Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disabled seat on buses

365 replies

Spidey66 · 13/06/2023 17:37

So about 10 days ago I tripped over a step and broke my arm. I had a cast on for a week, then it was removed but I still have a sling and am in considerable pain.

I took a brief trip to the high street on the bus for cash today. On the return I got on the bus and sat on the disabled seat nearest the driver. As i was on the inside, my injured left arm was against the window so I felt safe as I feel anxious about others bumping into me, or losing my balance at an emergency stop. I feel I am entitled to use the disabled spot as I have a temporary disability, which given I have a sling is obvious.

An older woman sat next to me on the outside of the seat then a much older lady got on and there didn't appear to be a seat for her. I felt dead guilty (damn you Catholic childhood!) and ended up explaining to her why I wasn't able to stand up for her. As it was, she was fine with my explanation and the lady sat next to me offered her the seat.

So is it is OK for a middle age woman to use a disabled seat because of a broken arm? Noone on the bus made me feel bad except myself but I don't know their thoughts!

OP posts:
Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 08:31

I've also got pain and poor sleep. I know it's temporary but it's still there!

I didn't have a cast last time either but had surgery. For about the millionth time, I'm waiting to hear whether surgery is needed this time. I've got an appointment tomorrow.

I'm not going to take advice from a random person as to whether my arm is bad depending on how many weeks I'm in a cast. I'll go with how I'm feeling and what my xrays reveal and the advice from orthopaedics.

Jeez.

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 15/06/2023 08:25

I think it was fine to use the seat, OP. You are obviously injured. It's hardly like some young, fit, non-disabled and non-injured person taking the piss and just not fancying standing up for someone who needs the seat more.

It's actually quite hard to walk around a moving bus with only one functioning arm, and quite easy to lose your balance.

YANBU.

sashh · 15/06/2023 08:18

PatientZorro · 15/06/2023 07:06

God the vitriol being displayed above by those determined to thump the OP for using a seat she was entitled to is unbelievable. Those posters need to address whatever in life is making them so angry rather than tearing chunks out of the OP for no good reason.

What's making me angry?

Disability.
Pain.
People's attitudes to the concessions disabled people have fought for over the years.
People's attitudes to disability.
Lack of sleep.
Did I mention pain?

jannier · 15/06/2023 08:17

hattyhathat · 15/06/2023 07:37

Sorry but it's OP's arm she knows the situation

12 weeks and surgery is bad, 4 to 6 average 10 days precautionary for all arms

stormytwilightnight · 15/06/2023 08:09

sashh · 15/06/2023 05:08

Are you mute? When you get on the bus tell the driver I need you to not drive off until I am in a seat as I have a broken arm and if I fall it will rebreak and I will need an ambulance"

You are not disabled.

I hope you never are but this experience might give you an insight into what people with permanent disabilities have to deal with.

Anyway I’ve taken an extra dihydrocodeine tablet which is now kicking in so I’ll try and get some sleep now. Good night.

That must be nice, to be able to sleep without waking up in pain at stupid O'clock.

Well you are lucky you have been on buses where a driver will wait for you to sit down before driving off, because most won’t, even when asked, in fact some will deliberately lurch more.

Have you actually bothered to read OPs posts, where she has explained numerous times she knows she is not disabled, but temporarily is vulnerable so needs a priority seat. She has also said she has early onset of osteoporosis, where she could easily become very disabled - you know crumbling spine, regularly breaking bones at the drop of a hat, nothing to worry about it seems, as so many of you seem to think she is making a mountain out of a molehill having another broken arm, did you also miss the part where she explained she had previously broken her other arm.

Many elderly people are quite capable of standing on a bus, and a lot aren’t, but other people on front seats could have offered up their seat to the elderly person, but didn’t, you and many others seem blinkered to thinking only OP should have offered her seat up, which she was more than entitled to sit on.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 15/06/2023 07:48

brunettemic · 14/06/2023 10:43

Ah, the AIBU board, the gift that keeps on giving. “I’ve not got a disability but can I use a disabled seat” 😂

Doesn’t disabled mean not being able. Whilst it’s just a short term issue rather than permanent she is not currently able to move around as normal and therefore does have a temporary disability. There are lots of jobs she currently can’t do, currently can’t drive and currently can’t safely stand on a moving bus.

hattyhathat · 15/06/2023 07:37

jannier · 14/06/2023 08:47

Sorry bad breaks are in casts 6 weeks not just over 1. Did you have an operation?

Sorry but it's OP's arm she knows the situation

Apricotflanday · 15/06/2023 07:36

And yes of course priority seats are for people less able to stand up safely.

Really, though, bus drivers should be allowed by their employers to refrain from moving until everyone has sat down safely and to give people time to get off the bus safely at bus stops.

hattyhathat · 15/06/2023 07:35

brunettemic · 14/06/2023 16:33

Oh get a grip, I was using the term OP used and you knew exactly what I meant. Whatever you call the seat it’s for someone who needs it and I’m sorry but having a temporary arm injury but two fully functioning legs and another fully functioning arm does not, in my opinion, require a priority seat. Everyone is fine to disagree with each other but frankly if OP wants everyone to agree then an internet message board is really not the place to go.

OP is the one with the injury it's up to her if she required it. I hope you don't go round vetting people's needs for priority seating IRL - they shouldn't have to disclose to you

Apricotflanday · 15/06/2023 07:33

The idea that public transport isn't there to be safe and convenient and that we should instead contribute to lung problems in children, road traffic deaths and global warming by buying a car or just randomly win the lottery to pay for taxis instead of having a sensible, safe, sane, user-friendly public transport system is so very typical of Mumsnet! It reminds me of what is so very wrong with our society.

Apricotflanday · 15/06/2023 07:31

Inmydreams88 · 15/06/2023 07:14

I don’t see anything wrong with you sitting in the priority seat if it was unoccupied, and you’ve admitted you’ve done this even before your broken arm. But the part that makes me cringe for you is then an elderly lady got on and you explained to her why you needed the seat more than her. Wow. That’s got to take some guts to be that selfish and entitled. Broken arm or not I would have got up and given her my seat. You said being elderly doesn’t mean disabled but you also are not disabled either. The old lady could have arthritis, bad eyesight, heart issues etc that weren’t clearly visible. I think you were unreasonable here. You should have just sat in a normal seat further along the bus as by sitting in the priority seat there’s a chance someone with an obvious disability could have got on the bus for instance a blind man. Would you have gotten up then? or explained to him about your arm??

Many blind men (if physically healthy) can easily stand on buses. As can many elderly people!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 15/06/2023 07:22

Phoebo · 14/06/2023 02:34

Yeah sorry this. Imagine if the elderly lady fell and broke a hip! If I was that paranoid of my arm, I'd catch a cab

But the elderly woman could also get a cab if she is worried about falling, not saying g she should but she could. Presumably both wanted to take the bus as cabs are more expensive and using them all the time is probably not financially convenient.

Inmydreams88 · 15/06/2023 07:14

I don’t see anything wrong with you sitting in the priority seat if it was unoccupied, and you’ve admitted you’ve done this even before your broken arm. But the part that makes me cringe for you is then an elderly lady got on and you explained to her why you needed the seat more than her. Wow. That’s got to take some guts to be that selfish and entitled. Broken arm or not I would have got up and given her my seat. You said being elderly doesn’t mean disabled but you also are not disabled either. The old lady could have arthritis, bad eyesight, heart issues etc that weren’t clearly visible. I think you were unreasonable here. You should have just sat in a normal seat further along the bus as by sitting in the priority seat there’s a chance someone with an obvious disability could have got on the bus for instance a blind man. Would you have gotten up then? or explained to him about your arm??

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 15/06/2023 07:14

I think it’s fine. It’s not safe for you to stand due to risk of balance/someone banging in to you so you should get a seat. If you could easily get to another use that but you shouldn’t be made to stand.

PatientZorro · 15/06/2023 07:06

God the vitriol being displayed above by those determined to thump the OP for using a seat she was entitled to is unbelievable. Those posters need to address whatever in life is making them so angry rather than tearing chunks out of the OP for no good reason.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 06:37

Ok I’ll say that to them next time. However I expect they’ll say ‘’sit on one of the priority seats if you’ve got an injury. It’s what it’s for.’’🙂

OP posts:
sashh · 15/06/2023 06:30

Yes I have met lots of London bus drivers. None of them want to have to stop and call an ambulance.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 05:41

Didn't get back to sleep due to pain and stiffness in my shoulder blade..up having a cuppa now.

No I'm not mute but have you met many London bus drivers? They run by their own set of rules!

Of course i know I don't have a disability. I don't know how many times I need to say I'm very aware that this is temporary. But as also has been pointed out, the seat I was in is not simply for those with disabilities but are less able to stand. In order to ensure this remains as temporary as possible, I need to keep myself safe from further injury.....which means sitting in a priority seat. As pointed out by @Needmorelego in her photos, I was not doing anything wrong by doing so.

OP posts:
sashh · 15/06/2023 05:08

Spidey66 · 13/06/2023 17:46

Because to get there, I would have to walk up and down the bus while it was moving putting me at risk of falling and/or bumping into others.

Are you mute? When you get on the bus tell the driver I need you to not drive off until I am in a seat as I have a broken arm and if I fall it will rebreak and I will need an ambulance"

You are not disabled.

I hope you never are but this experience might give you an insight into what people with permanent disabilities have to deal with.

Anyway I’ve taken an extra dihydrocodeine tablet which is now kicking in so I’ll try and get some sleep now. Good night.

That must be nice, to be able to sleep without waking up in pain at stupid O'clock.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 04:02

But just because you felt I was unreasonable, doesn’t mean the whole of MN did!

Anyway I’ve taken an extra dihydrocodeine tablet which is now kicking in so I’ll try and get some sleep now. Good night.

OP posts:
myladydarbanville · 15/06/2023 03:57

at 57, I could be considered elderly to a 28 year old

Don't be silly. You know and we know what elderly means.

I think you were being unreasonable. You don't think you were being unreasonable, despite posting in AIBU asking if you were being unreasonable.

You felt entitled to take that seat. The end.

Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 03:50

Oh and while I’ve disagreed with people, I don’t think I’ve been rude. In fact, I’ve had far more vitriol towards me. If you feel I’ve been unreasonably angry, feel free to report me to MNHQ. There has also been a large number of supportive posters so clearly it’s not a case of me asking AIBU, MN saying a clear ‘yes’ but me still being firm that I’m not!

OP posts:
Spidey66 · 15/06/2023 03:38

Being elderly is not a disability, and is quite ageist to suggest it. Disregarding my current situation, at 57, I could be considered elderly to a 28 year old….but if I’m on a bus with a 28 year old who is pregnant, or has a broken leg, should they give me the priority seat by virtue of my age? Of course not! Priority seats are for those who need them..

And I’ve no idea why the hospital removed the cast. It was put on in A&E and removed a week later in the fracture clinic. Maybe orthopaedics disagreed with it as a treatment plan? I don’t know. I do know that while the itching drove me insane, I did feel it provided my arm with support and there has been more pain without it, especially at night for some reason. I slept better with it as without it I have struggled to get comfortable (which is why I’m posting at stupid o’clock…slept ok from 11.30 to 2.30, woke for the loo and struggling to get comfortable again).

OP posts:
myladydarbanville · 14/06/2023 23:29

Next time you go on a bus, try boarding it with only one arm while simultaneously trying to avoid anyone bumping into the other one and maybe you will understand my difficulty.

For someone who twittered on about their "Catholic guilt" re taking this seat, you certainly have been very angry with anyone who said you were unreasonable - including people who have been navigating public transport for many years, while dealing with great pain, and/or with injuries, who would not dream of occupying a seat when an elderly person got on board.

Why bother asking, in AIBU, if you are so certain you are reasonable?

HangingOver · 14/06/2023 23:21

Why on earth did the take the cast off of a broken arm? I've broken loads of bones and never had one off after a week, even for the little breaks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread