Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this may amount to child neglect?

155 replies

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 19:50

Hi all. Basically what the title suggestions, quick back story. Split from narcissistic, emotionally abusive ex-h end of 2019. He was physically abusive in the end and I left. Have 2 DS, one 12 and one 7. Ex husband is increasingly neglectful towards our children. He has them overnight 3 nights per week 3 weeks of the month and 2 nights per week 1 week of the month. My boys have told me numerous things (not questioned by me just in conversation) that he doesn't brush their teeth, falls asleep straight after dinner and they "put them selves' to bed, is always angry and screaming at them for one thing or another and I have witnessed myself when I pick them up on a Sunday, they are always in the same underwear and socks I put them on over 24 hours earlier before dropping them off to him. On occasion they are both still dressed in the exact same clothes I put on them 24 hours earlier and have told me they've slept in them. His home is so unclean and messy, cant see floor in living room or hallway and cant see kitchen worktops due to amount of crap on them. AIBU to say this amounts to child neglect? I am really concerned this will be messing them up and I just don't think he is looking after them as he should, but don't really know where to go or how I would go about contesting his current access.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 13/06/2023 21:45

I think people are being deliberately obtuse here: yes technically children of this age can change their underwear and brush their teeth but the OP has painted a picture of an environment where there is no supervision and no pastoral care.

If my DD was staying at my ex's several nights a month and she didn't undertake basic self-care he either would step in and make sure it got done or say something to me. And my ex is hardly a paragon of fatherhood so the bar is fairly low.

It's very clear from this post that he is living in squalor and making no attempt to make the most basic checks on their hygiene and welfare. Parroting that they can brush their own teeth wildly misses the point. He is responsible for their welfare and if they can't or won't do it he should step in.

Does he have a drink or substance problem?

I think you would be well within your rights to refuse overnight stays until he gets his act together. Can you seek to get a court order?

MeridianB · 13/06/2023 21:44

He screams at his sons? So why would they keep going back? Isn’t it just teaching them that it’s ok for someone who is supposed to love them to scare and upset them? 😢

Nasolabial · 13/06/2023 21:43

Agree with others. Am more than a bit surprised at the 12y needing prompting to brush teeth etc. And surely they should
take spare pants and pyjamas for their own comfort. And the 7y old needs more care and attention.

I don’t think it sounds bad enough for social services to intervene though, given current thresholds.

I would just make sure the boys go with all
they need. And if they want to stop going then listen to them.

reallyworriedjobhunter · 13/06/2023 21:42

Does the 12 year old have a phone? Does he ever take photos there so you can see what state the house is in?

Lack of personal care when they are there suggests to me that there is no routine and that the home may not be set up for their normal way of doing things. Do they have a clean bathroom and clean towels to use while they are there? A clean safe bed to sleep in? A room which gives them some privacy to get changed and where they feel secure and relaxed enough to get a good night's sleep?

EmeraldFox · 13/06/2023 21:42

ContinuousProcrastination · 13/06/2023 21:38

12 y o sounds like they need a kick in the pants!

Why aren't they packing a rucksack witb pjs, toothbrush, clean pants & tshirt etc in when they know they are going overnight?

They are there I think 11/28 nights? They should have basic clean clothes there and some things like coats and shoes going between houses. I'd expect a rucksack for 2/14 nights.

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 21:42

Anotherdayanothermoodswing · 13/06/2023 21:34

I'll probably be shouted down here but sounds to me like dad - and potentially youngest - could have ADHD.... 🤷🏼‍♀️ Not an excuse but a possible reason!?

Yes, I also think they both have ADHD but was also scared of being shot down in comments lol.

OP posts:
ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 21:41

So I used to do this, and found that any clothes I put in bags were swiftly removed and not returned. Any PE kit/changes I put in school bags are also removed and not returned. I could put PJs clothes pants etc in bags, I would be buying new ones every week for them to take as they'd not be returned unfortunately.

OP posts:
cyncope · 13/06/2023 21:39

He does sound like a shit lazy dad but I'm not sure if it is bad enough to be neglect (in a safeguarding sense).

The 12 year old should be able to put himself to bed and know that you have to change your clothes and shower and put on fresh clothes every morning. I'd expect a child of that age to pretty much manage their own bedtime/morning routine.

The 7 year old is borderline, yes their dad should be helping them get ready for bed - but I would start teaching him to be a bit more responsible for himself and to be able to brush his own teeth and change his clothes.

ContinuousProcrastination · 13/06/2023 21:38

12 y o sounds like they need a kick in the pants!

Why aren't they packing a rucksack witb pjs, toothbrush, clean pants & tshirt etc in when they know they are going overnight?

LightlySearedontheRealityGrill · 13/06/2023 21:37

Doesnt sound like he could care for a pot plant let alone two children.

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 21:35

Should mention, have had to go no contact with exh due to constant nasty calls and messages as he wanted to change the days he has our sons. When I said no, he flipped and said he then couldn't have them on certain days. All contact now goes through my mum.

I think he is most likely depressed, however is the type of man that will not admit this and would never ever get help even though it may be needed.

OP posts:
UneFoisAuChalet · 13/06/2023 21:35

We put our boys ‘to bed’ - 15, 13 and 11. Unfortunately they need prompting that it’s time to shower, brush teeth, put devices down and close the lights. Perhaps we baby them 🤷‍♀️as we also go in their rooms, have a little chat, kiss and hug. It only takes a few minutes, but they expect this routine. If one of them is tired and in bed, they’ll shout out ‘mum, dad can one of you put me to bed please?’

We also shout out ‘don’t forget to put deodorant on! You’ve got PE!’ But that’s us…

Anotherdayanothermoodswing · 13/06/2023 21:34

I'll probably be shouted down here but sounds to me like dad - and potentially youngest - could have ADHD.... 🤷🏼‍♀️ Not an excuse but a possible reason!?

FusionChefGeoff · 13/06/2023 21:31

Agree this is a shit show from Dad and no it shouldn't be down to the kids. However, also like the idea of you teaching them the life skills early as a way to mitigate the worst.

My other question is why is he falling asleep after dinner every night? Does he work shifts / game until late? I have to admit I jumped to drinking and passing out rather than being asleep.

Huytffdddc · 13/06/2023 21:30

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 19:50

Hi all. Basically what the title suggestions, quick back story. Split from narcissistic, emotionally abusive ex-h end of 2019. He was physically abusive in the end and I left. Have 2 DS, one 12 and one 7. Ex husband is increasingly neglectful towards our children. He has them overnight 3 nights per week 3 weeks of the month and 2 nights per week 1 week of the month. My boys have told me numerous things (not questioned by me just in conversation) that he doesn't brush their teeth, falls asleep straight after dinner and they "put them selves' to bed, is always angry and screaming at them for one thing or another and I have witnessed myself when I pick them up on a Sunday, they are always in the same underwear and socks I put them on over 24 hours earlier before dropping them off to him. On occasion they are both still dressed in the exact same clothes I put on them 24 hours earlier and have told me they've slept in them. His home is so unclean and messy, cant see floor in living room or hallway and cant see kitchen worktops due to amount of crap on them. AIBU to say this amounts to child neglect? I am really concerned this will be messing them up and I just don't think he is looking after them as he should, but don't really know where to go or how I would go about contesting his current access.

This behaviour is the same as my ex. It is low level neglect and schools should pick it up but won’t as they have too much to do elsewhere.

I took the view that you teach the kid’s independence and raise things
if you have a real concerns.

good luck!

EmeraldFox · 13/06/2023 21:30

I'd expect a 7 and 12 year old to brush their own teeth, shower, change underwear and put on clean clothes in the morning. Clean clothes if necessary, only underwear and socks need changing every day, other clothes if needed. I would expect a 7 year old to be prompted to get ready for bed but they should know what this means.

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 21:29

Yep I think I'll need to have another talk with 12 year old and think about getting him to be more independent. MrsBennettsPoorNerves I also really struggled when I moved into my first home, due to being a spoiled only child so this actually sounds sensible thing to do teaching eldest things he can do himself 😊 12yo is march born, so goes to high school this August (we are scotland based). Yes he takes them to school 2 mornings a week, has made them late once every month since August last year. Doesn't do any homework with them, that's done in my home. 12yo is actually good and will do homework at dads. School rang me in feb saying both boys were sent to school in wet jumpers and youngest was bit agitated by it, when asked ex h he said he washed them at 7am the morning of school and "they didn't dry in time' 🙁

Emotionally 12yo is v sensitive. Always has been but more so now. Has had talking therapy sessions in school and is now much more confident and happy, but still struggles with emotions. 6yo behavior is not good, he is v moody and have been called to school 3 times previously due to his behavior. Youngest is v v like his dad in terms of temperament which worries me also 🙁

OP posts:
sadsack78 · 13/06/2023 21:19

It sounds like his conduct and potential mental health issues are the problem.

Practicalities like bedtimes, teeth brushing and supplying of clothes etc could easily be straightened out between the two of you as adults if you could actually have a reasonable conversation with him about co-parenting and he cared about managing it properly between your two households. As it is, having read he physically abused you, he sounds unsafe to be around and like you can't parent your kids together or trust him.

Perhaps if he is moody and volatile the kids don't feel able to act like things are normal and go about their routines as usual if they feel unsafe around him or like they don't know what will happen next. I wouldn't want to get undressed around someone who shouted and screamed and was obviously mentally unwell, as he sounds.

Only OP can know if that is a true representation of how things are, I'm just going on what is in the post.

JanglyBeads · 13/06/2023 21:19

I haven't RTFT, just bits, but I'm completely with you OP, and am sure that there are safeguarding issues here.
If he falls asleep for the evening then he's effectively leaving a 12 yo in charge of a 7 yo.
And goodness knows what emotional stuff is going on.

Do they have unrestricted access to screens at his as well?

He must take them to school some mornings, are they in correct uniform, homework done as necessary?

Saying the "need" to see their dad suggests that's been drilled into them (by him?) and also that they don't like going but are too afraid to say.

How are they emotionally and behaviourally?

You could raise these concerns with a school nurse, parent support advisor, GP or a teacher.

But you'll need to think through how he'll react.

For the sake of your boys I think you need to do something.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/06/2023 21:17

Fair enough, OP. I get your frustration. He sounds like a piss poor dad... maybe time to cut down the overnight stays if the kids aren't too bothered about them.

In the meantime, don't underestimate what your kids can do for themselves... even the 7yo. Think of it as teaching them valuable life skills rather than trying to overcompensate for their lazy-arse dad?

ElleC90 · 13/06/2023 21:14

No the police were not involved in the DV incident. This happened in front of ex husbands sister whilst on a weekend away. I want my kids to have their dad in their life, I want them to have a great relationship with him and I wish I could come on here and say he's a great dad and does everything for them. I want more than anything for them to have the same life I give them in my home when they're with their dad, and I DON'T want to stop contact unless absolutely necessary/I am afraid for their wellbeing which to be honest, I am, and have been for some time. Totally appreciate the comments about babying them and maybe I am come to think of it 🥴 however I need to be clear I'm not trying to stop him seeing them. I would rather have a meeting with him somewhere neutral with someone else present, and ask him to step up and do normal parenting duties. I've text him and asked him multiple times to brush teeth, give clean clothes etc but he denies any wrongdoing. I would love to sing his praises and say he's fantastic with them, unfortunately this isn't the case.

OP posts:
Alargeoneplease89 · 13/06/2023 21:10

I think its very reasonable for a 12 year old and 7 year old to clean their teeth change into bed clothes and tell the time to know when its bedtime.

I think the boys are enjoying causing more animosity between you and your ex. You should be asking why your eldest isn't capable of basic routine, he obviously goes to high school, follows a timetable and hopefully responsible for homework and attending lessons?

7 year old has a bit more leeway but should be capable of hygiene.

3dogsandarabbit · 13/06/2023 21:10

Didn't mean to say it, meant to be 'they'.

3dogsandarabbit · 13/06/2023 21:08

If they don't have clothes at their dad's house then just pack the clothes they will need. By 12 a child should be able to shower, change clothes daily, clean teeth etc without being told if it has been taught from a young age. I would say a 7 year old needs prompting.

He should not be shouting at them.

thewillowbunnies · 13/06/2023 21:08

If you have concerns over their safety whilst at his house absolutely go back to court.

I'm sorry but this whole thread just sounds like you have issues over your husband and you're directing this and finding reasons to stop him seeing his children.

You've already put your kids in conflict by splitting up their homelife in the first place.

Personally, this all sounds quite minor. Not ideal but he's their Dad and if they're happy seeing him, leave it.

Kids go to cub camp and don't wash for a week.

I'm actually very surprised however that a Dad that was physically abusive to their Mum is even allowed to have the children? Were the police not involved?

Swipe left for the next trending thread