Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to social services re: my niece and nephews...

528 replies

mrsneate · 13/06/2023 21:48

To cut a long story short, this is the fourth time in 9 years social services are involved with my brother and his children.

The first time. I drove 200 miles with no notice to collect Brother and his three kids. They lived with me for 8 months. It was hell. Small 3 bed house, 3 children of my own and my ex husband (we were still married) I supported them all financially, got them into schools, he was then given a council property, the children were taken off the register (on it because of their mum)

Fast forward 3 years, a neighbour reported him for various things. They were put back on the register, my brother worked with them, I supported him.

18 months ago, 2am police knock on my door with my eldest nephew. (16 at this point!) him and dad had gotten into a physical fight, could I take him, of course I said yes, the next day social worker came round, when police had entered their property. It was t fit to live in. Stinking dirty, rubbish everywhere.

Me and my SIL (other brothers wife) went round, and blitzed his house, I did 20 loads of washing, 16 dishwasher cycles. The house was spotless.

They asked me to take all 3. I couldn't, I work full time night shifts and was a single parent, my nephew was with me for 10 weeks with no support from
Social services or my brother financial or otherwise, then my nephew was 17 and could decide he wanted to go home. He went home. Case was closed

This week, I randomly had a phone call from a social worker. There had been an anonymous report from someone that he was leaving the youngest alone for long periods (she's 11) and there was no food in the house. He's drinking all the time, the house is a state.

I only ever see my brother these days when he pops to my house with my niece. She always looks clean.

They told me it's looking like it's going down the route of removing the children (11 and 16?) and would I be in a position to take them in, until he decides to cooperate and work with them, told them no, although I'm no longer single, my fiancé works away for months at a time and I still work night shifts, and still only live in a 3 bed house with 2 of my boys (oldest has moved out) she got really arrogant with me after that. I pointed out they need to stop closing the case, keep them on the register.

But guilt is eating me up, there has been a suggestion they go back to their mother. But that will be a disaster. I have text my brother and offered to help him clean the house. Again, but I am
Pissed off with him, and it's annoying me that he keeps having passes because he's a male single parent! He works school hours and earns good money, he's not skint.

What would you do?

OP posts:
Phineyj · 14/06/2023 13:43

I definitely wouldn't be so sure that DC whose needs are neglected for a sibling or cousin (or whatever reason) grow up totally sanguine about it.

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:42

whumpthereitis · 14/06/2023 13:37

People can be certain and still post to vent. It isn’t always an invitation to have their mind changed.

You may think it a reasonable sacrifice to make on behalf of your children, but that isn’t necessarily what your children would think. And that is something that could very easily have lifelong repercussions on all of you, and lead to far more regret than refusing to take them would.

Fair enough. Probably she’s made up her mind already. But she did ask what others would do and that is going to attract a variety of responses including ones like mine which are - without a second thought - i’d take the kids.

HerbsandSpices · 14/06/2023 13:40

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:31

Yes definitely. I mean, i wouldn’t murder my own kids to save the lives of my nieces and nephews or put them through physical torture or whatever but in terms of my life priorities i personally would consider my nieces and nephews as almost on a par with my own kids.

So if it meant making do, sharing rooms, going without etc, yes i would definitely do this. My sister and brother would do the same for mine too. To us, that’s family.

So you would compromise the well being of a non-NT child by making them share a room when they really need their own space? You would deprive your children of things like (maybe) extra-curriculars, life experiences, the ability to save to support them through further education if they take the route, allow your relationship with them and their cousins to possibly be damaged by the whole experience, compromise your own ability to support yourself so that it impacts your own old age (and maybe puts stress on your kids, if they are inclined to financially aid you)? You would make yourself less available to support your own child with developmental challenges and risk your own mental health, which would make you less capable of meeting the needs of your own children? You would risk putting so much stress on your own relationship that it may end, reducing your income even further, demanding more sacrifice of your children?

It's easy to be idealistic when your not in someone else's shoes. I also wonder if the same would be expected so readily of a man who has a family to support.

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:40

jeaux90 · 14/06/2023 13:37

There is absolutely no way OP should be forcing her ADHD child to share, or bring other kids with SEN etc full time into the home. God some of these posters have absolutely no clue.

OP find a sentence you are comfortable with for the meeting with the SW tomorrow, keep repeating it.

I have a child with severe SEN so it’s not a fair assumption that i don’t have a clue.

Phineyj · 14/06/2023 13:40

I don't think I would give up work, go on benefits and make my partner's life much harder when I'd already spent nearly a decade helping my (employed!) sibling.

It would be throwing good money after bad and not actually helping anyone long term. If you cover household costs for a substance abuser, you're indirectly enabling the habit.

I'd consider it my duty to stay stable and solvent in that situation for the sake of my own dependents and so I could at least be a reliable relative and role model outside the household for the niece and nephews.

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:37

monsteramunch · 14/06/2023 13:21

I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids

Ok but what if doing the former means you aren't doing the latter?

If protecting your siblings' kids meant you were risking the stability of your own kids?

That's the conflict here, it's not as simple as people are making out.

Ok so we could get into silly ground here. If an evil wizard asked me to choose between the literal lives of my kids or nieces and nephews or my own kids, obviously i would choose my own.

If taking in my siblings kids meant mine had to suffer in terms of reduced time from me, possible reduction in academic attainment (because i guess in this scenario i don’t have time to help them with homework), having less space, worse food as we can’t afford nice food any more, worse christmases, more instability… for me personally, i would think those were an acceptable trade for protecting my siblings’ kids. I have a son with special needs and often meeting his needs means his brother goes without and that to me is similar. My younger son will understand when he’s older that we had to prioritise my elder son’s needs at times. Equally in the fictional situation that i take in my sibling’s children, i would feel that my children were learning a far more important lesson around looking after others, making sacrifices for family and so on.

whumpthereitis · 14/06/2023 13:37

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:19

The OP asked what would [I] do. So that’s my answer. I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids, and if I didn’t I would regret it forever. However the OP is not me, so may well feel differently. We all have different views and priorities. I guess if she was that certain though she wouldn’t post on mumsnet asking.

People can be certain and still post to vent. It isn’t always an invitation to have their mind changed.

You may think it a reasonable sacrifice to make on behalf of your children, but that isn’t necessarily what your children would think. And that is something that could very easily have lifelong repercussions on all of you, and lead to far more regret than refusing to take them would.

jeaux90 · 14/06/2023 13:37

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:31

Yes definitely. I mean, i wouldn’t murder my own kids to save the lives of my nieces and nephews or put them through physical torture or whatever but in terms of my life priorities i personally would consider my nieces and nephews as almost on a par with my own kids.

So if it meant making do, sharing rooms, going without etc, yes i would definitely do this. My sister and brother would do the same for mine too. To us, that’s family.

There is absolutely no way OP should be forcing her ADHD child to share, or bring other kids with SEN etc full time into the home. God some of these posters have absolutely no clue.

OP find a sentence you are comfortable with for the meeting with the SW tomorrow, keep repeating it.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 14/06/2023 13:35

eurochick · 13/06/2023 22:47

You mention another sil who helped you clean. Where is your other brother in this?

Indeed. All the caring responsibilities automatically get dumped onto the women, without even blinking.

CecilyP · 14/06/2023 13:33

My sister and brother would do the same for mine too. To us, that’s family.

I bet your sister and brother are great parents too, so you wouldn't be in this situation!

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:31

Yes definitely. I mean, i wouldn’t murder my own kids to save the lives of my nieces and nephews or put them through physical torture or whatever but in terms of my life priorities i personally would consider my nieces and nephews as almost on a par with my own kids.

So if it meant making do, sharing rooms, going without etc, yes i would definitely do this. My sister and brother would do the same for mine too. To us, that’s family.

Phineyj · 14/06/2023 13:30

I think you should also bear in mind all the families who will be indirectly harmed by you quitting your job.

You would be very hard to replace and have a passion for what you do.

My niece is a happy healthy 15 year old. She was cared for by SCBU nurses in her first few weeks of life.

Thank you for what you do.

monsteramunch · 14/06/2023 13:21

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:19

The OP asked what would [I] do. So that’s my answer. I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids, and if I didn’t I would regret it forever. However the OP is not me, so may well feel differently. We all have different views and priorities. I guess if she was that certain though she wouldn’t post on mumsnet asking.

I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids

Ok but what if doing the former means you aren't doing the latter?

If protecting your siblings' kids meant you were risking the stability of your own kids?

That's the conflict here, it's not as simple as people are making out.

HerbsandSpices · 14/06/2023 13:21

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:19

The OP asked what would [I] do. So that’s my answer. I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids, and if I didn’t I would regret it forever. However the OP is not me, so may well feel differently. We all have different views and priorities. I guess if she was that certain though she wouldn’t post on mumsnet asking.

Even if your own kids would suffer because of it?

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 13:19

The OP asked what would [I] do. So that’s my answer. I’d do anything to protect my siblings’ kids even if it meant making huge sacrifices, just as i would protect my own kids, and if I didn’t I would regret it forever. However the OP is not me, so may well feel differently. We all have different views and priorities. I guess if she was that certain though she wouldn’t post on mumsnet asking.

whumpthereitis · 14/06/2023 13:16

Betsybetty · 14/06/2023 11:51

Look, I understand what you are saying, OP’s own children being negatively affected, it is the Social Services that need to be taking care of them, in some cases it has turned out better for kids to be given to foster care etc. etc. One can equally argue that also in some cases foster care works out shit for children, that SS are shit themselves (sorry, under pressure), and in some cases own children won’t be too negatively affected but will actually be one big happy family. No-one can know or predict the actual result in ten years time, and no-one knows the personalities of people involved here, do you?

So what I am saying is, given these uncertainties, I would personally do what I could realistically have control over to reduce that uncertainty - which is taking an action to give them the best house I can. Yes that involves sacrifice. I would be willing to do that sacrifice, if the alternative was an uncertain future in foster care. Others can feel free to advice otherwise, this is what I feel and would do, given the information we have.

It’s a huge gamble to take with the well-being of her own children, and frankly a stupid one. She’s listed the glaring issues, and it’s clear that if there’s a possibility of it turning into ‘one big happy family’, it’s an incredibly slight one. It’s all very well sacrificing your own needs, but sacrificing those of your children is another matter entirely.

She isn’t responsible for her brothers children in any way, shape or form, and despite this she’s already gone above and beyond. It’s totally fair for her to say ‘no more’.

anyway, that’s beside the point. She’s said no.

Triptoqueen · 14/06/2023 13:10

Won't you have to allow access for the parents to see these DCs.
It's not that you will have them and be fully supported. It's that you will be left to get on with it also, possibly, arranging diffcult access to the DPs on a regular basis which won't help with their mental health or yours.
I think for the 2 kids fostering long term is the best option.
You really don't have time to look after 2 probably damaged teenagers. For their sake don't take them on.

igor · 14/06/2023 13:06

There is no possible way that you can take the children in.

There's no room, no resources and your responsibility lies with your own children.

It's shit, but it's your brothers doing - I'd hope that the possibility of actually losing them might give him the shake up he needs, but I highly doubt it.

The SW is lazy and projecting onto your guilt to make her own job easier, she's just pushing them from one bad situation to what will become another bad situation

JenniferBooth · 14/06/2023 13:03

@mrsneate That meeting tomorrow? Record it

CecilyP · 14/06/2023 13:02

KingsHeath53 · 14/06/2023 11:23

What would i do? I’d take the kids. Family is everything and those kids need stability. It sucks that some people get dealt a rough hand with having to clean up after family members but on your deathbed i think you’d regret it more if you knew you could have done more.

Alternatively, the older boys stay where they are as they are capable of taking care of themselves if their dad is out all day. And the 11 year old girl gets placed with a caring foster family who have both the time and the space to accommodate her and won't have the personal connection to the dad which means they won't be constantly furious with him.

mrsneate · 14/06/2023 12:42

Betsybetty · 14/06/2023 11:09

Op I read your posts. Tbh, it sounds like you made your mind up, and are using this thread to justify it to yourself because you feel guilty. There's no answer, you have to work if out yourself. Between a career and two vulnerable children I'd choose the children. On your deathbed, what will you regret more? Having your career or abondaning two kids? All the kids are not so young, its really a few years of sacrifice. This is my personal opinion.

My career is what gives my own children the life they have. I would loose a lot of money each month if I stopped working my current job and night shifts, it's not just about my career, my kids had it pretty shit with their own father (who thankfully has sorted his shit out now!) and I spent years struggling to feed and clothe them. I am not taking that away from them. I did my degree as a single mum to 3 children over 5 years, to give my children a better life.

If I take my niece in, my youngest boy would have to share with his older brother (who has adhd and prone to outbursts and meltdowns!) and lose his bedroom,

I would be down about £1000 a month and struggle to pay mortgage and bills. I'd still have to find child care and pay for child care for 12/13 hour day shifts. Or Monday to Friday 8-6 IF I could get a community role. They are few and far between.

I could have stayed on benefits and lived off the state as a single mum, but I didn't want that,

Me and my fiancé have made the decision to not have a child together because of the massive impact it would have on our of our lives and finances, the impact of taking an 11 year old girl with many issues doesn't just affect me.

OP posts:
Hecatoncheires · 14/06/2023 12:40

OP, it sounds like you have done a lot for your brother and his children. You are absolutely right not to sacrifice your own children's lives to take on your niece and nephews. As you say, this would only end up with 6 unhappy children. You sound like a lovely sister and auntie and I wish you all the best with a very difficult situation.

JenniferBooth · 14/06/2023 12:35

As a Social Worker, I would take the 11 year old. I think its so sad when children end up in care and feel rejected by their families

This is the kind of emotional blackmail people are complaining about. Im child free by choice. I have a niece who is now 28. DB was/is a decent father but if he hadnt been and i had been asked to take her in the answer would have been no. "rejected by their familes" Parents and grandparents chose to have kids.

Those of us who are aunts or uncles get NO SAY in whether our sibling chooses to procreate or not. But perhaps we should if this is to be expected of us. I would strongly object to being guilt tripped and emotionally blackmailed when mother hood is not the life i have chosen. And for good reason. I just havent got the patience for a kid. And maybe if more people realised that before deciding to have children there wouldnt be situations like this and bullying social workers wouldnt be harassing other family members.

WhatNoRaisins · 14/06/2023 12:24

It's all well and good telling the OP to make a sacrifice for these children but,

a. It's not just her that makes a sacrifice, she has to decide to make it on behalf of her own children

b. It doesn't even mean a happy outcome necessarily. What if she makes the sacrifice for them, finds she can't help them, they end up in a bad way as adults and she's damaged her relationship with her children for nothing?

longtompot · 14/06/2023 12:22

I hope the meeting with the SW goes well tomorrow.

Their thoughtless comment to you reminded me of one made by an Occupational health person who was assessing our house for DFG and said why did we buy such an unsuitable house! I was gobsmacked and just laughed, but it still annoys me to this day, about 5 years later. Because it was the best house in our price bracket. With a bit of tweaking it will be perfect. I wish she saw the others we viewed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread