Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To park this life goal for now

114 replies

FlyingSoap · 13/06/2023 18:05

TL,DR: house buying in current times !!

Everyone talking about how rates are soaring. An article I saw yesterday saying FTBs will now pay over 10k in interest on average was the final straw. Apparently your actual equity would only account for 30% of the astronomically large payments. We have a deposit saved away in ISA but would still need a 95% (possibly 90) LTV so is a high risk for negative equity(owing more to the bank than the value of the house). This will matter and might come back to bite us as like most (all) people getting onto the ladder we can’t afford the home we’ll live in forever straight away, sadlynot practical for us

We rent in a beautiful village where everyone knows one another and there is zero risk of being evicted, and payments will only go up by nominal amounts. So lucky for this.

Is being a homeowner worth it if you’re compromising on other areas of life ?? It’s always been my goal but lately I’ve been thinking we might as well enjoy life a bit more rather than being so house poor and maxing out our budget. A low deposit and an extremely long term is essentially renting from the bank with all the drawbacks of property maintenance, right ? Just sounds like the opposite of secure to me

Even thinking now DH and I could make the best of our little home despite being rented and start our family here given we would then have a larger amount of disposable income to help buffer reduced income over maternity, then later childcare fees (although we will only need one full day of paid childcare anyway). We earn equally and I do intend to go back to work FT and love my job. Maybe this is illogical as lenders would then lop more off our affordability for dependant, though DHs salary should be on the rise over the next several years with commission and enhancements anyway.

I do see my attitude might be wrong but trying to be considered based on the research I have done, and other threads read on here

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 14/06/2023 17:50

A landlord needs to charge 125% of the mortgage charge and have access to less favourable rates so it’s cheaper to buy the same property compared to renting.

That only applies if the landlord has a mortgage. Most don’t.

EmpressSoleil · 14/06/2023 17:45

I'm not a home owner, I'm in social housing, so I have no real idea how it all works. But what I'm curious about is what the profit actually is from owning. I get the principle that if you say buy a house at 200k and sell it for 250, theoretically you've made a 50k profit. But if there are so many fees, a high rate of interest etc, haven't you just put that 50k (or more!) into the house yourself and are therefore "breaking even" if that makes sense?

I also get that it allows you to potentially move up the ladder. But if someone has a stable place with low rental costs would they be better off maybe investing their spare cash elsewhere?

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 17:41

ksjsb · 14/06/2023 17:22

We lived in military housing in our 20s which was incredibly cheap (at one point we were paying £130 a month in the 2010s for a large 3 bed semi in zone 6 London) but the downside is it's military housing......

That is cheap!

OP posts:
ksjsb · 14/06/2023 17:22

We lived in military housing in our 20s which was incredibly cheap (at one point we were paying £130 a month in the 2010s for a large 3 bed semi in zone 6 London) but the downside is it's military housing......

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 17:20

And it’s true that it’s not linked to market rent yes! Imagine if it were

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 17:13

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Yes. Estate rentals, HA rentals, renting from family, landlord owns property, number of things really I suppose

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 14/06/2023 17:07

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Too, the “market rent” is not linked to what would be “125% of the mortgage payment” for an owner-occupier mortgage based on a 90/95% LTV mortgage.

Market rent isn’t linked to that figure.

So sissynova is confusing to very different figures.

Travelfan2021 · 14/06/2023 16:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 13:56

Just heard on the radio that the base rate is going up next week too 😬

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 13:03

Backstreets · 14/06/2023 12:56

Oh yeah, unless I win the lottery or one of the fit karate dads from Cobra Kai on Netflix ask for my hand in marriage and we need more space, I'm staying put. So that was a consideration when deciding to buy, too.

Haha this made me laugh

OP posts:
Backstreets · 14/06/2023 12:56

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:28

@Backstreets this is it, not sure I want the financial vulnerability at such an expensive stage of life either! Will you stay in your apartment for a while?

Oh yeah, unless I win the lottery or one of the fit karate dads from Cobra Kai on Netflix ask for my hand in marriage and we need more space, I'm staying put. So that was a consideration when deciding to buy, too.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 12:41

Wiennetta · 14/06/2023 10:35

We’re looking to buy at the moment as first time buyers. It’s really slow in the area we are looking with barely anything coming up. We’re only looking to borrow 2.5 times our salaries and we have a 10-15% deposit so we’re in a good position and can pay the mortgage at the current rates. But we aren’t in a rush - if it takes us a while to find something we’re ok with that.

Oh you’re in a great position! Hopefully your repayments will be low, finding the right house can be hard can’t it

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:54

AP5Diva · 14/06/2023 10:44

Majority of rental properties are owned outright or have a very small mortgage. The most you can borrow on a btl is usually 75% of the property value. This is much stricter than when you buy for your own home.

So “125% of monthly mortgage payment” when many rental properties either are not mortgaged or the mortgage is only on 75% of the home - can easily see how the rental payment could be less than a mortgage with a loan at 90-95% of the home value.

Perfect explanation

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 14/06/2023 10:44

Sissynova · 13/06/2023 19:36

How is it not? Pretty much every lender still requires a btl to set the monthly rent at a minimum 125% of the monthly mortgage payment.

Majority of rental properties are owned outright or have a very small mortgage. The most you can borrow on a btl is usually 75% of the property value. This is much stricter than when you buy for your own home.

So “125% of monthly mortgage payment” when many rental properties either are not mortgaged or the mortgage is only on 75% of the home - can easily see how the rental payment could be less than a mortgage with a loan at 90-95% of the home value.

Wiennetta · 14/06/2023 10:35

We’re looking to buy at the moment as first time buyers. It’s really slow in the area we are looking with barely anything coming up. We’re only looking to borrow 2.5 times our salaries and we have a 10-15% deposit so we’re in a good position and can pay the mortgage at the current rates. But we aren’t in a rush - if it takes us a while to find something we’re ok with that.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:28

@Backstreets this is it, not sure I want the financial vulnerability at such an expensive stage of life either! Will you stay in your apartment for a while?

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:22

Namechanger355 · 14/06/2023 09:49

No harm in waiting a few months to reassess

but you do seem to be convincing yourself that renting is a better longer term proposition than buying which it just isn’t

house prices may reduce temporarily but in the long term they will always increase - land is scarce and people need somewhere to live. Land will always be in line with or beat inflation in the long run. Plus you are saving cash as you pay off the capital element of your mortgage - and this capital element increases over time

renting longer term is never a good idea compared to owning - it is a true cost, and you are paying a landlords mortgage. Plus people who rent into old age needs their pension to be able to fund that

personally we bought a 2 bed house back in 2016 after the referendum for 5% - scary and didn’t seem like a good move

but now we have a 4 bed in London with over 75% ltv

we couldn’t have done that if we had spent money renting - that rent taking our income and also not letting us save

personally in the short term I would always sacrifice on nice holidays etc for a few years to get on the ladder and - short term pain long term gain

I suppose if you are uncomfortable about doing anything right now it could make sense to wait until 2024

but interest rates are unlikely to ever reduce to the low levels we got used to - and not before 2028

also even if you only have one day of nursery - children are expensive. School activities, days out, play dates, clothes - it all adds up

all the best op

Thank you

OP posts:
Backstreets · 14/06/2023 10:22

Certainly not cheap to buy. I spend more than twice on housing now than when I was renting, mortgage including. I know I'm paying off loans so it's not quite the same, but my spending allowance doesn't know the difference.

Worth it? Meh, I like my apartment and love being able to do DIY without having permission from a landlord. I can afford the stupid outgoings. It's fine. I'd be fine without it, too.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:07

Annipeck · 14/06/2023 10:04

I know nothing about estate rentals and their security or otherwise, but a main criterion for me would be how certain I could be of not having to leave my rented home -- the insecurity of renting apartments where we got moved on so frequently was what made DP and I buy a tiny flat in the first place.

Then, when we moved out of London, we rented in a village at first, and felt lucky, as there was virtually no rental stock in the area at all, BUT after a few years (by now we had a young child at the village school) the owners decided to sell up, so we ended up buying the house, reluctantly, as there was literally nothing else to rent for many miles around.

Understood, I mean security is a big thing isn’t it! Was it easy enough to buy your house when the owners sold? It must’ve been stressful

OP posts:
Annipeck · 14/06/2023 10:04

I know nothing about estate rentals and their security or otherwise, but a main criterion for me would be how certain I could be of not having to leave my rented home -- the insecurity of renting apartments where we got moved on so frequently was what made DP and I buy a tiny flat in the first place.

Then, when we moved out of London, we rented in a village at first, and felt lucky, as there was virtually no rental stock in the area at all, BUT after a few years (by now we had a young child at the village school) the owners decided to sell up, so we ended up buying the house, reluctantly, as there was literally nothing else to rent for many miles around.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 10:03

@ksjsb never considered the election but of course! Sure the last one was when the last first time buyer incentives were introduced if I remember rightly

OP posts:
ksjsb · 14/06/2023 09:57

Also OP, with an election year coming up, it wouldn't surprise me if we start to see some programmes to help first time buyers, even if Labour get into power no government wants to see the property market fail, so another reason to perhaps bide your time.

FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 09:55

BelindaBears · 14/06/2023 09:54

No way would I be buying with 95% mortgage at the moment, especially if you have a secure and affordable rental property. Even if you plan to stay put, being in negative equity can have consequences when your mortgage deal ends. You really don’t want to end up on a SVR, many of them are already touching 8%.

This is exactly what I’m scared about! Especially given we’d be buying a small property that we know we’d have to sell at one point, I would be devastated if we lost all our money due to prices falling

OP posts:
FlyingSoap · 14/06/2023 09:54

ksjsb · 14/06/2023 09:25

@FlyingSoap yes I think you are in the same boat we were in 2017(with a less scary but still uncertain Brexit market) we were also in cheap, stable rental accommodation so it was very much about what we thought we should do in the long term.

As it's looking like prices aren't going anywhere fast any time soon, I would concentrate on building up that deposit, bide your time, we are only just seeing what the impact will be on the market, I think there are a lot of delusional house prices on Rightmove. See what happens to interest rates, keep an eye on prices for the properties that appeal, and reassess in 2024. Normally I would say if you have the deposit and the means just buy because the market will rise and fall and it's a home first and foremost, but I can see the value in pausing at the moment! It's so unsettled.

It is really unsettled! Think we will continue to save and see where we are

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 14/06/2023 09:54

No way would I be buying with 95% mortgage at the moment, especially if you have a secure and affordable rental property. Even if you plan to stay put, being in negative equity can have consequences when your mortgage deal ends. You really don’t want to end up on a SVR, many of them are already touching 8%.

Swipe left for the next trending thread