Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:43

Hopingforagreatescape · 15/06/2023 21:15

Yes, we don't hear about the hundreds of lives saved, because we can't ever see "what might have happened" if a child had stayed. What we do hear about is parents complaining to the press when their child is taken "for no reason". Sometimes that parent gets their child back (and not because they actually want them - just because they don't want the social workers to win) and then goes on to kill them.

I was once involved in a situation with extended family who had SS involved (SS were absolute incompetent dicks there too, and it wasn’t an abuse issue). I supported by way of providing childcare temporarily etc. so I joined a Facebook support group for families with SS involvement.

I had to leave in the end because the amount of people who said things like “My children have been removed because a social worker came round and there was a bit of mess on the floor. Nothing bad just toys and clothes. Then they came round today with an emergency care order I can’t believe they’ve removed my kids over a bit of mess” and I just thought WOW you fucking liars.

Hopingforagreatescape · 15/06/2023 21:15

Yes, we don't hear about the hundreds of lives saved, because we can't ever see "what might have happened" if a child had stayed. What we do hear about is parents complaining to the press when their child is taken "for no reason". Sometimes that parent gets their child back (and not because they actually want them - just because they don't want the social workers to win) and then goes on to kill them.

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:03

Sorry ignore my post I’m an idiot I thought you meant they day he was killed

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 21:03

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 20:57

I get that there is huge deception and cover up, but if a Police Officer arrived at a crime scene and found an adult who had just been subjected to the above torture, surely they would be able to ascertain that something was horrifically, hideously wrong?

I imagine the police response to that call will be central to the learning review - I too am interested to know what happened there.

From the videos I’ve seen online they made her stay in the home and call her boyfriend rather than follow Alfie to hospital. I’m guessing they arrested her then and there

TheHandmaiden · 15/06/2023 21:02

I cannot imagine how hopeless that child felt when the police arrived and he was left there.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 20:57

I get that there is huge deception and cover up, but if a Police Officer arrived at a crime scene and found an adult who had just been subjected to the above torture, surely they would be able to ascertain that something was horrifically, hideously wrong?

I imagine the police response to that call will be central to the learning review - I too am interested to know what happened there.

WilkinsonM · 15/06/2023 19:29

Itisalwayspossibletobekind · 15/06/2023 18:56

Thank you for the clear explanations of the various processes, and associated limitations. I just can't fathom why Alfie wasn't removed by the Police Officer when he was clearly in extreme immediate danger when the neighbour rang and reported Alfie being waterboarded, tortured and beaten at the very time the crime was happening. Especially given the wider context where so many other concerns had already been raised about him.

Just to be clear, I really appreciate you and all the other posters outlining the processes and am not expecting specific answers.

It is also clear that SWs processes take time, but the Police are the only ones with the powers to immediately remove children in immediate danger. I get that there is huge deception and cover up, but if a Police Officer arrived at a crime scene and found an adult who had just been subjected to the above torture, surely they would be able to ascertain that something was horrifically, hideously wrong?

I'm sure we will find out what happened and didn't happen in due course.
FWIW what usually happens when police take police protection is either children go back within the 72 hours with a safety plan OR the local authority makes an emergency application for a court hearing which should be no later than the day after the application is made. This is difficult if they take PP on Friday evening because the 72 hours doesn't pause on weekends. Police can't extend PP either.

Itisalwayspossibletobekind · 15/06/2023 18:56

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 17:17

How many calls from how many people including child screaming including existing sw concerns and a ban on the bf staying over would trigger removal

Theres no number of calls, assessments are made based on the situation of the family. From what I gather (not being involved in the case) the boyfriend wasn’t meant to be staying over but not banned from the property (social work don’t have the power to do that).

Existing concerns would form part of that assessment as would police reports but each case is assessed individually and they take time, and in most cases children remain at home while investigations are completed. Each call made will contribute to that investigation but children aren’t removed on the basis of a call from a neighbour.

Unless police had reason to believe the child was in immediate danger when they attended they have no grounds to use emergency powers to remove a child.

Social work have no power to remove a child at all - that decision is made by the courts based on information provided by services including social work and police and it’s not unusual for court to go against social work recommendations.

There will be a review of this case including police actions which will highlight gaps in practice, we’ll have a better idea then of any agency failings.

Thank you for the clear explanations of the various processes, and associated limitations. I just can't fathom why Alfie wasn't removed by the Police Officer when he was clearly in extreme immediate danger when the neighbour rang and reported Alfie being waterboarded, tortured and beaten at the very time the crime was happening. Especially given the wider context where so many other concerns had already been raised about him.

Just to be clear, I really appreciate you and all the other posters outlining the processes and am not expecting specific answers.

It is also clear that SWs processes take time, but the Police are the only ones with the powers to immediately remove children in immediate danger. I get that there is huge deception and cover up, but if a Police Officer arrived at a crime scene and found an adult who had just been subjected to the above torture, surely they would be able to ascertain that something was horrifically, hideously wrong?

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 15/06/2023 18:26

Exactly, that is what I am saying. The Police have powers SW dont.

potniatheron · 15/06/2023 17:47

OlympicProcrastinator · 15/06/2023 07:21

You need to have a good level of maths and English, a degree, plus the Step Up to Social Work is a graduate scheme whereby you gain another degree in social work. The starting pay is £32000 rising to £40000 with experience.

The comments on here blaming social workers are naive. You only see the ones missed. You have no idea how many children are rescued. A social worker could have a career and save hundreds of children, one gets missed and they are called incompetent.

It is not the fault of social workers, it’s the fault of the abusers. Contrary to popular belief, social workers don’t have the power to remove children, they need to have a high threshold of evidence to present in court and the court decided. Often courts go against social services. Only the police have the power to just walk in and take a child in immediate danger and we all know how underfunded they are.

Who would do a job where you are hated by the service users and you’ve got the general public calling for you to be jailed if you make the wrong call? Not me for sure.

And lessons do actually get learned. Serious case reviews have direct action on new ways of working that are implemented and will have saved many. But you’ll continue to only hear about the failures.

People will continue to berate the workers on the front line trying their best while the government continues to underfund the police, social services, family support, and CAHMS and the sentences given to dangerous offenders will carry on being paltry and ineffective.

The comments on here blaming social workers are naive. You only see the ones missed. You have no idea how many children are rescued. A social worker could have a career and save hundreds of children, one gets missed and they are called incompetent.

Exactly this. It's like with medicine. A heart surgeon could save hundreds of lives but she'll only be in the papers the one time she makes a mistake.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 17:17

How many calls from how many people including child screaming including existing sw concerns and a ban on the bf staying over would trigger removal

Theres no number of calls, assessments are made based on the situation of the family. From what I gather (not being involved in the case) the boyfriend wasn’t meant to be staying over but not banned from the property (social work don’t have the power to do that).

Existing concerns would form part of that assessment as would police reports but each case is assessed individually and they take time, and in most cases children remain at home while investigations are completed. Each call made will contribute to that investigation but children aren’t removed on the basis of a call from a neighbour.

Unless police had reason to believe the child was in immediate danger when they attended they have no grounds to use emergency powers to remove a child.

Social work have no power to remove a child at all - that decision is made by the courts based on information provided by services including social work and police and it’s not unusual for court to go against social work recommendations.

There will be a review of this case including police actions which will highlight gaps in practice, we’ll have a better idea then of any agency failings.

Tracker1234 · 15/06/2023 16:51

I wish they wouldnt call these animals step father's or partners. They are the Mother's latest lay. They certainly arent step fathers. I know that some will excuse this behaviour by saying the Mother has low self esteem but in this case it seems the woman had no boundaries. She put herself first so that this man would stay with her and went along with the beatings and abuse.

GobbolinoCat · 15/06/2023 16:46

And people tried evry single avenue to help including the school

GobbolinoCat · 15/06/2023 16:45

@MrsTerryPratchett

How many calls from how many people including child screaming including existing sw concerns and a ban on the bf staying over would trigger removal.

GobbolinoCat · 15/06/2023 16:42

@Itisalwayspossibletobekind

In don't personally know in this case but in past cases the boyfriend has hiden, or the mum has lied about where he is eg not there.

Also many times the police don't have access to the back ground files, so they are not armed with any useful information at all.

GobbolinoCat · 15/06/2023 16:37

Can anyone imagine the sort of people who would do this.

Not the sort of people you want to get on the wrong side of. Reporting comes with risk always.

People are putting themselves in potentially harms way to report these people time and time and to me again and yet nothing is done.

Itisalwayspossibletobekind · 15/06/2023 16:20

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 14:42

The thing is everyone has “evidence” sometimes recorded sometimes fabricate. Social work deal with all sections of society - the caring, concerned, Ernest, the judgmental, biased, prejudiced and the vengeful, abusive, hateful. It’s not always, or even often, clear. It’s the least black and white professions - we constantly operate in shades of grey.

It’s very easy to sit in your comfortable home, coffee in hand, with limited information and the benefit of hindsight, and decide what is and isn’t clear, what decisions were obvious and the absolutely correct course of action. But that’s not where social workers practice, ever.

I'm struggling to understand how the Police operate in this context. The neighbour called Police whilst one of the horrific, numerous crimes against Alfie was actually being committed. And from what I understand, an officer went round. What happens then? They (Police) had all the information about the boyfriend's prior convictions. From what I can understand, only the Police have /had the power to immediately remove a child in danger.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 14:59

And where are the NSPCC when these things happen? I know they’re always asking for donations but they are never mentioned in child abuse cases. I have never heard anything about them preventing them or helping in any way.

The NSPCC don’t do preventative or active child protection work - they’re essentially a campaigning organisation with a couple of helpline services and some therapeutic services. I always roll my eyes when folk say to contact the NSPCC - they just hand it to the local authority.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/06/2023 14:48

I've had fabricated evidence submitted. Three other people didn't see what I saw on the video which made the faking obvious once you'd spotted it.

I'm not saying everyone shouldn't strive for constant improvements. We all should, those of us with lives in our hands even more so. But pretending that if random MNers were doing the job all these deaths would have been prevented, while no innocent parents would lose their children is 100% bollocks.

Anyone remember the Orkney child abuse scandal? That's why we don't just remove.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/06/2023 14:42

The thing is everyone has “evidence” sometimes recorded sometimes fabricate. Social work deal with all sections of society - the caring, concerned, Ernest, the judgmental, biased, prejudiced and the vengeful, abusive, hateful. It’s not always, or even often, clear. It’s the least black and white professions - we constantly operate in shades of grey.

It’s very easy to sit in your comfortable home, coffee in hand, with limited information and the benefit of hindsight, and decide what is and isn’t clear, what decisions were obvious and the absolutely correct course of action. But that’s not where social workers practice, ever.

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 15/06/2023 14:37

Evidence, that should have said.

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 15/06/2023 14:36

That's why I said 'where there is proof'. In this situation the neighbours had recordings of the abuse happening in the garden.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/06/2023 14:24

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 15/06/2023 11:28

Maybe MPs should be lobbied to ensure Police remove and arrest adults from the house in the first instance of complaints of abuse of children, if there is evidence from neighbours, as there was in this case. If it had been an adult attacking another adult with proof or witnesses then the victim would be asked if they wanted to press charges, or apply for a restraining order. Someone in authority should be fighting for the rights of children who are probably too scared to speak up. The threat of a criminal record for child abuse at the first instance may be enough for that adult to leave the house if they are not the biological parent.

You're assuming all the neighbours are nice. Malicious calls are a huge huge proportion of calls to SS.

As a SW, how do you know if a call where the caller said, "the neighbours are abusing their children, you know what those Muslims are like" is just a racist, or a racist with very real and proper concerns? What about the place with neighbours giving the same story in the same words and the disabled mum says they are all out to get her? Same words either means it's rehearsed (and they are lying) or maybe just that they've discussed it before coming to you? Or the alcoholic neighbour complaining about the autistic child making noise at night, and the parents being absent, which sounds worrying? Is he reliable? Does he actually know it happened at 3am as he says when the parents' seem baffled and very scared of their neighbour?

There aren't cases with lovely, reliable, caring neighbours and evil child abusers with 666 on their heads. People all lie, say what they think they should, misremember, embellish. When you find these inconsistencies do you throw out all their concerns? Do you allow yourself to be a flying monkey for the harassment of innocent people and remove a loved child OR do you leave a child in place to be killed?

SW is a field where there is NO right answer. Hindsight with all the information, including the tragic death, makes it seem obvious and easy. 'Just remove' results in SS being accused of baby-snatching and leads to further abuse because foster families and children's group homes are worse than biological parents 90% of the time. Leaving in place means a risk of a poor child continuing to be abused by the parent(s).

captainjacksparrow · 15/06/2023 13:45

The types of reforms needed to resolve some of this are not (despite the outcry on this thread) popular options and not what the general public would agree.

for instance a pp asked why he wasn’t removed as soon as it was know he was living in the house - simply put, social workers have no right to do this or even make this decision. This is for the court to determine.

now you could increase powers so social workers had the right to entry, and the right to remove the same as the police but the vast majority of the public would fight this I expect

captainjacksparrow · 15/06/2023 13:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lovely 🤔do you often resort to name calling when someone challenges you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread