Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that surely known coercion invalidates medical consent ?

79 replies

Coercion · 13/06/2023 12:49

If all medical professionals are aware that a patient is being coerced/forced and this was in their medical notes then any consent given is invalidated ?

Im in a situation where it being told that’s not The case - that if I signed then it’s valid consent despite the fact they recorded on multiple occasions my disclosures of abuse and being forced, coerced and threatened. They even witnessed it and noted it.

Im told ‘ultimately you were an adult and consented’

This isn’t right is it ?

OP posts:
Coercion · 13/06/2023 22:25

Namasti · 13/06/2023 21:27

I wondered have you approached the NHS trust?

I don’t think the GMC were the right people; ultimately they are a regulatory body and looking at medical malpractice and very serious wrongdoing by doctors as individuals.

This sounds like a problem with the service as a whole and lack of knowledge.

In 2000 this would have been before the mental capacity act so they still cannot be judged by todays standards around capacity and consent for adults.

I imagine however unfairly that they regarded what happened between you and your mum as being ‘family dynamics’ or ‘relational difficulties’.

I don’t think they would have called the police or social services- I can’t see what they would have done either - but were you spoken to about going to a refuge or accessing any other support?

I unfortunately do see how they would have regarded you as an adult, who was reluctantly having the TOP in preference to being homeless and destroying their relationship with their own mother.

Now I think standards are more strict and there would be more of an intervention.

I am ultimately, very sorry that this happened.

I was just desperate and though that the police or social services would help I was very vocal and kept asking and begging for help clearly stating exactly what was happening to me .

They gave me no other options at all. It was one option only and 24/7 I had from my mother how if I had the baby it would be removed or I’d have to work and it would be in a nursery all day every day and I would they a good nursery that I’d have to use one where I’d be at the bus stop at 6 am as it would be far away and each day I’d have to worry was my baby looked after badly etc etc. I feel embarrassed to admit I didn’t know that actually I’d have got benefits etc I thought she was telling me the truth I was terrified but I kept saying I still couldn’t do it.
I had no money , no phone, no freedom and no choice . The drs just backed her up - she was insisting on a certain thing so it had to be done

OP posts:
ABugWife · 13/06/2023 21:38

I am very sorry this happened to you. Whilst 18 and technically an adult, 18 is still very young and I can see why your mum had so much control over you.

They were wrong, your mum was wrong, you should never have had to deal with that.

I expect they won't apologise because that is admitting liability and opening themselves upto further action. It absolutely sucks though.

Namasti · 13/06/2023 21:27

I wondered have you approached the NHS trust?

I don’t think the GMC were the right people; ultimately they are a regulatory body and looking at medical malpractice and very serious wrongdoing by doctors as individuals.

This sounds like a problem with the service as a whole and lack of knowledge.

In 2000 this would have been before the mental capacity act so they still cannot be judged by todays standards around capacity and consent for adults.

I imagine however unfairly that they regarded what happened between you and your mum as being ‘family dynamics’ or ‘relational difficulties’.

I don’t think they would have called the police or social services- I can’t see what they would have done either - but were you spoken to about going to a refuge or accessing any other support?

I unfortunately do see how they would have regarded you as an adult, who was reluctantly having the TOP in preference to being homeless and destroying their relationship with their own mother.

Now I think standards are more strict and there would be more of an intervention.

I am ultimately, very sorry that this happened.

Coercion · 13/06/2023 20:57

I think my biggest shock was how they enabled an abuser who wasn’t making any secret of it ? I know if I did that to one of my daughters I’d probably be arrested within 24 hours !

OP posts:
Coercion · 13/06/2023 20:55

Greentree1 · 13/06/2023 20:32

I don't know what you want, you agreed and signed forms to a procedure, you think you were pressurised into doing it. It was a long time ago, how long? What do you want money or what? Just let it go you need to enjoy your life.

I think my issue is that I knew at the time I’d begged for help I thought I hadn’t begged enough.
I tried to get my notes in 2005 and wasn’t allowed I tried again in 2021 and got them and was so shocked how each person had carefully documented the coercion, that my mother insisted, my begging for help for SS or the police , how they kept writing I was stating I wanted to continue the pregnancy but they needed to tell me to reconsider and plans to keep rebooking me etc etc

So it’s just made it raw again I think ? And angry. I don’t want compensation I think I wanted recognition that this was wrong legally and morally , an apology ?

OP posts:
TheCheeseTray · 13/06/2023 20:37

007DoubleOSeven · 13/06/2023 14:31

You WERE violated, op and it WAS wrong, very wrong. Your experience and treatment there was horrific and it's appalling it happened - it never should have happened.

I don't know if it would still be worth speaking with a solicitor with experience in pursuing medical mistreatment, if only to help you find some peace of mind even if you don't intend to pursue further but I'm by no means urging you, your welfare comes before all else and if you don't believe it will help then ignore it.

What you describe sounds more like something from the 60s and its appalling that it happened as recently as 2000.

You can talk here as much as you need to Flowers

This.

You were violated. You did not give consent. Your mother is a vile excuse for a human being.

I have experienced abuse - numerous times. By my father.

On one occasion he went to hit me - over getting a question on my homework wrong - I ducked and hit my head on the marble table and his hand connected hard with the back on my head. He knocked me out. When I came too - I was on my way to the local hospital. I needed stitches in my head. I was asked how I had injured myself - I told them I had been hit by my father - local MP etc - nothing every happened to him and I was hit on the way home for telling them.

have you tried writing to your local MP or a solicitor who specialises in cases of consent, abortion or abuse? To see what they say.

absolutely horrendous treatment and I’m sorry you were let down by the people who were supposed to love you the most.

an apology is not enough, nor compensation. I really hope you are in a happy place now and surrounded by those that do respect your boundaries etc

Greentree1 · 13/06/2023 20:32

I don't know what you want, you agreed and signed forms to a procedure, you think you were pressurised into doing it. It was a long time ago, how long? What do you want money or what? Just let it go you need to enjoy your life.

Coercion · 13/06/2023 20:24

Oblomov23 · 13/06/2023 19:33

No, I doubt they will. Sad

I took 2 complaints as far it would go, School complaint to DofE. Was told 'we don't apologise. Ever'!

They aren’t the only ones but it’s sort of expected from the nhs I suppose. My mother on the other hand - any time I ever dared to mention it she said ‘oh you’ll NEVER let me forget it will you ??’

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 13/06/2023 19:33

No, I doubt they will. Sad

I took 2 complaints as far it would go, School complaint to DofE. Was told 'we don't apologise. Ever'!

Coercion · 13/06/2023 19:30

Oblomov23 · 13/06/2023 18:56

I'm sorry this happened to you 23 years ago, but maybe your focus is misdirected. Your'll never get an apology from nhs, they just don't give it. (I love a good fight especially when there has been an injustice, but I've learnt by fighting primary school and SS that it is not very satisfying). Fighting legally for numerical recompense is also unlikely. Counselling is probably your best bet.

I’m not interested in any kid of compensation , I did want some kind of apology but can see they will never say sorry 😞

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 13/06/2023 18:56

I'm sorry this happened to you 23 years ago, but maybe your focus is misdirected. Your'll never get an apology from nhs, they just don't give it. (I love a good fight especially when there has been an injustice, but I've learnt by fighting primary school and SS that it is not very satisfying). Fighting legally for numerical recompense is also unlikely. Counselling is probably your best bet.

007DoubleOSeven · 13/06/2023 18:37

Coercion · 13/06/2023 18:11

Thankyou I really appreciate how kind everyone has been on here. Iv what had the worst day as ever though it was so long ago the response to my complaint just upset me as it’s like they are minimising it and victim blaming and I was so upset. I really appreciate everyone being so nice and validation for my feelings

As very hard as it is, try not to take their response personally. Their reply isn't personal, even though its about such a huge part of your life. Its a response carefully drafted to cover themselves legally, emotions haven't gone into it. It's a non-emotive, legally-approved response from an organising body, it isn't an empathetic reaction to the trauma you've been through.

Coercion · 13/06/2023 18:12

Sorry for the typos my phone seems to be playing up a bit

OP posts:
Coercion · 13/06/2023 18:11

007DoubleOSeven · 13/06/2023 14:31

You WERE violated, op and it WAS wrong, very wrong. Your experience and treatment there was horrific and it's appalling it happened - it never should have happened.

I don't know if it would still be worth speaking with a solicitor with experience in pursuing medical mistreatment, if only to help you find some peace of mind even if you don't intend to pursue further but I'm by no means urging you, your welfare comes before all else and if you don't believe it will help then ignore it.

What you describe sounds more like something from the 60s and its appalling that it happened as recently as 2000.

You can talk here as much as you need to Flowers

Thankyou I really appreciate how kind everyone has been on here. Iv what had the worst day as ever though it was so long ago the response to my complaint just upset me as it’s like they are minimising it and victim blaming and I was so upset. I really appreciate everyone being so nice and validation for my feelings

OP posts:
007DoubleOSeven · 13/06/2023 14:31

You WERE violated, op and it WAS wrong, very wrong. Your experience and treatment there was horrific and it's appalling it happened - it never should have happened.

I don't know if it would still be worth speaking with a solicitor with experience in pursuing medical mistreatment, if only to help you find some peace of mind even if you don't intend to pursue further but I'm by no means urging you, your welfare comes before all else and if you don't believe it will help then ignore it.

What you describe sounds more like something from the 60s and its appalling that it happened as recently as 2000.

You can talk here as much as you need to Flowers

Coercion · 13/06/2023 14:22

Maray1967 · 13/06/2023 14:20

I am so very sorry. What happened to you was very wrong. I was much older than you were in 2000. I had thought this might have been in the 70s.

Unless you have a lot of money or a keen lawyer who will pursue this for you, you might need to focus on getting the support you need now. I hope very much you get that support. 💐

I can’t pursue this s I know I will hit the same wall over and over and it will make me unwell. I’m just so hurt by it all and I just need an outlet .
Im really grateful for all the kindness here it means a lot because I really felt so frustrated with the GMC response and I was so upset

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 13/06/2023 14:20

I am so very sorry. What happened to you was very wrong. I was much older than you were in 2000. I had thought this might have been in the 70s.

Unless you have a lot of money or a keen lawyer who will pursue this for you, you might need to focus on getting the support you need now. I hope very much you get that support. 💐

Coercion · 13/06/2023 14:20

She had told him that but then told me he had called and said he didn’t want anything to do with me anymore. She was manipulative and clever and then took my mobile phone (she hated it from the second I got it) so then i had no way to verify anything and I was so so unwell it was horrendous

OP posts:
Coercion · 13/06/2023 14:18

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 13/06/2023 14:05

I was a teen mum in '96 so there was definitely help around at that time.

As you were an 18 year old I don't understand how your mum could enforce anything?

I lived in her house and I had to abide by her rules. I had a job and a boyfriend and was thinking of moving out. I got pregnant but got severe hyperemesis and this is what gave her power. I was too sick to move and she relentlessly bullied me. When my boyfriend called she had told him I didn’t want to see him or speak to him and then she took total control.
She had always been emotionally abusive and I think she was panicking about me wanting to leave home

OP posts:
VeterinaryCareAssistant · 13/06/2023 14:05

Coercion · 13/06/2023 13:59

2000

I was a teen mum in '96 so there was definitely help around at that time.

As you were an 18 year old I don't understand how your mum could enforce anything?

RandomMess · 13/06/2023 14:02

The treatment you received was utterly horrific SadAngryFlowers

Coercion · 13/06/2023 14:00

Vavazoom · 13/06/2023 13:59

OP, this is said with kindness.

Sometimes in life we don’t get justice. Sometimes it’s because the system doesn’t work in our favour, sometimes it is because we don’t have the strength for the fight and sometimes it is because life is very very unfair. Regardless of the reason why, there are times when the best thing we can do is find a way to live with what happened. You have to give yourself space to grieve for the person you would have been, or the life (or indeed the child) that you would have had if this thing had not been done to you. You will never be that person or have that life, but that doesn’t mean that you can’t be happy. Nothing can give you back the person that you were before, and fighting for justice in the face of overwhelming opposition won’t right the wrong. Sometimes the best thing that you can do for yourself is accept that you were wronged and learn to love and value the person that you are now.

I was raped many years ago and spent a long time suffering from PTSD. I began to recover once I let go of the idea that justice would bring back the person I was before and the person I would have been if it hadn’t happened. I would never have got justice and the fight would have destroyed me. I grieved for a long time for the person I lost and eventually I found happiness and peace in accepting the person I became. I am stronger and kinder than I would ever have been if it hadn’t happened. I hope that you can learn to live with what happened to you and find a similar peace and acceptance.

Thankyou ❤️

OP posts:
Coercion · 13/06/2023 14:00

Readyplayerthr33 · 13/06/2023 13:57

It sounds like they decided to use their own judgement rather than actual follow the law around consent or do anything to help.

If you couldn’t say no to your mother, then how could you raise a baby? That’s probably what they saw. An 18 year old still not able to stand on her own 2 feet or just tell her mother no, so they made a decision that it was for the best and they ignored your request for social services involvement etc.

They had your consent and they just went ahead with it because they probably all decided it was just for the best. They treated you like a child. They shouldn’t have. They shouldn’t have used their own judgement and their own opinion to decide what you had to go through.

Have you had counselling to help you through the trauma?

Yes so much counselling but it is still hurting

OP posts:
Vavazoom · 13/06/2023 13:59

OP, this is said with kindness.

Sometimes in life we don’t get justice. Sometimes it’s because the system doesn’t work in our favour, sometimes it is because we don’t have the strength for the fight and sometimes it is because life is very very unfair. Regardless of the reason why, there are times when the best thing we can do is find a way to live with what happened. You have to give yourself space to grieve for the person you would have been, or the life (or indeed the child) that you would have had if this thing had not been done to you. You will never be that person or have that life, but that doesn’t mean that you can’t be happy. Nothing can give you back the person that you were before, and fighting for justice in the face of overwhelming opposition won’t right the wrong. Sometimes the best thing that you can do for yourself is accept that you were wronged and learn to love and value the person that you are now.

I was raped many years ago and spent a long time suffering from PTSD. I began to recover once I let go of the idea that justice would bring back the person I was before and the person I would have been if it hadn’t happened. I would never have got justice and the fight would have destroyed me. I grieved for a long time for the person I lost and eventually I found happiness and peace in accepting the person I became. I am stronger and kinder than I would ever have been if it hadn’t happened. I hope that you can learn to live with what happened to you and find a similar peace and acceptance.

Coercion · 13/06/2023 13:59

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 13/06/2023 13:58

How long ago was this? I ask, because I was a pregnant teen and refused point blank to have an abortion.
At the age of 18 you were legally an adult, could you have contacted a women's refuge for help or the local council?

2000

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread