to DP this morning. Including the unjustified personal guilt.

I called the police a few months a go after witnessing this boy being hit repeatedly over the head by his step "father". We were in a pub garden and this man was clearly a bully. Got a huge kick out of intimidating him. He then asked the boys mum if he could properly punish him and the grin that came over his face when she agreed was beyond disturbing. He then started dragging him around and smacking him across the head. I couldn't stand it. I called the police who said it would be a priority response, so we left after that. I hope to goodness that the scum bag was charged and subsequently not involved with this family any more, but I suspect even if that was the case, the mum would have moved on to another evil bastard.

I often wonder what happened and even worry that I made things worse.

This CAN NOT keep happening.

This. This guy gets off on it. As did this guy who already had convictions for child cruelty.

Dymaxion · 14/06/2023 09:51

@captainjacksparrow roughly how often would you say 'working' with families actually works ?

Bagpuss2022 · 14/06/2023 09:49

I never actually heard the “phone calls” or the cries of him there really is some evil in this world and it usually is men but also women who allow it regardless if they are also abused being a parent should and instinctively come first (also fathers but it’s mainly the parents new partners)
like I have said we had SS involved and rightly so but looking back we were a easy case for them and we could easily be concealing abuse.
I just keep thinking of that poor boy what horror he had to endure and people did try to help ans why was he let down? Give me ten minutes with either of those scumbags

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 09:46

What do you think would happen?

I know that sounds antagonistic and it isn’t meant that way. But any sort of collective action would have to be done via the unions. Individual or even groups of social workers refusing to carry out tasks would see them disciplined.

tescocreditcard · 14/06/2023 09:42

@BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah I agree with everything you e said but have a question for you.

You say social workers are being asked to do more and more. What would likely happen if they simply said no?

BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah · 14/06/2023 09:31

I work for Adult Social Services though I'm not a social worker.

So many people on this thread are utterly clueless. You have no idea what we're up against.

13 years of government cuts and we are being asked to do more and more. Cuts to other public services like NHS mental health services and education etc etc mean even if we want to help we can't get placements / support etc etc.

Staff turnover is so high my employer is looking to recruit social workers from abroad. The wages are a pittance given the responsibility that a social worker has.

So yes, it's tragic what happened to this little boy and absolutely awful that opportunities to help were missed. But this will keep happening until the public stands up and demands better. Because one social worker with a caseload of 100 kids is going to miss stuff. And no amount of screeching on Mumsnet about how lazy they are is going to change that.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 14/06/2023 09:27

It’s absolutely heartbreaking, I was in tears.

And yet another case where Covid was used both as an opportunity by murderers to kill in plain sight and an excuse for the authorities not to do their jobs properly.

”lessons will be learned” well when exactly. Because this has happened too many times and it’s just devastating

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 09:26

I haven’t done that @Jellycatspyjamas but I do think that concerns can be expressed without peoples heads being bitten off and being told they have to retrain or foster before being fit to pass comment. I’m not accusing you personally of having done that but I’m finding it very uncomfortable.

’You’re not a social worker? Shut up then.’ Can people honestly not see that a system where no comment is allowed is one where abuse can continue to thrive?

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 09:22

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 09:21

Yes I would be very interested to know how many of the mums involved came from abusive backgrounds

Pretty much all. And pretty much all abusive men also.

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 09:22

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 07:38

@MySugarBabyLove
The reality though is that this has nothing to do with the Tory government or lack of funding.

not true. The tories removed guaranteed bursaries for social work training, massively reducing the numbers coming through. They pushed the 'step up' programme as their pet project which produces under prepared social workers who burn out more quickly. They cut funding for tier 3/early help support services through successive years of austerity meaning the numbers of children coming into social work teams increased and the complexity increased just as numbers of social workers were falling.

They have also cut other services like children centers and council maintained nurseries which support disadvantaged families in the early years

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 09:21

adomizo · 14/06/2023 07:44

This though...how can young girls and woman be better supported so they don't get into these relationships and instead prioritise their children. And support for women who do end up in relationships where they are being abused themselves is so poor. These should be a priority for government to stop the cycles of abuse. We won't get this from a Tory government.

Yes I would be very interested to know how many of the mums involved came from abusive backgrounds

Swipe left for the next trending thread