Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
Betsybetty · 14/06/2023 12:37

why is this happening to so many children...why are there so many evil people...what can we do to change...would voting labour make it better? I am so haunted by these cases. keep imagining them. I am so fine fed up by reading lessons to be learned. how hard are these lessons to learn? so many phone calls, from everyone. wtf are these government doing

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 12:37

Ted27 · 14/06/2023 12:08

@Zola1

the SW I was referring to in my original post was the supervisor of my foster child’s social worker, not my SW,, That SW left last week, so until a replacement is found her caseload needs to be reallocated or the supervisor has to pick things up.
To my knowledge there are quite a few vacancies in my LA

It's normal for managers to have oversight of 100+ children. That's not an unreasonable caseload for a manager.

Sausagedogmum · 14/06/2023 12:33

PointeShoesandTutus · 14/06/2023 10:57

First point - what happened to Alfie, and all those other children is horrific and unforgivable.

I used to work in child protection (not a social worker thank goodness but worked closely alongside them.)

Let's do some maths.

Training social workers works on assumption they'll manage between 5-15 families.

But there's a chronic shortage of workers.

So at any given time one social worker might have 50 families on their book. That could be 150 children if there are sibling sets.

They work a 50 hour week - maybe with some overtime but let's face it, they can't go out on visits to families at 5am or 11pm.

So they have one hour to allocate per week to each family if it was divided evenly. It's not, of course. Let's say one family is struggling and is ringing the worker multiple times a day. They might move up the priority list. Then a couple of the children on your books start to self harm. You need to see them urgently. Wait, one of your parents has announced she's pregnant! Quick! That'll need an unborn assessment. And one of your teenagers has run away. Oh and all these families are a 15-20 minute drive apart. And you need to keep a record and write up each visit for evidence. So you can't possibly get round everyone.

Then your colleague goes off with work related stress (very very common, unsurprisingly). So you have to take on her caseload too. Now you've got 100 families, maybe 300 kids.

You finally get to court on one family. The Court system is a mess so you sit all day waiting. The Judge grants temporary removal. You go to pick up the child but there's no placement, so you drive the poor terrified child around and around, through the McDonalds drive through trying to keep them calm whilst your managers ring around to try to find a foster home. There's a whole day gone. No other families have been visited.

Finally you get home at 11pm, drained. You read on mumsnet and the Daily Mail that you're lazy and shit. Then your phone pings. One of your children has broken ribs. Not the family you expected. Never the family you expected. Your heart drops out of your chest. You drive to hospital to sit with the child, support them through x rays and medical procedures, sometimes for days at a time because you're the only familiar face they'll see.

I'm good at my job, really good. I've supported thousands of families. But I couldn't keep going, and had to get out before my mental health was destroyed.

Oh and you're paid buttons too. Not that that really matters.

So yes - there are some shit social workers, but the vast majority are firefighting whilst managing a sinking feeling that something will go horribly wrong any moment.

Well said 👏 .

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 12:24

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 11:54

I do. In my LA caseloads are nowhere near that high. 30 children is common in assessment, in family safeguarding it's more like 22 for experienced social workers. That's still too high but I don't recognise people talking about caseloads of 50+ children. That is a hugely dysfunctional local authority and probably rated inadequate and in special measures, which is not the norm.

Depends where you work.

Large city with large areas of social deprivation, inequalities, crime, etc? There'll be more cases.

If you work in the Cotswolds, a small town or similar you'll obviously have lower need.

A bit like in the early stages of COVID when virtually all health services were shut down and a few major cities were having a shit time in their hospitals when other areas, even major cities but in different areas of the country had virtually empty hospitals for months.

Things vary from city to city and area to area.

I work in a large city. The outskirts of which come under a different commissioning area. Their GP and MH services have massively shorter waiting times and their social services, probation services and youth offending services have massively reduced caseloads in comparison.

Postcode lotteries exist.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 14/06/2023 12:18

One of the SW’s I know through some voluntary work is meant to work in a team of 12. There are current 7 of them, plus their manager. One is working their notice and another goes on maternity soon and isn’t coming back

the shortage of SW’s is massive

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 12:13

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 11:53

Fair enough but I do think as a general sort of point no one should be above questioning.

That includes social workers but extends to teachers, medical professionals, care workers, those who work in finance, in government.

The answer is not ‘you are not one of us, so shut up.’

No-one said that though. Or implied it. No-one was saying that social services or social services don't fail. Or that there aren’t some incompetent, inadequate, lazy or uncaring SW. Because there will always be a small number of assholes in any profession.

They were responding to the extremely critical and somewhat abusive posts on the first few pages saying how shit CPYSS are, have blood on their hands, there are far too many child deaths caused by SW and how SW should be imprisoned for failing to remove children who later are killed.

Which was abusive, offensive and just not understanding at all, the laws involved in removing children, the consequences for those children and how CYPS works.

And incredibly ignorant in discussing a profession which already struggles to find and retain staff. It's not an attractive career for a number of reasons and suggesting there is a risk of imprisonment for 'not doing enough or getting it wrong' would just result in even fewer people wanting a career in that area.

Then all the fuckwits suggesting it will complain even more about how 'someone should be doing something'

Ted27 · 14/06/2023 12:08

@Zola1

the SW I was referring to in my original post was the supervisor of my foster child’s social worker, not my SW,, That SW left last week, so until a replacement is found her caseload needs to be reallocated or the supervisor has to pick things up.
To my knowledge there are quite a few vacancies in my LA

ZoeCM · 14/06/2023 12:00

MumblesParty · 14/06/2023 00:39

Anyone who ever wonders how these tragedies occur without the authorities stepping in only has to read MN for a few days.

So many people on here advocate minding your own business. I see it time and again. “I saw my neighbour drag her 4 year old along the pavement and smack him hard when he cried, should I report to SS?”. And the replies come thick and fast “mind your own business, keep your nose out, you don’t know what’s going on in her life, she might have mental health problems, don’t be a judgey pants, leave the poor woman alone, we can’t all be as perfect as you” etc etc.

And so abuse goes unnoticed, because no one wants to intervene.

Absolutely. Whenever these cases make the news, there's always some brief outrage on MN - posts about how child abuse is everyone's business, society needs to take more responsibility, etc. And then, in no time at all, it's back to "Why are you judging this poor mother? Maybe she was just having a bad day, you just saw a snapshot, she probably apologised and gave the kids a hug as soon as they got home..."

DancingQueen2019 · 14/06/2023 11:56

Apologies, just reading from a BBC report neighbours were also intimidated. It just seems sad no one would stick up for this poor little boy.

DancingQueen2019 · 14/06/2023 11:54

Absolutely Social Workers need more support and funding. They are hugely overworked.

I'm puzzled as to if the neighbours saw a poor boy out in the cold in the middle of the night they did not repeatedly call police or intervene themselves? I could not sleep if I knew that was happening.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 11:54

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 11:34

Child social workers have around 30 cases.

And each of those cases will have multiple children involved. I don’t know of any full time social worker carrying a case load of 30 children.

I do. In my LA caseloads are nowhere near that high. 30 children is common in assessment, in family safeguarding it's more like 22 for experienced social workers. That's still too high but I don't recognise people talking about caseloads of 50+ children. That is a hugely dysfunctional local authority and probably rated inadequate and in special measures, which is not the norm.

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 11:53

Ted27 · 14/06/2023 11:45

@Elderflowerraspberry

I wasn’t directiing my reply at any one individual on this thread

Fair enough but I do think as a general sort of point no one should be above questioning.

That includes social workers but extends to teachers, medical professionals, care workers, those who work in finance, in government.

The answer is not ‘you are not one of us, so shut up.’

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 11:50

Dymaxion · 14/06/2023 09:51

@captainjacksparrow roughly how often would you say 'working' with families actually works ?

We couldn't tell you the numbers of children who DON'T get hurt or killed because of our interventions. Just yesterday a SW and I worked all day to get in court to protect a child who might otherwise have died due to the risk they were facing. That's not everyday but it's common. People have NO IDEA what we do to keep children safe every day and how many children aren't hurt or killed because of what we do.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 11:48

tescocreditcard · 14/06/2023 09:42

@BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah I agree with everything you e said but have a question for you.

You say social workers are being asked to do more and more. What would likely happen if they simply said no?

You can't just say no. It's your job. We all care about the children in our service. I'm a manager and I've done loads of casework when there has been no social worker available to do it and urgent issues needing done. Nobody refuses to work. Or if they do, they get signed off sick and everyone else has to pick up their slack...

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 11:46

Changechangechanging · 14/06/2023 11:09

Maybe we need to educate men about being suitable partners?

Yes. But when they've brought up in violent homes and it's all they've known and been modelled as how adult relationships work, it's as difficult as it is to educate the girls who grew up in violent homes.

And working with a number of young people who grew up in violent homes and are now replicating that in their early relationships; there's a really difficult balance to be found between educating a domestically violent 15/16/17 year old who is still legally a child and often in LAC or in a shitty abusive home that it is not at all acceptable that he behaves this way while also treating him as the traumatised child he is.

There are no specific psychoeducation programmes in my area for perpetrators of domestic/relationship violence under the age of 18. Because they're still children and should be treated as victims of their own trauma rather than perpetrators.

So everyone's stuck in trying to help them in a meaningful way. And once they turn 18 most of the support from agencies falls away. And when they're late teens and early 20s and beyond and still perpetrators of domestic violence, no-one in society really gives a shit anymore that they witnessed their Mum being beaten or raped. They're adults now and should know better.

And as dramatic as it sounds, its really possible that Alfie would have gone on to be an adult man like that, had he lived, given the household he was living in.

But when you are tragically murdered by abusive parents aged 9, everyone falls over themselves to weep about it.

But more boys like Alfie don't get murdered and in 10+ years are the adults like his 'Step'-Dad who murdered him. And then no-one gives a shit and says he was just an evil bastard.

And it goes round and round and round.

And there are always girls and women who come from equally dysfunctional and abusive backgrounds wanting to be in relationships with dysfunctional and abusive men. Because that's what they know to be how relationships work.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 14/06/2023 11:46

It's awful but it's not just down to SS. I'm sick of seeing women with children allow men to abuse their children time and time again. I hold a lot of blame towards the 'mother'. She not only let the abuse happen but had an active role. And I'm sorry but even if they were a victim of past abuse, it's not a good enough reason. Plenty of people survive abusive childhoods and strive to ensure their child does not have the same.

JuneOsborne · 14/06/2023 11:46

Zola1 · 14/06/2023 11:14

This isn't accurate as the supervising social worker just oversees the foster carers, so they are overseeing maybe carers for 100 children. The children have their own social workers. Child social workers have around 30 cases.

Where do you get that figure from?

Ted27 · 14/06/2023 11:45

@Elderflowerraspberry

I wasn’t directiing my reply at any one individual on this thread

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 11:34

Child social workers have around 30 cases.

And each of those cases will have multiple children involved. I don’t know of any full time social worker carrying a case load of 30 children.

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 11:27

I haven’t @Ted27

But there is an enormous grey space between ‘all social workers are useless’ and ‘do not EVER question a social worker unless you’re prepared to be one yourself or be a foster carer’

The former is provocative and unhelpful. The latter encourages secrecy, deception and lies and I don’t think should be encouraged.

FourTeaFallOut · 14/06/2023 11:27

Jesus, another abusive step father and scumbag complicit mother. What a miserable short life that poor boy had.

Bideshi · 14/06/2023 11:25

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2023 02:31

As someone who used to have a caseload of 10s of people who this could happen to, who was overworked, underpaid, blamed and pilloried for existing, and everyone knew better than me how to do my job... I left.

People think SWs have a caseload of maybe 20, with one person where this could happen. It's more like 100, where in 50 cases this could happen. There are NO easy cases. SWs aren't psychic, they have to assess, listen to unreliable witnesses who all lie, knowing that removing a child will definitely fuck their whole life up. Definitely.

SWs save lives every day but it is completely invisible. They can't talk about it and no one knows.

If you think SWs are thick (from this thread), incompetent (from everywhere) and lazy and heartless, retrain. Do it yourself. Quickly while you know everything. Make sure to never make a mistake, never miss anything, know who is lying, know who is telling the truth and finish all your work while there's still time to sleep and eat.

Or:

  1. Don't vote Tory
  2. Be important in the life of a child
  3. Volunteer
  4. Welcome the DC who are smelly, poorly behaved and violent to your homes
  5. Actually care about your neighbours
  6. Foster
  7. Don't vote Tory

I know it's easier to blame the people who do the hard work while you're sitting on your arse, but the fact is violent abuse happens every day. It's constant. You just don't have to see it every day. SWs do, poor bastards.

This.
Absolutely true of the social workers I know who start out idealistic and end up drained and in many cases psychologically traumatised. The burn out rate for SWs in child protection is frighteningly short.
Easy to criticise but the men involved with these single mothers are crafty, duplicitous and often violent and threatening - did anyone see the video of this particular POS in previous encounter with the police? I wouldn't have wanted to take him on, and the police don't have time to back up social workers.The work loads are immense and if you show signs of being good at your job, yet more cases are piled on you.
This was lock-down tragedy if I've got that right. Cases like this were inevitable.
Agree with@MrsTerryPratchett. Nobody sees all the cases handled by SWs that do have good and positive outcomes.
We need to think about how we treat the poor and disadvantaged in our society and how they can be supported or enabled to do better by themselves and, above all, by their children.

Ted27 · 14/06/2023 11:23

Of course not everyone is equipped or is in the position to be a foster carer.

What you can do is not seek to lay the blame at the door of those who are working in child protection, and criticise a whole profession as lazy and incompetent. Maybe we cannot throw up our hands in horror at the thought of a children’s residential home or young persons hostel in our street.

The people who are to blame are the perpetrators of the crime. In my view too few cases of child abuse and neglect end up in court and the sentences are woeful or inappropriate.

I find it quite telling that my son’s birth mother has lost 4 children to adoption or foster care. She has never been prosecuted for any offence relating to the children. Yet she has served multiple short sentences for petty crime. She had a 6 week sentence for shoplifting a box of cigarette lighters.
Maybe that shows were our priorities as a society lie.

BigCheekBitch · 14/06/2023 11:17

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 14/06/2023 07:58

Boris has blood on his hands. So many kids were abused during lockdown, and fell through the cracks, and we have only skimmed the surface with the ones we know about.

162 posts and only 2 of them mentioning lockdown.

We trapped these children in houses with their abusers and stopped their access to safe observant adults.

We stretched the police and social services. We shifted society fundamentally for a time.

How many more children were drowned in the bath, but didn't die? I hope the covid enquiry covers cases like Alfie's.

My heart breaks. How could the police hear this phone call

"It sounds like he's being hit and held under the water or something and loads of thrashing around."

and not remove this child? As the OP said "I feel like I failed him." I do too, I think we all failed him.

Achwheesht · 14/06/2023 11:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.