Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 17:35

musicalold · 14/06/2023 15:07

@potniatheron I just found this link - it's not enough but I didn't realise that SW students still get a bursary. There are also fast track options so no debt is incurred at all.

I don't agree at all that SW (or nursing) should revert to not being a graduate profession.

www.communitycare.co.uk/2023/03/15/government-has-no-plans-to-review-level-of-social-work-bursaries-despite-nine-year-freeze/

All SW students used to be entitled to a bursary but the tories restricted numbers. This happened the year after I qualified and the numbers of students on the course I did dropped by 1/3 the following year.

Ffswhatsthepoint · 14/06/2023 17:10

There has always been child abuse/murders. When I was 7 my friends, who lived across the road, got murdered by their mother. She found a new bf, kids were a thorn in her side. She set the house on fire, both of them died. I watched the house burn down from my bedroom window. And yet 40 years later we are no further forward. It needs a team of people (who only have the childrens best interests at heart) to come together, join resources, possibly remove/change some of the red tape that surrounds protecting children and seems to be more of a hinderence...and most definitely more investment in every sense in SW's.

I haven't read every response on here yet, I will later. I've had a job interview today and haven't had time to catch up. But thanks for all the replies.

OP posts:
Freysimo · 14/06/2023 15:16

BerriesPineCones · 14/06/2023 00:11

ALL public services are run into the ground under this government. People are dying waiting for ambulances. State schools are in a mess/teacher shortages. Mental health services are dire. Jailing social workers/ paramedics/ teachers won't help. You need to look at who's running the country.
Doubtless I'll now be inundated with people saying the government are doing a marvellous job and it's just those lazy social workers/paramedics etc

It's not just the UK government. Wales Government is responsible for Child Services here and we've not long had the case of poor Logan Mwangi.

musicalold · 14/06/2023 15:07

@potniatheron I just found this link - it's not enough but I didn't realise that SW students still get a bursary. There are also fast track options so no debt is incurred at all.

I don't agree at all that SW (or nursing) should revert to not being a graduate profession.

www.communitycare.co.uk/2023/03/15/government-has-no-plans-to-review-level-of-social-work-bursaries-despite-nine-year-freeze/

KnitMePurlMe · 14/06/2023 15:03

@crazeekat have you read ANY of the thread or did you just think “yay another social worker pile on, I’ll join in”? 🙄

MaPaSpa · 14/06/2023 14:58

The issue is you often have subpar students who are passed because services are desperate for staff

newly qualified sw who are put on extremely complex cases with barely any supervision.
senior sw who are leaving due to rubbish pay and massive caseloads. It’s absolutely dangerous.

that without even going in the lack of emergency placements, foster care, care homes, kinship care, care for children with complex trauma etc etc

piedbeauty · 14/06/2023 14:44

This is one of the saddest stories I've read. What happened after all the neighbours' calls to the police? Someone must be held accountable. Alfie was not protected. He was failed.

Seymour5 · 14/06/2023 14:38

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 14:27

Something that would massively help with the recruitment and retention of social workers would be to massively improve the public image of them and show respect for the workforce.

as a profession we suffer insane amounts of abuse both verbal and physical and get very little recognition unless we are being slated in the press

I agree. And I'm not a social worker.

crazeekat · 14/06/2023 14:35

heads need to roll for this they have said to the public report report and keep reporting every single time, thwy didn't remove him cos the mum was engaging, what a crock of shit!!! other cases i think social work have done what they thwy an and they get shafted by the courts, this time with Alfie, they have not. they need to all be singularly held accountable now. enough is enough. the whole lot needs to be proper open investigation, courts , schools, swd hospitals. every time someeone dies it is ooooh wee see the failures now. but nothing changes. excuses excuses excuses.

mogsrus · 14/06/2023 14:33

Lessons will be learned, no they won’t, they’re never in the right classroom ! Not fit for purpose. Poor child once again let down by the establishment. We must never let this happen again, they say. Until the next time.

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 14:27

Something that would massively help with the recruitment and retention of social workers would be to massively improve the public image of them and show respect for the workforce.

as a profession we suffer insane amounts of abuse both verbal and physical and get very little recognition unless we are being slated in the press

potniatheron · 14/06/2023 14:17

ZoeCM · 14/06/2023 14:14

This is why it drives me nuts when children who ask their mothers not to move her boyfriend into the home are criticised on MN. They're accused of trying to run their mother's life - when, actually, they're quite possibly just protecting their own. Having an unrelated male move into the home is one of the most dangerous things that can happen to a child, yet when they instinctively object to this, they're considered brats. No one would expect an adult woman to be happy to share a home with a strange man, yet plenty of kids are expected to do just that.

My mother moved a new man into the home when I was 8 and that's when my serious abuse began in earnest. I'm still dealing with it now in my 50s.

But to stay on topic, the one big policy change that could be made to address the national shortage of social workers is to remove the degree requirement and put it back to the on the job training and qualifications that were required before the Blair government. Requiring a social work degree has deterred a lot of people who could be very good SWs but aren't necessarily academics, or don't wish to start life saddled with debt.

the same goes for nurses but that is a different thread.

ZoeCM · 14/06/2023 14:14

potniatheron · 14/06/2023 13:37

There's another issue however - and that is of single mums getting into relationships with men who go on to kill the mother's child. This seems to be the pattern. What work can be done to prevent this? Why are women willing to accept abuse from new partners towards children? What programmes are in place for these women? (Because while she is guilty let's face it there was no record of abuse until he came on the scene)

It's called the Cinderella Effect. It has been observed in chimpanzee 'families as well as humans. There is a reason why the 'wicked stepmother' is a trope in folktales and old stories. The introduction of a step parent significantly increases a child's risk of abuse.

This is why it drives me nuts when children who ask their mothers not to move her boyfriend into the home are criticised on MN. They're accused of trying to run their mother's life - when, actually, they're quite possibly just protecting their own. Having an unrelated male move into the home is one of the most dangerous things that can happen to a child, yet when they instinctively object to this, they're considered brats. No one would expect an adult woman to be happy to share a home with a strange man, yet plenty of kids are expected to do just that.

musicalold · 14/06/2023 14:04

@Dymaxion "Dymaxion
@captainjacksparrow roughly how often would you say 'working' with families actually works ?"

Obviously even one child death is one too many. But I think asking the question that you have demonstrates a real lack of understanding about the sheer numbers of children and families that SWs are working with and about the fact that their work is vital and in the vast vast majority of situation have positive outcomes. We will only ever hear about the tragedies. We will only every hear about things that have gone wrong. I don't understand why people don't get that, I really don't.

Bagpuss2022 · 14/06/2023 14:04

Betsybee88 · 14/06/2023 12:48

There's an interview with a peadophile online, which he goes into horrific detail of how he'd target lone parents, especially those lone parents where the father has no involvement, even better when there's no other family to intervene.
I suspect it's the same for these child abuses,they know what and who to look for, they know how to reel them in and they know when to start lashing out at kids.

This!!! And I can say personally my mum ran a charity for SA children after me and my DS were SA by our father she was groomed and actually met my stepfather at said charity event he knew she had daughters and we were victims.
he ended up SA me for 7 years and also almost killing my mum she had no idea what he was doing to me but even after disclosing she kicked him out but as a victim herself she took him back.
He went onto another family and the same happened some people mainly Men are just monsters and prey on children and women is Alfie’s mum as culpable as him yes she is but she was prayed on by that monster

captainjacksparrow · 14/06/2023 13:57

Dymaxion · 14/06/2023 09:51

@captainjacksparrow roughly how often would you say 'working' with families actually works ?

Thousands. We close hundreds of referrals every week with support in place and those cases never come back because actually 99% of parents want to do a good job and keep their kids safe.

for every child we remove there are hundreds we able to keep with families.

but the positive outcomes are never front page news.

potniatheron · 14/06/2023 13:37

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 00:05

So it sounds like a combination of too much work and perhaps incompetence is resulting in more cases like this than necessary. Both of those problems could potentially be improved through more funding.

It also says that they were in legal discussions to remove the boy, and also implies that they were led to believe the man had moved out.

There's another issue however - and that is of single mums getting into relationships with men who go on to kill the mother's child. This seems to be the pattern. What work can be done to prevent this? Why are women willing to accept abuse from new partners towards children? What programmes are in place for these women? (Because while she is guilty let's face it there was no record of abuse until he came on the scene)

There's another issue however - and that is of single mums getting into relationships with men who go on to kill the mother's child. This seems to be the pattern. What work can be done to prevent this? Why are women willing to accept abuse from new partners towards children? What programmes are in place for these women? (Because while she is guilty let's face it there was no record of abuse until he came on the scene)

It's called the Cinderella Effect. It has been observed in chimpanzee 'families as well as humans. There is a reason why the 'wicked stepmother' is a trope in folktales and old stories. The introduction of a step parent significantly increases a child's risk of abuse.

FourTeaFallOut · 14/06/2023 13:36

That's an interesting take. Rather than targeting vulnerable women to abuse them/ their children they are targeting them to achieve a stable housing situation. That makes sense.

However, the idea that they become resentful and end up abusing children is a stretch for me. It makes more sense that maladjusted men who cannot achieve stability on their own terms because of, say, criminality/ drug taking and the factors that led to that situation, are more likely to be predisposed to being violent and abusive from the outset.

Gettybetty · 14/06/2023 13:25

Betsybee88 · 14/06/2023 12:48

There's an interview with a peadophile online, which he goes into horrific detail of how he'd target lone parents, especially those lone parents where the father has no involvement, even better when there's no other family to intervene.
I suspect it's the same for these child abuses,they know what and who to look for, they know how to reel them in and they know when to start lashing out at kids.

It's not the same in most cases.

I don't think most men are targeting single mothers with the intent to physically abuse their children.

What happens is single adult men who are not in work and/or cannot afford to privately rent are last on the list for any kind of social housing. Even if they are care leavers or addicts or suffering from mental illness, there are still lots of families, disabled people, refugees and single Mums with children who are ahead of them.

Their choices are sofa-surfing with family or friends, street homelessness or hostels if they can get one. All shit.

Or they meet a woman willing to enter into a relationship with them and invite them to live with her. Who usually has children.

And the men are often dysfunctional, as are the women. And the drug use that usually is part of these relationships and the abuse which is usually part of these relationships occurs. And you have women who just want a man in their lives for whatever reason and a man who might not even like the woman so much but she's providing the roof over his head and it's preferable to sleeping in the streets or in a hostel.

Or he might like her but it's not his kid he's suddenly playing step-Dad that he has no bond to and it's likely the child is annoying to him crying or needing attention or they can't do the things he wants to do as a couple because there's a child to consider.

So he feels trapped. He could leave but the alternatives are shitter than the way he's living now. So he gets more and more resentful and abusive.

It's not in any way an excuse. He could always choose to sofa-surf or be street homeless or live in a hostel. And he could choose to not be an abuser. But the women could also choose to not move in someone quickly and ignore or facilitate the abuse of their children.

It's just what happens in a lot of cases.

Somanycats · 14/06/2023 12:54

PointeShoesandTutus · 14/06/2023 10:57

First point - what happened to Alfie, and all those other children is horrific and unforgivable.

I used to work in child protection (not a social worker thank goodness but worked closely alongside them.)

Let's do some maths.

Training social workers works on assumption they'll manage between 5-15 families.

But there's a chronic shortage of workers.

So at any given time one social worker might have 50 families on their book. That could be 150 children if there are sibling sets.

They work a 50 hour week - maybe with some overtime but let's face it, they can't go out on visits to families at 5am or 11pm.

So they have one hour to allocate per week to each family if it was divided evenly. It's not, of course. Let's say one family is struggling and is ringing the worker multiple times a day. They might move up the priority list. Then a couple of the children on your books start to self harm. You need to see them urgently. Wait, one of your parents has announced she's pregnant! Quick! That'll need an unborn assessment. And one of your teenagers has run away. Oh and all these families are a 15-20 minute drive apart. And you need to keep a record and write up each visit for evidence. So you can't possibly get round everyone.

Then your colleague goes off with work related stress (very very common, unsurprisingly). So you have to take on her caseload too. Now you've got 100 families, maybe 300 kids.

You finally get to court on one family. The Court system is a mess so you sit all day waiting. The Judge grants temporary removal. You go to pick up the child but there's no placement, so you drive the poor terrified child around and around, through the McDonalds drive through trying to keep them calm whilst your managers ring around to try to find a foster home. There's a whole day gone. No other families have been visited.

Finally you get home at 11pm, drained. You read on mumsnet and the Daily Mail that you're lazy and shit. Then your phone pings. One of your children has broken ribs. Not the family you expected. Never the family you expected. Your heart drops out of your chest. You drive to hospital to sit with the child, support them through x rays and medical procedures, sometimes for days at a time because you're the only familiar face they'll see.

I'm good at my job, really good. I've supported thousands of families. But I couldn't keep going, and had to get out before my mental health was destroyed.

Oh and you're paid buttons too. Not that that really matters.

So yes - there are some shit social workers, but the vast majority are firefighting whilst managing a sinking feeling that something will go horribly wrong any moment.

This, absolutely this. . I have no idea why people don't understand this.
A kid, who's case I had in common with a social worker went missing overnight. A court case was pending with a view to removal. It kept being delayed. He had absconded as we both suspected because he had been assaulted again by his parents and he'd made a break for it. Below zero degrees and snow on the ground. The sw was so stressed by this, she actually threw up.
He was found by a dog walker unconscious and hypothermic in the woods mid morning. He could easily have died - whose fault would that have been? He was fine in the end and eventually removed.
Didn't make the papers of course, just a run of the mill (horrific) event. This happened for all the reasons above. And for as long as we don't want to pay more taxes, it will continue to be the case.

TheHandmaiden · 14/06/2023 12:54

Yes - look at all the posts on here with biological fathers who aren't very bothered re their kids.

Now contrast that with an unrelated man who want to move and help with your children in a short period of time.

It is a huge and obvious risk. And what is not discussed in these cases is that often domestic abusers are also sexual abusers too. The discipline administered by men and the mothers is a precursor to that happening.

Betsybee88 · 14/06/2023 12:48

There's an interview with a peadophile online, which he goes into horrific detail of how he'd target lone parents, especially those lone parents where the father has no involvement, even better when there's no other family to intervene.
I suspect it's the same for these child abuses,they know what and who to look for, they know how to reel them in and they know when to start lashing out at kids.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 12:46

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 12:42

That is a hugely dysfunctional local authority and probably rated inadequate and in special measures, which is not the norm.

It depends on where you are. I work in a very populous area with high levels of deprivation with 4 bordering local authorities with a similar demographic. Vacancy levels for social workers sit between 40-60% in those areas - recruitment isn’t an issue but retention is due to the complexity of the work involved. Children on CP plans and CSOs need an allocated social worker - if the teams were fully staffed case loads would sit around 20-25 children but teams aren’t remotely fully staffed and so caseloads become higher. And the cycle continues.

Exactly. That's a dysfunctional local authority with that level of staff vacancy. That's not the case across the board.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/06/2023 12:42

That is a hugely dysfunctional local authority and probably rated inadequate and in special measures, which is not the norm.

It depends on where you are. I work in a very populous area with high levels of deprivation with 4 bordering local authorities with a similar demographic. Vacancy levels for social workers sit between 40-60% in those areas - recruitment isn’t an issue but retention is due to the complexity of the work involved. Children on CP plans and CSOs need an allocated social worker - if the teams were fully staffed case loads would sit around 20-25 children but teams aren’t remotely fully staffed and so caseloads become higher. And the cycle continues.

Betsybetty · 14/06/2023 12:41

@PointeShoesandTutus thank you for explaining your day, I think it makes it clearer for everyone the load you are under. this can only be resolved by a change of government.

I am though trying to understand whether we always had this many evil people in the country, or has it gone up because of some social reasons? are we going through collective madness?