Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be constantly irritated by my sister and annoyed about one upmanship

140 replies

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 15:30

I don't really know if any of this makes sense but I feel like I'm starting to lose the plot. I have a sister (as well as other siblings), we are a few years apart both in 30s. She has a couple of kids, I have three. Growing up we were quite close, shared a room etc but since we have grown up we still see each other alot but I feel constantly irritated. She copies absolutely everything I/we do as a family. Sounds petty, but I mean everything. Whatever I buy my eldest, it is then brought for her eldest ( a year younger), even if I don't share she will remark on the things on the background of photos for example and within a day they have it. I then get constant 'oh I cant believe my DC had this/done this a year earlier' 🙄 and absolutely everything is upgraded so it comes with 'oh do you have the standard one, we brought the XL version, the bigger set..etc etc' it sounds petty, but i kid you not, it's unrelenting, to the point she is booking the same holiday as us but of course a better room, package etc. I say nothing, but I'm at the point I don't tell her/show her much because I just know what's going to happen. It's constant one upmanship.
She absolutely demands attention, to the point she makes things up, her pregnancies being the worst times. we (our family) had a running commentary of everything, and I admit she had a few health niggles in that time but I caught her out lying time and time again about things that didnt quite add up but were scaring my mum to bits unnecessarily.
Now it's the thought of her announcing another pregnancy. Sounds utterly ridiculous again I know, but I'm absolutely worn down by it as the hints have started coming. I want her to be happy I really do, but it's the constant messages, the constant demands for attention and she will then have the youngest grandchild (and unlikely to be anymore to come from any of us) so will likely need some sort of parade for that too...🙄

My mum mentioned a few months ago when I voiced (in private) I was irritated by the one upmanship as my eldest has actually noticed himself (and he's 5!!) that she thinks she's jealous which I just don't get. She earns more, has a much "swankier" life style than us. I am content with my life and am not trying to compete for more. I just want to enjoy my things without feeling like it will either be put down or see it "done better" and rubbed in my face.

Am I being petty or is there a better way to manage this, I feel like I'm having to think about it way too much. I can't really distance myself as we meet regularly without it being very noticeable to everyone. I just find myself having to grit my teeth all the time.

OP posts:
OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 16:38

Thanks I'm reading through the replies and will respond. I'm trying to consider if this is my issue too, I just feel so annoyed.

Today's example, sister saw my dad this past weekend for 'fathers day'. Her choice as they were supposedly busy. We will see him this weekend. I've now just heard they will be going too because 'her son feels as they live further away noone in the family loves him' he's 4.
So there goes our father's day plans. It's constant emotional blackmail with my mum 🙄

And they see each other once a week for certain, and usually every other weekend so despite the distance geographically they see each other tonnes.

OP posts:
ejbaxa · 13/06/2023 16:38

She sounds sad/mad. Either way, very annoying.

Just stop posting photos and sharing stuff online. And don’t tell her where you’ve booked holidays or what you’ve bought. Or feed her fake news. If you book a holiday to Majorca, keep it quiet and tell her you’re thinking of going to Tenerife.

ThatFraggle · 13/06/2023 16:32

Tell her you are having family systems therapy.

DorritLittle · 13/06/2023 16:28

Just don’t send her photos, then she won’t know what you are up to. She’ll find that annoying! You are letting her observe your life and emulate it by sending them to her.

I agree though that it’s probably a compliment. I have raised my kids similarly to my sister who had kids before me. It wasn’t really copying so much as me feeling less confident about my choices and taking inspiration from hers.

The youngest grandchild thing is an odd one. I get feeling sad about not having another small baby, but that’s a small period of time. I have the youngest grandchild and don’t feel any more special because of it. And your kids are very little still too.

Londoncallingnananana · 13/06/2023 16:27

Something is happening in her life that she's battling with..she clearly has low self esteem and you may have no idea why.

If I were you, turn that anger and frustration into care, empathy and patience. And try and find out what has happened. Be there for her.

It could be something like her husband or ex cheated on her and she hasn't told you. It could be something worse.

It could be current or historic.

You guys are on the same team.

Turfwars · 13/06/2023 16:22

People can be jealous even when they have more than you in every way. It's a form of insecurity and it's irritating -but imagine how exhausting and relentless it must feel to constantly be on the lookout and get something someone else has just because of some compulsion.

Yeah just send her a link from now on. She's a sister. It's your duty to take the piss out of her mercilessly.

MMorales · 13/06/2023 16:20

Shes probably just competitive.

It's like you have to win all the time. The thing that you're winning at doesnt matter, you just want to win.

It doesnt have to make sense to anyone else, as long as it makes sense to her.

And it doesnt mean she is insecure, winning just feels good.

HotelNotPortofino · 13/06/2023 16:20

I’d just attach a link to every message/post

kids having fun
(link for you sis 😘)

Sunnydaysareuponus · 13/06/2023 16:16

Draw on a fake tattoo op and stand back and wait.
Mention an appointment for a delicate piercing...
Aren't you dyeing your hair red at the week end.?

Catchasingmewithspiders · 13/06/2023 16:15

If you come across as content with your life, and there is nothing wrong with that, and she is not content, for whatever reason, she could be trying to replicate your life "but better" in order to try to replicate your contentedness

sp12344 · 13/06/2023 16:15

Perhaps she feels insecure and that you make better choices than her and so wants to copy you. I would try to control the narrative either by saying ‘look what I’ve bought/done, why don’t you get it too?’ It may put her off or encourage her more but would be interesting to see if she wants advice.
Also you could falsely show things as if you’re doing them and then ‘change’ your mind when she is committed. It could put her off? With the holidays you could say you’re going to one place and then go somewhere else. If it’s upsetting you it could be fun to make a game of it, not to be mean but just to make it better for you.

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 16:13

Should add she's desperate (as in suffered gender disappointment) for a girl, and currently has two boys. I have a daughter.

OP posts:
OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 16:11

@AmeIia I get what you are saying and I would be jealous if she has another baby but purely from the point of view that I probably will never stop wanting them myself so it's the cute factor and broodiness 🤣 but I know I would only now be having another for ME if that makes sense. Financially, our house etc etc doesn't make any sense to have more, I'd be putting our self under strain. On her side she tries to live a jet set life and insists her children are more well travelled (which is true) and she wants them to experience culture etc. All fine, but I genuinely think another child would make it much more difficult to continue with her current life style. I'm not sure if she will have another or she's just trying to suggest it to gauge a reaction. She is very sadistic in that respect - as in trying to suggest she will do something for kicks (not suggesting she's sadistic to want more children).

I just genuinely hate the impact it has elsewhere too, making my mum worry about her pregnancy/ children for fictitious reasons to gain more attention.

Argh. Sorry I'm probably just venting.

OP posts:
AmeIia · 13/06/2023 16:00

Could it be a rivalry between you both that you're not realising? The fact that you say "and she will have the youngest grandchild" stood out, because why would you even think that way if there's no issue/jealousy/rivalry from your side?

Aside of that I'd just leave her to it and take it as a compliment that she copies everything you have/do. My aunt is the exact same with my Mum and she just sits back and watches with pride when yet again she's copied. It screams that she knows my Mum has good choice 😄

Curseofthenation · 13/06/2023 16:00

I feel quite sad for her. She must live a very hollow life to act this way.

If it's really annoying though and you're feeling petty then you could go the other way and play her at her own game to make her uncomfortable. Tell her how lucky she is, how you desperately wish you could have afforded the expensive holiday package etc, but that your DC have to make do. Really ram it down her throat every time.

If you think she might get a kick out of the first approach then I might do the same thing but in a really sarcastic tone. Essentially constantly ribbing on her in a lighthearted way.

I am petty though. The mature thing to do is obviously grin and bear it. She won't change as it's obviously quite deliberate and obsessive behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread