Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to social services re: my niece and nephews...

528 replies

mrsneate · 13/06/2023 21:48

To cut a long story short, this is the fourth time in 9 years social services are involved with my brother and his children.

The first time. I drove 200 miles with no notice to collect Brother and his three kids. They lived with me for 8 months. It was hell. Small 3 bed house, 3 children of my own and my ex husband (we were still married) I supported them all financially, got them into schools, he was then given a council property, the children were taken off the register (on it because of their mum)

Fast forward 3 years, a neighbour reported him for various things. They were put back on the register, my brother worked with them, I supported him.

18 months ago, 2am police knock on my door with my eldest nephew. (16 at this point!) him and dad had gotten into a physical fight, could I take him, of course I said yes, the next day social worker came round, when police had entered their property. It was t fit to live in. Stinking dirty, rubbish everywhere.

Me and my SIL (other brothers wife) went round, and blitzed his house, I did 20 loads of washing, 16 dishwasher cycles. The house was spotless.

They asked me to take all 3. I couldn't, I work full time night shifts and was a single parent, my nephew was with me for 10 weeks with no support from
Social services or my brother financial or otherwise, then my nephew was 17 and could decide he wanted to go home. He went home. Case was closed

This week, I randomly had a phone call from a social worker. There had been an anonymous report from someone that he was leaving the youngest alone for long periods (she's 11) and there was no food in the house. He's drinking all the time, the house is a state.

I only ever see my brother these days when he pops to my house with my niece. She always looks clean.

They told me it's looking like it's going down the route of removing the children (11 and 16?) and would I be in a position to take them in, until he decides to cooperate and work with them, told them no, although I'm no longer single, my fiancé works away for months at a time and I still work night shifts, and still only live in a 3 bed house with 2 of my boys (oldest has moved out) she got really arrogant with me after that. I pointed out they need to stop closing the case, keep them on the register.

But guilt is eating me up, there has been a suggestion they go back to their mother. But that will be a disaster. I have text my brother and offered to help him clean the house. Again, but I am
Pissed off with him, and it's annoying me that he keeps having passes because he's a male single parent! He works school hours and earns good money, he's not skint.

What would you do?

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 14/06/2023 01:33

There’s no point listening to people who are heroes only hypothetically. Everyone who’s sure they’d take them has no idea what they’d really do, and there’s nothing stopping them from registering as a foster carer if they think it’s so straightforward and they’re so caring.

If you can’t, you can’t. Only you know that. I’m sorry your brother and his wife have put you in this position.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 14/06/2023 01:31

You don't have to do anything. It's easy for us to say we'd take them when it's not our lives.

Would I take my sisters toddler? Yes. But that's one child and I haven't had the pain you've had before.

Only you know what you can cope with. They won't have a good life in care, but that's not your fault. You're not the shit parent your brother is.

Would it be good if you to take them? Of course. But it's not your responsibility to yank your finances and life for them.

Only you can decide. You have a life and children. Only you can make that decision.

Cindan · 14/06/2023 01:26

It sounds like you simply don’t have enough space to accommodate the kids.

I really feel for the children though. If they were accommodated elsewhere do you and your other brother could have the kids round once a fortnight each to hang out for the day and have dinner?

They will be so much at risk emotionally and educationally but even one strong relationship with a loving stable adult can protect them and give them a good chance. It wouldn’t have to be accommodating them full-time but being in their life, encouraging them at school, taking them on days out or holidays together for enrichment etc etc. Showing them they are loved and part of a family.

Would their father be willing to get treatment for alcohol? Could there be something else going on with him - ADHD , anxiety, depression? That could be ameliorated with medication or therapy?

BillyBraggisnotmylover · 14/06/2023 01:19

I don’t know if it’s been mentioned already OP but you could suggest a family group conference to the social worker (if they haven’t already) which could lots of you getting together, with support, to consider the options available for either caring for the children or supporting your brother to care for them.

user1492757084 · 14/06/2023 01:15

Your brother needs to man up and take responsibilities for his own drinking. Long term that is the best sustainable positive outcome.
Help clean up the house. Arrange for your brother to join AA.
Seek SS help for services to assist him. What cleaners are available?
Are there meals on wheels?
Is there a charity that will help brother attend AA meetings?
Do foster carers care part time for 11 year olds - a day or two per week?
Your brother needs to thank his family for past help but realise that his children are at risk unless he changes and takes control of many aspects of his life.
Will any area of SS support him to correct his drinking?

Otherwise, you can not give full time care. Have the kids for holiday sometimes to relieve foster carers and to maintain communication about whether the foster carers are suitable.

WhyWhyWhyMum · 14/06/2023 01:05

Cakeandcoffee93 · 14/06/2023 01:01

it doesn’t make sense the system- if you foster you get 500 a week per child- but if it’s one you know you get nothing.
surely it’s better for you to have them and get the money support

In my LA you do get paid to foster relatives

BillyBraggisnotmylover · 14/06/2023 01:04

Cakeandcoffee93 · 14/06/2023 01:01

it doesn’t make sense the system- if you foster you get 500 a week per child- but if it’s one you know you get nothing.
surely it’s better for you to have them and get the money support

That’s not the case. If you take on a child are an alternative to them going into care, then the council has duties to you and the child, including financially supporting the placement. It’s really, really important that people wait to be asked and are clearly asking the question “will they go into care if I don’t do this” (and get the response documented) so that there can be no “confusion” or avoidance of duties further down the line.

BillyBraggisnotmylover · 14/06/2023 01:02

WhyWhyWhyMum · 14/06/2023 00:59

You could become a kinship foster carer for them and receive help (monetary and other support)

www.gov.uk/looking-after-someone-elses-child

As has been pointed out above, OP’s circumstances make it unlikely she’d get through a viability assessment.

Cakeandcoffee93 · 14/06/2023 01:01

it doesn’t make sense the system- if you foster you get 500 a week per child- but if it’s one you know you get nothing.
surely it’s better for you to have them and get the money support

WhyWhyWhyMum · 14/06/2023 00:59

You could become a kinship foster carer for them and receive help (monetary and other support)

www.gov.uk/looking-after-someone-elses-child

Idkdy · 14/06/2023 00:50

What about a State boarding school for the 11 year old? They do not charge for academic fees and just boarding fees only and even then can be subsidised. Can your brother pay for that or SW step in and facilitate this?

https://www.gov.uk/types-of-school/state-boarding-schools#:~:text=State%20boarding%20schools%20provide%20free,assess%20children's%20suitability%20for%20boarding.

This webpage has a guide to state boarding schools and list of then (about 35 in the country)
https://www.boarding.org.uk/for-parents-pupils/types-of-boarding-school/

I do not have any experience of what you are going through, so no advice just wishing the best for a positive outcome for your brother's kids.

Types of school

Types of school and how they're run - community schools, academies, free schools, faith schools, state boarding schools

https://www.gov.uk/types-of-school/state-boarding-schools#:~:text=State%20boarding%20schools%20provide%20free,assess%20children's%20suitability%20for%20boarding.

Fiddlefall · 14/06/2023 00:35

Soscrewed · 13/06/2023 22:56

I don't often post, but I cannot believe the number of posters suggesting you just take them or go in and clean the house regularly.

You can't do this. You don't have capacity. It's not fair on you, your children or your nieces and nephews. They need to be moved to Foster care, to someone who has the time and experience to support them. You can visit and send card and gifts and support from afar. (If you want). But this is not your problem, so don't feel guilty. And when the dust has settled complain about that social worker.

They do it to try and get the case off their desk. And the more involved and helpful you are, the more they push.

You sound lovely and I'm sorry upi are going through this as it must be very upsetting.

but I cannot believe the number of posters suggesting you just take them or go in and clean the house regularly

Do you mean zero? Because the number of posters who suggested OP cleaning the house (at least before your post, and possibly after) was zero... There were however multiple suggestions for the brother to hire a cleaner since he earns well. Which I think is fair

MumblesParty · 14/06/2023 00:33

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 14/06/2023 00:17

Got to agree.

How did you cope when you took in a relative’s kids? Maybe you could give OP some hints.

MumblesParty · 14/06/2023 00:31

Given how many people on here think it’s a straightforward decision and OP should take in the kids, I’m baffled at the shortage of foster carers in this country. Shouldn’t there be thousands? Or Could it be, just maybe, that people are preaching a pile of crap and they wouldn’t do any different from OP?!

cheshirebloke · 14/06/2023 00:30

YANBU to decline. It's unfortunate, but you simply don't have the resources to cope with two extra kids. It does sound like a significant part of the problem is your brother's relationship with alcohol. If he could get that sorted out, hopefully the rest will follow. And maybe you not picking up the pieces this time and letting the kids go into care will be the kick up the arse he needs.

I've had the same merry go round with SS, but with my own kids. My ex was primary carer, and I had our kids 3 days/nights a week. Every so often, my ex would go totally off the rails (drinking to oblivion, self harming, overdoses going awol etc). Each time a referral would get made to ss, they'd contact me, and I'd take the kids full time for 3 or 4 weeks, until ex had recovered. And each time ss would close the case on the basis that "dad steps in and takes over the care of the children when mum gets sick." Then we'd go back to the shared care routine.

I told ss that I was quite happy to have the kids full time, but I couldn't keep dropping everything (work predominantly, being self employed) and running to pick up the pieces each time (I believe a significant part of it was my ex trying to exert post breakup control over me, and this was the best way she could achieve it). It was obviously very unsettling for the kids to keep chopping and changing, and there was a fair bit of low level neglect from their mum. SS advised me to get legal advice about applying for residency. But lawyers would say I had no chance because the ss reports didn't conclude that the kids were at risk with mum (only because I was stepping in).

So in the end the only thing I could do was to call SS's bluff - the next time they phoned my with an emergency situation I initially told them I wouldn't take the kids. Obviously I had no intention of not taking them, but I had to say that in an attempt to break the cycle. I explained again why we couldn't just keep going on and on like this, then backed down and agreed to.

Anyway, it worked and ss changed their tune and backed me applying for full custody, which the court awarded without question. The SS (rather than cafcass) report was so damning on my ex that the judges couldn't do anything else.

I guess it's just how SS work, for better or worse. They're stretched, and so is the care system, so first (and easiest) resolution is to find a close relative to step in. Not ideal, and I can imagine in some situations it's out the fire and into the frying pan for some kids unfortunately.

Mummanoodle · 14/06/2023 00:25

So sorry to hear what’s happening in your family and the pressures you have felt. I’m shocked at some of the responses you’ve had on here from people who clearly don’t understand the enormity of taking on children that are not your own (regardless of them being extended family). I am a children’s social worker and have worked for many years with children in care, including those who live with other family members like in your situation. Children who have experienced trauma and/or neglect are unfortunately not ‘straightforward’ to care for. They can often lack trust, may demonstrate disruptive behaviours, and may find it hard to keep friends and be on track with their education. Offering a clean home and food does not repair them! OP I hope a suitable solution is found for your nieces and nephews and that your brother is also supported with his own issues. You are trying your best for everyone - your own children, as well as your nieces and nephews will recognise this and understand your reasons for having to say no on this occasion.

Okaaaay · 14/06/2023 00:24

OP this is awful, I’m so sorry. You’re not obliged to help. Simple as that. However, the fact that you’re asking the question makes me wonder whether you’ll find a way of justifying not helping to yourself or whether it will eat you up.

I wouldn’t give your career up for anything. But there are ways around some of the job challenges. There are places desperate for nurses which work easier patterns than you do (primary care in particular). Also, you could ask for a career break or a special arrangement. I would support this (as an NHS ops manager) to keep your skills in the service. Some sort of special arrangement might help you support the 11 year old for a time. The other option is to agree reduced hours (another special arrangement) with work, or even a career break, and then negotiate SS to pay you what they would do to a foster family. Just thoughts and I’m so sorry you’re having to consider this.

pinkginfizz9 · 14/06/2023 00:24

No and it is not in anyone's interests that you do. These poor children do not want to be in overcrowded accomodation.

Dinnaehinksae · 14/06/2023 00:23

OP don't feel bad for not being able to do it. My nephews were in a similar situation and removed from the home, I now have one living with me and it's a lot. It's not even the financial side as I do get money for him but there's just so much more to it. It has to be something you can commit to 110% without guilt as there is so much involved. There are so many hoops to jump through with minimal support, the kids have trauma and behavioural issues and the parent is doing everything they can to make things so much more difficult just because they can. Do not let anyone guilt you, you taking them in under duress would just be a bad idea all round.

Batalax · 14/06/2023 00:21

Please don’t beat yourself up op. You’ve gone above and beyond.

You cant have them. Ss can see you waivering and wanting to help, so they’ll keep pressurising because they can close the case once again.

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 14/06/2023 00:17

drpet49 · 13/06/2023 21:58

I couldn’t let the kids go into the care system.

Got to agree.

mrsneate · 14/06/2023 00:12

Jeevesnotwooster · 13/06/2023 23:55

I would take them. Will the oldest move out/go to college at 18?
It will be difficult though

He's going to college in sept but will still live at home. Even if he goes off to uni when he's 18. I'd have to somehow fund this! As well as my own child who is the same age.

OP posts:
mrsneate · 14/06/2023 00:11

Whyohwhyohwhy123 · 14/06/2023 00:08

Does your brother earn enough to pay for boarding school for the youngest? It would then leave the holidays only when help would be needed. Not that the rest of the family should have to help but it would be manageable and there would be stability for your niece.

He doesn't earn enough for that.

OP posts:
mrsneate · 14/06/2023 00:09

ThereIbledit · 14/06/2023 00:00

I don't see how you CAN take them. Have you put it to the pushy SW, made it her problem to solve - "OK if I take them, who is going to look after them while I am at work? Who is going to pay for them?"

I did this, she suggested my boys father take them whilst I work. We've been divorced 8 years and it's only the past year or so things have been amicable with us,

Plus he has nothing to do with my family members anymore other than our shared children. She was so brazen when she suggested it

OP posts:
caringcarer · 14/06/2023 00:09

@Hopelesscynic, I'm a foster carer and I can assure you Foster Carers are not generously paid. They get more than kinship carers yes but not generously paid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread