Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be constantly irritated by my sister and annoyed about one upmanship

140 replies

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 15:30

I don't really know if any of this makes sense but I feel like I'm starting to lose the plot. I have a sister (as well as other siblings), we are a few years apart both in 30s. She has a couple of kids, I have three. Growing up we were quite close, shared a room etc but since we have grown up we still see each other alot but I feel constantly irritated. She copies absolutely everything I/we do as a family. Sounds petty, but I mean everything. Whatever I buy my eldest, it is then brought for her eldest ( a year younger), even if I don't share she will remark on the things on the background of photos for example and within a day they have it. I then get constant 'oh I cant believe my DC had this/done this a year earlier' 🙄 and absolutely everything is upgraded so it comes with 'oh do you have the standard one, we brought the XL version, the bigger set..etc etc' it sounds petty, but i kid you not, it's unrelenting, to the point she is booking the same holiday as us but of course a better room, package etc. I say nothing, but I'm at the point I don't tell her/show her much because I just know what's going to happen. It's constant one upmanship.
She absolutely demands attention, to the point she makes things up, her pregnancies being the worst times. we (our family) had a running commentary of everything, and I admit she had a few health niggles in that time but I caught her out lying time and time again about things that didnt quite add up but were scaring my mum to bits unnecessarily.
Now it's the thought of her announcing another pregnancy. Sounds utterly ridiculous again I know, but I'm absolutely worn down by it as the hints have started coming. I want her to be happy I really do, but it's the constant messages, the constant demands for attention and she will then have the youngest grandchild (and unlikely to be anymore to come from any of us) so will likely need some sort of parade for that too...🙄

My mum mentioned a few months ago when I voiced (in private) I was irritated by the one upmanship as my eldest has actually noticed himself (and he's 5!!) that she thinks she's jealous which I just don't get. She earns more, has a much "swankier" life style than us. I am content with my life and am not trying to compete for more. I just want to enjoy my things without feeling like it will either be put down or see it "done better" and rubbed in my face.

Am I being petty or is there a better way to manage this, I feel like I'm having to think about it way too much. I can't really distance myself as we meet regularly without it being very noticeable to everyone. I just find myself having to grit my teeth all the time.

OP posts:
Kitkatfiend31 · 13/06/2023 19:44

I have a similar thing with my sister but much more low key. She and her DH have always had more money than us but got a car like ours a few weeks later, got married soon after us, had their first child soon after us. Always wanted to know what we were doing for holidays etc. It does seem to have died down a lot now but was weird when they can afford to do whatever holiday etc they want to but had to copy us. I do agree with the poster who said it is because you are content and she clearly isn't as I can see this in my situation.

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 19:43

Thanks everyone. I've already heard the 'thats what she's like' comments so I guess you are right. She really pushes them into things they've said they will not do so I guess this is it 🤷🏼 I will just have to take what I can get.

OP posts:
WaterIris · 13/06/2023 19:26

I'd make your social media private from her and pull back.

Tell her as little as possible and grey rock all the way.

MorganSeventh · 13/06/2023 19:23

I'm not sure necessarily that drastic, but there's been a lot of 'oh, you know what they're like' about my tricky relative over the years (ie don't rock the boat).

The status quo in your family seems to be that your sister is the tricky one, and you're the sibling who puts up with it, and it's likely your parents are familiar with that status quo and would prefer it to continue.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 13/06/2023 19:18

Keep an eye on what your parents do though, as often these patterns of behaviour are laid down in childhood, and it may be that they're, consciously or not, reinforcing them.

I would agree with this. It’s very noticeable in my cousin when someone else has a success story, new job or baby or something. It’s almost like she has a crisis and starts getting worse. The parents pander to her and if people don’t she becomes aggressive and accusational, sometimes targeting the person with lies. I’ve backed off a lot now I see it more and more. She’ll be off copying some one else soon and they’ll call it “flattering” without realising it’s actually quite single white female 🤣.

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 19:18

I mean potentially of course. That would be heartbreaking.

OP posts:
OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 19:17

@MorganSeventh so you mean that they will just 'side' with her and cut me out 😔

OP posts:
OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 19:15

@Whatthediddlyfeck that's brilliant. I will keep that one for when I need it😁

OP posts:
MorganSeventh · 13/06/2023 19:14

I think yes, unfortunately, the only way to win is not to play. I've had to step back from similar relatives, and come off social media. It's a shame because you do see less of the wider family as a result, but you can't change people, only your reaction to them.

Keep an eye on what your parents do though, as often these patterns of behaviour are laid down in childhood, and it may be that they're, consciously or not, reinforcing them.

ThatFraggle · 13/06/2023 19:12

Whatthediddlyfeck · 13/06/2023 18:42

ask her if she’s looking forward to her holiday in Elevenerife

😂

newtb · 13/06/2023 19:11

We had friends that copied nearly everything we did, without ever acknowledging it. Drove me mental

Until we had dd, he'd had a vasectomy nearly 20 years before. That stopped him!

Try to think of it as imitation being the sincerest form of flattery. Might help.

cunningartificer · 13/06/2023 19:09

I had a similar issue and found that lavish praise for the person concerned really helped. To a ridiculous degree but after a while it felt as though they were 'sated' of attention and calmed down. I always leapt in and asked them first about the things I knew they wanted to boast about. I agree it comes from insecurity of some kind but it's very hard to deal with.

ModestMoon · 13/06/2023 19:05

I have a cousin like that. Her sister copes by pretending to buy things and pretending to sign her kids up to activities. Genuinely it is quite funny, you should try it. She told her sister she'd signed her kids up to circus class, you guess what the sister did...

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 19:03

Brilliant suggestions. I may even buy the musical instruments for her children's birthdays.

I'm going to really pull back on communication as you have all suggested, and share directly with my parents only. I'm just a bit sad by arranging separate events etc we will inevitably be missing the big days for the foreseeable (boxing, new year) but I guess that's better than feeling resentful and the kids sensing it

Thank you everyone, as I have been wanting to post for ages but was worried you'd all say I was being a child and suck it up or whatever (except obviously I am still broody so have held my hands up there!)

OP posts:
RhosynBach · 13/06/2023 18:58

It sounds incredibly annoying op. I think you need to hold back with the amount of things you tell her. Like others have suggested, can you just pop into your parents house as a surprise so she doesn’t rock up too? And don’t mention you’re going on holiday- just go. If she asks just say it was a last minute deal. I agree with a pp that if she’s desperate for a girl and you have one it could be why she’s desperate to prove (to herself more than anyone) that she has more than you- possessions and attention wise- to make herself feel better about the situation. Must drive you crazy.

also- pretend you’re buying recorders or drums for your kids…

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 13/06/2023 18:58

She sounds like a sad act!

Lsquiggles · 13/06/2023 18:57

If you already have plans with your dad, why doesn't he tell your sister that, especially if they've already done their fathers day get together? You're all enabling this behaviour unfortunately, just say no when she tries to change your plans and ignore all the hints/drama about the other stuff because it really is childish

FofB · 13/06/2023 18:49

But you can control what you show and tell her.

Don't send pictures. Don't put it on social media. Don't say what your plans are.

Arrange something quietly for your Dad- let her have the actual day- but organise something lovely for you both. And don't tell her.

I can't imagine she will change, so you can only change how you behave and react. She is making herself feel better by pushing you down. And you are letting her- I guess out of a sense of loyalty to her.

LovePoppy · 13/06/2023 18:46

MMorales · 13/06/2023 16:20

Shes probably just competitive.

It's like you have to win all the time. The thing that you're winning at doesnt matter, you just want to win.

It doesnt have to make sense to anyone else, as long as it makes sense to her.

And it doesnt mean she is insecure, winning just feels good.

This just shrieks insecurity to me

Cinnamo · 13/06/2023 18:44

Ah that resonated about saying ok when people say no

i am the same; and have a sibling who is excessively opposite. To the point where there is grandparent guilt and that element of secrecy when doing something without them

its shit isn’t it, and like you say, sad for the cousins because I can’t face the drama either so I’ve backed off a lot over the last few years

no advice, just a fist bump of solidarity and all the wine

Whatthediddlyfeck · 13/06/2023 18:42

ask her if she’s looking forward to her holiday in Elevenerife

OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 18:36

And less time with their cousins because I can't stand the conversation.

OP posts:
OhWellIAmJustNutsThen · 13/06/2023 18:35

Oh ok I see what you are saying. It is sad because inevitably it's also my children that miss out. I'm geographically closer so we have lots of pop ins and 'hi's!' but less full days out with my parents if that makes sense.

It's really thought provoking though thanks.

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/06/2023 18:32

Perhaps that's part of it.

Bingo. Because it is not fair. But life is not. And over thinking about it will just make you miserable. As much as she gets her own way, she is not happy, or she would not feel the need to do this. Just remind yourself of that.

Womencanlift · 13/06/2023 18:32

I am in no way an armchair psychologist but if she is desperate for a girl and you have one then this behaviour is likely because in her eye she wants to have something that you don’t, the bigger holiday villa, the better car etc

Or she is just a CF

One way to get round it is just doing the opposite you usually would. For example book your holiday but instead of telling her you have booked say Tenerife, say you have booked Greece. Maybe even lay out a few Greek tourist books. Say how you can wait to go. And then when she says she has booked it saying have a nice time, we can’t wait for our holiday too…. in Tenerife (or better still don’t tell her until after you are back)

Same for things in the house. Can you borrow something that you know she will like from a friend? Then have it sitting there for her to see. When she inevitably buys the “better” version, say oh I need to tell Friend as that is hers and I am sure she will like it