Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alfie Steele

313 replies

Ffswhatsthepoint · 13/06/2023 23:20

I checked there was no other thread before I posted this one. Alfie, 9, killed by mum and her bf. Drowned. A catalogue of abuse and many phone calls to police/ss by neighbours. The neighbours often fed him too. We HAVE to find people accountable in this case. It was reported. People knew. Nothing was done. Absolutely nothing. Its harrowing. I feel like I failed him. And I'm hundreds of miles away.

OP posts:
Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 06:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Simonjt · 14/06/2023 06:52

And that’s the problem - my two year old attends a private day nursery and we attend a couple of groups for toddlers, but unsurprisingly the parents of the abused and neglected don’t gravitate there.

Oh trust me, they do.

DelphiniumBlue · 14/06/2023 06:52

Sorry to hear that, Simonjt.
lve seen your posts over the years, enough to know that you are a genuine and empathetic person- how do you think outcomes can be improved?

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 06:52

DelphiniumBlue · 14/06/2023 05:55

I've been struck by comments on here about there being a shortage of foster carers. Are there no children's homes any more? I know there was a move to place children with families, but does that mean that children's homes don't exist now?
And obviously I'm aware of some the problems with children's homes, but surely the same issues can arise with individual foster carers.
I think the whole sector needs an urgent review on structure, funding, training and pay.

Very few. They don't have good outcomes for children at ALL. Children's homes tend to be privately run, very expensive and for the most challenging to place children/teenagers.they are no substitute for foster carers.

Elderflowerraspberry · 14/06/2023 06:50

I must say that I think the repeated use of the word ‘bleating’ to dismiss peoples concerns is both inappropriate, given the circumstances, and actually quite misogynistic.

Lockdowns have clearly been a contributing factor but the list of ‘advice’ given above is misguided at best (although it isn’t sincere.) I don’t vote Tory, but I also know that several very high profile cases of this nature happened deep in the heart of a Labour government - Victoria Climbie, Peter Connolly, Zachary Turner, as well as the grooming gangs scandals and those who abused children in plain sight spanning decades, so straddling many different governments (Savile obviously the most infamous.) It isn’t so much about a government but more about an inherent attitude we have as a society as to what it means to be a child and what will be tolerated.

Then ‘Be important in the life of a child.’ How? Go out and find a random one? I don’t want to sound facetious, the subject is too serious for that, but I do think it’s one of those comments that is largely meaningless.

Volunteer? Some of us genuinely aren’t in a position to do this, and an unreliable / poor volunteer is no help to anybody. We should ideally be welcoming all children into our homes, but that will realistically only come about if you have children old enough to organise their own socialising. And that’s the problem - my two year old attends a private day nursery and we attend a couple of groups for toddlers, but unsurprisingly the parents of the abused and neglected don’t gravitate there. Likewise, we should care about our neighbours and people did care and have cared but it didn’t save the child.

Fostering requires a lot of things that many people do not have; a spare bedroom for a start, an ability to work very flexible or to give up work altogether, a certain gap between your youngest child and youngest foster child. And yet if you don’t do it, you can’t pass comment on cases such as this?

Human nature being what it is, awful things will sometimes happen and I certainly don’t wish to malign social workers. I do however think it is reasonable to ask why this child remained, and can do so without being accused of ‘bleating’ or being told that since I am not a social worker myself I can’t pass comment Hmm

Brefugee · 14/06/2023 06:46

Greenshake · 14/06/2023 00:15

@Notcontent I agree - but again, people are always outraged until it involves them actually doing something pro-active. I remember getting ripped apart on here a few months ago when I commented that I had intervened in a situation where a parent was walloping a child.

Yhe Problem here is that there were multiple reports.

Check out all the threads on here with "some ol' cow asked my kid not to stand at the bottom of the slide stopping other kids playing on it" and the General (not completely universal) consensus is: nobody is allowed to speak to my kid or me.

That is the overwhelming impression I get - people are afraid to do more than report. For a variety of reasons.

The answer: more investment in social services, schools, clubs etc. More support for parents. More, much more money

Simonjt · 14/06/2023 06:44

DelphiniumBlue · 14/06/2023 05:55

I've been struck by comments on here about there being a shortage of foster carers. Are there no children's homes any more? I know there was a move to place children with families, but does that mean that children's homes don't exist now?
And obviously I'm aware of some the problems with children's homes, but surely the same issues can arise with individual foster carers.
I think the whole sector needs an urgent review on structure, funding, training and pay.

As someone who spent time in a group home, I was better cared for, better fed and safer with my abusive parent than I was in the group home.

ohfook · 14/06/2023 06:41

DelphiniumBlue · 14/06/2023 05:55

I've been struck by comments on here about there being a shortage of foster carers. Are there no children's homes any more? I know there was a move to place children with families, but does that mean that children's homes don't exist now?
And obviously I'm aware of some the problems with children's homes, but surely the same issues can arise with individual foster carers.
I think the whole sector needs an urgent review on structure, funding, training and pay.

Group homes exist. Just like everything publicly funded they are understaffed by low paid workers. They are not nice places for children to be and I understand why a SW would choose to attempt to rehabilitate a family rather than send a child there.

I agree with a previous poster, we need more foster carers desperately.

SpringIntoChaos · 14/06/2023 06:37

I was looking on my local government job website only yesterday. As I scrolled down it became apparent pretty quickly that there was a massive crisis in SW recruitment. I counted 38 jobs in my small county alone. 38 social worker jobs that needed filling!!! Just in my county! If that's a snapshot countrywide the service must be absolutely broken!

I'm not a SW by the way and wouldn't want to be for any amount of money!! I can't imagine what the staff are going through right now...how they must be getting through their caseloads with the crisis in society that we are seeing!

ohfook · 14/06/2023 06:34

Jailing social workers is not the answer. It'll just lead to even less people wanting to be one.

I work alongside social workers some times and in my career I've seen their case load triple and the structure that they work within become more restrictive. As with most professions I see competent and incompetent people but, without fail, I see the workload of the best ones get piled and piled and piled upon until they no longer have the time to build relationships with the very families and children who need it. They inevitably leave the profession when they are the very people we need to stay. The fact is that a very good social worker could be dealing with 20-30 potential Alfie's in one go all in the knowledge that if the very worst happens on your watch then you'll be hung out to dry. It's not a job I would do for any amount of money.

The fact is we need greater acceptance that the two biggest markers for this type of situation are poverty and the presence of a step parent in the home and a huge drive to recruit more social workers to drastically reduce the case loads down to between 7 and 10 families max.

Simianwalk · 14/06/2023 06:34

LifeIsPainHighness · 13/06/2023 23:51

People will say SWs are overworked and tired but I’ve worked with many and never met a competent one. I’m surprised half of them could simple maths let alone assess the risk a child is in.

I disagree I've worked with a few and some are amazing. However all have ridiculous caseloads, massively underfunded, and very little support for families in crisis. I bet the evil fucker that killed him grew up in a violent household (not an excuse but a reason why we must support the children of abuse). I work with families who had been through domestic violence and there is fuck all for children in terms of counseling support etc. The cycle just goes on.

Dhama · 14/06/2023 06:30

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2023 02:31

As someone who used to have a caseload of 10s of people who this could happen to, who was overworked, underpaid, blamed and pilloried for existing, and everyone knew better than me how to do my job... I left.

People think SWs have a caseload of maybe 20, with one person where this could happen. It's more like 100, where in 50 cases this could happen. There are NO easy cases. SWs aren't psychic, they have to assess, listen to unreliable witnesses who all lie, knowing that removing a child will definitely fuck their whole life up. Definitely.

SWs save lives every day but it is completely invisible. They can't talk about it and no one knows.

If you think SWs are thick (from this thread), incompetent (from everywhere) and lazy and heartless, retrain. Do it yourself. Quickly while you know everything. Make sure to never make a mistake, never miss anything, know who is lying, know who is telling the truth and finish all your work while there's still time to sleep and eat.

Or:

  1. Don't vote Tory
  2. Be important in the life of a child
  3. Volunteer
  4. Welcome the DC who are smelly, poorly behaved and violent to your homes
  5. Actually care about your neighbours
  6. Foster
  7. Don't vote Tory

I know it's easier to blame the people who do the hard work while you're sitting on your arse, but the fact is violent abuse happens every day. It's constant. You just don't have to see it every day. SWs do, poor bastards.

This with absolute bells on.

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2023 06:27

Police and sw's need more powers to be able to remove a child who is clearly being abused. The fact that the police were called numerous times by the neighbours and did nothing about it is appalling.

cornflakesandtea · 14/06/2023 06:26

I read about this this morning. The recording of that poor little lad screaming for them to open the door broke my heart. How can people, his own mother, be so cruel?
I don't know the answer but I hope to god that poor boy is at peace now.

loislovesstewie · 14/06/2023 06:22

No, you don't find many children's homes any more, the ones that exist are usually for kids too disturbed to be in foster care.

loislovesstewie · 14/06/2023 06:20

I think,firstly ,we should ask ,why do so many women have relationships with men who are to put it bluntly complete bastards? Why do so many single mothers prioritize the men over their own flesh and blood? Why do they fail to protect despite being warned of the consequences? I've sat with women who have been assaulted by their partners and told them they have to protect their child, only to be told he wouldn't hurt them. I've been trying to get them to a place of safety for crying out loud, and they are happy to stay with a man who beats them senseless, and they think the kids are OK.
I actually think the mother, in this case, should get life, because she allowed this.

JuneOsborne · 14/06/2023 06:17

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 14/06/2023 00:53

People need to stop voting for a government that obliterates the public sector and children's services and makes the social worker job impossible to do safely as they are stretched so thin

This is it, isn't it? Who'd be a children's social worker? Pay is rubbish, but you need a degree to do it. Cases coming in, left right and centre, with no where near enough staff to see to all of the cases. They're often subject to abuse themselves (I know of a children social worker who did take children away and they were subject to an horrific campaign of abuse, tik tok videos with the man threatening to rape her, kill her, burn down her house. Telling the world her name and address. And threatening to kill her kids. And more). Society views them dimly too.

Combined with an ethos that removal of children is to be avoided, and one that is difficult to achieve due to the process involved, the threshold required.

Let's not forget that the monsters responsible for this are the people who tortured that kid. The adults involved in this will be liars, manipulators, and accomplished deceptors.

I remember watching a TV show, possibly benefits street, with a child who had ss involvement. The kid had the filthiest feet. But as soon as any kind of appointment came up, they made sure he was clean and tidy. Not an extreme case but a really good example of there being no evidence for the sw.

We need double, triple, even quadruple the staff in these services. They need better tools, better support, the service needs more money. The courts need more sittings to hear their emergency cases (I know of a couple of courts that are currently not taking any LA cases, at all, so they have to use courts in the neighbouring counties, who are already stretched). And the same for other places that children come into contact, like schools. Schools don't have enough teachers or support staff, so the wider network that often props up a system like social services are decimated.

Until we put the safety and welfare of children first this will continue to happen. And even then, I'm sure cases like this will still get through. Evil people will find a way. But at least if ss we're funded and staffed and resourced properly, these cases, I think, would be come the exception rather than the norm.

I can't get on board with blaming social workers on an individual level.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 06:11

DaisesOnAChain · 14/06/2023 00:08

It is harrowing. The parents are pure evil. That poor boy lived a life of terror and abuse. He has been failed :(

I am wondering, are the social workers responsible, or is it the courts? I have read a few AMA social worker threads on here and they seem to say SWs don't have power to remove children, as this is a decision made by the courts?

That's correct
police Can remove a child for 72 hours but social workers cannot remove a child without a court order.
emergency court applications are possible but rarely used. Court applications are expected to be planned and work MUST be attempted with families before an application is made. In order to go to court social workers MUST have evidence. In the case of Alfie they needed to have the evidence that this man was still in the house. Sometimes we know what's happening but we are waiting for the evidence we need to go to court. That's how the system works.

Simonjt · 14/06/2023 06:08

clpsmum · 13/06/2023 23:42

I genuinely for life of me cannot understand for a second how the social workers can just do nothing

Because they don’t have the power to.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 06:07

Tigofigo · 13/06/2023 23:48

Is the problem that SS is understaffed / overworked / there's pressure to keep children with their parents?

Rather than SS just being incompetent?

And if the yare incompetent maybe we need to ask why. Who'd become a social worker these days, with the caseloads and underwhelming pay?

Of course ALL social workers aren't incompetent 🙄🙄🙄
yes the problem is systemic. Training is underfunded so there aren't enough of them, meaning the work is excessive and gruelling, as well as being emotionally draining. It's an incredibly challenging career and not particularly well paid.
social workers protect children every day. You have no idea how many children aren't hurt and killed because of social workers.

MrsClatterbuck · 14/06/2023 06:02

I used to work in a bank and we had to do a money laundering course each year. If you suspected someone was money laundering but didn't report you could go to prison don't remember the sentence but was at least 4 years I think . Money more important than a child's life.

WilkinsonM · 14/06/2023 06:01

UpaladderwatchingTV · 13/06/2023 23:40

We were talking about this this evening, as a PP said, it's always 'lessons will be learned' and yet they never are. It seems there are more and more cases of child murder by parents every year. Maybe it's time they started giving prison sentences to social workers, or those who were made aware what was happening, but failed to act, as well as the perpetrators, it would actually make a difference? It just seems that these people never actually take responsibility for failing these poor children, it's an absolute disgrace.

Actually there are not more children murdered every year. The numbers are stable. We would want them to go down of course but life means sadly there will always be parents who manage to murder their kids. We work incredibly hard and keep thousands and thousands of children safe every year. Threatening to jail social workers is a sure way to increase the number of dead kids 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄 good plan

Goodadvice1980 · 14/06/2023 05:57

They have learnt nothing from the tragic death of Jasmine Beckford.

DelphiniumBlue · 14/06/2023 05:55

I've been struck by comments on here about there being a shortage of foster carers. Are there no children's homes any more? I know there was a move to place children with families, but does that mean that children's homes don't exist now?
And obviously I'm aware of some the problems with children's homes, but surely the same issues can arise with individual foster carers.
I think the whole sector needs an urgent review on structure, funding, training and pay.

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2023 02:31

As someone who used to have a caseload of 10s of people who this could happen to, who was overworked, underpaid, blamed and pilloried for existing, and everyone knew better than me how to do my job... I left.

People think SWs have a caseload of maybe 20, with one person where this could happen. It's more like 100, where in 50 cases this could happen. There are NO easy cases. SWs aren't psychic, they have to assess, listen to unreliable witnesses who all lie, knowing that removing a child will definitely fuck their whole life up. Definitely.

SWs save lives every day but it is completely invisible. They can't talk about it and no one knows.

If you think SWs are thick (from this thread), incompetent (from everywhere) and lazy and heartless, retrain. Do it yourself. Quickly while you know everything. Make sure to never make a mistake, never miss anything, know who is lying, know who is telling the truth and finish all your work while there's still time to sleep and eat.

Or:

  1. Don't vote Tory
  2. Be important in the life of a child
  3. Volunteer
  4. Welcome the DC who are smelly, poorly behaved and violent to your homes
  5. Actually care about your neighbours
  6. Foster
  7. Don't vote Tory

I know it's easier to blame the people who do the hard work while you're sitting on your arse, but the fact is violent abuse happens every day. It's constant. You just don't have to see it every day. SWs do, poor bastards.