Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS breaking up with GF after trip

362 replies

Flutterflys · 13/06/2023 14:06

My eldest DS is 19, he’s at uni but still lives at home.
In October he started dating a girl who was the friend of one of his friends flatmates at uni (a party was hosted). She was about to turn 18 but in sixth form 2 hours drive/ hour on the train away. They’ve made it work long distance, either she comes here on the weekend or he goes there, lately he’s been going to hers more as he didn’t have an uni classes on a Friday so they got more time together.
They have a massive trip planned together, Netherlands, France, Spain, Switzerland and Italy, 14 cities, 6 weeks. They leave at the start of July, back mid august.
Their hotels are non refundable mostly as are flights/trains. She has paid more especially towards hotels than DS, her family is just far better off than we are she has savings funding much of the trip.
His GF plans to go to uni in London after summer. This would be 4.5 hour drive or 2.5 hours on the train from where we are. So I asked DS if he plans to keep going down on the weekends when she’s there. This is when he told me he actually plans to breakup with her after the trip. I asked why and he told me he still loves her but the travel would be too much every week and he doesn’t want a relationship where he hardly sees the other person. He said longer term he never wants to move to London and her planned career would almost require her to be in London so it wouldn’t work.
Now I think it’s awful that he’s going to go on a six week, romantic trip with her then break up with her once she has her A-Level results.
He thinks the alternative is worse as most of the trip is non-refundable so one of them would lose out on the trip and money and the other would probably have to go alone. He said he still loves her and enjoys being with her so a last trip to have some memories will be nice. He was upset talking about it but is adamant he will break up with her as he doesn’t see it being viable.

AIBU thinking this is awful? I’m so disappointed in him it feels like he is using her for a trip now?

OP posts:
nuttermother · 13/06/2023 17:14

BotterMon · 13/06/2023 16:32

I thought he was being realistic about the future until you updated to say he's just messaged her asking whether she has thought about their future just before her last exam.

He's rather immature isn't he? And why are you so involved in your adult son's relationships?

healthy parent-child communication about life and relationships exists

MN: WHAT? WHY? STOP!!!

Some people actually like their parents when they're adults. I wouldn't call this "so involved". If a friend of yours was talking to you about being in this situation, and you were giving your perspective etc. that wouldn't be "so involved" would it?

ModestMoon · 13/06/2023 17:14

I agree with you OP that your DS is doing something bad. At that age I was madly in love with my boyfriend, and would have been devestated by something like this. Just because she's young doesn't mean that her feelings aren't just as valid, or that her expectations for the future are less concrete. If anything, I really did expect to be with my boyfriend then forever. I'm way more cynical now in my 30s, I don't think I'd consider a 10 years relationship "forever".

AscensionToCheese · 13/06/2023 17:14

Puppers · 13/06/2023 16:45

No, people aren't lacking in comprehension or "banging on" about anything. They are voicing opinions, just like you are.

Whilst he can clearly cover (some of) his expenses, it's possible that she has friends who could do the same. Perhaps she'd prefer to find a friend who can join her. Or maybe even go alone. Or not at all. The point is, it's wrong of him to deceive her in order to benefit from her money and her body for a summer.

Yeah, but so many people were saying it as the obvious choice I thought that I'd misread, as the OP said it was not refundable. They are teenagers, so I wouldn't think it easy to find someone else with the spare cash lying around.

Everyone here implying that he needs to make it up to her for dumping is probably WHY he doesn't want to break up. Because if he still wants to get his money's worth he'll be seen as the baddie.

But well done... as a result of all this meddling the DS has now done something even more stupid and messaged the girl during her exams!

Chrissakes.

Although.. my uni boyfriend was almost singlehandedly responsible for my First, the day he ditched me was my best exam result ever so maybe I have a warped view of these things.

SquaresandStarlings · 13/06/2023 17:13

But she may be thinking exactly the same as him.

So many couples split up just before they go off to university for the same reasons, with loads travelling together beforehand or having a gap year together.

People assume one or both decided on the trip that it wouldn't work long term, but I bet loads had made their mind up before they went away.

The only difference with your son OP is that he was honest (or naive) enough to fess up to his mum!

Daisydu · 13/06/2023 17:09

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 13/06/2023 15:09

I really don't understand all the people saying he's being mature and realistic.

Would you be happy to book and pay for you and your partner to go on the trip of a lifetime, only to be dumped on your return? Really? Because I very much doubt it.

And if you came on here and posted about how upset you were because your DP had planned to dump you all along, I don't think anyone would say "YABU, your ex did the right thing by stringing you along for six weeks".

Honestly, this place is ridiculous sometimes.

but she isn’t going to know he’s planning on breaking up is he. And to be honest what odds does it make if he does it now. Surely she will be just as gutted.

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 17:07

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 13/06/2023 16:52

I can't relate that to anything that's been said.

She's spending more money than him.

And, I didn't say it, but I always expected my 19yo to behave a lot better than when he was 6. But we all have different expectations of our children, I guess.

ClareBlue · 13/06/2023 17:05

Has your son ever given a moments thought to how his girlfriends might feel. All the discussion seems to be about him and what he wants.
Obviously she is going to be better off long term without him, but lets just hope not too much damage is done and she eventually realises not everyone is as self centered as this.
He should tell her and let her make an informed choice.

Feraldogmum · 13/06/2023 17:04

After having a discussion with him ,you’re eff3ctively sitting by whilst she mulls over a text that hints at or instigates a discussion about breakup. Dear God , I had sympathy with your dilemma prior to this but you’ve presided over this ,knowing it’s before an important exam. How do you think this will affect her? I hope to god this last exam Friday isn’t proceeded by others and it’s only one exam she may flunk. You should have told him to be grown up,think of her ,be patient and wait til after her exams.
Other than that he needs to tell her before the holiday, though I’d guess she likely thinks she’s being dumped right now ,he could try and row it back. Don’t normally approve of lying but for the next couple of days it’s preferable , I’m sure her parents would agree. I’d prepare yourself for angry mum and dad on your doorstep.

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 17:00

Catspyjamas17 · 13/06/2023 15:56

People are infantilising them because of their ages but 19 is an adult and 17 soon will be, if this had happened to me at 17 I would’ve been destroyed. Feelings don’t change because of your age.

They really do change with age. My feelings about relationship breakups then were Thank you - Next! I wanted to be as free as possible, and not tie myself to anyone.

And as many people's feelings will be very intense, and genuinely believing they will be together long term. I certainly would not have booked such a long holiday with somebody I didn't take seriously, and I can't imagine many would.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 13/06/2023 17:00

Izzabird · 13/06/2023 14:24

He hasn't 'turned out' to be anything. He's a teenager. A work in progress.

He may officially be a teenager but he's an adult.

Happierwithouthim · 13/06/2023 16:57

I haven't read the full thread, only OP's posts and some replies. I'd be delighted if my son was as sensible as your ds is. He admits to loving her and enjoying her company but is willing to lose that for both of them to have the chance of finding someone they can spend more time with and has similar plans for the future.

I spent my first summer after college in Crete with my bf, we broke up the April after that when he cheated on me, it didn't tarnish my memories of a great summer away with him and we managed to co - exist in a small college course for the remaining years of our degree, and despite the cheating I compare my relationship with him to that of my current relationship, he was respectful and we were equals while we were together, it took me 20 years to find another like him(except for the cheating part!!)

Prisonbreak · 13/06/2023 16:57

My boyfriend and I were going on 1 last trip together because we were long distance and it was such a struggle.

that was 11 years ago 😂 and we are still together and bought a house together 7 years ago.

feelings change but you are best keeping out of it

rainbowstardrops · 13/06/2023 16:54

If my DS was planning to do this to his current girlfriend, I'd be absolutely disgusted with him.

nuttermother · 13/06/2023 16:54

No one can tell you what your son is/isn't like, but speaking from the experience of being on the exact other side of this: he should end it or at least tell her he intends that they go their separate ways. If he ends it after the holiday, I can almost guarantee she won't have fond memories. Either:

  1. She will have no idea that he was going to, and she will look back at every moment and doubt every feeling/instinct she had. As well as being heartbroken, she may also feel cheated.
  1. She will anticipate that he's going to, and cling to the trip as a way to "convince him" not to. You shouldn't spend what should be a life-defining holiday trying to get someone to love you.
  1. Very teeny tiny chance that she'll be on the same page. But I think the key thing here is age difference: it might only be her first or second serious relationship, and no one can know how they'll feel at university unless they're already there (like your son). Why would you plan a holiday together (esp. if it's just the two of you and not a group of friends) if you weren't planning on trying to stay together?

If he tells her before, it should be extremely clear to him by her reaction whether she'll be ok with it (i.e. whether she'll be number 3.) The very fact that he says "nothing she can say will change my mind" indicates that he doesn't think she'll be ok with it.

This is also a grown up lesson for him in honesty with his future partners. He's being quite paternalistic by holding back this information from her. As a mum this is a good chance to encourage him to be transparent. People's feelings over money. Especially if you "love" them.

This gives her the chance to use that trip to get over him, have fun, and make stupid teenager mistakes.

For context: I was in the exact same situation (guy was 2 years older, met him at the beginning of my gap year. At the end of it I was going to uni and he was going to do a post grad 2.5 hours apart by train. We planned a whole Interrailing trip and then he bailed on it & said he wasn't sure if we wanted to be together because we were going to be further apart. I had already bought my ticket so I went, very teenager-y and heartbroken, and had the best growth experience in getting over him and myself, and learning to enjoy spending time alone AND got better at meeting new random people along the way which was great for university!!!)

Greentree1 · 13/06/2023 16:54

He has already planned the break up, he just hasn't bothered to tell her. He's looking forward to a nice holiday with a willing GF who has no idea what delights he has planned for her when they get back. I wonder how many of his friends know about it and are also laughing behind her back. If a relationship breaks up fair enough, planning it in advance to suit your convenience and sexual requirements is creepy beyond belief.

thaegumathteth · 13/06/2023 16:54

Why the actual fuck has he messaged her that when she still has exams to do. I thought he sounded immature before but now he sounds like an absolutely manipulative twat. I hope she dumps him.

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 13/06/2023 16:52

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 16:42

But if she gave him her piggybank stuffed full of £10 notes her grandmas had been giving her for years, would you make him give it back? Or would you be reasonable or pragmatic and let him keep it?

I can't relate that to anything that's been said.

TheHandmaiden · 13/06/2023 16:51

God I would not have got involved with this at all. Why is your son talking to you about his girlfriend anyway, assuming this is real?

Tinkerbyebye · 13/06/2023 16:51

I think he is being awful. That poor girl thinks she is ona nice holiday with her boyfriend, who all the while knows ipad is going to dump her

he should do the decent thing and split now, forgo his holiday and she takes someone else

however I do believe in Karma, and one day someone will do this to him, and I hope it horrible for him

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 13/06/2023 16:49

Hairpinleg · 13/06/2023 16:40

'Just out of curiosity' he asked her if she thought they had a future. What bizarre phrasing and badly timed. You haven't done either of them any favour interfering in this today.

This.

Why mess with her exams? Poor girl.
Share

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 13/06/2023 16:48

This.

Why mess with her exams? Poor girl.

Puppers · 13/06/2023 16:48

Flutterflys · 13/06/2023 16:23

Thanks for the feedback everyone.
He has decided to message her an open ended question of
“just out of curiosity have you thought about how we will work when you’ve gone to uni” he’s waiting for a reply.
He said he will wait and see what she says then come up with a plan.

This can't be real.

So the guy who was planning to wait all summer before he dumped her, now can't wait until she finishes her last exam on Friday before he drops this on her? What a fucking prince. He seems to enjoy playing games with people.

mydogisthebest · 13/06/2023 16:47

Folklore9074 · 13/06/2023 16:34

Stay out of it. Of course he was never going to spend forever with her! You’re over thinking this… let them have their nice experience and part ways.

Why was he never going to spend forever with her? I know quite a few people who met very young and are still together.

My 2 sisters met their now husbands when they were young (one 16 and the other 18) and both have now been married over 40 years.

Two of my nieces also met their now husbands when they were 17. They are now 35 and 38 and still together.

Also have other relatives and friends with similar stories

Puppers · 13/06/2023 16:45

AscensionToCheese · 13/06/2023 16:17

Am I missing something, or is it the usual MN reading comprehension fail? Why are people banging on about her 'taking a friend', what happens to his money?
She has paid 'more'. Not 'the majority of his expenses'.

I'm torn OP. I don't think it's nice to be dumped.

But there's all that money to lose. He is well within his rights to dump her, he's not doing anything wrong to need to 'compensate' by giving her friend a free trip.

So who goes and who stays home?

It was stupid to book this sort of trip in the first place, but as PP say the trip may be a deciding factor in a break up... so...

No, people aren't lacking in comprehension or "banging on" about anything. They are voicing opinions, just like you are.

Whilst he can clearly cover (some of) his expenses, it's possible that she has friends who could do the same. Perhaps she'd prefer to find a friend who can join her. Or maybe even go alone. Or not at all. The point is, it's wrong of him to deceive her in order to benefit from her money and her body for a summer.

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 16:45

W0tnow · 13/06/2023 16:37

Exactly. Maybe she’s thinking along the same lines? Might as well go out with a bang.

...in the upgraded hotels she paid for. At least he'll being making sure she gets her money's worth! Nice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread