Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To park this life goal for now

114 replies

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 18:05

TL,DR: house buying in current times !!

Everyone talking about how rates are soaring. An article I saw yesterday saying FTBs will now pay over 10k in interest on average was the final straw. Apparently your actual equity would only account for 30% of the astronomically large payments. We have a deposit saved away in ISA but would still need a 95% (possibly 90) LTV so is a high risk for negative equity(owing more to the bank than the value of the house). This will matter and might come back to bite us as like most (all) people getting onto the ladder we can’t afford the home we’ll live in forever straight away, sadlynot practical for us

We rent in a beautiful village where everyone knows one another and there is zero risk of being evicted, and payments will only go up by nominal amounts. So lucky for this.

Is being a homeowner worth it if you’re compromising on other areas of life ?? It’s always been my goal but lately I’ve been thinking we might as well enjoy life a bit more rather than being so house poor and maxing out our budget. A low deposit and an extremely long term is essentially renting from the bank with all the drawbacks of property maintenance, right ? Just sounds like the opposite of secure to me

Even thinking now DH and I could make the best of our little home despite being rented and start our family here given we would then have a larger amount of disposable income to help buffer reduced income over maternity, then later childcare fees (although we will only need one full day of paid childcare anyway). We earn equally and I do intend to go back to work FT and love my job. Maybe this is illogical as lenders would then lop more off our affordability for dependant, though DHs salary should be on the rise over the next several years with commission and enhancements anyway.

I do see my attitude might be wrong but trying to be considered based on the research I have done, and other threads read on here

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 21:49

Unicorn2022 · 13/06/2023 21:47

You said you are good savers but you can't be if you have only got such a low deposit. Presumably you must earn about £30k each if you are being offered that mortgage?

It's up to you whether you buy or not and you are definitely talking yourself out of buying, but I disagree that it's the same as renting from the bank for years, as property should increase massively in value if you buy well whereas renting gives no return at all.

If we’d been able to buy two years ago then yes property would massively increase in value but now it’s actually forecast to massively decrease in value! You may be right and it’s possible talking myself out of it but I just can’t see the sense in it. Feel happy knowing we own a very small house in 35yrs time - but if we were house poor and had no money to enjoy life, what’s really the point in owning a house in decades to come?

OP posts:
Unicorn2022 · 13/06/2023 21:47

You said you are good savers but you can't be if you have only got such a low deposit. Presumably you must earn about £30k each if you are being offered that mortgage?

It's up to you whether you buy or not and you are definitely talking yourself out of buying, but I disagree that it's the same as renting from the bank for years, as property should increase massively in value if you buy well whereas renting gives no return at all.

Motheranddaughter · 13/06/2023 21:34

I would (and did) put home ownership above holidays and days out

ksjsb · 13/06/2023 21:33

Our mortgage will be almost doubling at this rate, but I don't regret it for a second; our mortgage payment isn't just a bill, it's an investment, we are building equity, interest is only part of the payment. It's also our stability, we are not at the mercy of a landlord.

But we bought after having kids, having kids doesn't have to be the cliff edge that means never owning a home. I do understand pausing at the moment and seeing what happens to the market, don't wait too long though, there's been a reason not to buy since 2016.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 21:27

Rocket1982 · 13/06/2023 21:25

Affordability checks are bullshit because they are one size fits all and don’t take into account your lifestyle. You can fail an affordability check for a mortgage much lower than current rent you have been successfully paying for a decade.

Not sure what you mean. We have an agreement in principle and know what we could borrow it’s more we’re reluctant to atm with the sky high rates

OP posts:
Rocket1982 · 13/06/2023 21:25

Affordability checks are bullshit because they are one size fits all and don’t take into account your lifestyle. You can fail an affordability check for a mortgage much lower than current rent you have been successfully paying for a decade.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 21:19

ThankmelaterOkay · 13/06/2023 21:12

Why do you need to make a profit? If house prices stagnate, then the next rung up the ladder will be more achievable.

Personally I believe if U.K. house prices tank, then the stock market won’t be fairing much better. Maybe if you invest in global stocks/funds and the wider global economy dodges a large recession, then maybe it could work out. But personally it feels like everything is interconnected nowadays. Either you are fully out or you are fully in.

It’s if they don’t stagnate, what if they fall? Just using random figures

200k house, 5% deposit. 190k owed to the bank over 35 years. At current rates that’s over 1000pcm. House prices fall by 10% (as forecast, with inflation). Suddenly you can only sell your house for less than 180k and you owe the bank more than that. Problem.

OP posts:
Sissynova · 13/06/2023 21:16

@Travelfan2021 ultimately a landlord is a business. I can’t imagine there are that many landlord who set their rent significantly below the market rent. Sure there will be some but it’s certainly not going to be common, for pretty obvious reasons.

ThankmelaterOkay · 13/06/2023 21:12

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 20:09

I appreciate this. Are there any specific ISAs you’d recommend? Nobody tells you about the risks of property ownership. We can’t buy a starter home with a 5% deposit as this would get us a really, really small house which would be fine if we knew we’d make profit but nobody can bank on house prices continuing to rise anymore - not with these interest rates!

Why do you need to make a profit? If house prices stagnate, then the next rung up the ladder will be more achievable.

Personally I believe if U.K. house prices tank, then the stock market won’t be fairing much better. Maybe if you invest in global stocks/funds and the wider global economy dodges a large recession, then maybe it could work out. But personally it feels like everything is interconnected nowadays. Either you are fully out or you are fully in.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 21:07

I should add, I think the fact that buying is usually the done thing is making me feel as if we should perhaps more than anything else.

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 20:51

Hermione101 · 13/06/2023 20:36

An ISA is just the wrapper for your investments, but the assets (stocks, bonds, funds, ETFs, etc..) you choose to hold in an ISA or a SIPP for that matter depend on your age, risk appetite, and how long you want to hold the asset for. Claer Barrett from the Financial Times has a great personal finance podcast that’s free and is a good play to start. I think it’s called Money Clinic. The Vanguard, Fidelity websites will
also have some good content around investing.

Most providers will have Lifestyle funds that are well diversified across assets, geographies, duration, risk. These can be a good place to start.

The other option could be to look into seller financing for a property (although I am not sure if this is a thing in the U.K.). Usually it is someone who really wants to sell, I think those deals are quite rare, but could be worth having on your radar if you find the right deal and want to go down the home ownership path.

Thankyou this is useful. I’d never even thought of this before as an alternative for now but may well be smarter

OP posts:
Hermione101 · 13/06/2023 20:36

An ISA is just the wrapper for your investments, but the assets (stocks, bonds, funds, ETFs, etc..) you choose to hold in an ISA or a SIPP for that matter depend on your age, risk appetite, and how long you want to hold the asset for. Claer Barrett from the Financial Times has a great personal finance podcast that’s free and is a good play to start. I think it’s called Money Clinic. The Vanguard, Fidelity websites will
also have some good content around investing.

Most providers will have Lifestyle funds that are well diversified across assets, geographies, duration, risk. These can be a good place to start.

The other option could be to look into seller financing for a property (although I am not sure if this is a thing in the U.K.). Usually it is someone who really wants to sell, I think those deals are quite rare, but could be worth having on your radar if you find the right deal and want to go down the home ownership path.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 20:22

Would echo what @Travelfan2021 said as it’s the exact same for us

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 20:09

Hermione101 · 13/06/2023 20:07

There are so many hidden costs to home ownership, and when people say they made 100k or whatever on their home, chances are, they’re not factoring in a number of fixed and variable costs. Overall people here have very high levels of mortgage debt, but very little actual wealth outside of property.

If you have affordable rent and can save, I would prioritize investing in a SIPP, work pension, and ISA to growing your wealth and take maximum tax advantages. Stick it in an well-diversified/lifestyle index fund or talk to a financial adviser. You can definitely build wealth and assets outside of property.

I appreciate this. Are there any specific ISAs you’d recommend? Nobody tells you about the risks of property ownership. We can’t buy a starter home with a 5% deposit as this would get us a really, really small house which would be fine if we knew we’d make profit but nobody can bank on house prices continuing to rise anymore - not with these interest rates!

OP posts:
Hermione101 · 13/06/2023 20:07

There are so many hidden costs to home ownership, and when people say they made 100k or whatever on their home, chances are, they’re not factoring in a number of fixed and variable costs. Overall people here have very high levels of mortgage debt, but very little actual wealth outside of property.

If you have affordable rent and can save, I would prioritize investing in a SIPP, work pension, and ISA to growing your wealth and take maximum tax advantages. Stick it in an well-diversified/lifestyle index fund or talk to a financial adviser. You can definitely build wealth and assets outside of property.

Travelfan2021 · 13/06/2023 20:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 19:48

Sissynova · 13/06/2023 19:36

How is it not? Pretty much every lender still requires a btl to set the monthly rent at a minimum 125% of the monthly mortgage payment.

Just a quick rightmove search will show you

OP posts:
Sissynova · 13/06/2023 19:36

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 18:42

It’s not at the mo

How is it not? Pretty much every lender still requires a btl to set the monthly rent at a minimum 125% of the monthly mortgage payment.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 19:32

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Mine too! Not to mention as a home owner you would also be responsible 100% for any other costs like maintenance and repairs

OP posts:
Travelfan2021 · 13/06/2023 19:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 19:14

ThankmelaterOkay · 13/06/2023 19:08

We’re still waiting but to be honest if we found a place we wanted to live, and a nice house, we’d buy. But we’ve got a fairly huge deposit and wouldn’t borrow more than 4x one of our, similar, salaries.

Don’t blame you one bit

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 19:09

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Definitely understand the logic there. Might be a good time to buy if there is a dip in prices too, you’ll be in a position to watch and wait

OP posts:
ThankmelaterOkay · 13/06/2023 19:08

We’re still waiting but to be honest if we found a place we wanted to live, and a nice house, we’d buy. But we’ve got a fairly huge deposit and wouldn’t borrow more than 4x one of our, similar, salaries.

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 18:50

SparklyShoesandTutus · 13/06/2023 18:21

It's a really personal decision. We brought in 2007 just before the crash. We had a 2 bed that ended up being the most expensive house on the street (mainly 3 & 4 beds) and we lost about 20k overnight. We ended up staying longer than planned and had both children there. We did move eventually and made about 90k.
So you need to think about what would happen should things crash again. We took the opportunity as we wouldn't have been able to get on the housing ladder any other way (open market homebuy so effectively 100% mortgage) We now have another new home and were able to put down a 20% deposit. Just depends if you can play the long game.
We wouldn't have been able to get a secure rental and wanted the stability that comes with home ownership.

I’m glad it worked for you in the end! It’s so tricky to know what to do isn’t it, especially when there’s risk of crash

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 18:42

Sissynova · 13/06/2023 18:25

It’s cheaper to buy than so I don’t understand your argument really. If you are renting say a small 2 bed comparing buying a large 4 bed then it’s apples and oranges really.
A landlord needs to charge 125% of the mortgage charge and have access to less favourable rates so it’s cheaper to buy the same property compared to renting.

When we bought our mortgage was several hundred pounds cheaper a month than our rent was.

It’s not at the mo

OP posts: