Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to resign

232 replies

Mossiebonbon · 13/06/2023 16:05

My husband works in a secondary school in pastoral care, whereby each year group is assigned a support member of staff. There are 5 Members of staff with the same role as him, he currently works with Y11.
Next year he has been assigned to work with Y8 , the year our daughter is in. My husband does not feel comfortable working with our daughters year group , potentially having to reprimand her friends for behavior or liaise with parents that he knows personally.

The head teacher has suggested he will have to resign if he doesn’t work with this year group. There is no explanation , to our knowledge, for why the other pastoral members of staff can’t swap to be with Y8. Headteacher just says she wants consistency.

AIBU to think headteacher cannot threaten my husband like this? I appreciate your comments

OP posts:
cansu · 13/06/2023 17:28

I think this sounds like a head who just dislikes being challenged. There are some like this. I would send a very polite email saying that he was concerned about issues relating to safeguarding and conflicts of interest. The head needs to be aware that he may be disciplining and dealing with sensitive information about students who may also be visiting his home as a guest and friend of his daughter. He will be talking to parents about these issues but also potentially hosting their children. If the head feels this is not an issue then he will of course continue in his role. She is being of course utterly ridiculous.

Preps · 13/06/2023 17:27

She's not threatening him and she can't ask him to resign, but she's making a reasonable request within his contract/job description, so bottom line is his choice is either to do it or resign. This will always be a risk if you're working in your child's school, it's up to him to manage that.

Ideally she'd take his concerns into account, but if that creates disruption for other staff and students, she doesn't need to.

MysteryBelle · 13/06/2023 17:26

I’m trying to think why the head teacher won’t even consider your dh switching years. Her stated reason is that she wants consistency.

Could it be that the other liaisons have had to work with their children’s year groups and so then op’s dh does too? Or, there is a specific student with a lot of difficulties who will now be in dh’s year group which means the other liaisons have already had to manage that student and now it’s dh’s “turn”—so this request looks like he’s trying to wiggle out of it which means one of the others would have to manage the student twice. ?

Just trying to figure out the possible logic of the head teacher’s position.

bridgetreilly · 13/06/2023 17:26

It should not be a big deal for a HT to sort this out. He could take the Y9s while the person supposed to have Y9 starts again with Y8. Yes, consistency is ideal but it can’t be guaranteed, e.g. if a member of staff leaves or moves to a new role. I would suggest he talks to his union and gets advice on how to fix this.

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 13/06/2023 17:26

I’ve been in this situation twice and it’s been ok - largely because my boys were pretty compliant and because I didn’t teach them in my subject (I refused that). Actually, at times it was a real help. Totally get why he doesn’t want to take the year group and I think my slt would probably seek to swap a year, just to avoid any difficulties.

HatchetJob · 13/06/2023 17:25

Is this a MAT? Who manages pastoral staff as it’s usually not HT but a deputy head, might get more sense out of them.
To be honest though, if he was a teacher he might have to teach your child. It’s why most people went to different schools to their parent teachers to avoid this.
I think it would be better to have a conversation that if an issue arose then maybe another year manager could step in if your child was involved in something. It might never even come up as an issue as well. Sometimes it’s better to go in with a solution than a problem, especially as there might not even be one.

HareRaising · 13/06/2023 17:24

Itsbeennice · 13/06/2023 16:50

The headteacher isn’t threatening him. She’s being very clear - if he’s not happy with her expectations, which sound completely reasonable, then his option is to resign.
in all honesty I think he might need to get over himself. This is what it’s like working in education - people know people.

This 100 times over. He has not been asked to resign at all.

pimplesquisher · 13/06/2023 17:22
  1. He hasn't been asked to resign
  2. Totally reasonable to be asked to work with Y8
princesssugarless · 13/06/2023 17:22

I suspect they may have a transition team for year 7 then year 8 a new pastoral lead takes over and follows them through to y11. Any other year groups would have had a lot of work put into relationships etc so I suppose they could be asked to change but the head would have to consider what plan is in the best interests of both year groups.

Asking him to resign is abit excessive though, but I suppose if there is no other job role available what other choice is there?

NewShoes · 13/06/2023 17:18

In my school teachers do not tend to teach classes in the year group their child is in. Seems to me the Head is being unreasonable here and I would contact the union for advice in this case.

pleasehelpwi3 · 13/06/2023 17:15

Idiot headteacher. My child was in the same year group a few years ago- that was awkward enough.
The HT is also undermining your husband even before the job starts- his ability to be seen to be treating all children fairly. He is also putting your daughter in a potentially difficult situation. You as the non teaching parent could complain about that as a parent to the governors- not about your husband but the situation from your daughter's point of view.
I don't even think it would count as a 'reasonable request' from the HT- although I'm a union rep for the NEU I'm not a knowledgable one- maybe one could come along and say if they considered it to be unfair dismissal if your husband refused to be HoY 8.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 13/06/2023 17:15

Is he a Head of Year OP? A qualified teacher? Or does he have a "learning mentor" or similar role. It makes a difference if he's asking to change the main pastoral lead / HoY for a year group or if he's one of several adults assigned to the year.

lieselotte · 13/06/2023 17:14

If he is head of year, can't he just say he doesn't want that role? Presumably it would mean a pay cut though.

I can see both sides - after all, you might have 3 kids and you couldn't refuse to work with all their year groups. But I would have thought there would be an alternative option if the head looks hard enough.

Ladybowes · 13/06/2023 17:10

Consistency is a rubbish argument - I can see why in an ideal world a school might want this - but teachers leave all the time and not always at the end of the school year. I don't understand why the head can't be more flexible. As I said already head teacher is not going to win any awards for their management style and support of staff!

maddening · 13/06/2023 17:09

My reply would be that I would not resign however I am raising a conflict of interest concern which should be taken through relevant governance in order that the management team can ensure that the manage this conflict appropriately.

I would also ask that they recognise that their request for resignation is inappropriate

towriteyoumustlive · 13/06/2023 17:09

Mossiebonbon · 13/06/2023 16:05

My husband works in a secondary school in pastoral care, whereby each year group is assigned a support member of staff. There are 5 Members of staff with the same role as him, he currently works with Y11.
Next year he has been assigned to work with Y8 , the year our daughter is in. My husband does not feel comfortable working with our daughters year group , potentially having to reprimand her friends for behavior or liaise with parents that he knows personally.

The head teacher has suggested he will have to resign if he doesn’t work with this year group. There is no explanation , to our knowledge, for why the other pastoral members of staff can’t swap to be with Y8. Headteacher just says she wants consistency.

AIBU to think headteacher cannot threaten my husband like this? I appreciate your comments

The head has not threatened him. They have assigned him Y8 and the reason being for consistency.

Is their reasoning correct? Is the current Y8 pastoral person moving to Y9. Y9 to Y10 etc...?

What about this year's Y7 pastoral person? Why are they not going to Y8?

Ultimately he is employed in a pastoral role and therefore can be assigned any year. He can either accept or resign.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 13/06/2023 17:08

Mossiebonbon · 13/06/2023 16:05

My husband works in a secondary school in pastoral care, whereby each year group is assigned a support member of staff. There are 5 Members of staff with the same role as him, he currently works with Y11.
Next year he has been assigned to work with Y8 , the year our daughter is in. My husband does not feel comfortable working with our daughters year group , potentially having to reprimand her friends for behavior or liaise with parents that he knows personally.

The head teacher has suggested he will have to resign if he doesn’t work with this year group. There is no explanation , to our knowledge, for why the other pastoral members of staff can’t swap to be with Y8. Headteacher just says she wants consistency.

AIBU to think headteacher cannot threaten my husband like this? I appreciate your comments

She isn't threatening him. She's giving him a choice. If he can't fulfill the role he's contracted to do, then she's right. He should resign.

Weird way of thinking on his part as well. That he doesn't want to reprimand his daughter's friends. Maybe should have thought of that before sending her to the school he works in.

Fairydustandsparklylights · 13/06/2023 17:08

toomanyleggings · 13/06/2023 17:05

@Fairydustandsparklylights the op hasn’t said he is a head of year

The Op said each year group is assigned a support member of staff which I just asssumed to mean head of year. No school I’ve ever worked at had an extra pastoral assistant or assistant heads of year for each year group, normally just a couple of pastoral assistants to cover all year groups. Apologies if I misunderstood.

MargaretThursday · 13/06/2023 17:06

If it's the case that they take year 8 through to 11 (which is what happens at our school) then I don't think they're being unreasonable.
The thought is that children, especially the vulnerable ones, can build up a relationship with the head of year who can give a degree of consistency.

toomanyleggings · 13/06/2023 17:05

@Fairydustandsparklylights the op hasn’t said he is a head of year

toomanyleggings · 13/06/2023 17:04

Is he actually a teacher or some other type of just pastoral role? It may be that the headteacher doesn’t want him in the role at all

Fairydustandsparklylights · 13/06/2023 17:03

If he is Y11, then in theory he should be going down to Y7. Is there a reason he isn’t doing this? I can understand the current y8, y9 and y10 heads of year going into y9, y10 and y11 not wanting to switch. You get to know the children and parents very well and that type of consistency is good and needed. The main question is, why is the person chosen to do y7 not able to do y8 instead?

Ladybowes · 13/06/2023 17:01

Itsbeennice · 13/06/2023 16:56

@Ljhunt
“even just classroom teachers wouldn’t teach the year group their child is in”
This isn’t true. Of course teachers teach the same year group their own child is in. Some have to teach their own child in niche subjects.
As a class teacher, the DH will possibly have to administer sanctions to the DD’s friends. As a head of year, the same too. It’s really no biggie - if he feels uncomfortable then it would be very odd if someone couldn’t deputise for him.
If her friends have all seen him moving the lawn in his speedos, of course, that might awkward as fuck - but his fault for not thinking ahead!

Agree with this too. Head teacher is being a dick making a massive deal out of this and suggesting the teacher resigns etc. Not a very supportive or caring head teacher from what is said here. And as pp has said could be seen as constructive dismissal.

TripleDaisySummer · 13/06/2023 17:01

Leftbutcameback · 13/06/2023 16:24

He needs to speak to his union rep, check his contract and related policies as to his role, and make sure he keeps a note of everything in writing.

This.

As long as he's raised concerns in writing any issues he could then point back to that if any issues do arise.

Twillow · 13/06/2023 17:00

Soontobe60 · 13/06/2023 16:10

Which can be done with any other year group.

Exactly. I taught in the school my children went to and was never placed in the same year group. Tell him to speak to his union asap - it's absolutely not a resign situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread