Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was unfair on DS7

64 replies

Silver35 · 13/06/2023 14:49

I don't think I'm being unreasonable here but it's always good to check what others think!

DS7 stayed at his Dad's the weekend just gone. His birthday is tomorrow. His half brother's birthday was yesterday, and he was 5.

On the weekend he was at his Dad's, my ex and his partner threw a birthday party for his younger brother, with presents, food, birthday cake, some of his friends and all the extended family (on that side) went.

DS7 came home very upset because despite his birthday being only 3 days after his brother's, it wasn't acknowledged at all. No presents, birthday cake, no one there to see him.

He now won't be seeing his Dad for 3 weeks as he couldn't have him his regular weekend as he's going away.

Surely that's an awful thing to do, or am I just being overprotective here? Me and my ex don't get along so I'm hoping that isn't clouding my judgement!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/06/2023 15:21

Ooooh that’s horrible. I really wouldn’t like that.

Ask ex what he’s doing for your son’s birthday.

How nasty, esp when they’re so close in age

Tigofigo · 14/06/2023 15:18

Awful. But you can somewhat make up for his shitness by doing a party for him yourself

marmb87 · 14/06/2023 15:11

Christ how absolutely awful :-(

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 09:45

MissTrip82 · 14/06/2023 09:15

But that is relevant. It isn't just that his dad has not managed to make a fuss of his son, but that he's failed to do so whilst simultaneously making a fuss of his other son. It's appalling treatment. Nobody, anywhere, has suggested the second child is less important; everyone has been clear that they are BOTH important and it is not acceptable to make a birthday fuss for one and ignore the other's birthday in this situation.

No decent parent would do this, and no decent step parent would do it either. How this child is treated is how her child will be treated when this man moves on.

Again though, this would depend to me what has happened in previous years. This is obviously not the first birthday both children have had close together.

I never plan or do a birthday party for my DSC but I do them for my children (and yes their birthdays aren't massively far apart either). This is because their mum always has done something herself for DSC that my husband is either involved with/attends or at the very least bigs up to his DSC I.e. 'i bet you can't wait for your party/sleepover at mums, who's coming, what will you do, will you be staying up dead late? Blah blah blah'.

I do not and have never felt guilty about not throwing the same party for DSC as I do my DC because their own mother does the same for them.

If OP usually does a celebration for her son, I can see why the dad and SM didn't feel the need to do another one at their house. Really it is just the two children being treated broadly the same (you'll never get exact because OPs son has two homes and that's just how it is).

The issue here is the dad has seemingly not mentioned his birthday at all nor even bought him a gift.

I assume given that OP is so annoyed that the 5 year old had a party and her son didn't that she is someone who throws children a party and will be doing that for her son.

The dad is at fault here imo. I would bet my house actually that it was the step mother who arranged the 5 year olds party and she has every right to do that for her child without having to do the exact same for her step son, who's mother most likely will do it for him.

As we see time and time again on threads here, it's often the case that the mothers, both step mother and mother, end up doing the vast majority for their own children. I would assume this is the case here, SM has just thrown her child a party and the dad was there simply because he lives with them. I don't think that makes her at fault.

The dad should be acknowledging his son's birthday, in some form or another even if not a separate party himself.

aSofaNearYou · 14/06/2023 09:16

I mean yes, it's shit, but I wonder about the politics.

Does your ex leave everything to SM to sort and this is a bone of contention between them? If so, I can see why this has happened. Things like this will often happen when the couple consists of a stepmum doing what most mum's do for their own kids, and a dad doing the bare minimum for his.

But yes it is shit of him to have done nothing.

MissTrip82 · 14/06/2023 09:15

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 07:44

Agreed. I don't think OP should come at this at the angle of mentioning the 5 year olds birthday or that they should have shared the party or whatnot.

It needs to be about the fact that seemingly his dad hasn't brought it up at all or even got him a present so far as we know. Certainly not one to open on the day it seems.

But that is relevant. It isn't just that his dad has not managed to make a fuss of his son, but that he's failed to do so whilst simultaneously making a fuss of his other son. It's appalling treatment. Nobody, anywhere, has suggested the second child is less important; everyone has been clear that they are BOTH important and it is not acceptable to make a birthday fuss for one and ignore the other's birthday in this situation.

No decent parent would do this, and no decent step parent would do it either. How this child is treated is how her child will be treated when this man moves on.

BananaBlue · 14/06/2023 08:59

Imagine being a dad and having a family party to acknowledge only 1 of your DC, with your unacknowledged DC having a birthday that same week, his family in attendance and him watching on?

If I was a present relative I’d be having serious words with the dad, that poor poor child.

I cannot imagine a 7 YO will be able to rationalise that it’s equal because dad did nothing for either of us (our mums did) when his family were right there.

Next year I’d be keeping DC home, he doesn’t need to have his nose rubbed in it that way.

SallyWD · 14/06/2023 07:58

I thought you were going to say his dad would see your DS on his actual birthday. As he's not seeing him for 3 weeks that's very poor form! How can anyone be so insensitive?

user1492757084 · 14/06/2023 07:54

I hope you are organising a Birthday for your 7 year old and inviting all of DS extended family and a couple of friends. Make it his own but do invite the half brother.
Be the better person; show them how it's done. Set a good example and remind your son that they each have a special day; his is next weekend.

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 07:44

Makemyday99 · 14/06/2023 07:12

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the 5 yo having his own party after all it wasn’t your DS birthday that day & his brother is just as important to his mother as your ds is to you however why it wasn’t acknowledged byway of cards & gifts before he came back to you is odd. I do hate this general view on MN that children born to ex’s after first children aren’t as important as those born first

Agreed. I don't think OP should come at this at the angle of mentioning the 5 year olds birthday or that they should have shared the party or whatnot.

It needs to be about the fact that seemingly his dad hasn't brought it up at all or even got him a present so far as we know. Certainly not one to open on the day it seems.

Northernladdette · 14/06/2023 07:43

This is terrible, but try not to let your son think what you think and go ahead with your plans for his birthday. Poor lad x

CreepingJenny · 14/06/2023 07:25

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 13/06/2023 14:54

That is awful, I'm not surprised he's upset, his dad needs a rocket up his arse.

This!

Makemyday99 · 14/06/2023 07:12

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the 5 yo having his own party after all it wasn’t your DS birthday that day & his brother is just as important to his mother as your ds is to you however why it wasn’t acknowledged byway of cards & gifts before he came back to you is odd. I do hate this general view on MN that children born to ex’s after first children aren’t as important as those born first

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 07:12

As a stepmother myself I would never presume to throw my stepchildren a party personally (but I do my own DC).

Their mum has always done something (although definitely with DH either in attendance or at the very least if he can't be there, mentioning it/bigging it up/getting DSC presents for the day of course). I suspect she'd hate it actually if I threw them parties.

Itsbeennice · 14/06/2023 07:06

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 06:56

If it is the SM who arranged it all, there's no way I'd be told I was allowed to throw a party for my own child without also throwing one for DSS. I would assume OP is planning something for her son, so the SM should be allowed to do the same.

It's the dad who's unreasonable here if he's not arranged anything for his child or even got him a present to open on the day.

This.
Tend to your own fire, surely?
And being noticeably upset about it yourself could lead to a sense of entitlement in your DS, and the feeling that he is owed attention - just give it to him in the form of a lovely party for himself, which I am sure (hope, given your concern) you have thrown?

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 14/06/2023 07:04

I don't think they did anything wrong as such in the 5yo's birthday. It isn't fair on siblings with close birthdays to have the birthdays lumped together. The 5yo should be able to have a party without the 7yo's birthday being featured, and visa versa. The issue for me is that your 7yo won't be acknowledged by his father on his birthday. I'm guessing you will have a party for him for his birthday, but they should have done something separately for him.

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 06:56

I was *not allowed

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 06:56

If it is the SM who arranged it all, there's no way I'd be told I was allowed to throw a party for my own child without also throwing one for DSS. I would assume OP is planning something for her son, so the SM should be allowed to do the same.

It's the dad who's unreasonable here if he's not arranged anything for his child or even got him a present to open on the day.

ChokedOnHisPigeonPie · 14/06/2023 06:53

I highly suspect that it was the dad's partner that arranged all this for her child, not him. To be honest I don't think that is unreasonable. If she wants to arrange a party for her child she can, just like you can arrange one for your son.

However, your ex should have been checking whether your son was having a celebration and at least acknowledged that your son's birthday was also coming up.

I don't agree they needed a joint party. I'd have hated that as a kid just never getting to have my own birthday.

If you are doing some form of party / celebration and your ex knows that then I don't think it's as terrible, although I'd have expected ex to be there or at least get him his present before his birthday not 3 weeks after it.

JudgeRudy · 14/06/2023 06:44

Silver35 · 13/06/2023 14:49

I don't think I'm being unreasonable here but it's always good to check what others think!

DS7 stayed at his Dad's the weekend just gone. His birthday is tomorrow. His half brother's birthday was yesterday, and he was 5.

On the weekend he was at his Dad's, my ex and his partner threw a birthday party for his younger brother, with presents, food, birthday cake, some of his friends and all the extended family (on that side) went.

DS7 came home very upset because despite his birthday being only 3 days after his brother's, it wasn't acknowledged at all. No presents, birthday cake, no one there to see him.

He now won't be seeing his Dad for 3 weeks as he couldn't have him his regular weekend as he's going away.

Surely that's an awful thing to do, or am I just being overprotective here? Me and my ex don't get along so I'm hoping that isn't clouding my judgement!

I can understand your son being a bit disappointed but l don't necessarily think he's done anything wrong. To start with I'd bet that it's his wife who's organised the party for her child, not him. It's a day early.
Yes, the birthdays are close but I think it would be odd to hold a joint party if they don't live together.
Do you normally arrange a party for him? How would you have felt if this year step mum said we're doing his party? They'd likely need to get contact details from you for friends then would you be invited? Or it wouldn't really be a joint party, it would be his brothers party but he was there.
I'm going to assume his dad has a gift for him and will be in touch on the day.
BTW
Happy Birthday Son of Silver

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 14/06/2023 06:36

Wow, that is cruel. What a shit father.

BananaBlue · 14/06/2023 06:30

Kiwano · 13/06/2023 17:54

I suspect it's a case of the 5 year old's mother arranging the party but deciding that it's not her job to do so for the 7 year old. Pretty mean of her, but really it was up to your ex to fill in the gap. Has he even left presents for him for tomorrow?

Yep, I’m sure I’ve seen a thread like this in the past.

It’s dads job but it’s also cruel. Adults would be upset if a friendship group did this, let alone a small child.

OP I cannot imagine how your heart has broken for your child. Do you think ex will slowly extract himself from DC life? Because I wouldn’t want my child exposed to this messaging - it’s damaging.

What an absolute bastard. He doesn’t love this child.

MNTourist · 14/06/2023 06:21

Is your boy having a party with you (I hope so)?
if not could you quickly arrange something for the weekend?

Will paternal grandparents etc who were at
the party come to visit your DS on his birthday?

Sewingdufus · 13/06/2023 18:44

That sounds awful. IIWY I would be very careful about contact dates around birthday time in future.

InSpainTheRain · 13/06/2023 18:35

Omg that's horrible, you poor son. They should have celebrated both together (unless DS was to have a separate party with his Dad on his birthday). I have no idea how his Dad or Stepmum could do that - so sorry for your DS. I think you have to take it up with your ex.