Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being expected to wear blazers today

208 replies

AskMeMore · 13/06/2023 13:16

DDs school have said they still have to wear blazers to school today. It is very hot here. I have just told her to take it off if she wants to. No way am I indulging the school in this level of ridiculousness.

OP posts:
MrsLilaAmes · 14/06/2023 11:47

Such nonsense. I grew up with a friend who was certain she couldn't handle hot weather. Hated it, couldn't cope, etc. Never wanted to go on holiday unless a winter type, hiking in the snow kind of holiday. Performance really faltered at school and she was likely to start being 'mouthy' at teachers and other adults when she normally didn't get into trouble. She went to a private school whereas I was at a comprehensive.

It turns out, when we became adults and she finally had autonomy over whether to wear a tie, a thick blazer, tights and closed-toe shoes or whether to dress appropriately in light fabrics and sandals, she was able to enjoy summer weather and act appropriately at work because she wasn't using up all her energy coping with the stupid unsuitable clothing.

Marsyas · 14/06/2023 11:41

DS came home with all the symptoms of heat exhaustion and some of the symptoms of heat stroke yesterday - vomiting, dehydration, exhaustion, raging headache. Part of that is on him - he didn’t take a hat. But I feel most of it is on the school - nowhere shady to go at lunchtime, very little time to fill their water bottles between classes and a zero tolerance approach which means kids like DS are worried about putting a foot wrong, won’t fill their bottle if they might be late for class, won’t tell the teacher if they are I’ll due to their ridiculous absence policy etc.

guineacup · 14/06/2023 11:37

@SummerDuck

Many schools see a big decline in behaviour and work standards when relaxation is allowed so I can see why they take a strict approach. There also has to be an element of consistency so the uniform retains its uniformity.

I'd be interested to see your evidence that failing to make children wear blazers and ties in sweltering classrooms leads to a "big decline in behaviour". Hmm

Even if true (and I don't believe it is for a moment as overheating children for the sake of petty compliance of a rule is never going to generate respect and will encourage otherwise compliant children to rebel), I could equally say that removing frequent and harsh beatings with a cane for minor misdemeanours would likely lead to a fall in discipline standards - it doesn't make it right!

JustFrustrated · 14/06/2023 11:32

My DD was put in isolation last summer for this. It was 42 degrees and I'd told her not to take her blazer in.

So the kids in isolation were put in the IT rooms, the only ones with AC, and the AC was put on maximum (confirmed by the learning mentor).

DH went ballistic. He'd just spent 2 days amending H&S policies on his sites because of the weather. He went down to the school (for another reason, but ended up in a meeting with one of the principles) and went through each and every h&s clause going.

The response? We are an education provider, not an employer. We are setting the children up to do well in future employment.

But that night got a text saying all children could wear PE kit.

It even made the local news (the schools positions).

This year, far more sensible. No blazers to be worn, but must be in bags. which is still stupid but ok.

Sirzy · 14/06/2023 10:36

StillWantingADog · 14/06/2023 10:31

@SummerDuck
Many schools see a big decline in behaviour and work standards when relaxation is allowed

I’m pretty sure schools see a decline in behaviour and work standards when everyone is too hot to concentrate. If the school was air conned to the max then fine but surely students need to be comfortable not a hot sweaty mess.

Exactly.

i also don’t think it’s wrong for schools to acknowledge that the heat makes things harder for children in school and to show them they are listening and making adjustments.

ds school has full school PE kit or full school uniform as options at the moment. Because the school have listened to the children they all seem to be following the new expectations and getting on with things.

meanwhile a neighbouring school are insisting on full uniform for all and it’s causing aggro on all fronts and from what I saw this morning children going in in all sorts of variation of the uniform. I know a friends child was put in internal exclusion the other day because they didn’t have their tie on!

i know which approach I prefer

StillWantingADog · 14/06/2023 10:31

@SummerDuck
Many schools see a big decline in behaviour and work standards when relaxation is allowed

I’m pretty sure schools see a decline in behaviour and work standards when everyone is too hot to concentrate. If the school was air conned to the max then fine but surely students need to be comfortable not a hot sweaty mess.

SummerDuck · 14/06/2023 10:16

Personally I agree with schools that the default position should be “blazers on at all times” and then if a particular classroom is exceptionally warm, the individual class teacher can give temporary permission for removal.

The DC’s school set a temperature threshold at which teachers can allow removal in classrooms, which js a fair approach.

Many schools see a big decline in behaviour and work standards when relaxation is allowed so I can see why they take a strict approach. There also has to be an element of consistency so the uniform retains its uniformity.

lemonaddde · 14/06/2023 00:04

It's a hill I'm willing to die on.

Told both my kids they do not have to wear it if
it becomes too hot or uncomfortable, and school can phone me if they have a problem with it.

I'm supportive of school, and my kids are always smart and in full uniform, but this is another level of ridiculous.

StrawberrySquash · 14/06/2023 00:00

It's ridiculous. The whole point of a blazer is you get cold you wear it, you get hot you take it off. This is how clothes work.

LifeIsPainHighness · 13/06/2023 23:27

It’s honestly strange and barbaric. I can’t think of a logical reason as to why children must wear blazers in scorching weather.

My kids’ primary school have very generously allowed them to roll their sleeves up 🙄🙄 whereas the school down the road has allowed a home clothes rule for the week. Have to say their kids look far more comfortable

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 13/06/2023 23:25

Runnersandtoms · 13/06/2023 13:22

Ours have been told they don't have to. My daughter has so much in the pockets she's still wearing hers though.

This 100% - i was talking to my boss when dd1 started yr7 about how unnecessary & archaic I found blazers & she laughed and said you wait - they'd lose everything without them - so true!

cctvrec · 13/06/2023 23:23

Our local high school sent us this text today!

"With the rising temperatures this week until Friday, we will allow pupils to attend school in 'appropriate' Shorts and T shirts for the rest of this week - No crop tops or Football colours. Thank you"

I nearly fell off my chair! In my day it was winter uniform (long sleeve shirt, tie, JUMPER and thick blazer) until an arbitrary date which if I recall was around 14th of June. No exceptions.
Summer uniform was long sleeve shirt and blazer but the kind souls let us take off our jumpers. How feckin nice of them.

alpenguin · 13/06/2023 21:58

My daughter’s high school is like this. They can take them off in class but must wear them in the corridors regardless of weather. My daughter was carrying hers around and she was sent to the year head for a talking to.

i’m still waiting for the call back. I suspect it will never come

CaveCanem · 13/06/2023 21:42

@guineacup you won’t get anywhere without following the school’s complaints policy and escalating in line with that. They can and will just ignore you. It’s more than just a complaint email, it has to be a formal letter and follow their process. Phone calls, ranting at staff, demanding meetings etc get you nowhere. Parents have been to the press with issues previously, again, the Head didn’t budge.

You have no idea of the fighting I have had to do with schools (and more) regarding SEN and health/disability issues over the years my dc have been in school. I have had to fight, schools, the LA, hospitals/GP’s and CCG’s, have instigated judicial reviews and been through tribunals and won. I am not an impotent parent that just lets thing lie. Bitter experience has told me though, that if you don’t go about things the right way, you will get nowhere and you are far more likely to win if you follow due process. I am exhausted from fighting, but I still stand up for my children whenever and wherever they need me to.

Anyway, small win today. Most teachers have allowed blazers off during lessons, although ties still had to stay, although still no school-wide change of policy.

guineacup · 13/06/2023 20:16

@Kiwano

I hope friend's parent has entered a formal complaint about this blatant breach of basic safeguarding requirements?

It would be a negligent parent who continued to send their kid into school in a blazer in such circumstances.

@CaveCanem As parents you need to more than fire of a complaint email. You're all letting down your kids by your limp responses.

Pottedpalm · 13/06/2023 19:27

Brefugee · 13/06/2023 14:41

Isn't it time parents banded together and insist that all teachers wear similar clothes to the uniform? all in jackets, everyone in a tie (women included) no trainers etc?

Why? Teachers are at their place of work, they are not pupils in school.
And blaming ‘the teachers’
for draconian rules is pointless. Teachers have no say in formulating the rules, they just get into trouble for not implementing them.

paininhell · 13/06/2023 18:47

My daughters school have told them not to wear blazers but the girls have to still wear knee high black socks and they have to still wear their ties. My daughter said she's starting a petition for girls to be able to wear black ankle socks in this weather.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 13/06/2023 17:49

I’m fairly sure that if this had happened at my school (back in the dark ages) we (the pupils) would have organised, protested and refused to wear them. What’s the school going to do if no-one complies?

DrCoconut · 13/06/2023 17:40

DS's school have said blazers are optional this week. I guess they will review next week. They seem fairly open to common sense unlike some other local schools.

Brefugee · 13/06/2023 17:37

StrawberryWater · 13/06/2023 16:52

I was rather fuming at pick up today as ds’s class were all forced to wear their blazers but the other classes were not. It was 29 degree and they were sweating and looking very uncomfortable. Meanwhile his teacher is swanning around in a big flowy dress. It’s utterly ridiculous.

I would have been having words with teacher and head. And telling my DC to wear as many / few layers as the teachers

NyanBinaryJohn · 13/06/2023 17:33

CaramelicedLatte · 13/06/2023 17:05

As someone in primary education, this is possibly one of the things about secondary that riles me up the most.

We spend years teaching children to use their common sense to dress themselves appropriately. Then they get to secondary and lose all bodily autonomy when it comes to temperature regulation.

Blazers make fuck. all. difference to behaviour. Uniform makes fuck all difference tbh. The obsession with it in UK secondary schools is entirely because the vast majority of them are fucking useless at actual education and it's the only way they feel they can exert control.

There, I said it.

I intend to agree with this. I grew up in a Western European country where we don't have uniforms. I went to a school in a posh town as a poor kid. Now I'm not saying that bullying isn't a thing over there, but I was never bullied for my affordable wardrobe, whilst classmates rocked around the school in €100 branded jeans and trainers.

From what I can see the issue in the UK is that we don't address bullying as effectively as we do in parts of Europe. Like I say, bullying exists, but not to the extent it does here.

No uniform will ever change that.

UnctuousUnicorns · 13/06/2023 17:15

At my private girls' school in the 80s, blazers were strictly outdoor wear, and were hung up on hooks as we entered the building. Indoor summer uniform consisted of short sleeved, open neck blouse (so no tie), skirt and socks, usually ankle socks, so bare legs. We could wear a sweater, cardigan or tank top, but it wasn't compulsory. Blazers indoors in this weather is ridiculous, like I said it wasn't even allowed in my school. 🤷‍♀️

CaramelicedLatte · 13/06/2023 17:05

As someone in primary education, this is possibly one of the things about secondary that riles me up the most.

We spend years teaching children to use their common sense to dress themselves appropriately. Then they get to secondary and lose all bodily autonomy when it comes to temperature regulation.

Blazers make fuck. all. difference to behaviour. Uniform makes fuck all difference tbh. The obsession with it in UK secondary schools is entirely because the vast majority of them are fucking useless at actual education and it's the only way they feel they can exert control.

There, I said it.

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 13/06/2023 17:00

Topseyt123 · 13/06/2023 16:42

This sort of bullshit is the sort of thing that turned me from being very pro school uniform to being anti. So many schools just enforce it for the sake of it, and to ridiculous levels.

Me too. Also creates conflict with pupils for classroom teachers who quite probably disagree yet have to enforce stupid rules.

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 13/06/2023 16:55

Mine don't have to wear them but do have to take them with them! It's like some mad power trip! And I say that someone who also works in education and whose default is to want to support school. No letting boys wear smart shorts is another one.