Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to resign

232 replies

Mossiebonbon · 13/06/2023 16:05

My husband works in a secondary school in pastoral care, whereby each year group is assigned a support member of staff. There are 5 Members of staff with the same role as him, he currently works with Y11.
Next year he has been assigned to work with Y8 , the year our daughter is in. My husband does not feel comfortable working with our daughters year group , potentially having to reprimand her friends for behavior or liaise with parents that he knows personally.

The head teacher has suggested he will have to resign if he doesn’t work with this year group. There is no explanation , to our knowledge, for why the other pastoral members of staff can’t swap to be with Y8. Headteacher just says she wants consistency.

AIBU to think headteacher cannot threaten my husband like this? I appreciate your comments

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 13/06/2023 18:09

Allergictoironing · 13/06/2023 18:00

The OP's husband may well be 100% professional, and able to compartmentalise work and social lives, but the situation is open to others' perception of there being a conflict of interest.

Placing him in a position where there is the potential for other people e.g. other parents, to accuse him of bias and/or unprofessional behaviour, could reflect very badly not just on him but on the HT/school as well.

You'd have to ask a lot of staff to leave their roles in schools if that is the case- or have a national ban on appointing locan people to work in schools.

MrsLiam · 13/06/2023 18:09

Surely if he's with departing Year 11 now, the most sensible thing would be for him to take on the incoming Year 7s? Then all the other staff could stick with their current group and move up with them.

Unless the Head feels there would be some benefit to working with his daughter's cohort? But she does, she hasn't explained it well.

greenstrawberry · 13/06/2023 18:08

Could he go to the governors with a plea for it to be considered? Sounds like he is being reasonable.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/06/2023 18:08

How is his being moved from yr 11 to yr8 'consistency'?
I'd have thought he'd be back to yr7 following the pattern 80smercedes describes.Confused

Purplecatshopaholic · 13/06/2023 18:05

You don’t generally jump straight to resignation! Is there a back story here? And/or is the HT woefully out of their depth in their role?

Allergictoironing · 13/06/2023 18:00

The OP's husband may well be 100% professional, and able to compartmentalise work and social lives, but the situation is open to others' perception of there being a conflict of interest.

Placing him in a position where there is the potential for other people e.g. other parents, to accuse him of bias and/or unprofessional behaviour, could reflect very badly not just on him but on the HT/school as well.

LillyoftheMountain · 13/06/2023 18:00

It’s a normal request for your husband to make. I get the feeling head teacher likes a bit of drama and doesn’t like being questioned even if they have made a stupid decision.

Telling an employee to quit if they’re not happy with something is the sort of thing an inexperienced manager does. I’m assuming they are new to role?

Dominoeffecter · 13/06/2023 17:58

80smercedes · 13/06/2023 16:09

In my children's school the head of year/pastoral support follows their year group through the school from Yr7 to Yr11, so in the scenario you describe this year's Yr7 colleague would have Yr8 them next year. Is there a reason why they aren't staying with their current year group?

A lot of schools have a dedicated year 7 head

Preps · 13/06/2023 17:53

I don't think having access to confidential information about families you know is an argument that can be used. He'd effectively be saying he can't be trusted to deal with that professionally.

LuluBlakey1 · 13/06/2023 17:52

PickySlackTastic · 13/06/2023 17:48

Ht mentioning resignation is not a good look.

My first thoughts were that it’s quite late in the year to be addressing this. Is it the first time the DH has brought this up? And as per pp, I’m surprised that the Dh isn’t line managed by a deputy head or pastoral lead? It’s possible that the Ht just felt a bit ambushed in the moment and reacted poorly. Ideally, this would have been discussed via line manger before Easter holidays.

As an aside, schools work in so many different ways, so this person may or may not be a teacher, may or may not be a HOY.

You are quite right. He may not be a HOY. He may simply support the HOY to manage aspects of the work with the year group- in which case it is even less of an issue for him.

LadyEloise1 · 13/06/2023 17:52

HerNameIsIncontinentiaButtocks · 13/06/2023 16:10

He's trying to carry out his job better by not being subject to conflicting loyalties. It does seem odd that the head isn't countenancing switching him to another year group.

I agree 💯 with you

Preps · 13/06/2023 17:51

I think he can contact his union for support re his options and how to approach the negotiation, I doubt very much that they'd get involved with the actual decision. IME unions will tell staff the school has done all it can/should where that is the case.

He could raise a grievance if it can't be resolved informally. Ultimately, whilst it may not be ideal, he's not being asked to do anything outside of his contract, so I can't really see the governors overruling the head.

Maybe and it is maybe, it would have to be done very carefully, parents would complain if they knew the parent of a child in the year group was to be HOY......?

LuluBlakey1 · 13/06/2023 17:50

cansu · 13/06/2023 17:33

HareRaising it is very unreasonable. Teaching your child's year group is very different to a pastoral role. This person will be dealing with very confidential information. How would you feel if the parent of your child's friend knew the ins and outs of say your child's mental health needs, Send, how they had been racist or bullied someone? How about having to attend a meeting about poor attendance or behaviour with a school friends parent? Perhaps you had been ill or you had been in an abusive relationship. Would you really want this? No.

It is often the case now in schools that local people work in secondary schools, many as support staff, and as such (now that teachers are much less often in pastoral roles) are often in jobs where they are aware of confidential info about children and families. A good school will make that whole area part of their training and induction of staff so that they are absolutely clear what is expected of them. It's no different to your child having a GP you might know, or a friend's parents being social workers, nurses, doctors or any other profession where they work to care for/support people. In my experience the biggest issue for the support staff HOY is the behaviour of parents who have challenging children and who think they can treat the member of staff with less respect because they are local.

PickySlackTastic · 13/06/2023 17:48

Ht mentioning resignation is not a good look.

My first thoughts were that it’s quite late in the year to be addressing this. Is it the first time the DH has brought this up? And as per pp, I’m surprised that the Dh isn’t line managed by a deputy head or pastoral lead? It’s possible that the Ht just felt a bit ambushed in the moment and reacted poorly. Ideally, this would have been discussed via line manger before Easter holidays.

As an aside, schools work in so many different ways, so this person may or may not be a teacher, may or may not be a HOY.

LlynTegid · 13/06/2023 17:45

I think the union should be contacted for support/advice. Whilst a teacher for one individual subject might not be able to avoid teaching their child and friends, this is very different.

LuluBlakey1 · 13/06/2023 17:41

Depends how the pastoral system in the school works.
Do the Head of Year change year groups every year or do they stay with their year group until the end of Y11?

If they stay with their year group that would mean 150 children (guessing at year group size) who already have a Head of Year who they know and who knows them, having to swop to accommodate your husband not wanting to be in charge of Y8. So their HOY would have to take Y8 so your husband could take their year group instead. It disrupts 150 children + another HOY.

That hardly seems fair when your husband's year group (Y11) have left and he is the freed up HOY.

However, if they change the HOY every year in the school, which would be unusual and not in any child's best interests, it makes no difference if he takes another year group

But, I bet his contract/job description says at the end, something like 'and carry out any other task reasonably required by the Headteacher'. This is one of those tasks and hr has to do it.

Zonder · 13/06/2023 17:36

He needs to contact his union.

Please don't say he's not in a union.

Sundaefraise · 13/06/2023 17:34

Huytffdddc · 13/06/2023 17:29

The school has to seek to keep independence, unless there is a compelling reason not to (e.g. short staffed).

Are you sure that there isn’t another issue driving this as Head Teachers (some) will deliberately put up conflict or issues (e.g. changing a teacher’s year group from 1 to 6 for no reason) if they want to clear house.

I was thinking this - that perhaps for whatever reason she doesn’t actually want to accommodate him, because if she really valued him and wanted him to stay I imagine something could be done.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 13/06/2023 17:33

Theunamedcat · 13/06/2023 16:17

He needs to get his concerns in writing before year start then any issues he can just refer back to it

Yes, this. The Head's lack of flexibility seems odd to me, but then, I have never taught in the English school system, so wouldn't really know what's what.

cansu · 13/06/2023 17:33

HareRaising it is very unreasonable. Teaching your child's year group is very different to a pastoral role. This person will be dealing with very confidential information. How would you feel if the parent of your child's friend knew the ins and outs of say your child's mental health needs, Send, how they had been racist or bullied someone? How about having to attend a meeting about poor attendance or behaviour with a school friends parent? Perhaps you had been ill or you had been in an abusive relationship. Would you really want this? No.

WhoToBeToday · 13/06/2023 17:32

You could always move your daughter.......

I am not sure what you expect really? The pastoral care of a whole school being disrupted (establish relationships altered/tactical planning thrown out of the window) because of one child. Your DH is being precious.

I would suggest the vast majority of kids have very little to do with the Head of Year....unless they are particularly troublesome/troubled background. And surely if something does occur specifically with your DD he just needs to agree a way forward in advance (so her tutor is the main point of call and then if a realy HOY issue it is potentially taken by the Pastoral Head.

As above, unless your DD has real issues I cannot see the problem

So there are 3 choices

  1. Your DH fulfils his job - and calls for support if an issue arises
  2. You DH resigns - either completely from the school because he does not feel he can do 1)
  3. You move your daughter because your DH does not feel he can do 1)
Huytffdddc · 13/06/2023 17:32

Preps · 13/06/2023 17:27

She's not threatening him and she can't ask him to resign, but she's making a reasonable request within his contract/job description, so bottom line is his choice is either to do it or resign. This will always be a risk if you're working in your child's school, it's up to him to manage that.

Ideally she'd take his concerns into account, but if that creates disruption for other staff and students, she doesn't need to.

It’s the HT’s job to manage risk, not staff. It’s also independence as a factor.

I agree it could be a reasonable request but if so, it should come with a reasonable explanation. It would be reasonable to understand what that is so any risk can be managed.

Huytffdddc · 13/06/2023 17:29

Mossiebonbon · 13/06/2023 16:05

My husband works in a secondary school in pastoral care, whereby each year group is assigned a support member of staff. There are 5 Members of staff with the same role as him, he currently works with Y11.
Next year he has been assigned to work with Y8 , the year our daughter is in. My husband does not feel comfortable working with our daughters year group , potentially having to reprimand her friends for behavior or liaise with parents that he knows personally.

The head teacher has suggested he will have to resign if he doesn’t work with this year group. There is no explanation , to our knowledge, for why the other pastoral members of staff can’t swap to be with Y8. Headteacher just says she wants consistency.

AIBU to think headteacher cannot threaten my husband like this? I appreciate your comments

The school has to seek to keep independence, unless there is a compelling reason not to (e.g. short staffed).

Are you sure that there isn’t another issue driving this as Head Teachers (some) will deliberately put up conflict or issues (e.g. changing a teacher’s year group from 1 to 6 for no reason) if they want to clear house.

bridgetreilly · 13/06/2023 17:28

Also, this is not the same as teaching a your child. This is a specifically pastoral role. I think the HT should be able to see that it’s not in anyone’s best interests.

DyslexicPoster · 13/06/2023 17:28

Can't your dh raise this with the chair of governors? If I was him I'd put my reasons in writing with aren't unreasonable. It's unlikely to be for consistency as he isn't currently pastoral lead for them now in year 7. Once the HT gives their reasons, if it still seem unreasonable I'd go to the chair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread