Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS breaking up with GF after trip

362 replies

Flutterflys · 13/06/2023 14:06

My eldest DS is 19, he’s at uni but still lives at home.
In October he started dating a girl who was the friend of one of his friends flatmates at uni (a party was hosted). She was about to turn 18 but in sixth form 2 hours drive/ hour on the train away. They’ve made it work long distance, either she comes here on the weekend or he goes there, lately he’s been going to hers more as he didn’t have an uni classes on a Friday so they got more time together.
They have a massive trip planned together, Netherlands, France, Spain, Switzerland and Italy, 14 cities, 6 weeks. They leave at the start of July, back mid august.
Their hotels are non refundable mostly as are flights/trains. She has paid more especially towards hotels than DS, her family is just far better off than we are she has savings funding much of the trip.
His GF plans to go to uni in London after summer. This would be 4.5 hour drive or 2.5 hours on the train from where we are. So I asked DS if he plans to keep going down on the weekends when she’s there. This is when he told me he actually plans to breakup with her after the trip. I asked why and he told me he still loves her but the travel would be too much every week and he doesn’t want a relationship where he hardly sees the other person. He said longer term he never wants to move to London and her planned career would almost require her to be in London so it wouldn’t work.
Now I think it’s awful that he’s going to go on a six week, romantic trip with her then break up with her once she has her A-Level results.
He thinks the alternative is worse as most of the trip is non-refundable so one of them would lose out on the trip and money and the other would probably have to go alone. He said he still loves her and enjoys being with her so a last trip to have some memories will be nice. He was upset talking about it but is adamant he will break up with her as he doesn’t see it being viable.

AIBU thinking this is awful? I’m so disappointed in him it feels like he is using her for a trip now?

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 13/06/2023 15:18

This isn’t your issue or your decision so yabu to try to intervene. He is being realistic and pragmatic. They are incredibly young and 99 per cent likely to break up shortly afterwards anyway as they both forge ahead with uni life. I don’t think she’ll be traumatised by the trip if he does break up with her due to practicalities. I broke up with a boyfriend when I went to uni for the same reason, and again at the end of uni when I moved cities for work. It’s life. He sounds like he has his head screwed on to be honest.

AgnesX · 13/06/2023 15:18

Have to say it comes across as he's using her to find a nice holiday. Not nice.

Bet the odds that if he told her this she'd find an alternative to going with him. At it stands it's a crap way for her to start university life.

Regardless of how "realistic" he (and other posters who aren't on the receiving end) think they are I guarantee she won't feel the same way.

Thebigblueballoon · 13/06/2023 15:17

One other point OP: if your son breaks up with her immediately after this trip of a lifetime, she’s going to wonder what the heck she did wrong during that time. He’s at risk of giving her a complex! And she’ll feel double upset and humiliated if she later learns she “wasted” her summer holiday before university. It’s living a lie on her dime, and if you condone it in any way, you’re teaching him some pretty dodgy lessons about trust and honesty.

Rainallnight · 13/06/2023 15:17

I can kind of see how he’s got into this situation because teenagers aren’t known for their long term thinking.

But now that he has realised, I think he needs to do the decent thing, tell her how he feels, and give her the option to go with someone else.

For me, honestly, it’s the sex thing. Assuming they’re having sex, and it’s a newish thing, then there’s every chance she’ll just feel dreadful getting dumped after a summer of possible shagging around Europe. She could feel so used.

GreenIsMyFavoriteColour · 13/06/2023 15:17

Nobody at 18 is assuming their current partner will be there forever, she will be well aware she likely won't be walking down the aisle with him.

If you can't go on holiday with a partner unless you're 100pc certain you'll be staying with them forever well, we'd all have missed out on some great holidays.

Also ending relationships isn't that easy. He may end up bottling it and letting her dump him when she gets fed up with a long distance relationship next year.

I hate to break it to you but his next GF probably won't be the one he stays with forever, either, or the one after that.

They're kids, they'll have a great time and have some happy memories.

If the concern is money, can't you pay his share as a gift and make that problem evaporate.

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 15:17

saltinesandcoffeecups · 13/06/2023 15:12

I thought they are both paying for the trip… She is paying more because she wanted better hotels.

Because she thinks they're going to be together. Would she have done the same if he'd told her he was dumping her afterwards? We won't ever know because he kept that from her in case it meant him missing out on a nice holiday.

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 15:17

Daisydu · 13/06/2023 15:08

Doesn’t sound like he’s doing it to get a trip out of it, it sounds like he genuinely loves her and loves spending time with her so wants to go on the trip with her, however he realises he can’t see it going anywhere because they are going in different directions. I actually think he sounds quite mature about it

He has said he wishes he could talk to her about it and both know going in that after the trip things would come to an end but he’s worried she will just not want to go if he mentions. I asked if it was the thought of losing his money or something else and he said it would be annoying to lose the money but he’d be upset at missing out on a trip with someone he lives and enjoys spending time with.

It very much does sound like he doesn't want to miss the trip. And that he knows she would not want to go with him if she knew. This is far from mature.

MorrisZapp · 13/06/2023 15:17

I put off dumping a guy for two weeks because my hoover broke and he had a Henry.

Payday finally came and I binned him, I wasn't 18 either 😬

IsThereAnEchoInHere · 13/06/2023 15:16

Maybe they’ll realise they make better friends and retain their friendship.

Yes, because lier, user, fuckboy, leech, scumbag makes such a good friend!

SpareHeirOverThere · 13/06/2023 15:16

His choice may be for the best for her. It may not be. She may wish - after the trip and he has ended it - that she wishes she had not gone. She may be glad that she went, regardless of the relationship ending. It's impossible for any of us to say.

So... stay out of it. It's his call, and it's not clear which choice is better.

The best time, for her, may be about a month or so after she starts uni. She'll be settled into her new exciting life at uni, surrounded by single men her age, the trip will seem a lifetime ago, and the connection between the trip and the break-up will be less obvious. No time's good for heartbreak, but that's a less-bad time.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/06/2023 15:16

Daisydu · 13/06/2023 15:08

Doesn’t sound like he’s doing it to get a trip out of it, it sounds like he genuinely loves her and loves spending time with her so wants to go on the trip with her, however he realises he can’t see it going anywhere because they are going in different directions. I actually think he sounds quite mature about it

Then he can say that to her. And she can make her own mind up.

Because regardless of his pure and lovely sentiments, she may look back on it as manipulative and exploitative.

Lacucuracha · 13/06/2023 15:14

I think it’s fine, a pragmatical approach to just one of those things.

Maybe they’ll realise they make better friends and retain their friendship.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 13/06/2023 15:14

She might well turn the tables and break up with him after the trip. That would be a good outcome. If I were her, I would definitely have this in view because, let's face it, her earning potential combined with family money-in-hand outstrips his.

He's not doing anything particularly wrong but it's not particularly right either. He should - at the least - find a way to make up his side of the money and give that to her; all fair and square then.

I would argue though that when you have plans of breaking up, you don't love the other person. Your son is being entirely self-serving, OP but, he's young and he'll no doubt find out what it's like when the boot is on the other foot.

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 15:14

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 13/06/2023 14:57

Oh dear, young love!

It's sad, but he's probably not in a position to commit long term at the moment/at his age, so he's just being realistic, and honest with you....I'd say nothing!

Honest with his mother but not honest with his girlfriend. So it's OK to take a holiday she's paid most for when he's planning on dumping her as long as he tells his mummy?

And, to be fair to the op, even she's dismayed by his actions.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 13/06/2023 15:14

Everyone saying 'oh I bet she's thinking the same thing', well we have no clue whether she is or not, but he has blatantly stated that he is.

He should tell her so the ball is in her court.

It's sneaky and underhand to not mention it.

I'd be mortified if I was the OP that a male I had brought up thought that it was totally fine to treat a woman like this.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 13/06/2023 15:12

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 13/06/2023 15:09

I really don't understand all the people saying he's being mature and realistic.

Would you be happy to book and pay for you and your partner to go on the trip of a lifetime, only to be dumped on your return? Really? Because I very much doubt it.

And if you came on here and posted about how upset you were because your DP had planned to dump you all along, I don't think anyone would say "YABU, your ex did the right thing by stringing you along for six weeks".

Honestly, this place is ridiculous sometimes.

I thought they are both paying for the trip… She is paying more because she wanted better hotels.

IsThereAnEchoInHere · 13/06/2023 15:12

Daisydu · 13/06/2023 15:08

Doesn’t sound like he’s doing it to get a trip out of it, it sounds like he genuinely loves her and loves spending time with her so wants to go on the trip with her, however he realises he can’t see it going anywhere because they are going in different directions. I actually think he sounds quite mature about it

😆
No one is this nàive! No way.
Really loves her?
Please, he wants (almost) free vacation and six weeks worth of pussy.
He’s not mature, he’s a user and a common player. Dime in a dozen of a man.

Whattodowithit88 · 13/06/2023 15:12

So her trip of a lifetime is actually going to be a complete lie!!!
God my heart is breaking for her already

EmpressSoleil · 13/06/2023 15:12

Many years ago I was dating someone long distance and we spent weekends together. One weekend he came up on the Friday as usual, we had a lovely time, then Sunday just before he left he broke up with me!

I asked him why he didn't do it on the Friday and he said "I wanted us to have one last good weekend together". I was furious!!! I was more upset about the way he did it than the actual break up. How dare he, is what I kept thinking.

So yes, they might have a nice last few weeks, but he's running the risk of her hating him afterwards. I felt bad enough based on just one weekend and no money spent! Imagine how much worse she'd feel!

Panama2 · 13/06/2023 15:12

Maybe she is planning on dumping him?

VivaLesTartes · 13/06/2023 15:11

Just from a different point of view: My ex did almost the exact same with me on a trip before I went to uni. Not such a long trip or so expensive but the trip was awful as he had already made the decision to end it after, but hadn't told me. However it was very clear something was wrong but we weren't talking about it and it really cut me up.
It felt horrible. Obviously I can't say if it would have felt worse to find out earlier and miss out on the trip all together but being sort of "strung along" really hurt.
In the end it was the right decision to split as I had a fab time being single at uni and not long after fell for my now DH. I just wish the split had been handled differently.

bjrce · 13/06/2023 15:10

Beautiful3 · 13/06/2023 14:41

He's just being honest and realistic. Let them have this nice trip away, before he breaks up with her. I think the long distance thing is a deal breaker, I couldn't do it. I hate London too, so wouldn't even consider moving there for a partner. There's nothing wrong with what he intends to do, as long as he does it a month after the trip, and explains that it's only because of the long distance.

But that's entirely the point - he is absolutely not being honest.

If he was being honest, he would have a conversation with the GF about his plans after the Summer and she can make a fully informed decision.

There is every likelihood she may be thinking the same way, but he isn't doing that.

I don't agree with posters stating, he is very mature and realistic.

In actual fact he is being dishonest! If he was in any way decent he would tell her the truth.

As it stands he's not thinking about the fallout after the holday and how she'll feel once she finds out he used her to go on the holiday, planning all the time to break up afterwards.

But he won't need to deal with the fall out - he'll be at the other end of the country in his university- not his problem.

Leaving her with entirely different memorise - not like the ones he plans to have.

I have to say OP - your son is a little selfish bastard! I'd be ashamed of him treating some one like that! Its even worse the fact she's been to your home and formed a relationship with you and your family.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 13/06/2023 15:09

I really don't understand all the people saying he's being mature and realistic.

Would you be happy to book and pay for you and your partner to go on the trip of a lifetime, only to be dumped on your return? Really? Because I very much doubt it.

And if you came on here and posted about how upset you were because your DP had planned to dump you all along, I don't think anyone would say "YABU, your ex did the right thing by stringing you along for six weeks".

Honestly, this place is ridiculous sometimes.

silverbubbles · 13/06/2023 15:09

Stay well out of this. How do you know that this trip might not end up being the making of them and they stay together forever....

Also how do you know that his thoughts are not based on things she has said to him? maybe she has indicated they probably won't last long term etc etc.
Maybe he is protecting himself??

Pigeon31 · 13/06/2023 15:08

For all you know, she's had the same thoughts and is planning to break up after the trip too ;)

Swipe left for the next trending thread